The purpose of this paper is to explore how shadowing has been applied as a method for principal development in China, in terms of its aims, the procedure and the transfer of learning. Four shadowing programmes countrywide were selected. The information on the experience of the participants, providers and mentors from high-performing site schools was obtained using semi-structured interviews. A total of 16 programme participants, 4 providers and 4 mentors from high-performing site schools were involved. This study presents a comprehensive picture of the use of shadowing as a method for principal development in China by exploring individuals who were directly involved in the shadowing programmes, and by bridging leadership learning to leadership practice stressing on transfer of learning upon completion of the programmes. The research found that learning by shadowing transferred into some positive changes in participants, at both cognitive and practical levels, when they shadow in high-performing schools. However, orientations for learning and relationships during learning were weakly established in most of the programmes, which could hardly support participants to internalise and contextualise their learning into practice for strategic or systematic changes.
AntoniouPLuM (2018) Evaluating the measuring properties of the principal instructional management rating scale in the Chinese educational system: implications for measuring school leadership. Educational Management Administration & Leadership46: 624–641.
2.
BanduraA (1977) Social Learning Theory. New York: General Learning Press.
3.
BarnettBShohoACoplandM (2010) Using Internships in the Preparation of School Leaders. Austin, TX: University Council for Educational Administration.
4.
BengtsonE (2012) Using peer learning support networks and reflective practice: The Arkansas Leadership Academy master principal program. International Journal of Educational Leadership Preparation7: 1–17.
5.
BloomBS (1956) Taxonomy of Educational Objectives, Handbook I: The Cognitive Domain. New York: David McKay Co Inc.
6.
BøeMHognestadKWaniganayakeM (2016) Qualitative shadowing as a research methodology for exploring early childhood leadership in practice. Educational Management Administration & Leadership 45: 605–620.
7.
BossertSTDwyerDCRowanB, et al. (1982) The instructional management role of the principal. Educational Administration Quarterly18: 34–64.
8.
BrionC (2020) Learning transfer: The missing linkage to effective professional development. Journal of Cases in Educational Leadership 23: 32–47.
9.
BrownJCollinsADuguidP (1989) Situated cognition and the culture of learning. Educational Researcher18(1): 32–42.
10.
BroadMLNewstromJW (1992) Transfer of Training: Action-Packed Strategies to Ensure High Payoff from Training Investments. Da Capo Press.
11.
BroadML (1997) Overview of transfer of training: from learning to performance. Performance Improvement Quarterly 10: 7–21.
12.
BrunerJS (1960) The Process of Education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
13.
BurkR (2012) New Building Level Leaders Perceptions: Experiences in the Pennsylvania Inspired Leadership’s Induction and Mentoring Program. Unpublished EdD dissertation. Indiana University of Pennsylvania.
14.
BurnsRB (2000) Introduction to Research Methods. New South Wales: Longman.
15.
BushT. (2009) Leadership development and school improvement: Contemporary issues in leadership development. Educational Review61: 375–389.
16.
ChaoDX (2015) Patterns of principal shadowing learning in China: A case study from Anhui province. Academy of Chinese Education6: 93–96.
17.
ChaoDXQiuZF (2016) Principal’s shadowing learning: Inquiries, analysis and evaluation. Theory and Discussion6: 1–6.
18.
ChenS (2011) Collective learning from success as perceived by school superintendents. Journal of School Leadership21: 478–509.
19.
ChenXM (2013) An analysis of a learning dilemma of beginning learners from the perspective of ‘legitimate peripheral participation’. Global Education42: 3–10.
20.
ChenY (2012) Analysis research of principals’ developmental training model owing to the principal professionalism. Journal of Educational Institute of Jilin Province28: 1–3.
21.
ChengZChenXH (2011) Strategy for mobile learning design under the perspectives of ‘legitimate peripheral participation’. Digitalization Education in China295: 39–43.
22.
CheungRWalkerA (2006) Inner worlds and outer limits: The formation of beginning school principals in Hong Kong. Journal of Educational Administration44: 389–407.
23.
CreswellJW (2012) Educational Research: Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating Quantitative and Qualitative Research. Boston: Pearson.
24.
CuiY (2017) Case studies for deep learning. People Education20: 43–48.
25.
DennenVPBurnerKJ (2007) The cognitive apprenticeship model in educational practice. In: SpectorJMMerrillMDVan MerriënboerJDriscollMP (eds) Handbook of Research on Educational Communications and Technology. Erlbaum: Mahwah, pp.425–439.
26.
DeRueDSAshfordSJ (2010) Who will lead and who will follow: A social process of leadership identity construction in organizations. Academy of Management Review35: 627–647.
27.
DeRueDSMeyersC (2014) Leadership development: a review and agenda for future research. In: DayD (ed) The Oxford Handbook of Leadership and Organizations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
28.
Drago-SeversonEMaslin-OstrowskiPHoffmanAM (2008) Resisting Fragmentation in Educational Leadership: Calling for a Holistic Approach to Professional Practice and Preparation. Orlando, FL: University Council for Educational Administration.
29.
EntwistleNJ (1979) Stages, levels, styles or strategies: Dilemmas in the description of thinking. Educational Review31.
30.
EntwistleN (2001) Styles of learning and approaches to studying in higher education. Learning Styles in Higher Education30: 593–602.
31.
EntwistleNJHanleyMHounsellDJ (1979) Identifying distinctive approaches to studying. Higher Education8.
32.
FergusonK (2016) Lessons learned from using shadowing as a qualitative research technique in education. Reflective Practice: International and Multidisciplinary Perspectives17: 15–26.
33.
FordJK (1994) Defining transfer of learning: The meaning is in the answers. Adult Learning5: 22–30.
34.
FuY (2017) Deep learning and teaching form. Globle Education46(7): 47–56.
35.
GermainLQuinnD (2005) Investigation of tacit knowl- edge in principal leadership. Educational Forum70.
36.
GheradiS (2009) Introduction: The critical power of the ‘practice lens’. Management Learning40.
37.
GillRBarbourJDeanM (2014) Shadowing in/as work: Ten recommendations for shadowing fieldwork practice. Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management: An International Journal9: 69–89.
38.
GrissomJMitaniHWooDS (2019) Principal preparation programs and principal outcomes. Educational Administration Quarterly55: 73–115.
39.
GunterHRibbinsP (2002) Leadership studies in education: Towards a map of the field. Educational Management and Administration30(4): 387–416.
40.
HallingerP (2018) Bringing context out of the shadows of leadership. Educational Management Administration and Leadership46: 5–24.
41.
HallingerPBridgesEM (2017) A systematic review of research on the use of problem-based learning in the preparation and development of school leaders. Educational Administration Quarterly53: 255–288.
42.
HeJ (2012) Shadowing learning under perspectives of ‘social interdependence theory’. Theory and Practice of Education32: 33–35.
43.
HedbergB (1981) How organizations learn and unlearn. In: NystronPCStarbuckWH (eds) Handbook of Organizational Design. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
HewittKKDavisAWLashleyC (2014) Transformational and transformative leadership in a research-informed leadership preparation program. Journal of Research on Leadership Education9: 225–253.
46.
HowardGSConwayCG (1986) Can there be an empirical science of volitional action?American Psychologist41: 241–251.
47.
HuberS (2004) Preparing School Leaders for the 21st Century: An International Comparison OfDevel- Opment Programs in 15 Countries. London: Routledge.
48.
IllerisK (2009) Transfer of learning in the learning society: How can the barriers between different learning spaces be surmounted, and how can the gap between learning inside and outside schools be bridged?International Journal of Lifelong Education28: 137–148.
49.
KirkpatrickDL (1998) Evaluating Training Programs: The Four Levels. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler.
50.
KnowlesMSHoltonEFISwansonRA (2005) The Adult Learner: The Definitive Classic in Adult Education and Human Resource Development. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
51.
KolbDABoyatzisREMainemelisC (2000) Experiential learning theory: Previous research and new directions. Perspectives on Thinking Learning and Cognitive Styles1: 227–247.
52.
KrippendorffK (2004) Content Analysis: An introduction to its Methodology. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
LeithwoodKPattenSJantziD (2010) Testing a conception of how leadership influences student learning. Educational Administration Quarterly46: 671–706.
55.
LiJF (2011) Impact of shadowing learning on principals’ professional development. Teacher Development Research5: 68–71.
56.
LiuJ (2019) Government, media, and citizens: Understanding engagement with PISA in China (2009–2015). Oxford Review of Education45: 315–332.
57.
LiuSXuXGrantL, et al. (2017) Professional standards and performance evaluation for principals in China: A policy analysis of the development of principal standards. Educational Management Administration & Leadership45: 238–259.
58.
LiuSNHallingerP (2018) Principal instructional leadership, teacher self-efficacy, and teacher professional learning in China: Testing a mediated-effects model. Educational Administration Quarterly54: 501–528.
59.
LouisMRSuttonRI (1991) Switching cognitive gears: From habits of mind to active thinking. Human Relations44: 55–76.
60.
LunenbergMZwartRKorthagenF (2010) Critical issues in supporting self-study. Teaching and Teacher Education26: 1280–1289.
61.
LvLJTuGY (2012) Exploration of ‘position experience’ mode in ‘shadow schoolmaster’ training. Journal of Dalian Education University28: 27–28.
62.
MannDReardonRMBeckerJD, et al. (2011) Immersive, interactive, web-enabled computer simulation as a trigger for learning: The next generation of problem-based learning in educational leadership. Journal of Research on Leadership Education6: 272–287.
63.
MaxwellJA (1996) Qualitative Research Design: An Interactive Approach. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
64.
MaxwellJ (1997) Designing a qualitative study. In: BickmanLRogDJ (eds) Handbook of Applied Social Research Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 69–100.
65.
McKenneySReevesTC (2013) Systematic review of design-based research progress: Is a little knowledge a dangerous thing?Educational Researcher42: 97–100.
66.
MeijerM-JKuijpersMBoeiF, et al. (2016) Professional development of teacher-educators towards transformative learning. Professional Development in Education43: 819–840.
67.
MengLMuñozMHessKK, et al. (2017) Effective teaching factors and student reading strategies as predictors of student achievement in PISA 2009: The case of China and the United States. Educational Review69: 68–84.
68.
MezirowJ (2012) Learning to think like an adult: core concepts of transformation theory. In: CrantonEWTP (ed) The Handbook of Transformative Learning: Theory, Research, and Practice. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 73–96.
69.
MezirowJTaylorEW (2009) Transformative Learning in Practice: Insights from Community, Workplace, and Higher Education. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
70.
MilesMBHubermanAM (1994) Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
71.
Ministry of Education (2013) Guidelines on further strengthening training for primary and secondary. principal. MOE. In Chinese: Jiaoyubu guanyu jinyibu jiaqiang zhongxiaoxue xiaozhang peixun gongzuo de yijian.
72.
Ministry of Education (2014) Notifications on implementing national training plans for. primary and. secondary principals. MOE. In Chinese: Guanyu qidong shishi zhongxiaoxue xiaozhang guojiaji peixun jihua de tongzhi.
73.
Ministry of Education (2017) Guidelines on three-phase training for rural principals. MOE. In Chinese: Xiangcun xiaoyuanzhang sanduanshi peixun zhinan.
74.
Ministry of Education (2020) Further strengthening the vitality for school governance for primary and. secondary schools. MOE. In Chinese: Guanyu jinyibu jifa zhongxiaoxue banxuehuoli de ruogan yijian.
75.
MorrisJELummisGWLockG, et al. (2020) The role of leadership in establishing a positive staff culture in a secondary school. Educational Management Administration and Leadership48: 802–820.
76.
MyranSSutherlandI (2019) Defining learning in educational leadership: Reframing the narrative. Educational Administration Quarterly55: 657–696.
77.
OECD (2020) Global Release of PISA Global Competence Assessment Results. 2020 Global Conference, AFS Intercultural Programmes. 23–24 October.
78.
O’MahonyGBarnettB (2008) Coaching relationships that influence how experienced principals think and act. Leading and Managing14: 16–37.
79.
Orland-BarakL (2010) Learning to Mentor-as-Praxis: Foundations for a curriculum in Teacher Education. London: Springer.
80.
OrrMTOrphanosS (2011) How graduate-level preparation influences the effectiveness of school leaders: A comparison of the outcomes of exemplary and conventional leadership preparation programs for principals. Educational Administration Quarterly47: 18–70.
81.
PalincsarA (1999) Response: A community of practice. Teacher Education and Special Education22: 272–274.
82.
ParsonsMStephensonM (2005) Developing reflective practice in student teachers: Collaboration and critical partnerships. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice11: 95–116.
83.
PattonMQ (2002) Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
84.
PengHZhuZ (2020) Deep learning research: The development vein and bottleneck. China Academic Journal Electronic Pulishing House32(1): 41–50.
85.
PisapiaJ (2009) The Strategic Leader: New Tactics for a Globalizing World. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Press.
86.
PontBNuscheDMoormanH (2008) Improving School Leadership: Policy & Practice. Paris: OECD.
87.
QiaoXYuSZhangL (2018) A review of research on professional learning communities in mainland China (2006–2015): Key findings and emerging themes. Educational Management Administration & Leadership46: 713–728.
88.
RaelinJA (2011) From leadership-as-practice to leaderful practice. Leadership7: 195–211.
89.
Reyes-GuerraDPisapiaJMickA (2016) The preparation of cognitively agile principals for turnaround schools: A leadership preparation programme study. School Leadership & Management36: 401–418.
90.
RoanARooneyD (2006) Shadowing experiences and the extension of communities of practice: A case study of women education managers. Management Learning37: 433–454.
91.
RobinsonVMJLloydCAKennethJR (2008) The impact of leadership on student outcomes: An analysis of the differential effects of leadership types. Educational Administration Quarterly44: 635–674.
92.
SchwarzABrauckmannS (2015) Between Facts and Perceptions: The Area Close to School as a Context Factor in School Leadership. Wuppertal, Germany: University of Wuppertal.
93.
SebastianH (2019) Red Swam: How Undertook Policy and Regulation to Facilitate China’s Rise. Zhongxin Press.
94.
ServiceBDalgicEGThorntonK (2016) Implications of a shadowing/ mentoring programme for aspiring principals. International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching in Education5: 221–238.
95.
SimkinsTClosePSmithR (2009) Work-shadowing as a process for facilitating leadership succession in primary schools. School Leadership & Management29: 239–251.
96.
TahirLSaidMNHMDaudK, et al. (2015) The benefits of headship mentoring: An analysis of Malaysian novice headteachers’ perceptions. Educational Management Administration & Leadership 44: 420–450.
97.
TengY (2020) The relationship between school climate and students’ mathematics achievement gaps in Shanghai China: Evidence from PISA 2012. Asia Pacific Journal of Education40: 356–372.
TrigwellKProsserMWaterhouseF (1999) Relations between teachers’ approaches to teaching and students’ approaches to learning. Higher Education37: 57–70.
100.
TuSG (2014) The “shadow principal” training: A self-directed professional development model of the principal. Vocational and Technical Education25: 43–47.
101.
VasquezCBrummansHGroleauC (2012) Notes from the field on organizational shadowing as framing. Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management: An International Journal7: 144–165.
102.
WalkerAHuRQianH (2012) Principal leadership in China: An initial review. School Effectiveness and School Improvement23: 369–399.
103.
WaltersWRobinsonDBWaltersJ (2019) Mentoring as meaningful professional development. International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching in Education9: 21–36.
104.
WangD (2006) The destiny of education and principal development. Hebei Education3.
105.
WangWDChaoDX (2016) Patterns of shadowing learning for primary and secondary teachers. The Inservice Education and Training of School Teachers354: 32–37.
106.
WangVTorrisi-SteeleGReinsfieldE (2020) Transformative learning, epistemology and technology in adult education. Journal of Adult and Continuing Education0: 1–17.
107.
Webster-WrightA (2009) Reframing professional development through understanding authentic professional learning. Review of Educational Research79: 702–739.
108.
WengerE (1998) Communities of Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
109.
WilsonMXueX (2013) School leader perspectives on leadership learning preparation and continuing professional development in the Chinese province of Fujian: An exploratory study. Educational Management Administration & Leadership41: 800–818.
110.
XiaoTT (2021) Salary analysis of people work in NGO organisations. Compensation China3: 48–51.
111.
XueXBushT (2021) Leadership preparation in China: Participants perspectives. International Journal of Leadership in Education 5: 990–1036.
112.
XueXBushTNgAYM (2020) Leadership preparation in China: Providers’ perspectives. Research in Education Administration and Leadership5: 990–1036.
113.
YinRK (2009) Case Study Research: Design and Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
114.
ZepedaSJ (2015) Job-Embedded Professional Development. New York: Routledge.
115.
ZhangL (2013) Issues of principalship for primary and secondary school principals: Under the perspevtives of professionalisation. Chinese Education Journal6.
116.
ZhengYWalkerAChenS (2013) Change and continuity: a critical analysis of principal development policy in Mainland China (1989–2011). Educational Management Administration and Leadership41: 484–503.
117.
ZhongQQ (2021) Deep learning: The symbol of classroom transformation. Global Education50: 14–33.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
