The benefits of related and unrelated diversification strategies in the Spanish context: What is the difference that executive leadership style can make?
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online February, 2016
The benefits of related and unrelated diversification strategies in the Spanish context: What is the difference that executive leadership style can make?
This article builds on the agency-stewardship approach to examine if the impact of related and unrelated diversification strategies on firm performance is contingent on the leadership style of diversifying Chief Executive Officers (CEOs) ranging from the agent model to the steward model. For this purpose, it proposes four hypotheses which are empirically tested using data from a sample of 183 Spanish firms. The findings provide new insights about the relevance of CEOs’ leadership style so that a right fit between diversification type and executive leadership style seems to be crucial for firms pursuing growth and profitability benefits.
AggarwalRSamwickA (2003) Why do managers diversify their firms? Agency reconsidered. Journal of Finance58(1): 71–118.
2.
Benito-OsorioDGuerras-MartínLAZúñiga-VicenteJA (2012) Four decades of research on product diversification: A literature review. Management Decision50(2): 325–344.
3.
BertrandMSchoarA (2003) Managing with style: The effect of managers on firm policies. Quarterly Journal of Economics118(4): 1169–1208.
4.
BindaVIversenMJ (2007) Towards a “managerial revolution” in European business? The transformation of Danish and Spanish big business, 1973–2003. Business History49(4): 506–530.
5.
CapaldoACogmanDSuonioH (2009) What's different about M&A in this down-turn. McKinsey Quarterly30: 31–36.
6.
ChakrabartiASinghKMahmoodI (2007) Diversification and performance: Evidence from East Asian firms. Strategic Management Journal28(2): 101–120.
7.
ChatterjeeSSinghS (1999) Are tradeoffs inherent in diversification moves? A simultaneous model for type of diversification and mode of expansion decisions. Management Science45(1): 25–45.
8.
CollisDJMontgomeryCA (1997) Corporate Strategy: Resources and the Scope of the Firm, Boston: McGraw-Hill.
9.
ColpanAMHikinoT (2005) Changing economic environments, evolving diversification strategies, and differing financial performance: Japan's largest textile firms, 1970–2001. Industrial and Corporate Change14(6): 897–940.
10.
DattaDRajagopalanNRasheedA (1991) Diversification and performance: Critical review and future directions. Journal of Management Studies28(5): 529–558.
11.
DavisJSchoormanFDonaldsonL (1997) Toward a stewardship theory of management. Academy of Management Review22(1): 20–48.
12.
DavisJSchoormanFDonaldsonL (2004) Toward a stewardship theory of management. In: ClarkeT (eds) Theories of Corporate Governance, Oxon: Routledge, pp. 118–134.
13.
DenisDDenisDSarinA (1997) Agency problems, equity ownership and corporate diversification. Journal of Finance52(1): 135–160.
14.
DenisDDenisDSarinA (1999) Agency theory and the influence of equity ownership structure on corporate diversification strategies. Strategic Management Journal20(11): 1071–1076.
15.
DessGLumpkinGEisnerA (2010) Strategic Management: Creating Competitive Advantages, New York: McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
16.
DringoliA (2011) Corporate Strategy and Firm Growth: Creating value for Shareholders, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
17.
FligsteinNDauberK (1989) Structural Change y Corporate Organization. Annual Review of Sociology15: 73–96.
18.
FoxMHamiltonR (1994) Ownership and diversification: Agency theory or Stewardship theory. Journal of Management Studies31(1): 69–81.
19.
FurrerO (2010) Corporate Level Strategy: Theory and Applications, London: Routledge.
20.
GalánJISanchez-BuenoMJ (2009) Strategy and structure in context: Universalism versus institutional effects. Organization Studies30(6): 609–627.
21.
GeorgeRKabirR (2012) Heterogeneity in business groups and the corporate diversification-firm performance relationship. Journal of Business Research65(3): 412–420.
22.
GeringerJMTallmanSOlsenDM (2000) Product and international diversification among Japanese multinational firms. Strategic Management Journal21(1): 51–80.
23.
GinsbergAVenkatramanN (1985) Contingency perspectives of organizational strategy: A critical review of the empirical research. Academy of Management Review10(3): 421–434.
24.
Godos-DíezJLFernández-GagoRMartínez-CampilloA (2011) How important are CEOs to CSR Practices? An analysis of the mediating effect of the perceived role of ethics and social responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics98(4): 531–548.
25.
GriffinRW (2013) Fundamentals of Management, New York, NY: Cengage Learning.
26.
GuptaAK (1984) Contingency linkages between strategy and general manager characteristics: A conceptual examination. Academy of Management Review9(3): 399–412.
27.
HåkonssonDBurtonRMObelB (2012) Strategy implementation requires the right executive style: Evidence from Danish SMEs. Long Range Planning45(2–3): 182–208.
28.
HeckmanJ (1979) Sample selection bias as a specification error. Econométrica47(1): 153–161.
29.
HernándezM (2008) Promoting stewardship behavior in organizations: A leadership model. Journal of Business Ethics80(1): 121–128.
30.
HernándezM (2012) Toward an understanding of the psychology of stewardship. Academy of Management Review37(2): 172–193.
31.
HillCWHittMHoskissonRE (1992) Cooperative versus competitive structures in related and unrelated diversified firms. Organization Science3(4): 501–521.
32.
HoechleDSchmidMWalterI (2012) How much of the diversification discount can be explained by poor corporate governance?Journal of Financial Economics103(1): 41–60.
33.
HoskissonRHittM (1990) Antecedents and outcomes of diversification: A review and critique of theoretical perspectives. Journal of Management16(2): 461–509.
34.
HoskissonRCannellaAATihanyiL (2004) Asset restructuring and business group affiliation in French civil law countries. Strategic Management Journal25: 525–539.
35.
JensenMMecklingW (1976) Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure. Journal of Financial Economics3(4): 305–360.
KimHHoskissonREWanWP (2004) Power dependence, diversification and performance in keiretsu member firms. Strategic Management Journal25(7): 613–636.
38.
KimKAl-ShammariHAKimB (2009) CEO leadership and corporate diversification behaviour. Journal of Business Research62(11): 1173–1180.
39.
KleinbaumDKupperLMullerK (1998) Applied Regression Analysis and Other Multivariate Methods, Boston: Duxbury Press.
40.
LaevenLLevineR (2007) Is there a diversification discount in financial conglomerates?Journal of Financial Economics85(2): 331–367.
41.
LubatkinMMerchantHSrinivasanN (1993) Construct validity of some un-weighted product count diversification measures. Strategic Management Journal14(6): 433–449.
42.
MarinelliF (2011) The relationship between diversification and firm's performance: Is there really a causal relationship, Working Paper, IESE Business School: .
43.
MarquardtDSneeR (1975) Ridge regression in practice. The American Statistician29(1): 3–20.
44.
Martínez-CampilloAFernández-GagoR (2011) What about the effects of increasing diversification in response to environmental transformations? The case of Spain. Transformations in Business and Economics10(1): 148–165.
45.
MartynovA (2009) Agents or stewards? Linking managerial behaviour and moral development. Journal of Business Ethics90(2): 239–249.
46.
MayerMCJWhittingtonR (2003) Diversification en context: A cross-national and cross-temporal extension. Strategic Management Journal24(8): 773–781.
47.
MillerD (2004) Firms’ technological resources and the performance effects of diversification: A longitudinal study. Strategic Management Journal25(1): 1097–1119.
48.
MillerD (2006) Technological diversity, related diversification and firm performance. Strategic Management Journal27(7): 601–619.
49.
MillerDLeBreton-MillerI (2006) Family governance and firm performance: Agency, stewardship, and capabilities. Family Business Review19(1): 73–87.
50.
NunnallyJC (1978) Psycometric Theory, New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
51.
O'Reilly CCaldwellDChatmanJ (2010) How leadership matters: The effects of leaders' alignment on strategy implementation. The Leadership Quarterly21(1): 104–113.
52.
PalichLCardinalLMillerC (2000) Curvilinearity in the diversification-performance linkage: An examination of over three decades of research. Strategic Management Journal21(2): 155–174.
53.
PengMDeliosA (2006) What determines the scope of the firm over time and around the world? An Asia Pacific perspective. Asia Pacific Journal of Management23(4): 385–405.
54.
PurkayasthaSManolovaTEdelmanL (2012) Diversification and performance in developed and emerging market contexts. International Journal of Management Reviews14(1): 18–38.
55.
RamaswamyKLiMPettitB (2004) Who drives unrelated diversification? A study of Indian manufacturing firms. Asia Pacific Journal of Management21(4): 403–423.
56.
RamaswamyKLiMVeliyathR (2002) Variations in ownership behavior and propensity to diversify: A study of the Indian corporate context. Strategic Management Journal23(4): 345–358.
57.
RamírezMEspitiaM (2002) The impact of product diversification strategy on the corporate performance of large Spanish firms. Spanish Economic Review4(2): 119–137.
58.
RumeltRP (1982) Diversification strategy and profitability. Strategic Management Journal3(4): 359–369.
59.
Sánchez-Bueno MJ, Galán JI and Suárez-González I (2006) Evolución de la estrategia corporativa y la estructura organizativa en los grandes grupos españoles. Universia Business Review 11(3): 22–35.
60.
SegalLGLehrerM (2012) The institutionalization of stewardship: Theory, propositions, and insights from change in the Edmonton Public Schools. Organization Studies33(2): 169–201.
61.
StoreyJ (2005) What next for strategic-level leadership research?Leadership1(1): 89–104.
62.
Súarez GonzálezI (1994) Estrategia de diversificación y resultados de la empresa española. Revista de Economía Aplicada2(4): 103–128.
63.
TeeceDJ (1982) Towards an economic theory of the multiproduct firm. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization23(1): 1–30.
64.
TosiHLBrownleeALSilvaP (2003) An empirical exploration of decision-making under Agency controls and Stewardship structure. Journal of Management Studies40(8): 2053–2071.
65.
VaradarajanPRamanujamV (1987) Diversification and performance: A re-examination using a new conceptualization of diversifying in firm. Academy of Management Journal30(2): 380–393.
66.
VillalongaB (2004) Diversification discount or premium? New evidence from the business information tracking series. Journal of Finance59(2): 475–502.
67.
WanWPHoskissonREShortJC (2011) Resource-based theory and corporate diversification: Accomplishments and opportunities. Journal of Management37(5): 1335–1369.
68.
WooldridgeJ (2002) Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, Cambridge: MIT Press.
