Is grading polarized in political science classrooms? We offer experimental evidence that suggests it is not. Many have argued that instructors’ grading in political science classrooms is skewed by the political characteristics of the instructor, the student, or an interaction between the two. Yet the evaluations of whether such biases exist has been asserted and denied with little evidence—even though prominent theories in political science suggest that the charge is not entirely implausible. Using a set of anonymous essays by undergraduates graded by teaching assistants at a variety of institutions, we test for the presence of bias in a framework that avoids the usual selection bias issues that confound attempts at inference. After evaluating the evidence carefully, we find that the evidence for bias is much weaker than activists claim.
AchenC. H.BartelsL. M. (2006, August). It feels like we’re thinking: The rationalizing voter and electoral democracy. Prepared for presentation at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Philadelphia, PA.
2.
AnsolabehereS.MeredithM.SnowbergE. (2013). Asking About Numbers: Why and How. Political Analysis, 21, 48-69.
BullockJ. G.GerberA.HillS.HuberG. (2013). Partisan bias in factual beliefs about politics (Working Paper No. w19080). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
8.
CampbellA.ConverseP.MillerW.StokesD. (1960). The American voter. New York, NY: John Wiley.
FlemingN. D. (1999). Biases in marking students’ written work: Quality? In BrownS.GlasnerA. (Eds.), Assessment matters in higher education: choosing and using diverse approaches (pp. 83-92). Buckingham, UK: Society for Research Into Higher Education and Open University Press.
14.
FosseE.FreeseJ.GrossN. (2011). Political liberalism and graduate student attendance: A longitudinal analysis (Working paper).
15.
GainesB.KuklinskiJ.QuirkP.PeytonB.VerkuilenJ. (2007). Same facts, different interpretations: Partisan motivation and opinions on Iraq. Journal of Politics, 69, 957-994.
16.
GirouxH. A. (2006). Academic freedom under fire: The case for critical pedagogy. College Literature, 33(4), 1-42.
GrossN. (2013). Why are professors liberal and why do conservatives care?Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
20.
HorowitzD.LaksinJ. (2009). One party classroom: How radical professors at America’s top colleges indoctrinate students and undermine democracy. New York, NY: Crown Forum.
JeritJ.BarabasJ. (2012). Partisan perceptual bias and the information environment. Journal of Politics, 74, 672-684.
24.
Kelly-WoessnerA.WoessnerM. C. (2006). My professor is a partisan hack: How perceptions of a professor’s political views affect student course evaluations. Political Science & Politics, 39, 495-501.
25.
KemmelmeierM.DanielsonC.BastenJ. (2005). What’s in a grade? Academic success and political orientation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 31, 1386-1399.
26.
LeeJ. (2006). The “faculty bias” studies: Science or propaganda?Washington, DC: American Federation of Teachers.
MarantoR.HessF. (2009). The politically correct university: Problems, scope and reforms. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.
29.
MarianiM. D.HewittG. (2008). Indoctrination U.? Faculty ideology and changes in student political orientation. Political Science & Politics, 41, 773-783.
YancyG. (2011). Compromising scholarship: Religious and political bias in American higher education. Waco, TX: Baylor University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
