Though contemporary discourse on cosmopolitanism has celebrated a cosmopolitan subject’s “rootedness” in two worlds – i.e. the polis and the cosmos – this emphasis has evaded analysis of the historical and damning term “rootless cosmopolitan.” Under the totalitarianisms of Nazism and late Stalinism, a “rootless cosmopolitan” was a life-threatening epithet aimed at those people, namely “the Jews,” criminalized for supposedly lacking national allegiance and affiliating with foreign cultures. This paper argues that an ethical problem arises when cosmopolitanism is understood in cultural terms. To illuminate this problem in the particular, this paper interprets Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment, specifically the novel’s nationalistic themes and its cosmopolitan villain, Peter Petrovich Luzhin. In the unfolding analysis that draws from scholarship in cultural criminology, it is revealed that the Russian writer’s designated masterful genius helped fuel one of the greatest crimes in history (the Holocaust) perpetrated against a people accused of cosmopolitanism. It is argued that interpreting the criminalization of Luzhin provides an allegorical occasion to gain conceptual clarity on present articulations of cosmopolitanism as a cultural construct. Attending to Dostoevsky’s anti-cosmopolitanism, and those whom he has in/directly influenced on this subject, provides a rationale for critiquing cultural cosmopolitanism – a construct that is conceptually and materially dangerous.
AppiahKA (2006) Cosmopolitanism. New York: W.W. Norton and Co., Inc.
3.
ArendtH (1973) The Origins of Totalitarianism. New York: A Harvest Book, Harcourt Brace.
4.
ArendtH (2006) Between Past and Future. New York: Penguin Books.
5.
AzadovskiiKEgorovB (2002) From anti-westernism to anti-semitism: Stalin and the impact of the ‘anti-cosmopolitan’ campaigns on Soviet culture. Journal of Cold War Studies4(1): 66–80.
6.
BeckU (2004) Rooted cosmopolitanism: Emerging from a rivalry of distinctions. In: SznaiderNBeckU (eds) Global America: The Cultural Consequences of Globalization. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, pp. 15–29.
7.
BeckerH (1963) Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance. New York: The Free Press.
8.
BeebeM (1955) The three motives of Raskolnikov: A reinterpretation of Crime and Punishment. College English17(3): 151–158.
9.
BrennenT (1997) At Home in the World: Cosmopolitanism Now. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
10.
BurumaIMargalitA (2004) Occidentalism. New York: Penguin Books.
11.
CalhounC (2003) ‘Belonging’ in the cosmopolitan imaginary. Ethnicities3(4): 531–568.
12.
CheahP (2006) Inhuman Conditions. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
13.
CohnN (2006) Warrant for Genocide. London: Serif Publishing.
DavydovS (1982) Dostoevsky and Nabokov: The morality of structure in ‘Crime and Punishment’ and ‘Despair.’Dostoevsky Studies3: 158–170.
16.
DeutscherI (1967) Stalin: A Political Biography. New York: Oxford University Press.
17.
DostoevskyF (1989) Crime and Punishment. New York: Norton and Company, Inc.
18.
FerrellJ (1995) Culture, crime, and cultural criminology. Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture3(2): 25–42.
19.
FerrellJ (1999) Cultural criminology. Annual Review of Sociology25: 395–418.
20.
FerrellJHaywardKYoungJ (2008) Cultural Criminology. London: Sage.
21.
FigesO (2008) The Whisperers: Private Lives in Stalin’s Russia. New York: Picador.
22.
FrankJ (2010) Dostoevsky: A Writer in His Time. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
23.
GoldsteinD (1981) Dostoevsky and the Jews. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
24.
GrunerF (2010) ‘Russia’s battle against the foreign’: The anti-cosmopolitanism paradigm in Russian and Soviet ideology. European Review of History—Revue europeenne d’histoire17(3): 445–472.
25.
HagemeisterM (2008) The Protocols of the Elders of Zion: Between history and fiction. New German Critique103(35): 83–95.
26.
HallS (1996) The question of cultural identity. In: HallSHeldDHubertD. (eds) Modernity: An Introduction to Modern Societies. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishers, pp. 596–632.
27.
HansenD (2008) Curriculum and the idea of a cosmopolitan inheritance. Journal of Curriculum Studies40(3): 289–312.
28.
HansenD (2011) The Teacher and the World: A Study of Cosmopolitanism as Education. New York: Routledge.
KiremidjianD (1976) Crime and Punishment: Matricide and the woman question. American Imago33(4): 403–433.
31.
KnightM (2000) Chesterton, Dostoevsky, and freedom. English Literature in Transition 1880–1920. 43(1): 37–50.
32.
KymlickaWWalkerK (2013) Rooted Cosmopolitanism: Canada and the World. Vancouver: UBC Press.
33.
LeatherbarrowWJ (1976) The aesthetic louse: Ethics and aesthetics in Dostoevsky’s ‘Prestupleniye i Nakazaniye.’The Modern Language Review71(4): 857–866.
34.
MacfarlaneA (dir.) (2006) Conversation between Stuart Hall and Pnina Werbner on the theme of cosmopolitanism. Film Interviews with Leading Thinkers. University of Cambridge. Available at: http://www.sms.cam.ac.uk/media/1119965 (accessed 18 May 2015).
35.
MillerMScottU (2010) Cosmopolitanism: The end of Jewishness?European Review of History—Revue europe‘enne d’histoire17(3): 337–359.
36.
MorsonG (1983) Dostoevsky’s anti-Semitism and the critics: A review article. The Slavic and Eastern European Journal27(3): 302–317.
37.
MorsonG (2009) The lingering stench: Airing Stalin’s archives. New Criterion27(7): 10–14.
38.
PachmussT (1980) Dostoyevsky’s Porfiry Petrovich: A new Socrates. New Zealand Slavonic Journal1: 17–24.
39.
PalmerM (2011) An introduction to Martin Heidegger: ‘Radical committed’ anti- cosmopolitanism. In: TrepanierLHabibKM (eds) Cosmopolitanism in the Age of Globalization: Citizens without States. Lexington, KY: University Press of Kentucky, pp. 161–183.
40.
PapastephanouM (2012) Thinking Differently about Cosmopolitanism: Theory, Eccentricity, and the Globalized World. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers.
41.
PinarW (2011) The Character of Curriculum Studies. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
42.
PollockSBhabhaHKBreckenridgeC. (2000) Cosmopolitanisms. Public Culture12(3): 577–590.
43.
PopkewitzT (2008) Cosmopolitanism and the Age of School Reform. New York: Routledge.
44.
PopkewitzT (2009) Curriculum study, curriculum history, and curriculum theory: The reason of reason. Journal of Curriculum Studies41(3): 301–219.
45.
RafterNBrownM (2011) Criminology Goes to the Movies: Crime Theory and Popular Culture. New York: NYU Press.
RensmannL (2013) The politics of paranoia: How – and why – the European radical right mobilizes antiSemitism, xenophobia, and counter-cosmopolitanism. In: SmallCA (ed.) Global Antisemitism: A Crisis of Modernity: Volume III. New York: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.
48.
RuggieroV (2003) Crime in Literature: Sociology of Deviance and Fiction. New York: Verso.
49.
RuggieroV (2015) Paul Nizan: Conspiracy and the contemplation of crime. Crime Media Culture. Epub ahead of print. DOI: 10.1177/1741659015596113.
SpeerA (1997) Inside the Third Reich. New York: Simon and Schuster.
56.
StrandT (2010) The making of a new cosmopolitanism. Studies in Philosophy and Education29: 229–242.
57.
SudjicD (2006) The Edifice Complex: How the Rich and Powerful – and Their Architects – Shape the World. New York: Penguin Books.
58.
TaylorR (1998) Film Propaganda: Soviet Russia and Nazi Germany. New York: I. B. Tauris and Co.
59.
WaldronJ (2000) What is cosmopolitan?The Journal of Political Philosophy8(2): 227–243.
60.
WelchL (1976) Luzhin’s crime and the advantages of melodrama in Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment. Texas Studies in Literature and Language18(1): 135–146.
