Motivations and drives for collecting have varied through time. From amassing as many examples of different species or artefacts in the sixteenth century to highlighting the importance and strength of the British Empire in the eighteenth century. General trends are seen across historic collections in museums. In an attempt to understand the motivations behind individual collectors, this paper reviews the lives of four mineral collectors from the collections in The Box, Plymouth: Sir John St. Aubyn (175801839), Colonel Sir William Serjeant (1857–1930), René Gallant (1906–1985), and Richard Barstow (1947–1986). Combined they acquired over 4,000 minerals, mostly from the South West of the British Isles. Through examining their lives and collections we may gain insight into their motivations, presenting an opportunity to exhibit new narrative and story-telling alongside the specimens, and in doing so, enriching the visitor experience.
AlvarezL. W.AlvarezW.AsaroF.MichelH. V.1980. Extraterrestrial cause for the Cretaceous-Tertiary extinction. Science. 208(4448). pp.1095–1108.
2.
Anon. 1924. Report on Sir William Serjeant’s Collection. Plymouth City Museum. In Archives in the natural history department, The Box (Plymouth Museums, Galleries, Archives).
3.
AsmaStephen T.2001. Stuffed Animals and Pickled Heads: The Culture and Evolution of Natural History Museums. New York, NY; Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
BabingtonWilliam. 1799. A New System of Mineralogy in the Form of a Catalogue, After the Manner of Baron Born’s Systematic Catalogue of the Collection of Fossils of Mlle. Eléonore de Raab. London: W. Phillips, G. C. and J. Robinson and T. Cox.
5.
BartonRita Margaret. 1964. An Introduction to the Geology of Cornwall. Truro: Truro Bookshop.
6.
BasuAsish R.PetaevMichail I.PoredaRobert J.JacobsenStein B.BeckerLuann. 2003. “Chondritic Meteorite Fragments Associated with the Permian–Triassic Boundary in Antarctica.” Science302 (5649): 1388–92.
7.
CooperMicheal P.2006. Robbing the Sparry Garniture – A 200 Year History of British Mineral Dealers. Tuscon, AZ: The Mineralogical Record.
8.
Cornish Guardian. 1930. “Sir WM Serjeant C.B. Death of a noted Cornishman. Solider, Writer and Sportsman.” The Cornish Guardian, 20March, 10.
9.
CotterellTom F.2016. “The Mineral Collection of William Bill Terrill, FCS MIMM. (1845-1901).” The Geological Curator10 (5): 201–20.
10.
CurreyD. A.1974. An Index to the Systematic Collection of Minerals. Devon: Plymouth City Museum and Art Gallery.
11.
CurreyD. A.1975. “Col. Sir William Serjeant Collection.” Newsletter of the Geological Curators Group3: 135–36.
12.
DasSubhadraLoweMiranda. 2018. “Nature Read in Black and White: Decolonial Approaches to Interpreting Natural History Collection.” Journal of Natural Science Collections6: 4–14.
13.
Eric MichaelDurranceLamingD. J. C., Editors. 1982. The Geology of Devon. Exeter: University of Exeter.
14.
EmbreyPeter G.SymesRobert F.1987. Minerals of Cornwall and Devon. London: The British Museum.
15.
FirestoneRichard B.WestAllenKennettJames P.BeckerL.BunchTed E.RevayZsolt S.SchultzPeter H., et al. 2007. “Evidence for an Extraterrestrial Impact 12,900 Years Ago that Contributed to the Megafaunal Extinctions and the Younger Dryas Cooling.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America104 (41): 16016–21.
16.
GallantRené. 1964. Bombarded Earth. London: John Baker.
17.
GallantRené. 1983. The lighter side of some war-time adventures. Torquay Natural History Society Transactions and Proceedings for the year 1981-8278: 114–24.
18.
GreeneJohn C.BurkeJohn G.1978. “The Science of Minerals in the Age of Jefferson.” Transactions of the American Philosophical Society68 (Part 4): 113.
19.
GreensladeB.1986a. René Gallant. Biography. Unpublished. In Archives in the natural history department, The Box (Plymouth Museums, Galleries, Archives).
20.
GreensladeS.1986b. Letter to Tristram Besterman dated 19th February 1986. In Archives in the natural history department, The Box (Plymouth Museums, Galleries, Archives).
21.
HawkesJ. R.1985. “The Dartmoor Granite and Later Volcanic Rocks.” In The Geology of Devon, Chapter 5, edited by DurranceE. M.LamingD. J. C., 85–116. Exeter: University of Exeter.
22.
HuntFrederick William. 1902. Libraries of Devonport: Naval, Military and Civil. Devonport: Hiorns and Miller.
23.
KerbeyHelen C.2013. “David Forbes F. R. S. (1828-1876): A Chemist and Mineralogist Who Advocated for Thin Section Microscopy.” The Geological Curator9 (10): 515–27.
24.
LewisC. L. E.2009. “Doctoring Geology: The Medical Origins of the Geological Society.” In The Making of the Geological Society of London, edited by LewisC. L. E.KnellS. J., 49–92. London: Geological Society, Special Publications 317.
25.
National Heritage Memorial Fund. 1987. “National Heritage Memorial Fund.” 7th Annual Report 1986-1987.
26.
NewmanPhil. 1998. The Dartmoor Tin Industry: A field guide. Devon: Chercombe Press.
27.
PenhallurickRoger D.1997. “The Mineral Collection of the Royal Institution of Cornwall.” UK Journal of Mines and Minerals18: 17–32.
28.
PinoMarioAbarzúaAna M.AstorgaGiselleMartel-CeaAlejandraCossio-MontecinosNathalieNavarroR. XimenaLiraMaria Paz, et al. 2019. “Sedimentary Record from Patagonia, Southern Chile Supports Cosmic-Impact Triggering of Biomass Burning, Climate Change, and Megafaunal Extinctions at 12.8 ka.” Scientific Reports9 (1): 1–27. doi:10.1038/447256a.
29.
RiderMartin. H.2005. Hutton’s Arse: 3 Billion Years of Extraordinary Geology in Scotland’s Northern Highlands. Rogart: Rider-French Consulting Ltd.
30.
SchmitzBirgerHarperDavid A. T.Peucker-EhrenbrinkBernhardStougeSvendAlwmarkCarlCronholmAndersBergströmStig M., et al. 2008. “Asteroid Breakup Linked to the Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event.” Nature Geoscience1: 49–53.
31.
SelwoodE. B.DurranceE. M.1982. “The Devonian Rocks.” In The Geology of Devon, Chapter 2, edited by DurranceE. M.LamingD. J. C., 15–41. Exeter: University of Exeter.
32.
SelwoodE. B.FreshneyE. C.DuranceE. M.1982. “The Variscan Geology.” In The Geology of Devon, Chapter 4, edited by DurranceE. M.LamingD. J. C., pp.66–84. Exeter: University of Exeter Press.
33.
ShepherdJessica. 2009a. “The St. Aubyn Mineral Collection (c.1794-2010) at Plymouth City Museum and Art Gallery.” The Geological Curator9 (2): 45–56.
34.
ShepherdJessica. 2009b. “Bringing a Herbarium to Life at Plymouth City Museum and Art Gallery.” NatSCA News17: 43–51.
35.
StarkeyR.CooperM. P.2010. “Richard W Barstow Mineral Dealer Extraordinaire.” UK Journal of Mines and Minerals31: 6–57.
36.
ToghillPeter. 2000. The Geology of Britain: An Introduction. Shrewsbury: Swan Hill Press.
37.
TorrensHugh S.1974. “Collections and Collectors of Note: Lichfield Museums (pre 1850).” Geological Curators Group Newsletter1: 5–10.
38.
TorrensHugh S.1998. “‘No Impact’: René Gallant (1906-1985) and His Book of 1964 Bombarded Earth (An essay on the geological and biological effects of huge meteorite impacts).” Earth Sciences History17 (2): 174–89.
39.
TruemanArthur Elijah. 1971. Geology and Scenery in England and Wales. Whittow, J. B. & Hardy, J. R. Revised. Pelican. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
40.
WilsonWendell E.1994. “The History of Mineral Collecting. With Notes on Twelve Hundred Early Mineral Collectors.” The Mineralogical Record25 (6): 7–239.
41.
WittkeJames H.WeaverJames C.BunchTed E.KennettJames P.KennettDouglas J.MooreAndrew MTHillmanGordon C., et al. 2013. “Evidence for Deposition of 10 Million Tonnes of Impact Spherules across Four Continents 12,800 y Ago.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America110 (23): E2088–97.
