In the last decade, there has been growing interest in professional learning communities (PLCs) outside mainstream Western contexts. In this paper, we provide a narrative synthesis of empirical studies of PLCs in kindergarten to 12th grade educational systems in mainland China published between 2006 and 2015. The review reveals five major emerging themes in the published literature: PLC characteristics; PLC practices in different regions; teacher collaboration in PLCs; the roles of university researchers; and educational leadership in PLCs. Significant progress has been identified in the enhancement of social harmony in teaching research groups, structural teacher collaboration, the construction of transregional PLCs and the complex roles of university researchers and school leaders. However, compared with the literature on PLCs in Western contexts, research on these communities in mainland China is still far from mature. The authors highlight the need for more empirically solid research on the development of sustainable PLCs in mainland China.
BrykACamburnELouisKS (1999) Professional community in Chicago elementary schools: Facilitating factors and organizational consequences. Educational Administration Quarterly35
(5): 751–781.
2.
*ChenMZhangX (2012) 网络学习共同体中知识建构策略研究. Modern Distance Education (5): 23–28.
3.
CohenLManionLMorrisonK (2007) Research Methods in Education. 6th ed. New York, NY: Routledge.
4.
*CraigCJZouYPoimbeaufRP (2015) A narrative inquiry into schooling in China: Three images of the principalship. Journal of Curriculum Studies47
(1): 141–169.
5.
DuFourR (2004) What is a “professional learning community”?Educational Leadership61
(8): 6–11.
6.
*FengTWangLZhouM (2013) The development and change of teachers’ strategic knowledge in teachers’ online community of practice. International Journal of Asian Business and Information Management4
(1): 1–9.
7.
*GaoSWangJ (2014) Teaching transformation under centralized curriculum and teacher learning community: Two Chinese chemistry teachers’ experiences in developing inquiry-based instruction. Teaching and Teacher Education44(1): 1–11.
8.
GilesCHargreavesA (2006) The sustainability of innovative schools as learning organizations and professional learning communities during standardized reform. Educational Administration Quarterly42
(1): 124–156.
9.
HaironSDimmockC (2012) Singapore schools and professional learning communities: Teacher professional development and school leadership in an Asian hierarchical system. Educational Review64
(4): 405–424.
10.
HallingerPChenJ (2015) Review of research on educational leadership and management in Asia: A comparative analysis of research topics and methods, 1995–2012. Educational Management Administration & Leadership43
(1): 5–27.
11.
HargreavesA (2003) Teaching in the Knowledge Society: Education in the Age of Insecurity. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
12.
HarrisAJonesM (2010) Professional learning communities and system improvement. Improving Schools13
(2): 172–181.
13.
*HeJ (2009) 在共同体活动中提升教师的教学语言修养. Global Education38(1): 94–96.
14.
HordSM (1997) Professional learning communities: Communities of continuous inquiry and improvement. Austin, TX: Southwest Educational Development Laboratory. Available at:http://www.sedl.org/pubs/change34/plc-cha34.pdf(accessed 2 May 2017).
15.
HuY (2012) 我国中学教研组性质的实证研究. Journal of Educational Studies8(6): 78–89.
16.
*HuY (2013) 专业学习共同体视角下的教研组建设. Educational Research (10): 37–43.
KruseSDJohnsonBL (2017) Tempering the normative demands of professional learning communities with the organizational realities of life in schools: Exploring the cognitive dilemmas faced by educational leaders. Educational Management Administration & Leadership45(4): 588–604.
20.
KruseSDLouisKS (2007) Building professional learning community top-down: A case-based reflection. In: StollLLouisKS (eds) Professional Learning Communities: Divergence, Detail and Difficulties. London, UK: Swets and Zeitlinger Publishers, pp.106–118.
21.
*KongFZhangS (2010) 中小学教研模式创新的思路与实践. Journal of the Chinese Society of Education (11): 67–69.
22.
LevineTH (2010) Tools for the study and design of collaborative teacher learning: The affordances of different conceptions of teacher community and activity theory. Teacher Education Quarterly37
(1): 109–130.
23.
*LiXQiCShiX (2013) 初中数学教师教学设计能力发展的实证研究. China Educational Technology (3): 56–61.
24.
*LiYGuanXZengF (2009) 区域网上研修活动的现状分析及对策. China Educational Technology (12): 83–86.
25.
*LiZ (2011) Learners’ reflexivity and the development of an e-learning community among students in China. Research in Learning Technology19
(1): 5–17.
26.
*LiuLRenJ (2009) 协作知识建构视角下的教师论坛组织策略研究. Modern Educational Technology19(10): 94–97.
27.
LouisKS (2006) Changing the culture of schools: Professional community, organizational learning, and trust. Journal of School Leadership16
(5): 477–489.
28.
LouisKSKruseSD (1995) Professionalism and Community: Perspectives from Urban Schools. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
29.
*MengZLanGXuMZhangY. (2015) 基于QQ群的教师学习共同体运行现状研究. Open Education Research21(5): 101–111.
30.
PaineLWFangY (2006) Reform as hybrid model of teaching and teacher development in China. International Journal of Educational Research45
(4–5): 279–289.
31.
*PengA (2007) Knowledge growth of mathematics teachers during professional activity based on the task of lesson explaining. Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education10
(4): 289–299.
*RyanJKangCMitchellIEricksonG (2009) China’s basic education reform: An account of an international collaborative research and development project. Asia Pacific Journal of Education29
(4): 427–441.
35.
*SargentTC (2015) Professional learning communities and the diffusion of pedagogical innovation in the Chinese education system. Comparative Education Review59
(1): 102–132.
36.
*SargentTCHannumE (2009) Doing more with less: Teacher professional learning communities in resource-constrained primary schools in rural China. Journal of Teacher Education60
(3): 258–276.
37.
ShieldsCM (2001) A dialogue about communities of difference: A rejoinder to Robert Boostrom. Curriculum Inquiry31
(1): 71–76.
38.
SnilstveitBOliverSVojtkovaM (2012) Narrative approaches to systematic review and synthesis of evidence for international development policy and practice. Journal of Development Effectiveness4
(3): 409–429.
39.
*SongH (2011) 课程改革、教师赋权增能与教师专业学习共同体. Journal of Educational Studies7(3): 63–74.
40.
*SongH (2012) The role of teachers’ professional learning communities in the context of curriculum reform in high schools. Chinese Education & Society45
(4): 81–95.
41.
*SongHWeiX (2011) 教师课改认同感与教师专业学习社群的关系研究. Research in Educational Development (10): 69–73.
StollLBolamRMcMahonAWallaceMThomasSM (2006) Professional learning communities: A review of the literature. Journal of Education Change7
(4): 221–258.
44.
TamACF (2015) The role of a professional learning community in teacher change: A perspective from beliefs and practices. Teachers and Teaching21
(1): 22–43.
45.
*TangXShaoF (2014) On the evolution of a lesson: Group preparation for teaching contest as teacher professional development activity for Chinese elementary science teachers. Journal of Science Education and Technology23
(2): 252–266.
46.
*ThomasSMPengWJLiJZ (2015) 学校增值表现与教师专业发展关联性探析. Educational Research (7): 64–72.
47.
*WanLZhaoCLiaoWShuF. (2012) 基于 QQ 群的网络学习共同体社会互动研究E-Education Research (9): 54–58.
48.
*WangC (2013) 信任、批判与挑战：教师专业发展模式探索. Curriculum, Teaching Material and Method33(3): 123–127.
49.
WangJPaineLW (2003) Learning to teach with mandated curriculum and public examination of teaching as contexts. Teaching & Teacher Education19
(1): 75–94.
50.
*WangQLuZ (2012) A case study of using an online community of practice for teachers’ professional development at a secondary school in China. Learning, Media and Technology37
(4): 429–446.
51.
*WangT (2015) Contrived collegiality versus genuine collegiality: Demystifying professional learning communities in Chinese schools. Compare45
(6): 908–930.
52.
WangT (2016) School leadership and professional learning community: Case study of two senior high schools in Northeast China. Asia Pacific Journal of Education36
(2): 202–216.
53.
*WongJL (2010a) Searching for good practice in teaching: A comparison of two subject-based professional learning communities in a secondary school in Shanghai. Compare40
(5): 623–639.
54.
*WongJL (2010b) What makes a professional learning community possible? A case study of a Mathematics department in a junior secondary school of China. Asia Pacific Education Review11
(2): 131–139.
55.
*WuG (2008) 新课程行动中的教师成长. PhD Thesis, East China Normal University, China.
56.
*WuHGaoJZhangW (2013) 在线共同体环境下草根教师专业成长的个案研究. China Educational Technology (5): 47–53.
57.
*WuW (2012) 年轻专家——新手教师合作研究叙事的知识论分析. Studies in Preschool Education (2): 44–48.
58.
*YangYGuoSTongH (2011) 城乡教师的网络学习共同体互动特征研究. China Educational Technology (11): 42–46.
59.
YinHLeeCKWangW (2014) Dilemmas of leading national curriculum reform in a global era: A Chinese perspective. Educational Management Administration & Leadership42
(2): 293–311.
60.
*ZhangD (2009) 课例研究：提升学校效能的文化工具. Journal of the Chinese Society of Education (10): 21–25.
61.
*ZhangHBuC (2007) 基于Blog提高中小学教师教育科研能力的实验研究. China Educational Technology (9): 66–69.
62.
*ZhangJLinL (2012) 基于知识管理SECI模型的教师学习共同体构建研究. E-Education Research (9): 31–35.
ZhangJYuanRYuS (2017) What impedes the development of professional learning communities in china? Perceptions from leaders and frontline teachers in three schools in shanghai. Educational Management Administration & Leadership45
(2): 219–237.
65.
*ZhaoJGuoS (2013) 网络环境下教师学习共同体运行效果的调查分析. China Educational Technology (9): 78–81.
66.
*ZhaoJ (2011) 网络环境下城乡互动教师学习共同体构建与运行研究. PhD Thesis, Northwest Normal University, China.
67.
*ZhaoJPeiXFengRChengJJinY. (2013) 我国教师的专业发展实践及其对学生成绩的影响. Global Education42(2): 22–33.
