Prospective Controlled Study of Carotid Endarterectomy with Hemashield Patch: Is It Thrombogenic?

Abstract

The use of patch angioplasty after carotid endarterectomy (CEA) has been shown to have superior results to CEA with primary closure. Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) patches have been shown to have comparable results to autogenous vein patching; however, PTFE has the disadvantage of prolonged hemostasis time. Therefore, many surgeons are using collagenimpregnated Dacron patches (Hemashield ^TM [HP]). We believe this is the first prospective controlled study of the use of HP in carotid endarterectomy. This study included 144 consecutive patients who had 151 CEAs with HP. Postoperative duplex ultrasounds were done at 1 month and every 6 months thereafter. The mean follow-up was 12 months (range: 1-30 months). Indications for CEA included symptomatic (64%) and asymptomatic (36%) stenoses. The overall incidence of ipsilateral stroke was 5% (4% perioperative), with a combined TIA and stroke rate of 12%. Incidence of ≥50% recurrent stenosis was 21% (7% symptomatic TIA/stroke) and ≥80% recurrent stenosis was 9%. Kaplan-Meier analysis showed that at 1 year and 2.5 years freedom from ≥50% recurrent stenosis was 78% and 57%, respectively, freedom from ≥80% recurrent stenosis was 92% and 77%, respectively, and a stroke-free survival rate of 94% and 72%, respectively. Women had a 22% and men a 14% recurrent stenosis rate (p=0.04). There was no correlation between other specific risk factors and recurrent stenosis except for hypertension (33% vs 12%, p=0.003). The authors concluded that CEA with HP had a higher incidence of recurrent stenosis (21%), and a higher perioperative stroke rate (4%) after a mean follow-up of 12 months than previously reported using PTFE or saphenous vein patching (2% and 9% recurrent stenosis rates, respectively, and I1% and 0% perioperative stroke rates, respectively after a mean follow-up of 30 months). This raises the question as to whether this patch is thrombogenic in this location. Therefore, a randomized controlled trial comparing this patch with other patches (PTFE or vein) is warranted.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Ranaboldo CJ , D'Sa AABB , Bell PRF , et al: Randomized controlled trial of patch angioplasty for carotid endarterectomy. Br J Surg 80:1528-1530, 1993.

2. Hertzer NR , Beven EG , O'Hara PJ , et al: A prospective study of vein patch angioplasty during carotid endartectomy. Ann Surg 206:628-635, 1987.

3. AbuRahma AF , Robinson PA , Saiedy S , et al: Prospective randomized trial of carotid endarterectomy with primary closure and patch angioplasty with saphenous vein, jugular vein, and polytetrafluoroethylene: Long-term follow-up. J Vasc Surg 27:222-234, 1998.

4. Clagett GP , Patterson CB , Fisher DF , et al: Vein patch versus primary closure for carotid endarterectomy: A randomized prospective study in a selected group of patients. J Vasc Surg 9:213-223, 1989.

5. Lord RSA , Raj TB , Stary DL , et al: Comparison of saphenous vein patch, polytetrafluoroethylene and direct arteriotomy closure after carotid endarterectomy. Part 1. Perioperative results. J Vasc Surg 9:521-529, 1989.

6. D'esiron Q , Detry O. Van Damme H , et al: Comparison of results of carotid artery surgery after either direct closure or use of a vein patch. Cardiovasc Surg 5:295-303, 1997.

7. Allen PJ , Jackson MR , O'Donnell SD , et al: Saphenous vein versus polytetrafluoroethylene carotid patch angioplasty. Am J Surg 174:115-117, 1997.

8. Reigel MM , Hollier LH , Pairolero PC , et al: Early experience with a new collagen-impregnated aortic graft. Am Surg 54:134-136, 1987.

9. Westaby S , Parry A , Giannopoulos N , et al: Replacement of the thoracic aorta with collagen-impregnated woven Dacron grafts: Early results. J Thoracic Cardiovasc Surg 106:427-433, 1993.

10.

10. Stegmann TH , Haverich A , Borst HG . Clinical experience with a new collagen-coated Dacron doublevelour prosthesis. Thoracic Cardiovasc Surg 34:54-54, 1986.

11.

11. Baker JD , Rutherford RB , Bernstein EF , et al: Suggested standards for reports dealing with cerebrovascular disease. J Vasc Surg 8:721-729, 1988.

12.

12. AbuRahma AF , Robinson PA , Khan S , et al: Effect of contralateral severe stenosis or carotid occlusion on duplex criteria of ipsilateral stenoses: Comparative study of various duplex parameters. J Vasc Surg 22:751-762, 1995.

13.

13. LeGrand DL , Linehan RL : The suitability of expanded PTFE-P for carotid patch angioplasty. Ann Vasc Surg 4:209-212, 1990.

14.

14. McCready RA , Siderys H , Pittman JN , et al: Delayed postoperative bleeding from polytetrafluoroethylene carotid artery patches. J Vasc Surg 15:661-663, 1992.

15.

15. Rosenthal D , Archie JP , Garcia-Rinaldi R , et al: Carotid patch angioplasty: Immediate and long-term results. J Vasc Surg 12:326-333, 1990.

16.

16. Rhodes VJ : Expanded polytetrafluoroethylene patch angioplasty in carotid endarterectomy. J Vasc Surg 22:724-731, 1995.

17.

17. Goldman KA , Su WT , Riles TS , et al: A comparative study of saphenous vein, internal jugular vein, and knitted Dacron patches for carotid artery endarterectomy. Ann Vasc Surg 9:171-179, 1995.

18.

18. Katz SG , Kohl RD : Does the choice of material influence early morbidity in patients undergoing carotid patch angioplasty? Surgery 119:297-301, 1996.

19.

19. Patel M , Arnell RE , Sauvage LR , et al: Experimental evaluation of ten clinically used arterial prostheses. Ann Vasc Surg 6:244-251, 1992.

20.

20. Hayashida N. Han MT , Wu MH , et al: Differential effect of the retropleural and retroperitoneal environments on healing of the inner wall of porous fabric prostheses in the thoracic and abdominal aorta of the same dog. Ann Vasc Surg 9:369-377, 1995.

21.

21. Durante KD , Wu HD , Sauvage LR : Implant site: A determinant of completeness of arterial prosthesis healing in the dog and possible in humans. Ann Vasc Surg 4:171-178, 1990.

22.

22. Wakefield TW , Shulkin BL , Fellows EP , et al: Platelet activity in human aortic grafts: A prospective, randomized midterm study of platelet adherence and release products in Dacron and polytetrafluoroethylene. J Vasc Surg 9:234-243, 1989.

23.

23. De Mol Vat Otterloo JCA , Van Brockel JH , Ponfoort ED , et al: Systemic effects of collagen-impregnated aortoiliac Dacron vascular prostheses on platelet activation and fibrin formation. J Vasc Surg 14:59-66, 1990.