Consent for genetics studies among clinical trial participants: findings from Action for Health in Diabetes (Look AHEAD)

Abstract

Background Increasingly, genetic specimens are collected to expand the value of clinical trials through study of genetic effects on disease incidence, progression or response to interventions.

Purpose and methods We describe the experience obtaining IRB-approved DNA consent forms across the 19 institutions in the Action for Health in Diabetes (Look AHEAD), a clinical trial examining the effect of a lifestyle intervention for weight loss on the risk of serious cardiovascular events among individuals with type 2 diabetes. We document the rates participants provided consent for DNA research, identify participant characteristics associated with consent, and discuss implications for genetics research.

Results IRB approval to participate was obtained from 17 of 19 institutions. The overall rate of consent was 89.6% among the 15 institutions that had completed consenting at the time of our analysis, which was higher than reported for other types of cohort studies. Consent rates were associated with factors expected to be associated with weight loss and cardiovascular disease and to affect the distribution of candidate genes. Non-consent occurred more frequently among participants grouped as African-American, Hispanic, female, more highly educated or not dyslipidemic.

Limitations The generalizabilty of results is limited by the inclusion/exclusion criteria of the trial.

Conclusions Barriers to obtaining consent to participate in genetic studies may differ from other recruitment settings. Because of the potentially complex associations between personal characteristics related to adherence, outcomes and gene distributions, differential rates of consent may introduce biases in estimates of genetic relationships.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Lavori PW , Krause-Steinrauf H , Brophy M et al. Prinicples, organization, and operation of a DNA bank for clinical trials: a Department of Veterans Affairs cooperative study . Controlled Clin Trials 2003; 23: 222–239 .

Look AHEAD Research Group . Look AHEAD: Action for Health in Diabetes. Design and methods for a clinical trial of weight loss for the prevention of cardiovascular disease in type 2 diabetes . Controlled Clin Trials 2003; 24: 610–628 .

Clayton EW , Steinberg KK , Khoury MJ et al. Informed consent for genetic research on stored tissue samples . JAMA 1995; 274: 1786–1792 .

Beskow LM , Burke W , Merz JF et al. Informed consent for population-based research involving genetics . JAMA 2001; 18: 2315–2321 .

Jones CP . Invited commentary: “Race,” racism, and the practice of epidemiology . Am J Epidemiol 2001; 154; 299–304 .

SAS Institute Inc. . 2004 SAS/STAT 9.1 user's guide. SAS Institute Inc.

Engel LS , Rothman N , Knott C et al. Factors associated with refusal to provide a buccal cell sample in the Agricultural Health Study . Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2002; 11: 493–496 .

Kozlowski LT , Vogler GP , Vandenbergh DJ , Strasser AA , O'Connor RJ , Yost BA . Using a telephone survey to acquire genetic and behavioral data related to cigarette smoking in “Made-Anonymous” and “Registry” samples . Am J Epidemiol 2002; 156: 68–77 .

Le Marchand L , Lum-Jones A , Saltzman B , Visaya V , Nomura AM , Kolonel LN . Feasibility of collecting buccal cell DNA by mail in a cohort study . Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2001; 10: 701–703 .

10.

McQuillan GM , Porter KS , Agelli M , Kington R . Consent for genetic research in a general population: the NHANES experience . Genet Med 2003; 5: 35–42 .

11.

Lovato LC , Hill K , Hertert S , Hunninghake DB , Probstfield JL . Recruitment for controlled clinical trials: literature summary and annotated bibliography . Controlled Clin Trials 1997; 18: 328–357 .

12.

Wyatt SB , Diekelmann N , Henderson F et al. A community-driven model of research participation: the Jackson Heart Study Participant Recruitment and Retention Study . Ethn Dis 2003; 13: 438–455 .

13.

El-Sadr W , Capps L . The challenge of minority recruitment in clinical trials for AIDS . JAMA 1992; 267: 954–937 .

14.

Shavers VL , Lynch CF , Burmeister LF . Racial differences in factors that influence the willingness to participate in medical research studies . Ann Epidemiol 2002; 12: 248–256 .

15.

Stoddart ML , Jarvis B , Blake B et al. Recruitment of American Indians in epidemiologic research: the Strong Heart Study . Am Indian Alask Native Ment Health Res 2000; 9: 20–37 .

16.

Haddock CK , Poston WSC , Dill PL , Foreyt JP , Ericsson M. Pharmacotherapy for obesity: a quantitative analysis of four decades of published randomized clinical trials . Int J Obesity 2002; 26: 262–273 .

17.

Gorkin L , Schron EB , Handshaw K et al. Clinical trial enrollees vs nonenrollers: The Cardiac Arrythmia Suppression Trial (CAST) Recruitment and Enrollment Assessment in Clinical Trials (REACT) project . Controlled Clin Trials 1996; 17: 46–59 .

18.

Cappelli M , Hunter AGW , Stern H et al. Participation rates of Ashkenazi Jews in a colon cancer communitybased screening/prevention study . Clin Genet 2002; 61: 104–114 .

19.

Rimer BK , Schildkraut JM , Lerman C , Lin TH , Audrain J . Participation in a women's breast cancer risk counseling trial. Who participates? Who declines? High Risk Breast Cancer Consortium . Cancer 1996; 77: 2348–2355 .

20.

Walker M , Shaper AG , Cook DG . Non-participation and mortality in a prospective health study of cardiovascular disease . Am J Epidemiol 1987; 41: 295–299 .

21.

Lindsted KD , Fraser GE , Steinkohl M , Beeson WL . Healthy volunteer effect in a cohort study: temporal resolution in the Adventist Health Study . J Clin Epidemiol 1996; 49: 783–790 .

22.

Froom P , Melamed S , Kristal-Boneh E , Benbassat J , Ribak J . Healthy volunteer effect in industrial workers . J Clin Epidemiol 1999; 52: 731–735 .

23.

Little RJA , Rubin DB .Statistical analysis with missing data, second edition. John Wiley and Sons , 2002.

24.

Fitzmaurice GM , Lipsitz, SR , Molenberghs G , Ibrahim JG . Bias in estimating association parameters for longitudinal binary responses with drop-outs . Biometrics 2001; 57: 15–21 .

25.

Zhao LP , Lipsitz S , Lew D . Regression analysis with missing covariate data using estimating equations . Biometrics 1996; 52: 1165–1182 .