This article offers three explanations for why some leaders embrace the skill of
framing and others struggle with it. The first explanation draws from
philosophical arguments in social constructionism over relativism, essentialism,
and agency to draw boundaries around that which is open to framing and that
which is not. The second explanation draws from O’Keefe’s
(1988; 1997) theory of ‘Message Design Logics’, which argues
that the logics that managers employ to produce and receive messages likely
impacts framing ability. The third explanation grapples with questions of
whether framing is a teachable skill and the contingencies associated with
effective learning. Finally, the article concludes with an argument for the
interrelationship among the three explanations.
Alexander, H. G.
(1969) Meaning and Language.
Glennview, IL: Scott Foresman
.
2.
Alvesson, M.
, &
Sveningsson, S.
(2003)
‘Good Visions, Bad Micro-management and Ugly Ambiguity:
Contradictions of a (Non-)Leadership in a Knowledge-intensive Organization’
, Organization Studies24:
961-988
.
3.
Astley, W. G.
(1985)
‘Administrative Science as Socially Constructed Truth’
, Administrative Science Quarterly30:
497-513
.
4.
Axley, S. R.
(1984)
‘Managerial and Organizational Communication in Terms of the
Conduit Metaphor’
, Academy of Management Review9:
428-437
.
5.
Barge, J. K.
(2001)
‘Practical Theory as Mapping, Engaged Reflection, and
Transformative Practice’
, Communication Theory11:
5-13
.
6.
Barge, J. K.
(2004)
‘Reflexivity and Managerial Practice’
, Communication Monographs71:
70-96
.
7.
Barge, J. K.
, &
Little, M.
(2002)
‘Dialogical Wisdom, Communicative Practice, and Organizational Life’
, Communication Theory12:
375-397
.
8.
Barge, J. K.
, &
Oliver, C.
(2003)
‘Working with Appreciation in Managerial Practice’
, Academy of Management Review28:
124-142
.
9.
Bargh, J. A.
(1989) ‘Conditional Automasticity: Varieties of
Automatic Influence in Social Perception and Cognition’, in
J. S. Uleman
&
J. A. Bargh
(eds) Unintended Thought, pp. 3-51.
New York: Guilford
.
10.
Bartunek, J. M.
(1988) ‘The Dynamics of Personal and
Organizational Reframing’, in
R. E. Quinn
&
K. S. Cameron
(eds) Paradox and Transformation: Toward a Theory of Change in
Organizations and Management, pp. 137-162.
Cambridge, MA: Ballinger
.
11.
Bass, B. M.
(1985) Leader and Performance: Beyond Expectations.
New York: Free Press
.
12.
Bass, B. M.
(1988) ‘Evolving Perspectives on Charismatic
Leadership’, in
J. A. Conger
&
R. N. Kanungo
(eds) Charismatic Leadership, pp. 40-77.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
13.
Bateson, G.
(1972) Steps to an Ecology of the Mind.
New York: Ballentine
.
14.
Bazerman, M. H.
(1984)
‘The Relevance of Kahneman and Tversky’s Concept of
Framing to Organizational Behavior’
, Journal of Management10:
333-343
.
15.
Becker, H. S.
(1963) Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance.
New York: Free Press
.
16.
Benson, J. K.
(1977)
‘Organizations: A Dialectical View’
, Administrative Science Quarterly22:
1-21
.
17.
Berger, P.
, &
Luckman, T. L.
(1966) The Social Construction of Knowledge: A Treatise on
the Sociology of Knowledge.
Garden City, NY: Doubleday
.
18.
Bryman, A.
(1992) Charisma and Leadership in Organizations.
London: SAGE
.
19.
Bryman, A.
(1996) ‘Leadership in
Organizations’, in
S. R. Clegg
,
C. Hardy
&
W. R. Nord
(eds) Handbook of Organization Studies, pp.
276-292.
London: SAGE
.
20.
Buzzanell, P. M.
(1996)
‘Book Review of The Art of Framing: Managing the Language of Leadership
by G. T. Fairhurst and R. A. Sarr’, Management
Communication Quarterly10:
243-254
.
21.
Calder, B. J.
(1977) ‘An Attribution Theory of
Leadership’, in
B. M. Staw
&
G. R. Salancik
(eds) New Directions in Organizational Behavior, pp.
179-202.
Chicago: St. Clair Press
.
22.
Carragee, K. M.
, &
Roefs, W.
(2004)
‘The Neglect of Power in Recent Framing Research’
, Journal of Communication54:
214-233
.
23.
Chia, R.
(2000)
‘Discourse Analysis as Organizational Analysis’
, Organization7:
513-518
.
24.
Cicourel, A. V.
(1972) ‘Basic and Normative Rules in the
Negotiation of Status and Role’, in
D. Sudnow
(ed.) Studies in Social Interaction, pp.
229-258.
New York: Free Press
.
25.
Clair, R. P.
(1994)
‘Resistance and Oppression as a Self-contained Opposite: An
Organizational Communication Analysis of One Man’s story of Sexual Harassment’
, Western Journal of Communication58:
235-262
.
26.
Clair, R. P.
(1998) Organizing Silence: a World of Possibilities.
Albany, NY: SUNY Press
.
27.
Collinson, D. L.
(1988)
‘ “ Engineering Humor”: Masculinity, Joking
and Conflict in Shop-floor Relations’
, Organization Studies9:
181-199
.
28.
Collinson, D. L.
(1992) Managing the Shop Floor: Subjectivity, Masculinity,
and Workplace Culture.
New York: Walter de Gruyter
.
29.
Collinson, D. L.
(2003)
‘Identities and Insecurities: Selves at Work.’Organization10:
527-547
.
30.
Conger, J. A.
(1989) The Charismatic Leader.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
31.
Conger, J. A.
(1991)
‘Inspiring Others: The Language of Leadership’
, The Executive5:
31-45
.
32.
Conger, J. A.
, &
Kanungo, R. M.
(1987)
‘Toward a Behavioral Theory of Charismatic Leadership in
Organizational Settings’
, Academy of Management Review12:
637-647
.
33.
Conger, J. A.
, &
Kanungo, R. N.
(1988) ‘Training Charismatic Leadership: A Risky
and Critical Task’, in
J. A. Conger
&
R. N. Kanungo
(eds) Charismatic Leadership, pp. 309-323.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
34.
Cooperrider, D.
,
Barrett, F.
, &
Srivastva, S.
(1995) ‘Social Construction and Appreciative
Inquiry: A Journey in Organizational Theory’, in
D. Hosking
,
P. Dachler
&
K. Gergen
(eds) Management and Organization: Relational Alterantives to
Individualism, pp. 157-200.
Aldershot: Avebury Press
.
35.
Courtright, J. A.
,
Fairhurst, G. T.
, &
Rogers, L. E.
(1989)
‘Interaction Patterns in Organic and Mechanistic Systems’
, Academy of Management Journal32:
773-802
.
36.
Cunliffe, A. L.
(2001)
‘Managers as Practical Authors: Reconstructing Our Understanding
of Managerial Practice’
, Journal of Management Studies38:
350-371
.
37.
Cunliffe, A. L.
(2002)
‘Social Poetics as Management Inquiry: A Dialogical Approach’
, Journal of Management Inquiry11:
128-146
.
38.
Deetz, S. A.
(1992) Democracy in an Age of Corporate Colonization:
Developments in Communication and the Politics of Everday Life.
New York: State University of New York Press
.
39.
Dewey, J.
(1938) Logic: the Theory of Inquiry.
New York: Basic Books
.
40.
Ellis, D. G.
(1995)
‘Fixing Communicative Meaning: A Coherentist Theory’
, Communication Research22:
515-544
.
41.
Entman, R.
(1993)
‘Framing: Toward a Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm’
, Journal of Communication43:
51-58
.
42.
Fairhurst, G. T.
(1993a)
‘Echoes of the Vision: When the Rest of the Organization Talks
Total Quality’
, Management Communication Quarterly6:
331-371
.
43.
Fairhurst, G. T.
(1993b)
‘The Leader-Member Exchange Patterns of Women Leaders in
Industry: A Discourse Analysis’
, Communication Monographs60:
321-351
.
44.
Fairhurst, G. T.
(2001) ‘Dualisms in Leadership
Research’, in
F. M. Jablin
&
L. L. Putnam
(eds) The New Handbook of Organizational Communication, pp.
379-439.
Newbury Park, CA: SAGE
.
45.
Fairhurst, G. T.
(in press) ‘Liberating Leadership in Corporation After Mr.
Sam: A Response’, in
F. Cooren
(ed.) Interacting and Organizing: Analyses of a Board Meeting.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
46.
Fairhurst, G. T.
, &
Chandler, T. A.
(1989)
‘Social Structure in Leader-Member Interaction’
, Communication Monographs56:
215-239
.
47.
Fairhurst, G. T.
, &
Sarr, R. A.
(1996) The Art of Framing: Managing the Language of
Leadership.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
48.
Fairhurst, G. T.
,
Cooren, F.
, &
Cahill, D.
(2002)
‘Discursiveness, Contradiction and Unintended Consequences in
Successive Downsizings’
, Management Communication Quarterly15:
501-540
.
49.
Fairhurst, G. T.
,
Green, S. G.
, &
Courtright, J. A.
(1995)
‘Inertial Forces and the Implementation of a Socio-technical
Systems Approach: A Communication Study’
, Organization Science6:
168-185
.
50.
Fairhurst, G. T.
,
Rogers, L. E.
, &
Sarr, R.
(1987) ‘Manager-subordinate Control Patterns and
Judgments About the Relationship’, in
M. McLaughlin
(ed.) Communication Yearbook 10, pp.
395-415.
Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE
.
51.
Foucault, M.
(1972) The Archeology of Knowledge and the Discourse on
Language.
London: Tavistock Publications
.
52.
Foucault, M.
(1980) The History of Sexuality.
New York: Vintage
.
53.
Foucault, M.
(1982) ‘The Subject and
Power’, in
H. L. Dreyfus
&
P. Rabinow
(eds) Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics, pp.
208-226.
Chicago: Chicago University Press
.
54.
Gemmil, G.
, &
Oakley, J.
(1992)
‘Leadership: An Alienating Social Myth?’
, Human Relations45:
113-129
.
55.
Giddens, A.
(1979) Central Problems in Social Theory.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
56.
Giddens, A.
(1984) The Constitution of Society.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
57.
Gioia, D. A.
(2003)
‘Give It Up! Reflections on the Interpreted World (a Commentary
on Meckler and Baillie)’
, Journal of Management Inquiry12:
285-292
.
58.
Goffman, E.
(1974) Frame Analysis.
Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press
.
59.
Gove, W. R. E.
(1980) The Labeling of Deviance.
Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE
.
60.
Grint, K.
(1997) Leadership: Classical, Contemporary, and Critical
Approaches.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
61.
Grint, K.
(2000) The Arts of Leadership.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
62.
Gronn, P.
(2002)
‘Distributed Leadership as a Unit of Analysis’
, Leadership Quarterly13:
423-451
.
63.
Hacking, I.
(1999) The Social Construction of What?Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
64.
Hargreaves, D. H.
,
Hester, S. K.
, &
Mellor, F. J.
(1975) Deviance in Classrooms.
London: Routledge & Kegan Paul
.
65.
Harré, R.
(1994) Discursive Psychology.
London: SAGE
.
66.
Harré, R. E.
(1986) The Social Construction of Emotions.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
67.
Holman, D.
, &
Thorpe, R.
(eds) (2003) Management and Language: The Manager as
Practical Author.
London: SAGE
.
68.
Holmer Nadesan, M.
(1996)
‘Organizational Identity and Space of Action’
, Organization Studies17:
49-81
.
69.
Honig-Haftel, S.
(1996)
‘Book Review of The Art of Framing: Managing the Language of Leadership
by G. T. Fairhurst and R. A. Sarr’, Academy of Management Executive10:
97-98
.
70.
Hoskin, K.
(2004)
‘Spacing, Timing and the Invention of Management’
, Organization11:
743-757
.
71.
House, R. J.
(1977) ‘A 1976 Theory of Charismatic
Leadership’, in
J. G. Hunt
&
L. L. Larson
(eds) Leadership: The Cutting Edge, pp.
189-207.
Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press
.
72.
Husserl, E.
(1962) Ideas: General Introduction to Pure
Phenomenology.
London: Collier-Macmillan
.
73.
Johnson, C.
(1997)
‘Book Review of The Art of Framing: Managing the Language of Leadership
by G. T. Fairhurst and R. A. Sarr’, The Journal of
Leadership Studies4:
171-173
.
74.
Kahneman, D.
, &
Tversky, A.
(1979)
‘Prospect Theory: an Analysis of Decision Under Risk’
, Econometrica47:
263-292
.
75.
Kerfoot, D.
, &
Knights, D.
(1996) ‘ “ The Best Is Yet To
Come?”: The Quest for Embodiment in Managerial
Work’, in
D. L. Collinson
&
J. Hearn
(eds) Men As Managers, Managers As Men, pp.
78-98.
London: SAGE
.
76.
Kerr, S.
, &
Jermier, J. M.
(1978)
‘Substitutes for Leadership: Their Meaning and Measurement’
, Organizational Behavior and Human Performance12:
374-403
.
77.
Kets de Vries, M. F. R.
(1990)
‘The Organizational Fool: Balancing a Leader’s Hubris’
, Human Relations43:
751-770
.
78.
Kets de Vries, M. F. R.
(1991)
‘Whatever Happened to the Philosopher-king? The
Leader’s Addiction to Power’
, Journal of Management Studies28:
339-351
.
79.
Kets de Vries, M. F. R.
, &
Miller, D.
(1985)
‘Narcissism and Leadership: An Object Relations Perspective’
, Human Relations38:
583-601
.
80.
Knights, D.
, &
Wilmott, H.
(1992)
‘Conceptualizing Leadership Processes: A Study of Senior Managers
in a Financial Services Company’
, Journal of Management Studies29:
761-782
.
81.
Kotter, J. P.
(1990) A Force for Change: How Leadership Differs from
Management.
New York: Free Press
.
82.
Laclau, E.
, &
Mouffe, C.
(1985) Hegemony and Socialist Strategy.
London: Verso
.
83.
Latour, B.
(1994)
‘On Technical Mediation: Philosophy, Sociology, Genealogy’
, Common Knowledge3:
29-64
.
84.
Meindl, J. R.
(1993) ‘Reinventing Leadership: A Radical,
Social Psychological Approach’, in
J. K. Munighan
(ed.) Social Psychology in Organizations: Advances in Theory and
Research, pp. 89-118.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
85.
Meindl, J. R.
,
Ehrlich, S. B.
, &
Dukerich, J. M.
(1985)
‘The Romance of Leadership’
, Administrative Science Quarterly30:
78-102
.
86.
Mumby, D. K.
(1997)
‘The Problem of Hegemony: Rereading Gramsci for Organizational
Communication Studies’
, Western Journal of Communication61:
343-375
.
87.
Mumby, D. K.
, &
Ashcraft, L. L.
(2004) Reworking Gender: A Feminist Communicology of
Organizations.
Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE
.
88.
Neale, M. A.
,
Huber, V. L.
, &
Northcraft, G. B.
(1987)
‘The Framing of Negotiations: Contextual Versus Task Frames’
, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes39:
228-241
.
89.
O’Keefe, B. J.
(1988)
‘The Logic Of Message Design: Individual Differences in Reasoning
About Communication’
, Communication Monographs55:
80-103
.
90.
O’Keefe, B. J.
(1991) ‘Message Design Logic and the Management
of Multiple Goals’, in
K. Tracy
(ed.) Understanding Face-to-Face Interaction: Issues Linking Goals and
Discourse, pp. 131-150.
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
91.
O’Keefe, B. J.
(1992)
‘Developing and Testing Rational Models of Message Design’
, Human Communication Research18:
637-649
.
92.
O’Keefe, B. J.
(1997) ‘Variation, Adaptation, and Functional
Explanation in the Study of Message Design’, in
G. Philipsen
(ed.) Developing Communication Theories, pp.
85-118.
Albany, NY: SUNY Press
.
93.
O’Keefe, B. J.
, &
Lambert, B.
(1989) Effects of Message Design Logic on the Communication
of Intention.
San Francisco: Speech Communication Association
.
94.
O’Keefe, B. J.
, &
Lambert, B.
(1995) ‘Managing the Flow of Ideas: A Local
Management Approach to Message Design’, in
B. R. Burleson
(ed.) Communication Yearbook 18, pp. 54-82.
Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE
.
95.
O’Keefe, B. J.
, &
Shepherd, G. J.
(1987)
‘The Pursuit of Multiple Objectives in Face-to-Face Persuasive
Interactions: Effects of Construct Differentiation on Message Organization’
, Communication Monographs54:
396-419
.
96.
O’Keefe, B. J.
,
Lambert, B. L.
, &
Lambert, C. A.
(1993) Effects of Message Design Logic on Perceived
Communication Effectiveness in Supervisory Relationships.
Washington, DC: International Communication Association
.
97.
Parker, I.
(1998) Social Constructionism, Discourse and Realism.
London: SAGE
.
98.
Pearce, W. B.
, &
Cronen, V. E.
(1980) Communication, Action, and Meaning.
New York: Praeger
.
99.
Pondy, L. R.
(1978) ‘Leadership is a Language
Game’, in
J. M.W. McCall
&
M. M. Lombardo
(eds) Leadership: Where Else Can We Go?, pp.
88-99.
Durham, NC: Duke University Press
.
100.
Potter, J.
(1996) Representing Reality: Discourse, Rhetoric and Social
Construction.
London: SAGE
.
101.
Price, V.
, &
Tewksbury, D.
(1997) ‘News Values and Public Opinion: A
Theoretical Account of Media Priming and Framing’, in
G. Barnett
&
F. Boster
(eds) Progress in Communication Sciences: Advances in Persuasion,
pp. 173-212.
Greenwich, CT: Ablex
.
102.
Putnam, L. L.
, &
Holmer, M.
(1992) ‘Framing, Reframing, and Issue
Development’, in
L. L. Putnam
&
M. E. Roloff
(eds) Communication and Negotiation, pp.
128-155.
Newbury Park, CA: SAGE
.
103.
Reed, M.
(2000)
‘The Limits of Discourse Analysis in Organization Analysis’
, Organization7:
524-530
.
104.
Rorty, R.
(1989) Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity.
Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press
.
105.
Rost, J. C.
(1991) Leadership for the Twenty-first Century.
New York: Praeger
.
106.
Searle, J. R.
(1995) The Construction of Social Reality.
New York: Free Press
.
107.
Senge, P.
(1990) The Fifth Discipline.
New York: Doubleday
.
108.
Shamir, B.
(1998)
‘Book Review of The Art of Framing: Managing the Language of Leadership
by G. T. Fairhurst and R. A. Sarr’, Leadership Quarterly9:
123-126
.
109.
Shamir, B.
(1999)
‘Leadership in Boundaryless Organizations: Disposable or Indispensible’
, European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology8:
49-71
.
110.
Shamir, B.
,
House, R. J.
, &
Arthur, M. B.
(1993)
‘The Motivational Effects of Charismatic Leadership: A
Self-concept Based Theory’
, Organization Science4:
577-594
.
111.
Shannon, C.
, &
Weaver, W.
(1949) The Mathemetical Theory of Communication.
Urbana: University of Illinois Press
.
112.
Shotter, J.
(1993) Conversational Realities: Constructing Life Through
Language.
London: SAGE
.
113.
Shotter, J.
, &
Cunliffe, A. L.
(2003) ‘Managers as Practical Authors: Everyday
Conversations for Action’, in
D. Holman
&
R. Thorpe
(eds) Management and Language, pp. 1-37.
London: SAGE
.
114.
Simons, H.
(1976) Persuasion: Understanding, Practice, and
Analysis.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
.
115.
Smircich, L.
, &
Morgan, G.
(1982)
‘Leadership: The Management of Meaning’
, Journal of Applied Behavioral Science18:
257-273
.
116.
Stohl, C.
(2001) ‘Globalizing Organizational
Communication’, in
F. M. Jablin
&
L. L. Putnam
(eds) The New Handbook of Organizational Communication, pp.
323-378.
Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE
.
117.
Tannen, D.
(1979) ‘What’s in a Frame? Surface
Evidence for Underlying Expectations’, in
R. O. Freedle
(ed.) New Directions in Discourse Processing, pp.
137-181.
Norwood, NJ: Ablex
.
118.
Tsoukas, H.
(2000)
‘False Dilemmas in Organization Theory: Realism or Social Constructivism’
, Organization7:
531-535
.
119.
Tversky, A.
, &
Kahneman, D.
(1981)
‘The Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice’
, Science211:
453-458
.
120.
Waldron, V.
, &
Cegala, D. J.
(1992)
‘Assessing Conversational Cognition: Levels of Cognitive Theory
and Associated Methodological Requirements’
, Human Communication Research18:
599-622
.
121.
Weick, K.
(1979) The Social Psychology of Organizing.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
.
122.
Weick, K.
(1981) ‘Psychology as Gloss: Reflections on
Usefulness and Application,’ in
R. A. Kasschau
&
C. N. Cofer
(eds) Psychology’s Second Century: Enduring Issues, pp.
110-132.
New York: Praeger
.
123.
Willihnganz, S.
,
Hart, J. L.
, &
Willard, C. A.
(2002) ‘The Logic of Message Design in
Organizational Argument’, in
D. Holman
&
R. Thorpe
(eds) Management and Language: the Manager as a Practical Author,
pp. 104-120.
London: SAGE
.
124.
Wittgenstein, L.
(1953) Philosophical Investigations.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
125.
Zaleznik, A.
(1977)
‘Managers and Leaders: Are They Different?’
, Harvard Business Review55:
67-78
.
