Antonio Gramsci: The fascist leadership as modern reactionary Caeserism and the novelty of the corporative State

Abstract

Antonio Gramsci’s detention in fascist jails from 1926 to 1937 forced him to see, in a very unpleasant way, the full affirmation of fascism in the vital ganglia of the country. During this pivotal period Gramsci developed a complex analysis of fascism's approach to leadership. He addressed Mussolini’s charisma in relation to the unique aspects of the fascist regime as a corporative system, a feature that was fostered by the mobilization of the petit-bourgeoisie and the depoliticization of the masses. Gramsci refuted Michels’ thesis about charisma and developed his own autonomous path of research, applying Max Weber's study on German militarism in new contexts. It may not be possible to identify a definitive analysis of fascism by Gramsci, but two different visions come to light in the Prison Notebooks, both of which highlight Mussolini's leadership as essential to grasp the idea of fascism as a weak regime or – conversely – as a new state able to ‘Americanize’ the European system of production.

Keywords

Gramsci fascism Mussolini totalitarianism corporativism Italy Marxism political theory elite theory

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baldan

(1978) Gramsci come storico. Studio delle fonti dei ‘quaderni dal carcere’. Bari, Italy: Dedalo Libri.

Bobbio

(1976) Gramsci e la concezione della societa civile. Milan, Italy: Feltrinelli.

Buci-Glucksmann

(1977) Egemonia e teoria dello stato in Gramsci. In: Badaloni

(ed.) Attualità di Gramsci, L’egemonia, lo stato, la cultura, il metodo, il partito. Milan, Italy: Il saggiatore. 53–71.

Buci-Glucksmann

(1980) Gramsci and the State. London: Lawrence and Wishart.

Buttigieg JA (1992) Preface and introduction. In: Gramsci A Prison Notebooks (vol. 1). Ed. Buttigieg JA. New York: Columbia University Press.

Caprioglio

(1962) Un mancato incontro Gramsci-D’Annunzio a Gardone nell’aprile 1921 (con una testimonianza di Palmiro Togliatti). Rivista storica del socialismo V. 263–273.

Cassese

(1968) Corporazioni e intervento pubblico nell'economia. Quaderni storici delle Marche 3: 402–457.

De Felice

(1973) Fascismo, democrazia e fronte popolare. Rome-Bari: Laterza.

De Man

(l974) Au-delà du marxisme. Paris: Editions du Seuil.

10.

Einaudi

(2002) Lezioni di politica sociale. Turin, Italy: Einaudi.

11.

Gramsci

(1966) A Marinetti il Rivoluzionario? 5 January 1921. In: Gramsci

(ed.) Socialismo e fascismo. L'ordine nuovo 1921–1922. Turin, Italy: Einaudi.

12.

Gramsci

(1971) Selections from the Prison Notebooks. New York: International Publishers.

13.

Gramsci A (1975a) Quaderni del Carcere (vol.1). Ed. Gerratana V. Turin, Italy: Einaudi.

14.

Gramsci A (1975b) Quaderni del Carcere (vol.2). Ed. Gerratana V. Turin, Italy: Einaudi.

15.

Green

Ives

(2009) Subalternity and language: Overcoming the fragmentation of common sense. Historical Materialism 17(1): 3–30.

16.

Michels R (1927) Some reflections on the sociological character of political parties. In: The American Political Science Review XXI: 753–772.

17.

Michels

(1931) Authority. In: Edwin

Seligman

Johnson

(eds). Encyclopaedia of the Social Sciences. Vol. 2: Alliance – Brigandage. New York: The Macmillan Co.. 319–321.

18.

Santomassimo

(2006) La terza via fascista. Il mito del corporativismo. Rome: Carocci.

19.

Tuccari

(1993) Il leader politico e l’eroe carismatico Carisma e democrazia nell’opera politica e sociologica di Max Weber e di Robert Michels. Annali di Sociologia Soziologisches Jahrbuch 9: 72–92.