Madden (in press) hopes that it is “Game Over” regarding the “Walrasian Fixed Supply Conjecture” and “Contest-Nash” solutions. In this paper, I argue that framing the debate as such misses the point of Winfree and Fort (2012). Furthermore, Madden (in press) argues that under certain assumptions, which need to be made, the model that follows was previously given in Madden (2011). However, I argue that Madden (2011) is one of many models that might follow and his assumptions do not hold in all leagues.
AlcaldeJ., & DahmM. (2007). Tullock and Hirshleifer: A meeting of the minds.Review of Economic Design, 11, 101–124.
2.
AlmJ., KaempferW. H., & SennogaE. B. (2012). Baseball salaries and income taxes: The ‘home field advantage’ of income taxes on free agent salaries.Journal of Sports Economics, 13, 619–634.
3.
CheY., & GaleI. (2000). Difference-form contests and the robustness of all-pay auctions.Games and Economic Behavior, 30, 22–43.
4.
DupuyT. N. (1987). Understanding war. New York, NY: Paragon House.
5.
EckardE. W. (2006). Comment: Professional team sports are only a game; The Walrasian fixed-supply conjecture model, contest-Nash equilibrium, and the invariance principle.Journal of Sports Economics, 7, 234–239.
6.
EpsteinG. S., & HefekerC. (2003). Lobbying contests with alternative instruments.Economics of Governance, 4, 81–89.
7.
FortR., & QuirkJ. (1995). Cross-subsidization, incentives and outcomes in professional team sports leagues.Journal of Economic Literature, 33, 1265–1299.
8.
FortR., & WinfreeJ. (2009). Sports really are different: The contest success function and the supply of talent.Reveiw of Industrial Organization, 34, 69–80.
9.
HirshleiderJ. (1989). Conflict and rent-seeking success functions: Ratio vs. difference models of relative success.Public Choice, 63, 101–112.
10.
KopkinN. (2012). Tax avoidance: How income tax rates affect the labor migration decisions of the NBA free agents.Journal of Sports Economics, 13, 571–602.
11.
MaddenP. (2011). Game theoretic analysis of basic sports leagues.Journal of Sports Economics, 12, 407–431.
12.
MaddenP. (in press). 'Walrasian Fixed Supply Conjecture’ versus ‘Contest-Nash’ solutions to sports league models: Game over?Journal of Sports Economics.
13.
McFaddenD. L. (1984). Econometric analysis of qualitative response models. In Z. Griliches and M. Intrilligator (Eds.), Handbook of econometrics, Vol. 2 (pp. 1396–1456). New York, NY: North-Holland.
14.
MünsterJ. (2009). Group contest success functions.Economic Theory, 41, 345–357.
15.
PeetersT. (2011). The shape of success: Estimating contest success functions in sports. Working paper.
SzymanskiS. (2004). Professional team sports are only a game; The Walrasian fixed-supply conjecture model, contest-Nash equilibrium, and the invariance principle.Journal of Sports Economics, 5, 111–126.
18.
SzymanskiS. (2006). Reply: Professional team sports are only a game; The Walrasian fixed-supply conjecture model, contest-Nash equilibrium, and the invariance principle.Journal of Sports Economics, 7, 240–243.
19.
SzymanskiS. (2009). Playbooks and checkbooks:An introduction to the economics of modern sports.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
20.
SzymanskiS. (2013). Some observations on Fort and Winfree's Nash conjectures and talent supply in sports league modelling: A comment on current modelling disagreements.Journal of Sports Economics, 14, 321–326.
21.
SzymanskiS., & Késenne, S. (2004). Competitive balance and revenue sharing in team sports.Journal of Industrial Economics, 52, 165–177.
22.
TullockG. (1980). Efficient rent seeking. In BuchananJ., TollisonR., & TullockG. (Eds.), Toward a theory of the rentseeking society (pp. 97–112). College Station, TX: Texas A&UniversityM. Press.
23.
VroomanJ. (1995). A general theory of professional sports leagues.Southern Economic Journal, 61, 971–990.
24.
WinfreeJ., & FortR. (2012). Nash conjectures and talent supply in sports league modeling: A comment on current modelling disagreements.Journal of Sports Economics, 13, 306–313.
25.
WinfreeJ., & FortR. (2013). Reply to Szymanski's ‘Some observations on Fort and Winfree's Nash conjectures and talent supply in sports league modelling': A comment on current modelling disagreements.Journal of Sports Economics, 14, 327–329
