Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2021-12
The influence of religious/spiritual beliefs on Malaysian hospital healthcare workers’ attitudes towards suicide and suicidal patients: a qualitative study
There has been mixed findings on whether a healthcare workers’ religious beliefs contribute positively or negatively to their attitudes towards suicidal patients.
Aims
This study aims to explore qualitatively the influence of religious/spiritual beliefs on healthcare workers’ attitudes towards suicide and suicidal patients in the culturally heterogeneous Malaysian population.
Methods
Thirty-one healthcare workers from diverse religious backgrounds, professions and medical disciplines were interviewed. Thematic analysis revealed the centrality of religion in determining healthcare workers’ acceptability of suicide, specific religious beliefs that influenced their views on the right-to-die issue, perceptions of the suicidal patient’s religiousness/spirituality, and the aspects and extent of religious relevance in professional philosophy and practice.
Results
Healthcare workers who could perceive the multifactorial nature of suicide causation had a more empathetic response. There were high levels of paternalism in the care of suicidal patients, involving unsolicited religious/spiritual advice practised as a form of suicide deterrent and social support.
Conclusions
The formal integration of religious/spiritual practices into the professional care of suicidal patients was indicated.
AhmedaniBKSimonGEStewartC, et al.(2014) Health care contacts in the year before suicide death. Journal of General Internal Medicine29(6): 870–877.
2.
AmarasuriyaSDReavleyNJRossettoA, et al.(2017) Helping intentions of undergraduates towards their depressed peers: A cross-sectional study in Sri Lanka. BMC Psychiatry17(1): 40.
3.
ArmitageCJPanagiotiMRahimWA, et al.(2015) Completed suicides and self-harm in Malaysia: A systematic review. General Hospital Psychiatry37(2): 153–165.
4.
BoukouvalasEEl-DenSMurphyAL, et al.(2019) Exploring health care professionals’ knowledge of, attitudes towards, and confidence in caring for people at risk of suicide: A systematic review. Archives of Suicide Research17: 1–31.
5.
BullockEC (2015) A normatively neutral definition of paternalism. The Philosophical Quarterly65(258): 1–21.
6.
ChanCMHAhmadWAWYusofMM, et al.(2015) Patient-centredness, job satisfaction and psychological distress: A brief survey comparing oncology nurses and doctors. Asian Pacific Journal of Cancer Prevention16(16): 6895–6898.
7.
Chan LF and Maniam T (2016) Cultural factors in suicide prevention. In: RC O’Connor and J Pirkis (eds) The International Handbook of Suicide Prevention. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 541–555.
8.
ChenXPEberlyMBChiangTJ, et al.(2014) Affective trust in Chinese leaders linking paternalistic leadership to employee performance. Journal of Management40(3): 796–819.
9.
Chentsova-DuttonYEVaughnA (2012) Let me tell you what to do: Cultural differences in advice-giving. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology43(5): 687–703.
10.
CookCCH (2014) Suicide and religion. British Journal of Psychology204(4): 254–255.
11.
DeJongTMOverholserJCStockmeierCA (2010) Apples to oranges?: A direct comparison between suicide attempters and suicide completers. Journal of Affective Disorders124(1): 90–97.
12.
Department of Statistics Malaysia (2016) Social Statistics Bulletin, Malaysia, 2016. Available at: http://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/ (accessed 21 November 2019).
13.
DougallNLambertPMaxwellM, et al.(2014) Deaths by suicide and their relationship with general and psychiatric hospital discharge: 30-year record linkage study. British Journal of Psychiatry204(4): 267–273.
14.
DoyleLMcCabeCKeoghB, et al.(2020) An overview of the qualitative descriptive design within nursing research. Journal of Research in Nursing25(5): 443–455.
15.
Eskin M (2016) Turkish Imams’ experience with and their attitudes toward suicide and suicidal persons. Journal of Religion and Health 56(3): 1–11.
16.
EskinMSunJMAbuidhailJ, et al.(2016) Suicidal behavior and psychological distress in university students: A 12-nation study. Archives of Suicide Research20(3): 369–388.
17.
FooXYAlwiMNMIsmailSIF, et al.(2014) Religious commitment, attitudes toward suicide, and suicidal behaviors among college students of different ethnic and religious groups in Malaysia. Journal of Religion and Health53(3): 731–746.
18.
FranzenAB (2017) Is this relevant? Physician perceptions, clinical relevance, and religious content in clinical interactions. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion55(3): 438–464.
19.
GearingREAlonzoD (2018) Religion and suicide: New findings. Journal of Religion and Health57(6): 2478–2499.
20.
HendryMPasterfieldDLewisR, et al.(2013) Why do we want the right to die? A systematic review of the international literature on the views of patients, carers and the public on assisted dying. Palliative Medicine27(1): 13–26.
21.
HofstedeGHofstedeGJMinkovM (2010) Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind, 3rd edn. New York: McGraw-Hill.
22.
IsgandarovaN (2015) Physician-assisted suicide and other forms of euthanasia in Islamic spiritual care. Journal of Pastoral Care and Counseling69(4): 215–221.
23.
JegannathanBKullgrenGDahlblomK (2016) How do young people in Cambodia perceive the impact of societal attitudes, media and religion on suicidal behaviour?International Journal of Social Psychiatry62(2): 114–122.
24.
KnizekBLKinyandaEAkotiaCS, et al.(2013) Between Hippocrates and God: Ugandan mental health professional’s views on suicide. Mental Health, Religion and Culture16(8): 767–780.
25.
KvaleSBrinkmannS (2009) Interviews: Learning the Craft of Qualitative Research Interviewing, Thousand Oaks: Sage.
26.
LawrenceREOquendoMAStanleyB (2016) Religion and suicide risk: A systematic review. Archives of Suicide Research20(1): 1–21.
27.
LeeHAnS (2016) Social stigma toward suicide: Effects of group categorization and attributions in Korean health news. Health Communication31(4): 468–477.
28.
LewBHuenJYuanL, et al.(2018) Religious orientation and its relationship to suicidality: A study in one of the least religious countries. Religions9(1): 15.
29.
LiefbroerAIOlsmanEGanzevoortRR, et al.(2017) Interfaith spiritual care: A systematic review. Journal of Religion and Health56(5): 1776–1793.
30.
McCormackRCliffordMConroyM (2012) Attitudes of UK doctors towards euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: A systematic literature review. Palliative Medicine26(1): 23–33.
31.
Malaysian Healthcare Performance Unit (2016) Malaysian Mental Healthcare Performance: Technical Report 2016, Putrajaya: Ministry of Health, Malaysia.
32.
ManiamTMarhaniMFirdausM, et al.(2014) Risk factors for suicidal ideation, plans and attempts in Malaysia – results of an epidemiological survey. Comprehensive Psychiatry55: S121–S125.
33.
Moreira-AlmeidaASharmaAvan RensburgBJ, et al.(2016) WPA position statement on spirituality and religion in psychiatry. World Psychiatry15(1): 87–88.
34.
MurgicLHébertPCSovicS, et al.(2015) Paternalism and autonomy: Views of patients and providers in a transitional (post-communist) country. BMC Medical Ethics16(1): 65.
35.
NielsenETownsendE (2017) Public perceptions of self-harm – a test of an attribution model of public discrimination. Stigma and Health3(3): 204.
36.
OsafoJKnizekBLAkotiaCS, et al.(2012) Attitudes of psychologists and nurses toward suicide and suicide prevention in Ghana: A qualitative study. International Journal of Nursing Studies49(6): 691–700.
37.
OsafoJKnizekBLAkotiaCS, et al.(2013) Influence of religious factors on attitudes towards suicidal behaviour in Ghana. Journal of Religion and Health52(2): 488–504.
38.
OxhandlerHKPargamentKI (2014) Social work practitioners’ integration of clients’ religion and spirituality in practice: A literature review. Social Work59(3): 271–279.
39.
OzcelikHTekirOSamanciogluS, et al.(2014) Nursing students’ approaches toward euthanasia. OMEGA – Journal of Death and Dying69(1): 93–103.
40.
Pelto-PiriVEngströmKEngströmI (2013) Paternalism, autonomy and reciprocity: Ethical perspectives in encounters with patients in psychiatric in-patient care. BMC Medical Ethics14(1): 49.
41.
PompiliM (2010) Exploring the phenomenology of suicide. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior40(3): 234–244.
42.
PompiliM (2015) The role of mirror neurons and empathy in the phenomenology of suicide. European Psychiatry30: 1220.
43.
RathorMYRaniMFAShaharMA, et al.(2014) Attitudes toward euthanasia and related issues among physicians and patients in a multi-cultural society of Malaysia. Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care3(3): 230.
44.
Reimer-KirkhamSSharmaSPesutB, et al.(2012) Sacred spaces in public places: Religious and spiritual plurality in health care. Nursing Inquiry19(3): 202–212.
45.
RibeiroJDYenSJoinerT, et al.(2015) Capability for suicide interacts with states of heightened arousal to predict death by suicide beyond the effects of depression and hopelessness. Journal of Affective Disorders188: 53–59.
46.
Salander RenbergEJacobssonL (2003) Development of a questionnaire on attitudes towards suicide (ATTS) and its application in a Swedish population. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior33(1): 52–64.
47.
SheridanLAGrovesHE (1967) The Constitution of Malaysia, Dobbs Ferry: Oceana Publications.
48.
SherwoodG (2015) Perspectives: Nurses’ expanding role in developing safety culture: Quality and safety education for nurses – competencies in action. Journal of Research in Nursing20(8): 734–740.
SmithMJBouchJBradstreetS, et al.(2015) Health services, suicide, and self-harm: Patient distress and system anxiety. Lancet Psychiatry2(3): 275–280.
51.
StackS (1983) The effect of religious commitment on suicide: A cross-national analysis. Journal of Health and Social Behavior24(4): 362–374.
52.
StackSKposowaAJ (2011) Religion and suicide acceptability: A cross-national analysis. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion50(2): 289–306.
53.
ThimmaiahRPoreddiVRamuR, et al.(2016) Influence of religion on attitude towards suicide: An Indian Perspective. Journal of Religion and Health55(6): 2039–2052.
54.
VerpoortCGastmansCDe BalN, et al.(2004) Nurses’ attitudes to euthanasia: A review of the literature. Nursing Ethics11(4): 349–365.
55.
VictorCPTreschukJ (2020) Critical literature review on the definition clarity of the concept of faith, religion, and spirituality. Journal of Holistic Nursing38(1): 107–113.
56.
WilligCStainton-RogersW (2008) The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research in Psychology, Thousand Oaks: Sage.
57.
WuAWangJYJiaCX (2016) Religion and completed suicide: A meta-analysis. PloS One10(6): e0131715.
