Abstract
Reacting to the impact of Pope Francis and President Donald J. Trump on the world stage, New York Times essayist, Austen Ivereigh, asked the question, “Is Pope Francis the Anti-Trump?” He concluded that the answer is not an obvious one. Using qualitative methods, this study explores this question through the dialectical tensions and management strategies present in the narratives evoked in the many speeches and tweets of Pope Francis and President Trump. The dialectical tensions found in this study include: truth–post–truth, popular–elite, and unity–disunity. Their management by these two leaders is very different, with Trump responding in a much more unilateral fashion than Francis. The implications of these findings for the study of post-truth leadership are discussed, especially regarding the role of narrative and social media.
Keywords
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abdallah
C
Denis
JL
Langley
A
(2011 )
Having your cake and eating it too: Discourses of transcendence and their role in organizational change dynamics . Journal of Organizational Change Management
24 (3 ): 333 –348 .
2.
Aleem
Z
(2018 ) Trump changed his mind on joining the TPP…again. Vox. Available at: https://www.vox.com/world/2018/4/18/17251242/trump-tpp-twitter-news-rejoin
3.
Andriopoulos
C
Lewis
MW
(2009 )
Exploitation-exploration tensions and organizational ambidexterity: Managing paradoxes of innovation . Organization Science
20 (4 ): 696 –717 .
4.
Baxter
LA
(2011 ) Voicing Relationships a Dialogic Perspective .
Washington, DC :
Sage .
5.
Boje
DM
(2001 ) Narrative Methods for Organizational & Communication Research .
London :
Sage .
6.
Boje
DM
(2008 ) Storytelling Organizations .
London :
Sage .
7.
Charmaz K (2006) Constructing Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide through Qualitative Analysis . Los Angeles: SAGE.
8.
Chen
MJ
(2002 )
Transcending paradox: The Chinese “middle way” perspective . Asia Pacific Journal of Management
19 (2–3 ): 179 –199 .
9.
Clarke
M
(1998 )
Can specialists be general managers? Developing paradoxical thinking in middle managers . Journal of Management Development
17 (3 ): 191 –206 .
10.
Chilton
P
(2017 )
“The people” in populist discourse using neuro-cognitive linguistics to understand political meanings . Journal of Language and Politics
16 (4 ): 582 –594 .
11.
Collins
J
Porras
J
(1994 ) Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary Companies .
New York :
Harper Business .
12.
Collinson
D
(2014 )
Dichotomies, dialectics and dilemmas: New directions for critical leadership studies?. Leadership
10 (1 ): 36 –55 .
13.
Colvin
G
(2017 ) The world’s 50 greatest leaders. Fortune . Available at: http://fortune.com/2017/03/23/worlds-50-greatest-leaders-intro/
14.
Cunha
MP
Putnam
LL
(in press)
Paradox theory and the paradox of success . Strategic Organization . DOI: 10.1177/1476127017739536.
15.
Czarniawska-Joerges
B
(2004 ) Narratives in Social Science Research .
London :
Sage .
16.
D’Ancona
M
(2017 ) Post-Truth: The New War on Truth and How to Fight Back .
London :
Ebury Press .
17.
Davis
JP
Eisenhardt
KM
(2011 )
Rotating leadership and collaborative innovation: Recombination processes in symbiotic relationships . Administrative Science Quarterly
56 (2 ): 159 –201 .
18.
Dean
J
(2017 ) Is the Trump’s norm-breaking presidency un-American or merely unorthodox? Available at: https://verdict.justia.com/2017/03/31/trumps-norm-breaking-presidency-un-american-merely-unorthodox
19.
Debord
G
(1967 ) The Society of the Spectacle , translation by Ken Knabb. London, UK: Rebel Press.
20.
Dowd
M
(2013 ) Why did Pope Benedict XVI resign? BBC News . Available at: http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-25121121
21.
Erickson
A
(2015 ) Some Americans really don’t like Pope Francis, here’s why. Washington Post . Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/local/2015/09/18/francis-is-a-global-sensation-but-to-certain-traditional-catholics-his-message-rings-hollow/?utm_term=.d5d9ac66ff82
22.
Fairhurst
GT
Sheep
ML
(in press) “If you have to say you are, you aren’t”: Paradoxes of Trumpian identity work knotting in a “post-truth” context . In
Brown
AD
(ed), The Oxford Handbook of Identities in Organizations .
Oxford, England :
Oxford University Press .
23.
Flores
R
(2018 ) Three church sex abuse survivors to meet with the Pope. CNN . Available at: https://www.cnn.com/2018/04/13/world/pope-vatican-chilean-abuse-survivors-visit/index.html
24.
Gabriel
Y
(2000 ) Storytelling in Organizations .
Oxford :
Oxford University Press .
25.
Gage
B
(2017 ) How ‘elites’ became one of the nastiest epithets in American politics. The New York Times Magazine . Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/03/magazine/how-elites-became-one-of-the-nastiest-epithets-in-american-politics.html
26.Gallup (n. d.) Presidential approval ratings—Donald Trump. Gallup . Available at: https://news.gallup.com/poll/203198/presidential-approval-ratings-donald-trump.aspx
27.
Galvin
G
(2017 ) The globalization of “Fake News”. US News . Available at: https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2017-12-30/how-fake-news-charges-spread-around-the-globe
28.
Gecewicz
C
(2017 ) U.S. Catholics, non-Catholics continue to view Pope Francis favorably. Pew Research Center . Available at: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/01/18/favorable-u-s-views-pope-francis/
29.
Grint
K
(2005 )
Problems, problems, problems: The social construction of leadership . Human Relations
58 (11 ): 1467 –1494 .
30.
Harlan
C
(2018 ) Why the Vatican continues to struggle with sex abuse scandals. Washington Post . Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/why-the-vatican-continues-to-struggle-with-sex-abuse-scandals/2018/08/12/483e16e2-9439-11e8-818b-e9b7348cd87d_story.html
31.
Heracleous
L
Wirtz
J
(2014 )
Singapore airlines: Achieving sustainable advantage through mastering paradox . Journal of Applied Behavioral Science
50 (2 ): 150 –170 .
32.
Holquist
M
(1990 ) Dialogism: Bakhtin and His World .
London :
Routledge .
33.
Homans
C
(2018 ) The post-campaign of Donald Trump. The New York Times Magazine. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/09/magazine/donald-trump-rallies-campaigning-president.html
34.
Horowitz
J
(2018 ) For Pope Francis, fake news goes back to the Garden of Eden. New York Times . Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/24/us/politics/pope-francis-fake-news.html
35.
Ivereigh
A
(2015 ) The Great Reformer: Francis and the Making of a Radical Pope .
New York, NY :
Henry Hold and Company, LLC .
36.
Ivereigh
A
(2017 ) Is the Pope the anti-Trump? New York Times . Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/04/opinion/sunday/is-the-pope-the-anti-trump.html?emc=eta1&_r=0
37.
Jamieson
KH
(1974 )
Interpretation of natural law in the conflict over Humanae Vitae . Quarterly Journal of Speech
60 : 201 –211 .
38.
Jamieson
KH
(1975 )
Antecedent genre as rhetorical constraint . Quarterly Journal of Speech
61 : 406 –415 .
39.
Jensen
MC
(2014 ) Integrity: Without it nothing works. Rotman Magazine: The Magazine of the Rotman School of Management , Fall 2009, pp. 16–20.
40.
Kakutani
M
(2018 ) The Death of Truth: Notes on Falsehood in the Age of Trump .
New York :
Tim Duggan Books .
41.
Korade
M
(2017 ) Trump blasts Senate rules in Saturday morning tweets. CNN . Available at: https://www.cnn.com/2017/07/29/politics/trump-health-care-senate-votes-tweet/index.html
42.
Kreiner
GE
Hollensbe
E
Sheep
ML
et al
. (2015 )
Elasticity and the dialectic tensions of organizational identity: How can we hold together while we are pulling apart?. Academy of Management Journal
58 (4 ): 981 –1011 .
43.
Kruse
M
Weiland
N
(2016 ) Donald Trump’s greatest self-contradictions. Politico . Available at: https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/05/donald-trump-2016-contradictions-213869
44.
Kuhn
T
(2012 )
Negotiating the micro-macro divide: Thought leadership from organizational communication for theorizing organization . Management Communication Quarterly
26 (4 ): 543 –584 .
45.
Lewis
MW
Andriopoulos
C
Smith
WK
(2014 )
Paradoxical leadership to enable strategic agility . California Management Review
56 (3 ): 58 –77 .
46.
Li
N
Hilgard
J
Scheufele
DA
et al
. (2016 )
Cross-pressuring conservative Catholics? Effects of Pope Francis’ encyclical on the U.S. public opinion on climate change . Climatic Change
139 (3 ): 367 –380 .
47.Los Angeles Times Editorial Board (2017 ) Our dishonest president [editorial series]. The Los Angeles Times . Available at: http://www.latimes.com/projects/la-ed-our-dishonest-president/
48.
Lyotard
J
(1979 ) The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge . 10th ed .
Minneapolis, Minnesota :
University of Minnesota Press .
49.
McIntyre
L
(2018 ) Post-Truth .
Cambridge, MA :
MIT Press .
50.
Miron-Spektor
E
Ingram
A
Keller
J
et al
. (2018 )
Microfoundations of organizational paradox: The problem is how we think about the problem . Academy of Management Journal
61 (1 ): 26 –45 .
51.
Morin
R
(2018 ) Trump labels media ‘the opposition party’ as newspapers pushback en masse. Politico . Available at: https://www.politico.com/story/2018/08/16/trump-calls-media-fake-news-as-newspapers-push-back-against-claim-779555
52.
Northcott MS and Scott PM (eds), (2014) Systematic Theology and Climate Change: Ecumenical Perspectives . Routledge: Abingdon.
53.NBC News (Producer) (2017 ) Conway: Press Secretary gave ‘alternative facts’. Meet the Press . Available at: https://www.nbcnews.com/meet-the-press/video/conway-press-secretary-gave-alternative-facts-860142147643?v=raila
54.
O’Keefe
E
(2016 ) The making of unprecedented. CNN . Available at: http://www.cnn.com/interactive/2016/politics/unprecedented/the-making-of-unprecedented/
55.
Oliver
JH
(2017 ) The Trump presidency. Last Week Tonight with John Oliver [television series]. New York: HBO.
56.
Poblete
ME
(2015 )
How to assess populist discourse through three current approaches . Journal of Political Ideologies
20 (2 ): 201 –218 .
57.
Putnam
LL
Fairhurst
GT
Banghart
S
(2016 )
Contradictions, dialectics, and paradoxes in organizations: A constitutive approach . The Academy of Management Annals
10 (1 ): 1 –107 .
58.
Rayman
N
(2015 ) 5 leadership lessons you can learn from Pope Francis. Time . Available at: http://time.com/3737887/pope-francis-leadership-lessons/
59.
Rhodes
C
Brown
A
(2005 )
Narrative, organizations, and research . International Journal of Management Reviews
7 (3 ): 167 –188 .
60.
Rucker
P
Parker
A
Dawsey
J
(2018 ) ‘Pure madness’: Dark days inside the White House as Trump shocks and rages. The Washington Post . Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/pure-madness-dark-days-inside-the-white-house-as-trump-shocks-and-rages/2018/03/03/9849867c-1e72-11e8-9de1-147dd2df3829_story.html?utm_term=.16141488225e
61.
Scherer
M
(2017 ) Can Trump handle the truth? A president who peddles falsehoods and dabbles in conspiracy confronts the challenge of government in reality. Time Magazine . Available at: http://time.com/4710614/donald-trump-fbi-surveillance-house-intelligence-committee/
62.
Shugerman
E
(2018 ) Donald Trump ranked worst president in US history by nearly 200 political scientists. The Independent . Available at: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/trump-worst-president-presidential-greatness-survey-presidents-day-obama-george-washington-a8218721.html
63.
Smith
W
Besharov
M
(in press)
Bowing before dual gods: How structured flexibility sustains organizational hybridity . Administrative Science Quarterly . DOI: 10.1177/0001839217750826.
64.
Smith
WK
Binns
A
Tushman
ML
(2010 )
Complex business models: Managing strategic paradoxes simultaneously . Long Range Planning
43 (2–3 ): 448 –461 .
65.
Smith
WK
Tushman
ML
(2005 )
Managing strategic contradictions: A top management model for managing innovation streams . Organization Science
16 (5 ): 522 –536 .
66.
Snyder
T
(2017 ) On Tyranny: Twenty Lessons from the Twentieth Century .
New York :
Tim Duggan Books .
67.
Sonenshein
S
(2006 )
Crafting social issues at work . Academy of Management Journal
49 (6 ): 1158 –1172 .
68.
Squires
N
(2013 ) Pope Francis the humble: Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio becomes first pontiff from the Americas. Telegraph . Available at: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/the-pope/9928857/Pope-Francis-the-humble-Cardinal-Jorge-Mario-Bergoglio-becomes-first-pontiff-from-the-Americas.html
69.
Srivastava
P
Hopwood
N
(2009 )
A practical iterative framework for qualitative data analysis . International Journal of Qualitative Methods
8 (1 ): 76 –84 .
70.
Stewart
B
(2017 ) Case study in chaos: How management experts grade a Trump White House. New York Times . Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/02/business/donald-trump-management-style.html
71.
Strachan
M
(2017 ) In 60 seconds, a ‘Daily Show’ guest brilliantly exposed the danger of ‘post-truth.’ Huffington Post . Available at: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/daily-show-fascism-post-truth_us_591c54abe4b0a7458fa48cbe
72.
Sykes
CJ
(2018 ) Republicans, don’t just tweet about it. Do something. New York Times . Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/21/opinion/sunday/republicans-trump-russia-putin.html
73.
Tharoor
I
(2017 ) Trump meets Pope Francis, his antithesis. Washington Post . Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/05/24/trump-meets-pope-francis-his-antithesis
74.
Tourish
D
Vatcha
N
(2005 )
Charismatic leadership and corporate cultism at Enron: The elimination of dissent, the promotion of conformity and organizational collapse . Leadership
1 (4 ): 455 –480 .
75.
Tracy
SJ
(2013 ) Qualitative Research Methods .
West Sussex, UK :
Wiley-Blackwell .
76.
Vaara
E
Sonenshein
S
Boje
D
(2016 )
Narratives as sources of stability and change in organizations: Approaches and directions for future research . Academy of Management Annals
10 (1 ): 495 –560 .
77.
Vasquez
C
Schoeneborn
D
Sergi
V
(2016 )
Summoning the spirits: Organizational texts and the (dis)ordering properties of communication . Human Relations
69 (3 ): 629 –659 .
78.
Waldman
DA
Bowen
DE
(2016 )
Learning to be a paradox-savvy leader . Academy of Management Perspectives
30 (3 ): 316 –327 .
79.
Wang
AB
(2016 ) ‘Post-truth’ named 2016 word of the year by Oxford Dictionaries. Washington Post . Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/11/16/post-truth-named-2016-word-of-the-year-by-oxford-dictionaries/?utm_term=.5b3a1e478620
80.
Wootson
CR
(2018 ) Not the enemy of the people. Washington Post . Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/arts-and-entertainment/wp/2018/08/11/not-the-enemy-of-the-people-70-news-organizations-will-blast-trumps-attack-on-the-press/?utm_term=.a93c5a9f700b
81.
Zakaria
F
(2018 ) Looking back at the economic crash of 2008. New York Times . Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/10/books/review/adam-tooze-crashed.html
82.
Zetlin
M
(n. d.) Why Pope Francis is so effective: 8 Lessons for every leader. Inc . Available at: https://www.inc.com/minda-zetlin/why-pope-francis-is-so-effective-8-lessons-for-every-leader.html
83.
Zoller
HM
Fairhurst
GT
(2007 )
Resistance leadership: The overlooked potential in critical organization and leadership studies . Human Relations
60 (9 ): 1331 –1360 .