Using insights from conversation analysis, the article analyses aphorisms from 20
different writers demonstrating how these combine common rhetorical formats. It then
proposes a simple framework that allows for aphorisms to be analysed further and in
terms of two continua: whether they are convex or concave, and whether they are
creative or destructive. The framework supplements content-based approaches with a
structural account of how aphorisms may be organized and deployed. This offers a new
approach for studying leaders’ rhetoric and introduces a more detailed
analysis of two speeches acknowledged as powerful pieces of oratory: Marcus
Antonius’ address inJulius Caesar, and Churchill’s
first speech as Prime Minister. Discussion of these speeches is informed by
consideration of two contextual features that influence the impact of aphorisms:
setting and sequence.
Aristotle (5th Century BCE/n.d.) Rhetoric (based on translation by W
Rhys-Roberts). Last accessed May 12, 2006. Available at: www.public.iastate.edu/%7Ehoneyl/Rhetoric/
2.
Aronoff, M.
, &
Rees-Miller, J.
(eds) (2001) The Handbook of Linguistics.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
3.
Atkinson, J. M.
(1984) Our Masters’ Voices: The Language and Body
Language of Politics.
London: Methuen
.
4.
Atkinson, J. M.
(1985) ‘Refusing Invited Applause: Preliminary
Observations from a Case Study of Charismatic Oratory’, in
T. A. van Dijk
(ed.) Handbook of Discourse Analysis, pp.
161-181.
London: Academic Press
.
5.
Awamleh, R.
, &
Gardner, W. L.
(1999)
‘Perceptions of Leader Charisma and Effectiveness: The Effects of
Vision Content, Delivery, and Organizational Performance’
, Leadership Quarterly10:
345-373
.
6.
Bligh, M. C.
,
Kohles, J. C.
, &
Meindl, J. R.
(2004)
‘Charisma under Crisis: Presidential Leadership, Rhetoric, and
Media Responses Before and After the September 11th Terrorist Attacks’
, Leadership Quarterly15(2):
211-239
.
7.
Cannadine, D.
(ed.) (1990) Blood, Toil, Tears and Sweat: Winston
Churchill’s Famous Speeches.
London: Cassell
.
8.
Carnegie, D.
(1981) How to Win Friends and Influence People.
London: Pocket Books
.
9.
Churchill, W. S.
(1939) Step by Step: 1936-1939.
London: Thornton Butterworth
.
10.
Churchill, W. S.
(1941)
‘Blood, Toil, Tears and Sweat’
. Speech to Parliament. Last accessed May 12, 2006.
Available at: www.winstonchurchill.org
11.
Clayman, S. E.
(1993)
‘Booing: The Anatomy of a Disaffiliative Response’
, American Sociological Review58(1):
110-130
.
12.
Clayman, S. E.
(1995)
‘Defining Moments, Presidential Debates and the Dynamics of Quotability’
, Journal of Communication45(3):
118-132
.
13.
Clayton, E. W.
(2004)
‘The Audience for Aristotle’s Rhetoric’
, RhetoricaXXII(2):
183-203
.
14.
Confucius
(1996) The Analects.
London: Wordsworth Classics
.
15.
Conger, J. A.
(1991)
‘Inspiring Others: The Language of Leadership’
, Academy of Management Executive5(1):
31-45
.
16.
Covey, S. R.
(1992) The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People.
London: Simon and Schuster
.
17.
Davis, M.
(1999)
‘Aphorisms and Clichés: The Generation and Dissipation
of Conceptual Charisma’
, Annual Review of Sociology25:
245-269
.
18.
Del Caro, A.
(2004)
‘Nietzsche’s Rhetoric on the Grounds of Philology and Hermeneutics’
, Philosophy and Rhetoric37(2):
101-122
.
19.
Den Hartog, D. N.
, &
Verburg, R. M.
(1997)
‘Charisma and Rhetoric: The Communicative Techniques of
International Business Leaders’
, Leadership Quarterly8(4):
355-391
.
20.
Foucault M.
(1969/2002) The Archaeology of Knowledge.
London: Routledge
.
21.
Gándara, L.
(2004)
‘“They That Sow the Wind...”: Proverbs and
Sayings in Argumentation’
, Discourse and Society15(2-3):
345-359
.
22.
Gibran, K.
(1923/1996) The Prophet.
London: Wordsworth Classics
.
23.
Gioia, D. A.
(1986) ‘Symbols, Scripts and Sensemaking:
Creating Meaning in the Organizational Experience’, in
H. Sims
&
D. A. Gioia
(eds) The Thinking Organization, pp. 49-74.
San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass
.
24.
Gioia, D. A.
, &
Poole, P. P.
(1984)
‘Scripts in Organizational Behavior’
, Academy of Management Review9(3):
449-459
.
25.
Gracián, B.
(1685/1994) The Art of Worldly Wisdom.
London: Mandarin
.
26.
Greatbatch, D.
, &
Clark, T.
(2003)
‘Humour and Laughter in the Public Lectures of Management Gurus’
, Human Relations56(12):
1515-1544
.
27.
Grint, K.
(2000) The Arts of Leadership.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
28.
Grint, K.
(2005)
‘Problems, Problems, Problems: The Social Construction of “Leadership”’
, Human Relations58(11):
1467-1494
.
29.
Huisman, M.
(2001).
‘Decision-making in Meetings as Talk-in-interaction’
, International Studies in Management and Organization31(3):
69-90
.
30.
Jenkins, R.
(2002) Churchill.
London: Pan
.
31.
Kenko
(1998) Essays in Idleness.
London: Wordsworth Classics
.
32.
Kenny, A.
(1973) Wittgenstein.
Harmondsworth: Penguin
.
33.
La Rochefoucauld, F.
(1665/1959) Maxims.
Harmondsworth: Penguin
.
34.
Langworth, R. M.
(2005)
‘“Blood, Toil, Tears and Sweat”: Evolution of
a Phrase’
, Finest Hour,
128-128
.
35.
Machiavelli, N.
(1532/1984) The Prince.
London: Penguin
.
36.
Mercer, D.
(ed.) (1989) Chronicle of the Twentieth Century.
London: Longman
.
37.
Merrow, K.
(2003)
‘“The Meaning of Every Style”: Nietzsche,
Demosthenes, Rhetoric’
, RhetoricaXXI(4):
285-307
.
38.
Mill, J. S.
(1859/1985) On Liberty.
London: Penguin Classics
.
39.
Morgan, G.
(1997) Images of Organization.
London: SAGE
.
40.
Morrell, K.
(2004)
‘Socratic Dialogue as a Tool for Teaching Business Ethics’
, Journal of Business Ethics53(4):
325-331
.
41.
Morrell, K.
, &
Hartley, J.
(2006)
‘A Model of Political Leadership’
, Human Relations59(4):
483-550
.
42.
Nietzsche, F.
(1886/1973) Beyond Good and Evil.
Harmondsworth: Penguin
.
43.
Okamoto, D. G.
, &
Smith-Lovin, L.
(2001)
‘Changing the Subject: Gender, Status, and the Dynamics of Topic Change’
, American Sociological Review66(6):
852-873
.
44.
Proctor, S.
,
Papasolomou-Dukakis, I.
, &
Proctor, T.
(2002)
‘What Are Television Advertisements Really Trying to Tell Us? A
Postmodern Perspective’
, Journal of Consumer Behaviour1(3):
246-255
.
45.
Reps, P.
(1991) Zen Flesh, Zen Bones.
London: Penguin
.
46.
Schank, R. C.
, &
Abelson, R. P.
(1977) Scripts, Plans, Goals and Understanding: An Inquiry
into Human Knowledge Structures.
Mahawah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
.
47.
Shakespeare, W.
(1599/1962) ‘Julius Ceasar’,
in
W. J. Craig
(ed.) The Complete Works of William Shakespeare.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
48.
Shamir, B.
,
Arthur, M. B.
, &
House, R. J.
(1994)
‘The rhetoric of Charismatic Leadership: A Theoretical Extension,
a Case Study, and Implications for Research’
, Leadership Quarterly5(1):
25-42
.
49.
Sun Tzu
(4th Century BCE/1971) The Art of War.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
50.
Tanner, M. K.
(1995) Nietzsche.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
51.
Weidhorn, M.
(1972)
‘Churchill the Phrase Forger’
, Quarterly Journal of Speech58(2):
161-174
.
52.
Weidhorn, M.
(1975)
‘Blood, Toil, Tears, and 8,000,000 Words: Churchill Writing’
, The Columbia Forum4 (Spring):
19-23
.
53.
Wittgenstein, L.
(1921/2001) Tractatus Logico-philosophicus.
London: Routledge
.
