Design of the Jerusalem Handwashing Study: meeting the challenges of a preschool-based public health intervention trial

Abstract

Background Rates of communicable disease among young children are considerably higher in Israel than in other western countries. Strategies for reducing the disease rates are needed.

Purpose The goal of the Jerusalem Handwashing Study (JHS) was to evaluate a preschool-based hygiene programme aimed at reducing illness absenteeism.

Methods The trial employed cluster randomization of preschools to intervention or control. The intervention programme was multifaceted, including various educational activities and environmental changes. The control group received the programme at the end of the study. A supplementary home component was tested using the innovative design strategy of an embedded individually-randomized trial. All-cause absenteeism and illness-related absenteeism was assessed by daily phone calls to the teachers, supplemented with phone calls to the parents to identify the cause of the absence. The primary endpoint was illness-related absenteeism. In an attempt to avoid bias, survey staff were blinded to the study design and the main outcome as well as intervention status. Validity checks were incorporated to assess the accuracy of educator absenteeism reports and were analysed for differences between the study arms. Observation of handwashing behaviour allowed assessment of behavioural change in the intervention group and spontaneous handwashing changes in the control group.

Results Cluster randomization with delayed implementation in the control group was a feasible and efficient strategy. The individually-randomized embedded sub-trial proved to be an efficient way to test a supplemental intervention component, and is particularly well-suited to programmes run in educational or other group settings, including workplaces, clinics, and community centres.

Limitations The trial design did not permit analysis of the intervention effect on illness.

Conclusions The techniques used in this trial made it possible for a rigorous study of a complex community-based health intervention to be carried out successfully. They should prove helpful to future researchers.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Fox JP , Hall CE (eds). Viruses in families: surveillance of families as a key to epidemiology of virus infections. PSG Publishing , 1980.

Kotch J , Weigle K , Weber D et al. Evaluation of an hygienic intervention in child day-care centers . Pediatrics 1994; 94: 990-994 .

Niffenegger J. Handwashing promotes wellness in child care . J Pediatr Health Care 1997; 11: 26-31 .

Masters D. Scheduled handwashing in an elementary school population . Fam Med 1997; 29: 336-339 .

Courtney K. The effect of a handwashing education program on illness-related absenteeism and attitudes toward handwashing [dissertation]. UMI Dissertation Information Service, 1995.

Bartlett A , Jarvis B , Ross V et al. Diarrheal illness among infants and toddlers in day care centers: Effects of active surveillance and staff training without subsequent monitoring . Am J Epidemiol 1988; 127: 808-817 .

Hammond B , Ali Y , Fendler E , Dolan M , Donovan S. Effect of hand sanitizer use on elementary school absenteeism . AJIC 2000; 28: 340-346 .

Roberts L , Smith W , Jorm L , Patel M , Douglas R , McGilchrist C. Effect of infection control measures on the frequency of upper respiratory infection in child care: a randomized, controlled trial . Pediatrics 2000; 105: 738-742 .

Guinan M , McGuckin M , Ali Y. The effect of a comprehensive handwashing program on absenteeism in elementary schools . AJIC 2002; 30: 217-220 .

10.

Dyer D , Shinder D , Shinder F. Alcohol-free instant hand sanitizer reduces elementary school illness absenteeism . Am Med 2000; 32: 633-638 .

11.

White C , Shinder F , Shinder A , Dyer D. Reduction of illness absenteeism in elementary schools using an alcohol-free instant hand sanitizer . Journal of School Nursing 2001; 17: 258-265 .

12.

Israel Center for Disease Control . Health status Israel. Publication 202 , 1997.

13.

Rosen LJ. A controlled trial to assess the effect of a health promotion intervention on hygiene behavior and absenteeism in Jerusalem preschools [dissertation]. Jerusalem (Israel): Hebrew University, 2004.

14.

Rosen L , Manor O , Engelhard D et al. Can a handwashing intervention make a difference? Results from a randomized controlled trial in Jerusalem preschools . Prev Med 2006; 42: 27-32 .

15.

Murray D. Design and analysis of group randomized trials. Oxford University Press , 1998.

16.

Gortmaker SL , Peterson K , Wiecha J et al. Reducing obesity via a school-based interdisciplinary intervention among youth: Planet Health . Ach Pediatr Adolec Med 1999; 153: 409-418 .

17.

Perry CL , Luepker RV , Murray DM et al. Parent involvement with children’s health promotion: a one-year follow-up of the Minnesota Home Team . Health Educ Quart 1989; 16: 171-180 .

18.

Nader PR , Sallis JF , Patterson TL et al. A family approach to cardiovascular risk reduction: results from the San Diego Family Health Project . Health Educ Quart 1989; 16: 229-244 .

19.

New Jersey State Department of Education . Division of Information, Management and Financial Services, Trenton, New Jersey , 1996.

20.

Friedman L , Furberg C , DeMets D. Fundamentals of clinical trials, 3rd edition. Springer , 1998.

21.

Zucker DM. Cluster randomization. In Geller N ed. Contemporary biostatistical methods in clinical trials. Marcel Dekker , 2000: 86-87.

22.

MacMahon B , Tricohpoulos D. Epidemiology, principles and methods, 2nd edition. Little Brown , 1996: 184-184.

23.

Haggerty PA , Muladi K , Kirkwood BR , Ashworth A , Manunebo M. Community-based hygiene education to reduce diarrhoeal disease in rural Zaire: impact of the intervention on diarrhoeal morbidity . Int J Epidemiol 1994; 23: 1050-1059 .