“Knuckle-Dragging Thugs”: Civilizing processes and the biosocial revolution in the National Hockey League

Abstract

In this article, we advocate for the development of a critical criminology of sport. To this end, we analyze news media coverage of a sample of National Hockey League suspensions to explore how the sporting world disseminates cultural messages about crime and punishment. Our analysis reveals that athlete “offenders” are likened to Lombrosian evolutionary throwbacks whose brutal on-ice violence recalls a less civilized past. Images of blood spilled on the ice and bodies carried away on stretchers shock our sensibilities. We argue that, as the arbiter of supplemental discipline, the National Hockey League regulates the bodies under its control and aims to signify that hockey and its fans are encapsulated in what Elias famously calls civilizing processes rather than mere barbaric sporting games. We situate these findings in the reemergence of a bio(social) criminology and express concerns regarding the spread of this rhetoric.

Keywords

Biosocial criminology civilizing processes sport violence visual criminology

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adami

(2007a) “Bullies” stigma still lingers. Vancouver Sun, 31 October.

Adami

(2007b) Please, no more apologies. Ottawa Citizen, 19 December, B2.

Allain

(2008) “Real fast and tough”: the construction of Canadian hockey masculinity. Sociology of Sport Journal 25(4): 462–481.

Allemang

(2012) The violence is within us all. The Globe and Mail, 21 April, S1.

Allen

(2002) Crime, punishment, and recidivism: lessons from the National Hockey League. Journal of Sports Economics 3(1): 39–60.

Allen

(1987) NHL cuts into violence. USA Today, 3 November, 04C.

Allen

(2016) Wideman’s 20-game ban sends right message. USA Today, 4 February, C6.

Anderson

(1993) Sports of the times; One guilty, but trial continues. The New York Times, 30 April, 7.

Armour

(2007) When World Series ball becomes a chew toy, there’s lesson to be learned. The Canadian Press, 22 December.

10.

Associated Press (2000) Brashear still hurts. Bangor Daily News, 25 February, C3.

11.

Atkinson

Young

(2008) Deviance and Social Control in Sport. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.

12.

Bairner

(2006) The Leicester School and the study of football hooliganism. Sport in Society 9(4): 583–598.

13.

Barnes

(2007) Don’t cast Simon as the NHL’s norm. Edmonton Journal, 19 December, C1.

14.

Barnes

(1988) Sports and the Law in Canada. Toronto, ON, Canada: Butterworths.

15.

Beaver

Nedelec

da Silva Costa

, et al. (2015) The future of biosocial criminology. Criminal Justice Studies 28(1): 6–17.

16.

Beloff

Kerr

Demetriou

, et al. (2012) Sports Law. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.

17.

Bennett

Dilulio

Walters

(1996) Body Count: Moral Poverty–and How to Win America’s War against Crime and Drugs. New York: Simon & Schuster.

18.

Berry

Smith

(2000) Race, sport, and crime: the misrepresentation of African Americans in team sports and crime. Sociology of Sport Journal 17(2): 171–197.

19.

Bloom

Smith

(1996) Hockey violence: a test of cultural spillover theory. Sociology of Sport Journal 13(1): 65–77.

20.

Botte

(2007) Simon saga: from banned to worse. New York Daily News, 20 December, 99.

21.

Boyle

(2014) Requiem for a “Tough Guy”: representing Hockey Labor, Violence, and Masculinity in. Goon. Sociology of Sport Journal 31(3): 327–348.

22.

Brantford Expositor (2012) Headshots must stop. Brantford Expositor, 21 April, A8.

23.

Brent

Kraska

(2013) “Fighting is the most real and honest thing”: violence and the civilization/barbarism dialectic. The British Journal of Criminology 53(2): 357–377.

24.

Brown

(2017) Visual criminology. In: Pontell

(ed.) Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology. Available at: https://oxfordre.com/criminology/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264079.001.0001/acrefore-9780190264079-e-206?print=pdf

25.

Burt

Simons

(2014) Pulling back the curtain on heritability studies: biosocial criminology in the postgenomic era. Criminology 52(2): 223–262.

26.

Burwell

(1993) Suspension sticks it to all NHL thugs. USA Today, 5 May, 03C.

27.

Cameron

MacDougall

(2000) Crime Prevention through Sport and Physical Activity, vol. 165. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Australian Institute of Criminology.

28.

Campbell

(1987) From speed, grace to in your face. The Globe and Mail, 6 November, D17.

29.

Cariou

(2000) A goon skates over the edge. Winnipeg Free Press, 23 February, C2.

30.

Carrabine

(2012) Just images: aesthetics, ethics and visual criminology. The British Journal of Criminology 52: 463–489.

31.

Carrabine

(2014) Seeing things: violence, voyeurism and the camera. Theoretical Criminology 18(2): 134–158.

32.

Carrier

Walby

(2014) Ptolemizing Lombroso: the pseudo-revolution of biosocial criminology. Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Criminology 1(1): 1–45.

33.

Carrington

Hogg

(2017) Deconstructing criminology’s origin stories. Asian Criminology 12(3): 181–197.

34.

Caruso

(2011) Crime and sport participation: evidence from Italian regions of the period 1997–2003. Journal of Socio-Economics 40(5): 455–463.

35.

Coates

(2007a) Good on the NHL for Simon’s 25-game Ban: whether lengthy suspension is enough is another question. Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 13 March.

36.

Coates

(2007b) Simon’s wild act of idiocy. Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 20 December, C1.

37.

Cohn

(2000) NHL proves gutless with McSorley. The Press Democrat, 26 February, C1.

38.

Cole

(2015) Sharks’ Raffi Torres’ 41-game suspension a decent move by NHL. Postmedia Breaking News, 5 October. Available at: http://www.vancouversun.com/sports/cole+sharks+raffi+torres+game+suspension+decent+move/11415940/story.html

39.

Connolly

Dolan

(2010) The civilizing and sportization of Gaelic football in Ireland: 1884–2009. Journal of Historical Sociology 23(4): 570–598.

40.

Connolly

(2015) Civilising processes and doping in professional cycling. Current Sociology 63(7): 1037–1057.

41.

Cox

(2000a) Gross misconduct–McSorley attack on Brashear opens new wounds for NHL. Toronto Star, 23 February, SP01.

42.

Cox

(2000b) NHL has itself to blame for attack. Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 9 March, C01.

43.

Donaldson

(2000) Will players get NHL’s message? Deseret News, 1 March, D01.

44.

Duhatschek

(2007) Simon feels the full force of the law. The Globe and Mail, 20 December, S1.

45.

Dunning

(1999) Sport Matters: Sociological Studies of Sport, Violence and Civilization. New York: Routledge.

46.

Dupont

(1993) Hunter ban enough? The Boston Globe, 30 April, 75.

47.

Elias

(1968) The Civilizing Process: The History of Manners (trans. Jephcott

). Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

48.

Fachet

(1988) Recent rulings show NHL afraid to fight real culprit. Washington Post, 8 November, E05.

49.

Fairclough

(1992) Discourse and text: linguistic and intertextual analysis within discourse analysis. Discourse and Society 3(2): 193–217.

50.

Fairclough

(2013) Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language. New York: Routledge.

51.

Feschuk

(2019) Gary Bettman and the NHL still won’t meet the concussion problem head on. Toronto Star, 1 May. Available at: https://www.thestar.com/sports/hockey/opinion/2019/05/01/gary-bettman-and-the-nhl-still-wont-meet-concussion-problem-head-on.html

52.

Finn

(1993) Islanders advance, but their top scorer falls. The New York Times, 29 April, 17.

53.

Francis

(2012) Length of headhunter’s ban by league disciplinarian Shanahan wrankles some old-time general managers. The Calgary Sun, 22 April, S2.

54.

Gardiner

O’Leary

Welch

, et al. (2012) Sports Law. 4th edn. New York: Routledge.

55.

Garland

(2001) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

56.

Gilbertson

(2016) Five facing Flames. Calgary Sun, 22 February, S5.

57.

Gildea

(1993) Irate Islanders call Hunter’s hit “gutless.” Washington Post, 29 April, B09.

58.

Giulianotti

(1999) Football: A Sociology of the Global Game. Cambridge: Polity Press.

59.

Giulianotti

(2016) Sport: A Critical Sociology. 2nd edn. Cambridge: Polity Press.

60.

Glaser

(1978) Theoretical Sensitivity. Mill Valley, CA: Sociology Press.

61.

Glaser

(1992) Emergence vs. Forcing: Basics of Grounded Theory Analysis. Mill Valley, CA: Sociology press.

62.

Glaser

Strauss

(1967) The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. Chicago, IL: Aldine.

63.

Gong

(2015) How to fight without rules: on civilized violence in “decivilized” spaces. Social Problems 62(4): 605–622.

64.

Gordon

(1993a) Tip of iceberg; Hunter takes ugly playoff shtick too far. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 30 April, 01E.

65.

Gordon

(1993b) Stick with it! Bettman off to good start. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 6 May, 04D.

66.

Gordon

(1999) Looking at who’s in and who’s out in the world of sports. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 11 February, D2.

67.

Gordon

(2007) NY Islanders tell Simon he needs help for rink rage. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 19 December, D2.

68.

Gordon

(2011) NHL “dove” Regier applauds Cooke suspension. The Globe and Mail, 22 March. Available at: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/sports/hockey/nhl-dove-regier-applauds-cooke-suspension/article573603/

69.

Grange

(2000) Hockey’s latest crisis. The Globe and Mail, 14 March, S1.

70.

Groombridge

(2017) Sports Criminology: A Critical Criminology of Sport and Games. Bristol: Policy Press.

71.

Hartley

(2009) Sport, Physical Recreation and the Law. New York: Routledge.

72.

Hartmann

Depro

(2006) Rethinking sports-based community crime prevention: a preliminary analysis of the relationship between midnight basketball and urban crime rates. Journal of Sport and Social Issues 30(2): 180–196.

73.

Hartmann

Kwauk

(2011) Sport and development: an overview, critique, and reconstruction. Journal of Sport and Social Issues 35(3): 284–305.

74.

Hartmann

Massoglia

(2016) Reassessing the relationship between high school sports participation and deviance: evidence of enduring, bifurcated effects. The Sociological Quarterly 48(3): 485–505.

75.

Hawk

(2000) Scheduling, Utah trip put dent in UNLV’s postseason plans. The Las Vegas Review-Journal, 24 February 24, 1C.

76.

Hayes

Lorenz

Bell

(2013) Victim blaming others: rape myth acceptance and the just world belief. Feminist Criminology 8(3): 202–220.

77.

Hayward

(2009) Visual criminology: cultural criminology-style. Criminal Justice Matters 78: 12–14.

78.

Healey

(2009) Sport and the Law. 4th edn. Sydney, NSW, Australia: University of New South Wales Press.

79.

Hickey

(2012) NHL needs impartial “hits” judge. Vancouver Sun, 24 April, C2.

80.

James

(2007) Repeat offender. Ottawa Citizen, 20 December, B1.

81.

Jones

(2000) Cloutier out with groin injury. St. Petersburg Times, 25 February, 7C.

82.

Karstedt

(2002) Emotions and criminal justice. Theoretical Criminology 6(3): 299–317.

83.

Kennedy

Silva

Coelho

, et al. (2019) “We are all broncos”: hockey, tragedy, and the formation of Canadian identity. Sociology of Sport Journal 36(3): 189–202.

84.

Kitchener-Waterloo Record (2000) NHL won’t police itself so let police do the job. Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 24 February, A10.

85.

Kitsap Sun (2000) Bruins’ McSorley suspended for vicious stick attack on Brashear. Kitsap Sun, 23 February, C04.

86.

Klein

Hackel

(2012) NHL slow to curb chaotic playoff violence; league crackdown comes as advertisers complain about brawls and injuries. Montreal Gazette, 23 April, B3.

87.

Langlands

(2000) Hockey and violence—goon mentality spoils hockey. Toronto Star, 1 March, LT01.

88.

Lapointe

(1993) One cheap shot claims a star and batters hockey’s image. The New York Times, 29 April, 17.

89.

Lewis

Taylor

(2008) Sport: Law and Practice. Oxford: Butterworths.

90.

Lopresti

(2000) McSorley hit crosses line by any standard. USA Today, 23 February, 03C.

91.

Luecking

(2000) McSorley’s stick swinging leaves the Blues stunned. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 23 February, D3.

92.

Lyon

(1989) Hextall deserves penalty. The Orange County Register, 28 May.

93.

MacDonald

(2018) Insert name of openly gay hockey player here: attitudes towards homosexuality among Canadian male major midget AAA ice hockey players. Sociology of Sport Journal 35(4): 347–357.

94.

Macfarlane

(2000) I’m not going to support the NHL anymore because I happen to like the sport of hockey. The Globe and Mail, 28 February, R2.

95.

McLaren

(2008) Corruption: its impact on fair play. Marquette Sports Law Review 19: 15–38.

96.

McLaren

(2011) Is sport losing its integrity? Marquette Sports Law Review 21: 551–556.

97.

McMurtry

(1974) Investigation and Inquiry into Violence in Amateur Hockey. Toronto, ON, Canada: Ministry of Community and Social Services.

98.

Mason

Thibault

Misener

(2006) An agency theory perspective on corruption in sport: the case of the International Olympic Committee. Journal of Sport Management 20(1): 52–73.

99.

Masters

(2015) Corruption in sport: from the playing field to the field of policy. Policy and Society 34(2): 111–123.

100.

May-Anderson

(2012) Keep your head up. Belleville Intelligencer, 21 April, A6.

101.

Moody-Ramirez

Cole

(2018) Victim blaming in Twitter users’ framing of Eric Garner and Michael Brown. Journal of Black Studies 49(4): 383–407.

102.

Nichols

(2010) Sport and Crime Reduction: The Role of Sports in Tackling Youth Crime. New York: Routledge.

103.

Ottawa Citizen (2007) Going down fighting. Ottawa Citizen, 31 December, A10.

104.

Pap

(2007) Players say no to “life.” Vancouver Sun, 21 December, G2.

105.

Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (2000) North American hockey is on thin ice, 26 February, C3.

106.

Pizzaro

Chermak

Gruenewald

(2007) Juvenile “Super Predators” in the news: a comparison of adult and juvenile homicides. Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture 14(1): 84–111.

107.

Podell

(2000) McSorley suspended for attack on Brashear. Associated Press Newswires, 22 February. Available at: https://www.apnews.com/6cab72d8a05bded4b7fa2006cefde94b

108.

Portland Press Herald (2000) NHL has the power to halt players’ fighting. Portland Press Herald, 25 February, 10A.

109.

Press

(2019) Bettman says banning hits to head would mean end of all hits. The Canadian Press, 1 May. Available at: https://www.ctvnews.ca/sports/banning-hits-to-head-would-mean-end-of-all-hits-in-nhl-bettman-says-1.4403927 (accessed 27 May 2019).

110.

Proudfoot

(1993) Bettman’s laying down the law. Toronto Star, 7 May, B4.

111.

Rafter

(1997) Creating Born Criminals. Urbana, IL: University of Chicago Press.

112.

Rafter

(2014) Introduction to special issue on visual culture and the iconography of crime and punishment. Theoretical Criminology 18(2): 127–133.

113.

Reid

(2012) Bettman’s passivity enabling headhunters. The Orange County Register, 21 April.

114.

Robertson

(1987) Don’t suspend goons—let them PLAY. Toronto Star, 4 November, E3.

115.

Rose

(2000) The biology of culpability: pathological identity and crime control in a biological culture. Theoretical Criminology 4(1): 5–34.

116.

Ross

(1987a) Brown makes Rangers see red. The Record, 27 October.

117.

Ross

(1987b) Brown a product of NHL’s insulated world. The Record, 1 November.

118.

Ross

(2007) Time to use heads, not aim for them. New York Daily News, 10 March.

119.

Rubino

(2000) Tonya could fill McSorley’s skates as NHL goon. The Press Democrat, 5 March, C2.

120.

Schept

(2017) Visuality and criminology. In: Pontell

(ed.) Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology. Available at: https://oxfordre.com/criminology/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264079.001.0001/acrefore-9780190264079-e-145?print=pdf

121.

Sexton

(1988) Shaw gets 12-game ban for attack on Lemieux. The New York Times, 3 November. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/1988/11/03/sports/shaw-gets-12-game-ban-for-attack-on-lemieux.html

122.

Silverwood

(2015) “Five for fighting”: the culture and practice of legitimised violence in professional ice hockey. Doctoral dissertation, Cardiff University, Cardiff.

123.

Smith

(1979) Hockey violence: a test of violent subculture hypothesis. Social Problems 27(2): 235–247.

124.

Sontag

(2003) Regarding the Pain of Others. New York: Picador Modern Classics.

125.

Spector

(2007) In defence of Simon: an NHL repeat offender. National Post, 19 December, S1.

126.

Spencer

Fitzgerald

(2015) Criminology and animality: stupidity and the anthropological machine. Contemporary Justice Review 18(4): 407–420.

127.

Stevens

(2000) McSorley legacy let in tatters? Winnipeg Free Press, 24 February, C8.

128.

Strachan

(1987) Solutions eluding NHL in quest to stop violence. The Globe and Mail, 7 November, E5.

129.

Strachan

(1993) Bettman’s response to public outcry will be revealing. The Globe and Mail, 30 April, C10.

130.

Strauss

Corbin

(1990) Basics of Qualitative Research. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.

131.

Taylor

(1993) Goons deserve harsh penalties. Winnipeg Free Press, 1 May.

132.

The Globe and Mail (2000) Hockey as a crime. The Globe and Mail, 24 February, A20.

133.

The New York Times (2000) Thuggery on the ice. The New York Times, 25 February, 18.

134.

Todd

(2011) Time for Cooke to pay hefty price. Montreal Gazette, 20 March, B1.

135.

Todd

(2012) Giroux excelling for Philly. Montreal Gazette, 23 April, B1.

136.

Toronto Star (2000) Hockey violence. Toronto Star, 24 February, ED01.

137.

Vaccaro

(2007) Greatness in our time—why sports fans should want Patriots to go 19-0. New York Post, 23 December, 90.

138.

Ventre

(1993) NBA, NHL appear a lot like WBC. Los Angeles Daily News, 2 May.

139.

Walby

Carrier

(2010) The rise of biocriminology: capturing observable bodily economies of “criminal man.” Criminology & Criminal Justice 10(3): 261–285.

140.

Waterloo Region Record (2012) Hockey takes a viceregal check. 21 April, A12.

141.

Watson

MacLellan

(1986) Smitting to spitting: 80 years of ice-hockey in Canadian courts. Canadian Journal of History of Sport 17(2): 10–29.

142.

Watson

(2017) Everyday nationalism and international hockey: contesting Canadian national identity. Nations and Nationalism 23(2): 289–308.

143.

Weber

(2000) Sports pages forced to tell wrong stories. Bangor Daily News, 23 February.

144.

Weinstein

Smith

Wiesenthal

(1995) Masculinity and hockey violence. Sex Roles 33(11–12): 831–847.

145.

Wheatley

(2000) MVC participants were refreshing in their sportsmanship. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 7 March, C1.

146.

Wilbon

(1993) For NHL, thuggery kills. Washington Post, 30 April, C01.

147.

Wilbon

(1998) NHL thugs deserve swift kick. Washington Post, 28 November, B01.

148.

Wright

Boisvert

(2009) What biosocial criminology offers criminology. Criminal Justice and Behavior 36(11): 1228–1240.

149.

Yost

(2018) Fighting continues to fade from NHL. Available at: https://www.tsn.ca/fighting-continues-to-fade-from-nhl-1.1216252

150.

Young

(2007) Images in the aftermath of trauma: responding to September 11th. Crime, Media, Culture 3: 30–48.

151.

Young

(2010) The Scene of Violence: Cinema, Crime, Affect. London: Routledge.

152.

Young

(1993) Violence, risk, and liability in male sports culture. Sociology of Sport Journal 10(4): 373–396.

153.

Young

(1997) Women, sport, and physicality: preliminary findings from a Canadian study. International Review for the Sociology of Sport 32(3): 297–305.

154.

Young

(2000) Sport and violence. In: Coakley

Dunning

(eds) Handbook of Sports Studies. London: Sage, pp. 382–408.

155.

Young

(2012) Sport, Violence and Society. New York: Routledge.

156.

Young

(2015) Accessing the sociology of sport: on sports violence and ways of seeing. International Review for the Sociology of Sport 50(4–5): 640–644.

157.

Youngman

(2000) What McSorley did was criminal. The Orange County Register, 23 February.

158.

Zgoda

(1987) Thomas regrets off-the-wall stunt. Star-Tribune, 8 November, 16C.