Abstract
Objectives & Introduction
It is possible to damage the natural intestinal barrier following severe burn injuries. Oral probiotics' positive effects on the innate immune system or intestinal epithelial layer are proven. This research aimed to evaluate the role of probiotics on plasma inflammatory changes and bacterial colonization in the burned wound after high-grade thermal trauma.
Methods
This double-blinded randomized controlled trial was conducted on 80 patients with a total body surface area of 20–70%. Patients were allocated to two groups based on four blocks randomization model. Intervention and control groups received daily LactoCare and placebo capsules for 14 consecutive days. Obtaining demographic data, burn and gastrointestinal symptoms were registered by filling out a questionnaire. Additionally, measuring plasma levels of highly sensitive C-reactive protein(hs-CRP), IgA, absolute neutrophilic, and lymphocytic count were performed cumulatively four times prior to and after the intervention.
Results
Considering eligible data, following the study period analysis showed significant mitigation of inflammatory status in probiotic receivers. The hs-CRP reduced following probiotic (21.38 ± 44.45) consumption compared with placebo (−36.36 ± 79.03) intake (p < 0.001). Also, the plasma level of IgA significantly decreased in the intervention group (0.88 ± 0.65) than in the control group (0.79 ± 0.18) (p < 0.001). Wound cultures showed no significant difference between groups, although the incidence rate of bacterial colonization was slightly lower after using probiotics (p = 0.159). Regarding wound healing, data illustrated that probiotics could accelerate wound healing after 14 days of regular consumption (p < 0.001).
Conclusion
Probiotics have advantages for the mitigation of inflammation and wound healing following severe thermal burn injuries. Trends toward Improvement Immune system by increasing IgA level and lymphocytic count and possible Reduction of wound area with exogenous probiotic administration in patients with burns suggest that further investigation in larger sample size is necessary to corroborate our initial, promising findings.
Introduction
Burns is one of the most expensive traumatic events that lead to a long period of hospitalization and high costs for the repair of the wounds and following complications. About 300,000 people worldwide die from burns yearly, mainly in developing and underdeveloped countries. Due to the advancement of medical knowledge and health care services in recent few decades mortality rate related to burn injuries has decreased globally, although morbid side effects remain unchanged.1–4
Previously local infection of the wound site was considered as paramount reason for post burning sepsis. 4 Despite the prescription of broad-spectrum antibiotics, the development of dressing materials and techniques, and upgraded surgical approaches incidence of sepsis has slightly decreased. The latter part has been explained by bacterial translocation of intestinal flora to the bloodstream following systemic effects of burn injury. During this phenomenon, the bacteria pass through the mucosal barrier of the digestive system and could be colonized in the liver, spleen, bloodstream, and mesenteric lymph nodes. 5
Innately, the normal flora of the healthy intestine prevents the pathologic translocation of microorganisms with different mechanisms, which is disrupted following severe burning. 6 The normal flora of the intestine plays important roles including absorption of food, production of different vital metabolites, signaling intestinal epithelia, and reinforcement of function of the immune system by precluding invasive pathogens. 7 Furthermore, the intestinal mucosal layer act as a local defensive barrier preventing either bacteria or endotoxins that normally exist in the area from penetration to extra-intestinal space. 5 Preservation of the latter needs normal mesenteric blood flow, which is disturbed following burn injuries concurrent with physiological stress. 8
Except for mesenteric blood flow disruption, extensive burning directly leads to blood flow shunting towards the site of injury and more oxygen consumption, which finally concludes in hypoxemia and free radical production, negatively influencing other tissues, including gastrointestinal(GI) tract. 6 Next, GI ischemia occurs, and the stressful digestive system plays a role as a pro-inflammatory source; following splenic perfusion reduction, inflammatory factors are released from the digestive system, which causes disruption of cell function and activation of neutrophils and other pro-inflammatory cells. One of the results of the latter is bacterial immigration to extraluminal space followed by the temporary weakness of the innate immune, intestinal barrier.5,6 Recently, advocates of the hypothesis of reinforcing intestinal barrier integrity with adding intestinal flora to deal with the aformentiond pathology have increased.6,9 Probiotics consist of live microorganisms helping host’s intestinal immune system against bacterial expansion specifically through functional improvement of Tol-like receptor 2(TLR2), activiation of intestinal epithelial cells, qualification of phagocytosis, and production of specific antibodies in plasma.9–12 Probiotics consist of live microorganisms helping the host’s intestinal immune system against bacterial expansion, specifically through the functional improvement of Tol-like receptor 2(TLR2), activation of intestinal epithelial cells, qualification of phagocytosis, and production of specific antibodies in plasma. 13
The main strains of probiotics include Lactobacillus Acidophilus, Lactobacillus casei, and some species of bifidobacterium colonizing in human’s small intestine and inhibiting the growth of pathogenic microorganisms through the production of organic acids, cytokines, and bacteriocidal factors.12,14 Further, other approved immune enhancing mechanisms directly related to probiotics can point to increasing numbers of macrophages and natural killer cells, production of hydrogen peroxide(H2O2) and lactic acid, prevention of anchoring pathogens to intestinal cells, and mitigation of inflammatory response caused by the pathogen.12,15,16
Probiotics bacteria also influence the immunological defense and inflammation system by the production of diverse cytokines that enhance the reaction of the immunological system to pathogens, enhancement of the phagocytic capabilities of polymorphonuclears, augmentation of natural killer cell activity, and amplification of production of specific antibodies and immunoglobulins against pathogenic bacteria. According to the aforementioned data and regarding the feasible availability and low expense of probiotics preparation in association with no significant side effects, it should be studied to find benefits, if any, of using such microorganisms in the treatment of selected cases. However, there have been few efforts to evaluate the possible benefits of the administration of probiotics in burn injury, so In the current study, we aimed to evaluate the effects of probiotics in selected burned patients on plasma inflammatory status and wound healing.
Methods
Participants
In this double-blind, randomized clinical trial, a total of 80 patients from Velayat Sub-Specialty Burn and Plastic Surgery Center in Guilan Province, Rasht, Iran, from May 2021 to February 2022. The ethics board of Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Rasht, Iran, approved the study protocol (reference number: IR.GUMS.REC.1400.303). All patients provided written informed consents, and All procedures were by the tenants of the Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments. 17 This trial was registered at http://www.irct.ir as IRCT20210524051384N3.
The sample size considering the power of the test of 80%, the error level 0.05 and the standard deviation of 2.2 (probiotic group) and 9.7 (control group) and d = 4.65, by applying 10% drop, was obtained 40 for each group.
18
The inclusion criteria were as follows: burn degree of 20–70% of total body surface area (TBSA); second degree patients with thermal burns; hospitalization within 24 h post-burn; age range of 18–60 years; body mass index (BMI) of 18–30 kg/m2; ability to eat and drink through the mouth; and willingness to participate in the study. On the other hand, patients with renal or hepatic failure, diabetes mellitus, connective tissue disorders, history of chemotherapy, malnutrition at admission, or need for parenteral or enteral nutritional support and mechanical ventilation support and Patients who needed a skin graft during the 14 days of intervention were excluded from the trial. Among 584 patients who were initially enrolled in this study, 87 met the inclusion criteria and entered the study. However, five patients died during the intervention (Figure 1). CONSORT flow diagram of subject enrollment, allocation, follow-up, and analysis.
Randomization
Eligible patients were allocated to two groups through a 1:1 stratified four blocks randomization method based on gender and degree of burning. It was performed by a blinded third-party administrator of the SAS version nine software. Patients, interventionists, and also an investigator of outcomes were blinded to group allocation.
Intervention
The probiotic product was formed as a capsule containing 109 CFU included L. casei, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Lactobacillus rhamnosus, Lactobacillus bulgaricus, Bifidobacterium breve, Bifidobacterium longum, Streptococcus thermophiles species, and prebiotic fructo-oligosaccharide as growing and activator factor for probiotic microorganisms. Called LactoCare capsule is designed and produced by Zist Khamtir (ZIST TAKHMIR, Tehran, Iran). Placebo capsule was designed absolutely identically to probiotic counterpart considering size, shape, color, weight, and package filled with starch. Participants, according to their groups, received proper capsules twice a day for oral intake. Capsul consumption last 14 days from the first day of study initiation, which was Maximum within 10 days after the burn injury. 19
Data collection
Demographic data including age, gender, height, educational level, job, drinking alcohol, cigarette smoking, and place of residence was obtained. Disease-related variables included length of hospital stay, antibiotic and/or antifungative treatment, number of skin grafting operations, and graft failure registered. Data related to gastrointestinal discomforts like constipation, diarrhea, vomiting, and the need for laxative use was written as a number of days of the presence of aforementioned morbidities.
Measuring plasma level of high-sensitive C-reactive protein(hs-CRP) (ELISA kit, Wuhan, China), IgA (ELISA kit, Wuhan, China), absolute lymphocytic and the neutrophilic count was done on the previous day of the study initiation for every individual and also rechecked respectively on 12th, 17th, and 24th followingly.
TBSA was calculated by burn fellow on the admission day using the Wallace criteria. 20 In this study, constipation was defined as not passing stool for three consecutive days, and diarrhea was defined as passing soft stool more than four times a day or passing two or more watery stools during 24 h. 19 Diarrhea which occurred after taking laxatives, was not taken into count. Diagnosis of wound infection was established while clinical evidence of suppurative discharge, adjacent cellulitis, unpleasant wound odor, fever, de-novo anorexia, tachycardia or tachypnea was presented and approved by following whether blood or wound culture study.
Statistical analysis
Data analysis was performed by Statistical Package for the Social Science (SPSS) version 24 (IBM, Chicago, USA). Quantitative variables were presented by numbers, mean, and standard deviation. Qualitative variables were explained by numbers and percentages. Analysis of the latter was performed using the Chi-squared, Fisher’s Exact, and ANOVA exams. While for comparing parametric data, the Kruskal–Wallis test was applied. The level of significance was defined as calculated p < 0.05.
Results
Comparation of demographic and primary clinical status.
Chi Square Test, **Fisher’s Exact Test **** Anova.
The mean starting of Capsul consumption was 6.3 ± 1.2 in the control group and in 5.9 ± 0.9 probiotics group which was not statistically significant(p = 0.563). Following 2 weeks of drug usage, no report of gastrointestinal complications was registered, whether in the control or in the intervention group.
The plasma level of hs-CRP dropped obviously following probiotic consumption (p < 0.001). Measurements revealed the latter was 21.38 ± 44.45 and 36.36 ± 79.03 mg/L for probiotic and placebo receivers, respectively. Also, the increased plasma level of IgA among probiotic consumers (89.3 ± 5.65 g/L) was statistically significant compared with the control group (103.18 ± 6.11 g/L) (p < 0.001).
Clinical outcome data at the end of the study.
*mean ± SD **Kruskal Wallise Test.
a day 9 b day 24.
Wound examination and culture study manifested that there was no optimal wound condition prepared following probiotic consumption; however, the incidence rate of positive cultures lowered among the intervention group (p = 0.159).
The total healed area of the wound was obviously increased among probiotic receivers after finishing the study (p < 0.001), although these recovery changes had no prominent difference after the first week of study initiation(p > 0.05) (Figure 2). The study period for all participants was completed, and there was no considerable side effect to report. Comparison of the difference in changes (reduction) of wound area in the studied groups.
Discussion
This double-blinded randomized controlled trial has evaluated the effects of oral probiotic intake in selected second or third-degree thermal burn injured patients for a 14 days period of time. An investigation consisted of changes in the plasma index of inflammation and wound characteristics, included of healing and bacterial colonization. The final analysis has implied positive effects on inflammatory mitigation and wound recovery following probiotic consumption. According to the author’s knowledge, this study was the first regarding its specific topic. However, there are many available studies evaluating the effects of probiotics on a different aspects of human health promotion or disease prevention and treatment.
The hs-CRP is known as an acute phase reactant that increases following the most stressful condition, like a traumatic injury. Although the latter leads to an aseptic inflammatory response, an elevated level of hs-CRP directly relates to the patient’s prognosis. Namely, a higher quantitative level of plasma hs-CRP predicts more unfavorable outcomes for the patient 21 Specifically, in the case of burn injuries, increased level of plasma hs-CRP conforms with higher grade and deeper tissue injury. 22 Further, an essay has claimed that plasma level of hs-CRP following burn trauma can predict survivors from victims. 23 Previous data has shown that decreasing mitigation of hs-CRP is associated with better wound healing which is in line with our finding. 10 Other advocates have implied positive effects of probiotic consumption on pediatric recovery after thermal burn injury, prevention of inflammation among intensive care unit admitted patients, and even precluding symptoms of benign histopathologic inflammatory disorders.18,19,24 They have concluded that probiotics possibly attenuate inflammatory reactive cascade through releasing of anti-inflammatory cytokines. Opponents have not supported of that intaking oral probiotics would lead to inflammatory preclusion, decreasing in plasma level of hs-CRP, or faster discharge from intensive care units. 25 Despite such discrepancy in results, it should be mentioned that there is no report of any side effects following probiotic consumption. Therefore, considering safety, availability, and low expense, it can be reasonable to use probiotics in selected cases.
The current study has revealed probiotic consumption is concurrent with increased IgA level and absolute lymphocytic count after the study has been finished on day 14th. Similarly, other authors have presented data about increased plasma levels of IgA among probiotic receivers who suffered from major traumatic injuries.18,26,27 Also, Alberda et al. reported a significant increase in IgA levels in the treatment group after examining synbiotics in ICU patients. 26 In another study, Tahir et al. state that despite the slight difference in septic complications, probiotics have the ability to improve the function of the body’s immune system and provide healthy granulation tissue for better graft survival. 28
Considering wound healing, we found sensible recovery and a greater area of healed tissue following probiotic consumption. Although the incidence rate of culture study of injured skin had no obvious difference between groups, positive cultures were slightly lesser than placebo receivers. Alberda et. Has been noticed that probiotics lead to the improvement of immune cell function and the generation of more qualified granulation tissue, causing more successful skin grafts. 26
Finally, a current survey has illustrated probiotic consumption plays an anti-inflammatory role and also helps with wound healing in selected burn patients. However, available data and details on this specific issue seem to be not sufficient for approved therapeutic consideration. Therefore, we explicitly recommend the conduction of multicentric studies with larger sample sizes and more long term follow up.
Limitations
This study was performed in a single burn-specific referral center with a limited number of participants. Burning etiologies, except thermal burns, were excluded. Long-term follow-up was not considered. Prescription and analysis of different dosages of probiotics were not planned. Although an attempt was made to match the patients by using the same antibiotic, the use of several types of antifungals was one of the limitations of this study. The inclusion of 20–70% patients was one of the limitations of the study due to the large difference in burn percentage
Conclusion
Intake of oral probiotics, even for a limited time after thermal burn injury, is costly benefited because these microorganisms can enhance the immune system, preclude inflammation, and promote wound healing. Additionally, the consumption of probiotics has no sensible complication. Trends toward Improvement Immune system by increasing IgA level and lymphocytic count and possible Reduction of wound area with exogenous probiotic administration in patients with burns suggest that further investigation in larger sample size is necessary to corroborate our initial, promising findings.
Footnotes
Acknowledgements
The authors are very grateful to the volunteers who participated in this study, and the Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Rasht, Iran and Velayat Sub-Specialty Burn and Plastic Surgery Center.
Author contributions
M.M.R. and S.M. designed the overall study. M.M.R. designed the patient’s diet. S.P. and M.r.M. participated in the recruitment and data collection and also M.r.M. investigated wound healing. M.E.GH. analyzed the data. A.H. designed the web-site for the randomization to group and carried out data analysis. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Declaration of conflicting interests
Each author has made substantial contributions to the conception and design of the study or acquisition of data or analysis and interpretation of data, drafting the article or revising it critically for important intellectual content. Each author has seen and approved the contents of the submitted manuscript. None of the authors has any personal or financial conflicts of interest.
Funding
This research This study is part of a master’s thesis and receive grant from Guilan University of Medical Sciences.
Ethics approval
This study approved by ethics committee of Guilan University of Medical Sciences with the code number of IR.GUMS.REC.1400.303.
Informed consent
All patients provided written informed consents and All procedures were in accordance with the tenants of the Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments.
Data Availability
The data and materials that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
