Engaging underserved populations in research requires substantial effort for recruitment and retention. The objective of this study is to describe the effort needed to recruit and retain urban participants in pediatric asthma studies and to characterize the Hardest-to-Reach group by demographics and asthma severity.
Methods
We included 311 children (3–10 years) with persistent asthma enrolled in two school-based asthma interventions in Rochester, NY. Contact logs were collected at four time points (baseline, 2 month, 4 month, 6 month). We defined “Hardest-to-Reach” (vs “Easier-to-Reach”) as being unable to reach a family by telephone at any given contact attempt due to disconnected or wrong numbers. Chi-square and Mann–Whitney tests were used to compare groups.
Results
Overall, we enrolled 311 children (60% Black, 29% Hispanic, 70% Medicaid, response rate 70%). On average, 3.1 contact attempts were required for recruitment (range 1–15), and 35% required rescheduling at least once for the enrollment visit. All but 12 participants completed each follow-up (retention rate = 96%). Completion of follow-ups required an average of 7.6 attempts; we considered 38% of caregivers “Hardest-to-Reach.” Caregivers in the Hardest-to-Reach group were slightly younger (33 vs 36 years, p = 0.007) with more depressive symptoms (41% vs 29%, p = 0.035) and smokers in the home (59% vs 48%, p = 0.048). Furthermore, more of the Hardest-to-Reach children had moderate-severe versus mild persistent asthma (64% vs 52%, p = 0.045). Importantly, even the Easier-to-Reach families required many contact attempts, with 52% having >5 attempts for at least one follow-up.
Conclusion
In conclusion, we found that among an already vulnerable population, the Hardest-to-Reach families demonstrated higher risk and had children with significantly worse asthma. This study highlights the importance of persistence in reaching those in greatest need.
National Asthma Education and Prevention Program. Expert panel report 3 (EPR-3): guidelines for the diagnosis and management of asthma-summary report 2007. J Allergy Clin Immunol2007; 120: S94–S138.
2.
CarrWZeitelLWeissK.Variations in asthma hospitalizations and deaths in New York City. Am J Public Health1992; 82: 59–65.
3.
LangDMPolanskyM.Patterns of asthma mortality in Philadelphia from 1969 to 1991. N Engl J Med1994; 331: 1542–1546.
4.
WeissKBSullivanSDLyttleCS.Trends in the cost of illness for asthma in the United States, 1985–1994. J Allergy Clin Immunol2000; 106: 493–499.
5.
WeissKBWagenerDK.Changing patterns of asthma mortality. Identifying target populations at high risk. JAMA1990; 264: 1683–1687.
6.
GeraldLBMcClureLAManganJMet al. Increasing adherence to inhaled steroid therapy among schoolchildren: randomized, controlled trial of school-based supervised asthma therapy. Pediatrics2009; 123: 466–474.
7.
ButzAMTsouklerisMGDonithanMet al. Effectiveness of nebulizer use-targeted asthma education on underserved children with asthma. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med2006; 160: 622–628.
8.
HaltermanJSSauerJFagnanoMet al. Working toward a sustainable system of asthma care: development of the School-Based Preventive Asthma Care Technology (SB-PACT) trial. J Asthma2012; 49: 395–400.
9.
HaltermanJSFagnanoMTajonRSet al. Effect of the School-Based Telemedicine Enhanced Asthma Management (SB-TEAM) program on asthma morbidity: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Pediatr2018; 172: e174938.
10.
HaltermanJSTajonRTremblayPet al. Development of School-Based Asthma Management Programs in Rochester, New York: presented in honor of Dr Robert Haggerty. Acad Pediatr2017; 17: 595–599.
11.
LevkoffSSanchezH.Lessons learned about minority recruitment and retention from the Centers on Minority Aging and Health Promotion. Gerontologist2003; 43: 18–26.
NessRBNelsonDBKumanyikaSKet al. Evaluating minority recruitment into clinical studies: how good are the data?Ann Epidemiol1997; 7: 472–478.
14.
ZookPMJordanCAdamsBet al. Retention strategies and predictors of attrition in an urban pediatric asthma study. Clin Trials2010; 7: 400–410.
15.
Corbie-SmithGThomasSBSt GeorgeDM.Distrust, race, and research. Arch Intern Med2002; 162: 2458–2463.
16.
AroianKJKatzAKulwickiA.Recruiting and retaining Arab Muslim mothers and children for research. J Nurs Scholarsh2006; 38: 255–261.
17.
DumvilleJCTorgersonDJHewittCE.Reporting attrition in randomised controlled trials. BMJ2006; 332: 969–971.
18.
FewtrellMSKennedyKSinghalAet al. How much loss to follow-up is acceptable in long-term randomised trials and prospective studies?Arch Dis Child2008; 93: 458–461.
19.
HaltermanJSBorrelliBFisherSet al. Improving care for urban children with asthma: design and methods of the School-Based Asthma Therapy (SBAT) trial. J Asthma2008; 45: 279–286.
20.
HaltermanJSFagnanoMMontesGet al. The school-based preventive asthma care trial: results of a pilot study. J Pediatr2012; 161: 1109–1115.
21.
HaltermanJSSzilagyiPGFisherSGet al. Randomized controlled trial to improve care for urban children with asthma: results of the School-Based Asthma Therapy trial. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med2011; 165: 262–268.
22.
AndrewsGSladeT.Interpreting scores on the Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K10). Aust N Z J Public Health2001; 25: 494–497.
23.
FaulstichMECareyMPRuggieroLet al. Assessment of depression in childhood and adolescence: an evaluation of the Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale for Children (CES-DC). Am J Psychiatry1986; 143: 1024–1027.
24.
MattGEWahlgrenDRHovellMFet al. Measuring environmental tobacco smoke exposure in infants and young children through urine cotinine and memory-based parental reports: empirical findings and discussion. Tob Control1999; 8: 282–289.
25.
WakefieldMBanhamDMartinJet al. Restrictions on smoking at home and urinary cotinine levels among children with asthma. Am J Prev Med2000; 19: 188–192.
26.
JuniperEFGuyattGHFeenyDHet al. Measuring quality of life in the parents of children with asthma. Qual Life Res1996; 5: 27–34.
27.
AkinbamiLJMoormanJESimonAEet al. Trends in racial disparities for asthma outcomes among children 0 to 17 years, 2001–2010. J Allergy Clin Immunol2014; 134: 547–553.
28.
CrockerDBrownCMoolenaarRet al. Racial and ethnic disparities in asthma medication usage and health-care utilization: data from the National Asthma Survey. Chest2009; 136: 1063–1071.
GuptaRSCarrion-CarireVWeissKB.The widening black/white gap in asthma hospitalizations and mortality. J Allergy Clin Immunol2006; 117: 351–358.
31.
DesaiMOppenheimerJJ.Medication adherence in the asthmatic child and adolescent. Curr Allergy Asthma Rep2011; 11: 454–464.
32.
FinkelsteinJALozanoPFarberHJet al. Underuse of controller medications among Medicaid-insured children with asthma. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med2002; 156: 562–567.
33.
OrtegaANGergenPJPaltielADet al. Impact of site of care, race, and Hispanic ethnicity on medication use for childhood asthma. Pediatrics2002; 109: E1.
34.
McDanielMKWaldfogelJ.Racial and ethnic differences in the management of childhood asthma in the United States. J Asthma2012; 49: 785–791.
35.
FloresGSnowden-BridonCTorresSet al. Urban minority children with asthma: substantial morbidity, compromised quality and access to specialists, and the importance of poverty and specialty care. J Asthma2009; 46: 392–398.
36.
ElyBColemanC.Recruitment and retention of children in longitudinal research. J Spec Pediatr Nurs2007; 12: 199–202.
37.
LoftinWABarnettSKBunnPSet al. Recruitment and retention of rural African Americans in diabetes research: lessons learned. Diabetes Educ2005; 31: 251–259.
38.
YanceyAKOrtegaANKumanyikaSK.Effective recruitment and retention of minority research participants. Annu Rev Public Health2006; 27: 1–28.
39.
SeedMJuarezMAlnatourR.Improving recruitment and retention rates in preventive longitudinal research with adolescent mothers. J Child Adolesc Psychiatr Nurs2009; 22: 150–153.
40.
ShahabiABernsteinLAzenSPet al. Recruitment and retention of African American and Latino preadolescent females into a longitudinal biobehavioral study. Ethn Dis2011; 21: 91–98.
41.
KarlsonCWRapoffMA.Attrition in randomized controlled trials for pediatric chronic conditions. J Pediatr Psychol2009; 34: 782–793.
42.
SenturiaYDMcNiff MortimerKBakerDet al. Successful techniques for retention of study participants in an inner-city population. Control Clin Trials1998; 19: 544–554.
43.
EzellJMSaltzgaberJPetersonEet al. Reconnecting with urban youth enrolled in a randomized controlled trial and overdue for a 12-month follow-up survey. Clin Trials2013; 10: 775–782.
44.
SchoeppeSOliverMBadlandHMet al. Recruitment and retention of children in behavioral health risk factor studies: REACH strategies. Int J Behav Med2014; 21: 794–803.
45.
CuiZSeburgEMSherwoodNEet al. Recruitment and retention in obesity prevention and treatment trials targeting minority or low-income children: a review of the clinical trials registration database. Trials2015; 16: 564.
46.
ProbstfieldJLFryeRL.Strategies for recruitment and retention of participants in clinical trials. JAMA2011; 306: 1798–1799.
