Sensing the border(s): Sound and carceral intimacies in and beyond indefinite detention

Abstract

This article examines a sound-based digital project co-created with refugees and asylum seekers held in indefinite detention in Australia and Papua New Guinea to advance understandings of the sensory violence of borders – and resistance to borders – and their reordering of intimate realms. In where are you today (2020), refugees/asylum seekers catalogued their carceral environments in 10-minute sonic vignettes which were distributed to listeners daily via text message, for 30 consecutive days. Drawing on sensory methodologies and feminist orientations towards the intimate, the article considers how this sound project alerts us to an alternative sensory politics attuned to the quiet, quotidian and exhausting labour of resisting Australia’s racialised border regime. Through a close listening to selected recordings, we argue the intimacies shared through where are you today produce knowledge about embodied practices of care, breath, touch and waiting in indefinite detention. Networked, transborder sound projects can unsettle both incarcerated and non-incarcerated subjects’ relationships to their environments, opening affiliative possibilities for coming into relation with the border(s) in new ways. We conclude that the project’s creators forge and sustain carceral intimacies within and despite the border’s affective violence, and that sound is a particularly affective and evocative means of conveying and creating these intimacies, in and beyond indefinite detention.

Keywords

Borders carceral intimacy indefinite detention migration policy politics of listening sensory criminology

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahmed

(2000). Strange Encounters: Embodied Others in Post-Coloniality. Routledge.

Bandesh

Rahmati

Brooks

(2021) I call it a prison because it is a prison. Infrastructural Inequalities 2 (Policing, Crisis, Abolition): 1–10.

Berlant

(1998). Intimacy: A special issue. Critical Inquiry 24(2): 281–288.

Blagg

Anthony

(2019) Decolonising Criminology: Imagining Justice in a Postcolonial World. Palgrave Macmillan.

Boochani

(2018) No Friend but the Mountains: Writing From Manus Prison (trans. Tofighian

Omid

). Pan MacMillan.

Boochani

(2020) The ‘politicisation of seeking asylum’ webinar. Challenging Racism Project, University of Western Sydney. Available at: https://www.westernsydney.edu.au/challengingracism/challenging_racism_project (accessed 19 April 2021).

Brooks

(2020) Listening beyond the border: Self-representation, witnessing, and the white sonic field. Law Text Culture 24(1): 96–116.

Brown

Carrabine

(2019) The critical foundations of visual criminology: The state, crisis, and the sensory. Critical Criminology 27(1): 191–205.

Bull

Back

(2015) The Auditory Culture Reader, 2nd edn. Routledge.

10.

Burridge

Gill

Kocher

, et al. (2017) Polymorphic borders. Territory, Politics, Governance 5(3): 239–251.

11.

Butler

(2009) Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? Verso.

12.

Butler

(2016) Rethinking vulnerability as resistance. In Butler

Gambetti

Sabsay

(eds) Vulnerability in Resistance. Duke University Press, pp. 12–27.

13.

Campt

(2017) Listening to Images. Duke University Press.

14.

Dao

(2018) ‘How are you today’ at the Ian Potter Museum of Art. The Monthly, October 9.

15.

Dao

(2020) What I heard about Manus Island (when I listened to 14 hours of recordings from Manus Island). Law Text Culture 24: 60–78.

16.

Dao

Boochani

(2020) Interview: André Dao and Behrouz Boochani. Law Text Culture 24: 50–59.

17.

Dehm

Loughnan

Steele

(2021) COVID-19 and sites of confinement: Public health, disposable lives and legal accountability in immigration detention and aged care. University of New South Wales Law Journal 44(1): 60–103.

18.

Department of Immigration and Border Protection (DIBP) (2017) Immigration detention facilities and detainee services contract between the Commonwealth of Australia and Serco Australia. Available at: https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/foi/files/2017/FA161000977-documents-released.pdf (accessed 8 August 2021)

19.

de Souza

(2018) What does racial (in) justice sound like? On listening, acoustic violence and the booing of Adam Goodes. Continuum 32(4): 459–473.

20.

de Souza

(2020) Beyond the Horizon of the State: Listening to offshore detention’s longue durée. Law Text Culture 24(1): 4.

21.

Doughty

Lagerqvist

(2016) The ethical potential of sound in public space: Migrant pan flute music and its potential to create moments of conviviality in a ‘failed’ public square. Emotion, Space and Society 20: 58–67.

22.

Emejulu

Bassel

(2020) The politics of exhaustion. City 24(1–2): 400–406.

23.

Fanon

(1965) A Dying Colonialism. Grove/Atlantic, Inc.

24.

Fleetwood

(2015) Posing in prison: Family photographs, emotional labor, and carceral intimacy. Public Culture 27(3): 487–511.

25.

Gallagher

Kanngieser

Prior

(2017) Listening geographies: Landscape, affect and geotechnologies. Progress in Human Geography 41(5): 618–637.

26.

Giannacopoulos

Loughnan

(2020) ‘Closure’ at Manus Island and carceral expansion in the open air prison. Globalizations 17(7): 1118–1135.

27.

Gill

(2017) Health and intimacies in immigration detention. In Hiemstra

Conlon

(eds) Intimate Economies of Immigration Detention. Routledge, pp.171–186.

28.

Hartman

(1997) Scenes of subjection: Terror, slavery, and self-making in nineteenth-century America. Oxford University Press.

29.

Hemsworth

(2016) ‘Feeling the range’: Emotional geographies of sound in prisons. Emotion, Space and Society 20: 90–97.

30.

Herrity

Schmidt

Warr

(2021) Sensory Penalities: Exploring the Senses in Spaces of Punishment and Social Control. Emerald.

31.

Hjorth

Lim

(2012) Mobile intimacy in an age of affective mobile media. Feminist Media Studies 12(4): 477–484.

32.

Keenan

(2020) What is the Australian border? Overland, 10 August. Available at: https://overland.org.au/2020/08/what-is-the-australian-border/ (accessed 6 August 2021).

33.

Kushner

(2020) Carceral aesthetics: Nicole R. Fleetwood in conversation with Rachel Kushner. Artforum. Available at: https://www.artforum.com/print/202007/nicole-r-fleetwood-in-conversation-with-rachel-kushner-83681 (accessed 6 August 2021).

34.

LaBelle

(2015) Background Noise: Perspectives on Sound Art. Bloomsbury.

35.

Lacey

(2011) Listening overlooked: an audit of listening as category in the public sphere. Javnost—The Public 19(4): 5–20.

36.

Lenette

Miskovic

(2018) ‘Some viewers may find the following images disturbing’: Visual representations of refugee deaths at border crossings’. Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal 14(1): 111–120.

37.

Lobo

(2014) Affective energies: Sensory bodies on the beach in Darwin, Australia. Emotion, Space and Society 12: 101–109.

38.

Loughnan

(2020) ‘Not the Hilton’: ‘Vernacular violence’ in COVID-19 quarantine and detention hotels. Arena Quarterly No.3. Available at: https://arena.org.au/not-the-hilton-vernacular-violence-in-covid-19-quarantine-and-detention-hotels (accessed 22 February 2022).

39.

MacFarlane

(2020) Negative research: Sonic methods in geography and their limits. The Professional Geographer 72(2): 297–308.

40.

Madianou

(2016) Ambient co-presence: Transnational family practices in polymedia environments. Global Networks 16(2): 183–201.

41.

Manthorpe

(2020) Immigration Detention Oversight. Review of the Ombudsman’s activities in overseeing immigration detention. Commonwealth Ombudsman. Available at: https://www.ombudsman.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0017/109700/Immigration-Detention-Oversight-Report_January-to-June-2019.pdf (accessed 24 February 2022).

42.

Meier

(2020) Affective border violence: Mapping everyday asylum precarities across different spaces and temporalities. Emotion, Space and Society 37: 1–7.

43.

Moreton-Robinson

(2015) The White Possessive: Property, Power, and Indigenous Sovereignty. University of Minnesota Press.

44.

Mountz

Hyndman

(2006) Feminist approaches to the global intimate [Special Issue: The Global and the Intimate]. Women’s Studies Quarterly 34(1/2): 446–463.

45.

Parker

Stern

(2020) How are you today by the Manus Recording Project Collective. Law Text Culture 24(1): 9–49.

46.

Perera

(2009). Australia and the insular imagination: Beaches, borders, boats, and bodies. Palgrave Macmillan.

47.

Perera

(2013) Oceanic corpo-graphies, refugee bodies and the making and unmaking of waters. Feminist Review 103(1): 58–79.

48.

Perera

Pugliese

(2011) Introduction: Combat breathing: State violence and the body in question. Somatechnics 1(1): 1–14.

49.

Pink

(2015) Doing Sensory Ethnography. Sage.

50.

Rae

Holman

Nethery

(2018) Self-represented witnessing: The use of social media by asylum seekers in Australia’s offshore immigration detention centres. Media, Culture & Society 40(4): 479–495.

51.

Rice

(2016) Sounds inside: Prison, prisoners and acoustical agency. Sound Studies: An Interdisciplinary Journal 2(1): 1–15.

52.

Russell

(2020) Carceral atmospheres on Manus Island: Listening to how are you today. Law Text Culture 24: 1–21.

53.

Russell

Carlton

(2020) Counter-carceral acoustemologies: Sound, permeability and feminist protest at the prison boundary. Theoretical Criminology 24(2): 296–313.

54.

Russell

Carlton

Tyson

(2020) Carceral churn: A sensorial ethnography of the bail and remand court. Punishment & Society. Epub ahead of print 28 October 2020. DOI: 10.1177/1462474520967566.

55.

Russell

Rae

(2020) Indefinite stuckness: Listening in a time of hyper-incarceration and border entrapment. Punishment & Society 22(3): 281–301.

56.

Shalhoub-Kevorkian

(2016) The occupation of the senses: The prosthetic and aesthetic of state terror. The British Journal of Criminology 57: 1279–1300.

57.

State Library of Queensland (2012) Aboriginal boundary posts. In: State Library of Queensland, John Oxley Library. Available at: https://www.slq.qld.gov.au/blog/aboriginal-boundary-posts (accessed 9 June 2021).

58.

Stoler

(2016) Duress: Imperial Durabilities in Our Times. Duke University Press.

59.

Turner

(2016) The Prison Boundary: Between Society and Carceral Space. Palgrave.

60.

Vogl

Fleay

Loughnan

, et al. (2021) COVID-19 and the relentless harms of Australia’s punitive immigration detention regime. Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal 17(1): 43–51.