In this article we ask ‘how can we judge whether a policy initiative
produces innovation?’. We focus first on the concept of innovation,
touching on some aspects of its recent development, noting a resurgence of interest
in it over the past few years in the schools policy field in England and proposing a
tentative definition. We then refer to the national initiative known as Diversity
Pathfinders (DP), of which we are conducting an evaluation, and briefly consider the
implications of the idea of ‘pathfinding’ and related notions.
Finally we describe some possible examples of innovations from our DP case studies
and draw some conclusions for thinking about and researching innovations.
Anderson, L.
and
Bennett, N.
, eds (2003) Developing Educational Leadership: Using Evidence
for Policy and Practice.
London, SAGE
.
2.
Bolam, R.
(1975) ‘The Management of Educational Change:
Towards a Conceptual Framework’, in
V.P. Houghton
,
D.A.R. McHugh
and
C. Morgan
(eds) The Management of Education, Reader 1: the Management of
Organisations and Individuals.
London: Croom Helm
.
3.
Chapman, J.
(2002) System Failure: Why Governments Must Learn to Think
Differently.
London: Demos
.
4.
Chin, R.
and
Benne, K. D.
(1976) ‘General Strategies for Effecting Changes
in Human Systems’, in
W.G. Bennis
,
K.D. Benne
,
R. Chin
and
K.E. Corey
(eds) The Planning of Change, 3rd edn, pp.
22-45.
New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston
.
5.
Coburn, C. E.
(2003),
‘Rethinking Scale: Moving Beyond Numbers to Deep and Lasting Change’
, Educational Researcher32(6):
3-12
.
6.
DfES
(2001) Schools Achieving Success.
London: Department for Education and Skills
.
7.
Elmore, R.
(1996),
‘Getting to Scale with Good Educational Practice’
, Harvard Educational Review66(1):
1-26
.
8.
Fullan, M.
(2001) The New Meaning of Educational Change, 3rd edn.London: Routledge/Falmer
.
9.
Glatter, R.
(1986) ‘The Management of School
Improvement’, in
E. Hoyle
and
A. McMahon
(eds) The World Yearbook of Education: The Management of Schools,
pp. 87-99.
London: Kogan Page
.
10.
Glatter, R.
(2003a) ‘Governance and Educational
Innovation’, in
B. Davies
and
J. West-Burnham
(eds) Handbook of Educational Leadership and Management, pp.
228-237.
London: Pearson Longman
.
11.
Glatter, R.
(2003b)
‘Collaboration, Collaboration, Collaboration: the Origins and
Implementation of a Policy’
, Management in Education17(5):
16-20
.
12.
Gross, N.
,
Giacquinta, J. B.
and
Bernstein, M.
(1971) Implementing Organizational Innovations: a
Sociological Analysis of Planned Educational Change.
New York: Harper and Row
.
13.
Hallgarten, J.
and
Watling, R.
(2001)
‘Buying Power: The Role of the Private Sector in Education Action Zones’
, School Leadership and Management21(2):
143-157
.
14.
Hargreaves, D.
(2003) Education Epidemic: Transforming Secondary Schools
through Innovation Networks.
London: Demos
.
15.
Hargreaves, D.
(2004) Working Laterally: How Innovation Networks Make an
Education Epidemic.
London: Department for Education and Skills
Innovation Unit, Demos and the National College for School Leadership
.
16.
Havelock, R. G.
(1973) The Change Agents’ Guide to Innovation in
Education.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Educational Technology Publications
.
17.
Leithwood, K.
,
Jantzi, D.
and
Steinbach, R.
(2002) ‘Future Schools and Leaders’
Values’, in
M. Preedy
,
R. Glatter
and
C. Wise
(eds) Strategic Leadership and Educational Improvement.
London: Paul Chapman Publishing/The Open University
.
18.
March, J.
(1999) The Pursuit of Organisational Intelligence.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
19.
McMillan, E.
(2004) Complexity, Organizations and Change.
London: Routledge
.
20.
Miller, R.
and
Bentley, T.
(2003) Possible Futures: Four Scenarios for 21st Century
Schooling.
Nottingham: National College for School Leadership
.
21.
Morgan, G.
(1993) Imaginization.
London: SAGE
.
22.
NCSL
(2003) Creative Waves.
Nottingham: National College for School Leadership
.
23.
Ofsted
(2003) Excellence in Cities and Education Action Zones:
Management and Impact, HMI 1399.
London: Office for Standards in Education
.
24.
Pettigrew, A.
,
Woodman, R. W.
and
Cameron, K. S.
(2001)
‘Studying Organisational Change and Development: Challenges for
Future Research’
, Academy of Management Journal44(4):
697-714
.
25.
Wallace, M.
(2002) Managing Complex Educational Change: Large-scale
Reorganisation of Schools.
London: Routledge/Falmer
.
26.
Woods, P. A.
,
Bagley, C.
and
Glatter, R.
(1998) School Choice and Competition: Markets in the Public Interest?London: Routledge
.
27.
Woods, P. A.
,
Castle, F.
,
Cooper, D.
,
Evans, J.
and
Glatter, R.
(2003)
‘Pathfinding and Diversity: Similarities and Differences in
LEAs’ and Schools’ Responses to a Government Initiative
at Local Level’
, paper presented at the Annual Conference of the British
Educational Research Association, Edinburgh, September.
