Dark-Side Personality Trait Interactions: Amplifying Negative Predictions of Leadership Performance

Abstract

Drawing on trait interaction theory and personality disorder subtypes, we examined narcissism-by-trait interactions (e.g., narcissism × antisocial tendencies) for predicting leadership performance in four independent archival samples (Ns = 285, 120, 106, 559). This study extends research on multiplicative effects of normative leader characteristics to consider how narcissism becomes particularly disruptive when combined with other extreme interpersonal tendencies. Moderated multiple regression results show interactions involving selected trait pairs varied across samples. Pooled analyses showed (a) differential generalizability across trait pairings and (b) that lower tiered managerial roles and weaker industrial contexts may release such effects. Inconsistencies suggest the need to consider sample-specific trait demands in future trait interaction research, normal, or maladaptive. All told, findings suggest that subclinical personality interactions might accelerate leader derailment, offer unique insights into leader competence, and extend trait interaction research to aberrant tendencies.

Keywords

dark side leadership Millon variants narcissism antisocial trait interactions trait configurations hierarchical level

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akhtar

(2003). New clinical realms: Pushing the envelope of theory and technique. London, England: Aronson.

Allport

G. W.

(1961). Pattern and growth in personality. New York, NY: Holt, Rinehart, & Winston.

American Psychiatric Association. (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM-IV-TR) (4th ed., Text Rev.). Washington, DC: Author.

American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.

Ashforth

(1994). Petty tyranny in organizations. Human Relations, 47, 755-778.

Baguley

(2009). Standardized or simple effect size: What should be reported? British Journal of Psychology, 3, 603-617.

Bass

B. M.

(1985). Leadership and performance beyond expectations. New York, NY: Free Press.

Bentz

V. J.

(1967). The Sears experience in the investigation, description, and prediction of executive behavior. In Wickert

F. R.

McFarland

D. E.

(Eds.), Measuring executive effectiveness (pp. 147-206). New York, NY: Appleton-Century-Crofts.

Blair

C. A.

Hoffman

B. J.

Helland

K. R.

(2008). Narcissism in organizations: A multisource appraisal reflects different perspectives. Human Performance, 21, 254-276.

10.

Bligh

M. C.

Kohles

J. C.

Justin

J. E.

Pearce

C. L.

Stovall

(2007). When the romance is over: Follower perspectives of aversive leadership. Applied Psychology: An International Review, 56, 528-557.

11.

Bono

J. E.

Judge

T. A.

(2004). Personality and transformational and transactional leadership: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89, 901-910.

12.

Braddy

P. W.

Gooty

Fleenor

J. W.

Yammarino

F. J.

(2014). Leader behaviors and career derailment potential: A multi-analytic method examination of rating source and self-other agreement. Leadership Quarterly, 25, 373-390.

13.

Burke

L. A.

Witt

L. A.

(2004). Personality and high-maintenance employee behavior. Journal of Business and Psychology, 18, 349-363.

14.

Cabrera

E. F.

Raju

N. S.

(2001). Utility analysis: Current trends and future directions. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 9, 92-102.

15.

Conger

J. A.

(1990). The dark side of leadership. Organizational Dynamics, 19, 44-55.

16.

Davis

R. D.

Patterson

M. J.

(2005). Diagnosing personality disorder subtypes with the MCMI–III. In Craig

R. J.

(Ed.), New directions in interpreting the Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory–III (MCMI-III) (pp. 32-70). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.

17.

Dawson

J. F.

(2014). Moderation in management research: What, why, when, and how. Journal of Business and Psychology, 29, 1-19.

18.

Dawson

J. F.

Richter

A. W.

(2006). Probing three-way interactions in moderated multiple regression: Development and application of a slope difference test. Journal of Applied Psychology, 91, 917-926.

19.

De Fruyt

Wille

Furnham

. (2013). Assessing aberrant personality in managerial coaching: Measurement issues and prevalence rates across employment sectors. European Journal of Personality, 27, 555-564.

20.

De Meuse

K. P.

Dai

. (2011). Leadership skills across organizational levels: A closer examination. Psychologist-Manager Journal, 14, 120-139.

21.

DeRue

D. S.

Nahrgang

J. D.

Wellman

N. E. D.

Humphrey

S. E.

(2011). Trait and behavioral theories of leadership: An integration and meta-analytic test of their relative validity. Personnel Psychology, 64, 7-52.

22.

Dierdorff

E. C.

Rubin

R. S.

Morgeson

F. P.

(2009). The milieu of managerial work: An integrative framework linking work context to role requirements. Journal of Applied Psychology, 94, 972-988.

23.

Digman

J. M.

(1990). Personality structure: Emergence of the five-factor model. Annual Review of Psychology, 41, 417-440.

24.

Dotlich

Cairo

(2003). Why CEOs fail. New York, NY: Jossey-Bass.

25.

Douglas

Bore

Munro

(2012). Distinguishing the dark triad: Evidence from the five-factor model and the Hogan development survey. Psychology, 3, 237-242.

26.

Foster

J. D.

Trimm

R. F.

IV (2008). On being eager and uninhibited: Narcissism and approach–avoidance motivation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 34, 1004-1017.

27.

Foti

R. J.

Hauenstein

N. M. A.

(2007). Pattern and variable approaches in leadership emergence and effectiveness. Journal of Applied Psychology, 92, 347-355.

28.

Furnham

(2010). The elephant in the boardroom: The causes of leadership derailment. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

29.

Furnham

Richards

S. C.

Paulhus

D. L.

(2013). The dark triad of personality: A 10 year review. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 7, 199-216.

30.

Gardner

W. L.

Avolio

B. J.

(1998). The charismatic relationship: A dramaturgical perspective. Academy of Management Review, 23, 32-58.

31.

Glad

(2002). Why tyrants go too far: Malignant narcissism and absolute power. Political Psychology, 23, 1-37.

32.

Grijalva

Harms

P. D.

(2014). Narcissism: An integrative synthesis and dominance complementarity model. Academy of Management Perspectives, 28, 108-127.

33.

Grijalva

Harms

P. D.

Newman

D. A.

Gaddis

Fraley

R. C.

(2015). Narcissism and leadership: A meta-analytic review of linear and nonlinear relationships. Personnel Psychology, 68, 1-47.

34.

Gustafson

S. B.

Ritzer

D. R.

(1995). The dark side of normal: A psychopathy-linked pattern called aberrant self-promotion. European Journal of Personality, 9, 147-183.

35.

Harms

P. D.

Spain

S. M.

Hannah

S. T.

(2011). Leader development and the dark side of personality. Leadership Quarterly, 22, 495-509.

36.

Highhouse

(2002). Assessing the candidate as a whole: A historical and critical analysis of individual psychological assessment for personnel decision making. Personnel Psychology, 55, 363-396.

37.

Hogan

(2001). Assessing leadership: A view from the dark side. International Journal of Selection and assessment, 9, 40-51.

38.

Hogan

(2007). Hogan Personality Inventory manual (3rd ed.). Tulsa, OK: Hogan Assessment Systems.

39.

Hogan

(2009). Hogan Development Survey manual (2nd ed.). Tulsa, OK: Hogan Assessment Systems.

40.

Hogan

Kaiser

R. B.

(2011). Management derailment: Personality assessment and mitigation. In Zedeck

(Eds.), APA handbook of industrial and organizational psychology: Vol. 3. Maintaining, expanding, and contracting the organization (pp. 555-575). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

41.

Hogan

Holland

(2003). Using theory to evaluate personality and job-performance relation: A socioanalytic perspective. Journal of Applied Psychology, 88, 100-112.

42.

Hogan

Kaiser

R. B.

(2005). What we know about leadership. Review of General Psychology, 9, 169-180.

43.

House

R. J.

Howell

J. M.

(1992). Personality and charismatic leadership. Leadership Quarterly, 3, 81-108.

44.

Humphreys

J. H.

Novicevic

M. M.

Hayek

Gibson

J. W.

Haden

S. P.

Williams

W. A.

Jr. (2016). Disharmony in new harmony: Insights from the narcissistic leadership of Robert Owen. Journal of Management History, 22, 146-170.

45.

Hunter

J. E.

Schmidt

F. L.

(1982). Fitting people to jobs: The impact of personnel selection on national productivity. In Dunnette

M. D.

Fleishman

E. A.

(Eds.), Human performance and productivity: Human capacity assessment (Vol. 1, pp. 232-284). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

46.

Hussong

A. M.

Curran

P. J.

Bauer

D. J.

(2013). Integrative data analysis in clinical psychology research. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 9, 61-89.

47.

Ironson

G. H.

Smith

P. C.

Brannick

M. T.

Gibson

W. M.

Paul

W. M.

(1989). Construction of a job in general scale: A comparison of global, composite, and specific measures. Journal of Applied Psychology, 74, 193-200.

48.

Jensen

J. M.

Patel

P. C.

(2011). Predicting counterproductive work behavior from the interaction of personality traits. Personality and Individual Differences, 51, 466-471.

49.

Judge

T. A.

Bono

J. E.

Ilies

Gerhardt

M. W.

(2002). Personality and leadership: A qualitative and quantitative review. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87, 765-780.

50.

Judge

T. A.

Erez

(2007). Interaction and intersection: The constellation of emotional stability and extraversion in predicting performance. Personnel Psychology, 60, 573-596.

51.

Judge

T. A.

LePine

J. A.

Rich

B. L.

(2006). Loving yourself abundantly: Relationship of the narcissistic personality to self- and other perceptions of workplace deviance, leadership, and task and contextual performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 91, 762-776.

52.

Judge

T. A.

Piccolo

R. F.

Kosalka

(2009). The bright and dark sides of leader traits: A review and theoretical extension of the leader trait paradigm. Leadership Quarterly, 20, 855-875.

53.

Judge

T. A.

Zapata

C. P.

(2015). The person–situation debate revisited: Effect of situation strength and trait activation on the validity of the Big Five personality traits in predicting job performance. Academy of Management Journal, 58, 1149-1179.

54.

Kaiser

R. B.

Craig

S. B.

Overfield

D. V.

Yarborough

(2011). Differences in managerial jobs at the bottom, middle, and top: A review of empirical research. Psychologist-Manager Journal, 14, 76-91.

55.

Kaiser

R. B.

Hogan

(2007). The dark side of discretion: Leader personality and organizational decline. In Hooijberg

Hunt

Antonakis

Boal

(Eds.), Being there even when you are not: Leading through strategy, systems and structures (Vol. 4, pp. 177-197). London, England: Elsevier Science.

56.

Kaiser

R. B.

LeBreton

J. M.

Hogan

(2015). The dark side of personality and extreme leader behavior. Applied Psychology: An International Review, 64, 55-92.

57.

Kellerman

(2004). Bad leadership: What it is, how it happens, why it matters. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.

58.

Kernberg

(1970). Factors in the psychoanalytic treatment of narcissistic personalities. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 18, 51-85.

59.

Kets de Vries

M. F. R.

(2006). The leader on the couch. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

60.

Kets de Vries

M. F. R.

Miller

(1997). Narcissism and leadership: An object relations perspective. In Vecchio

R. P.

(Ed.), Leadership: Understanding the dynamics of power and influence in organizations (pp. 194-214). Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.

61.

Khoo

H. S.

Burch

G. S. J.

(2008). The “dark side” of leadership personality and transformational leadership: An exploratory study. Personality and Individual Differences, 44, 86-97.

62.

King

E. B.

George

J. M.

Hebl

M. R.

(2005). Linking personality to helping behaviors at work: An interactional perspective. Journal of Personality, 73, 585-607.

63.

Kirkpatrick

S. A.

Locke

E. A.

(1991). Leadership: Do traits matter? Academy of Management Executive, 5, 48-60.

64.

Krueger

R. F.

Derringer

Markon

K. E.

Watson

Skodol

A. E.

(2012). Initial construction of a maladaptive personality trait model and inventory for DSM-5. Psychological Medicine, 42, 1879-1890.

65.

Levy

K. N.

Chauhan

Clarkin

J. F.

Wasserman

R. H.

Reynoso

J. S.

(2009). Narcissistic pathology: Empirical approaches. Psychiatric Annals, 39, 203-213.

66.

Lewin

(1935). A dynamic theory of personality. New York, NY: Ballantine Books.

67.

Lombardo

M. M.

Ruderman

M. N.

McCauley

C. D.

(1988). Explanations of success and derailment in upper-level management positions. Journal of Business and Psychology, 2, 199-216.

68.

McCall

M. W.

Jr. Lombardo

M. M.

(1983). Off the track: Why and how successful executives get derailed (Technical Report No. 21). Greensboro, NC: Center for Creative Leadership.

69.

Meehl

P. E.

(1959). A comparison of clinicians with five statistical methods of identifying psychotic MMPI profiles. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 6, 102-109.

70.

Meyer

R. D.

Dalal

R. S.

Bonaccio

(2009). A meta-analytic investigation into the moderating effects of situational strength on the conscientiousness–performance relationship. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 30, 1077-1102.

71.

Meyer

R. D.

Dalal

R. S.

Hermida

(2010). A review and synthesis of situational strength in the organizational sciences. Journal of Management, 36, 121-140.

72.

Millon

(1995). Disorders of personality: DSM-IV and beyond. (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Wiley.

73.

Millon

(2011). Disorders of personality: Introducing a DSM/ICD spectrum from normal to abnormal. (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Wiley.

74.

Montano

Reeske

Franke

Hüffmeier

(2016). Leadership, followers’ mental health and job performance in organizations: A comprehensive meta-analysis from an occupational health perspective. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 38, 327-350.

75.

Morgeson

F. P.

Campion

M. A.

Dipboye

R. L.

Hollenbeck

J. R.

Murphy

Schmitt

(2007). Are we getting fooled again? Coming to terms with the limitations in the use of personality tests for personnel selection. Personnel Psychology, 60, 1029-1049.

76.

Moscoso

Salgado

J. F.

(2004). “Dark side” personality styles as predictors of task, contextual, and job performance. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 12, 356-362.

77.

Mumford

M. D.

Zaccaro

S. J.

Johnson

J. F.

Diana

Gilbert

J. A.

Threlfall

(2000). Patterns of leader characteristics: Implications for performance and development. Leadership Quarterly, 11, 115-133.

78.

Murray

H. A.

(1938). Explorations in personality. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

79.

O’Boyle

E. R.

Forsyth

D. R.

Banks

G. C.

McDaniel

M. A.

(2012). A meta-analysis of the dark triad and work behavior: A social exchange perspective. Journal of Applied Psychology, 97, 557-579.

80.

I. S.

Berry

C. M.

(2009). The five-factor model of personality and managerial performance: Validity gains through the use of 360 degree performance ratings. Journal of Applied Psychology, 94, 1498-1513.

81.

Owens

B. P.

Wallace

A. S.

Waldman

D. A.

(2015). Leader narcissism and follower outcomes: The counterbalancing effect of leader humility. Journal of Applied Psychology, 100, 1203-1213.

82.

Padilla

Hogan

Kaiser

R. B.

(2007). The toxic triangle: Destructive leaders, susceptible followers, and conducive environments. Leadership Quarterly, 18, 176-194.

83.

Paulhus

D. L.

Williams

K. M.

(2002). The dark triad of personality: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy. Journal of Research in Personality, 36, 556-563.

84.

Paunonen

S. V.

Lönnqvist

Verkasalo

Leikas

Nissinen

(2006). Narcissism and emergent leadership in military cadets. Leadership Quarterly, 17, 475-486.

85.

Penney

L. M.

David

Witt

L. A.

(2011). A review of personality and performance: Identifying boundaries, contingencies, and future research directions. Human Resource Management Review, 21, 297-310.

86.

Petrocelli

J. V.

Glaser

B. A.

Calhoun

G. B.

Campbell

L. F.

(2001). Early maladaptive schemas of personality disorder subtypes. Journal of Personality Disorders, 15, 546-559.

87.

Pollock

G. H.

(1978). Process and affect. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 59, 255-276.

88.

Resick

C. J.

Whitman

D. S.

Weingarden

S. M.

Hiller

N. J.

(2009). The bright-side and dark-side of CEO personality: Examining core self-evaluations, narcissism, transformational leadership, and strategic influence. Journal of Applied Psychology, 94, 1365-1381.

89.

Rosenthal

S. A.

Pittinsky

T. L.

(2006). Narcissistic leadership. Leadership Quarterly, 17, 617-633.

90.

Rothstein

M. G.

Goffin

R. D.

(2006). The use of personality measures in personnel selection: What does current research support? Human Resource Management Review, 16, 155-180.

91.

Russell

C. J.

(2001). A longitudinal study of top-level executive performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86, 560-573.

92.

Saucier

Ostendorf

(1999). Hierarchical subcomponents of the Big Five personality factors: A cross-language replication. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76, 613-627.

93.

Schein

E. H.

(1990). Organizational culture. American Psychologist, 45, 109-119.

94.

Schyns

Schilling

(2013). How bad are the effects of bad leaders? A meta-analysis of destructive leadership and its outcomes. Leadership Quarterly, 24, 138-158.

95.

Scott

(2005). A survival guide for working with bad bosses. New York, NY: AMACOM.

96.

Sedikides

Rudich

E. A.

Gregg

A. P.

Kumashiro

Rusbult

(2004). Are normal narcissists psychologically health? Self-esteem matters. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 87, 400-416.

97.

Skogstad

Einarsen

Torsheim

Aasland

M. S.

Hetland

(2007). The destructiveness of laissez-faire leadership behavior. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 12, 80-92.

98.

Stone-Romero

E. F.

Anderson

L. E.

(1994). Techniques for detecting moderating effects: Relative statistical power of multiple regression and the comparison of subgroup-based correlation coefficients. Journal of Applied Psychology, 79, 354-359.

99.

Tabachnick

B. G.

Fidell

L. S.

(2013). Using multivariate statistics (6th ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson.

100.

Tett

R. P.

Burnett

D. D.

(2003). A personality trait-based interactionist model of job performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 88, 500-517.

101.

Tett

R. P.

Christiansen

N. D.

(2007). Personality tests at the crossroads: A response to Morgenson, Campion, Dipboye, Hollenbeck, Murphy, and Schmitt (2007). Personnel Psychology, 60, 967-993.

102.

Tett

R. P.

Simonet

D. V.

Walser

Cameron

(2013). Trait activation theory: Applications, further developments, and implications for workplace fit. In Christiansen

N. D.

Tett

R. P.

(Eds.), Handbook of personality at work (pp. 71-100). New York, NY: Routledge.

103.

Van Dijk

De Cremer

. (2006). Self-benefiting in the allocation of scarce resources: Leader-follower effects and the moderating role of social value orientations. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 32, 1352-1361.

104.

Watts

A. L.

Lilienfeld

S. O.

Smith

S. F.

Miller

J. D.

Campbell

W. K.

Waldman

I. D.

. . . Faschingbauer

T. J.

(2013). The double-edged sword of grandiose narcissism implications for successful and unsuccessful leadership among US Presidents. Psychological Science, 24, 2379-2389.

105.

Wickham

Chang

(2016). ggplot2: An implementation of the grammar of graphics (R package version 2.1.0). Retrieved from https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/ggplot2/index.html

106.

Wille

De Fruyt

De Clercq

(2013). Expanding and reconceptualizing aberrant personality at work: Validity of five-factor aberrant personality tendencies to predict career outcomes. Personnel Psychology, 66, 173-223.

107.

Wink

(1991). Two faces of narcissism. Journal of Personality and Social psychology, 61, 590-597.

108.

Winter

D. G.

Barenbaum

N. B.

(1999). History of modern personality theory and research. In Pervin

L. A.

John

O. P.

(Eds.), Handbook of personality: Theory and research (2nd ed., pp. 3-27). New York, NY: Guilford Press.

109.

Witt

L. A.

Burke

L. A.

Barrick

M. R.

Mount

M. K.

(2002). The interactive effects of conscientiousness and agreeableness on job performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87, 164-169.

110.

Yukl

(2006). Leadership in organizations (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

111.

Zaccaro

S. J.

(2007). Trait-based perspectives of leadership. American Psychologist, 62, 6-16.