Recently, we introduced and validated annual state-level estimates of the public’s policy mood and party identification from 1956 to 2010 and self-identified political ideology from 1976 to 2010. In this issue, Berry, Ringquist, Fording, and Hanson (BRFH) compare our measure of policy mood with a measure they created, and they conclude that their measure is “the best available indicator of state policy mood for researchers doing pooled cross-sectional time-series analysis.” In this article, we show that BRFH’s skepticism of our measure and confidence in their measure result from a failure to fully consider over-time dynamics. When we consider over-time variation, the Enns and Koch measure of policy mood continues to perform well. By contrast, some concerning patterns emerge with the BRFH measure. In addition to further validating the Enns and Koch measure, this article speaks to similarities in opinion change across states and offers initial evidence of an over-time relationship between state policy mood and state spending priorities.
AbramowitzAlan I.SaundersKyle L.1998. “Ideological Realignment in the U.S. Electorate.” Journal of Politics60:634–52.
2.
BeckNathanielKatzJonathan N.1995. “What to Do (And Not to Do) with Time-Series Cross-section Data.” American Political Science Review89:634–47.
3.
BeckNathanielKatzJonathan N.2011. “Modeling Dynamics in Time-Series–Cross-section Political Economy Data.” Annual Review of Political Science14:331–52.
4.
BerryWilliam D.FordingRichard C.RingquistEvan J.HansonRussell L.KlarnerCarl E.2010. “Measuring Citizen and Government Ideology in the U.S. States: A Re-appraisal.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly10 (2): 117–35.
5.
BerryWilliam D.FordingRichard C.RingquistEvan J.HansonRussell L.KlarnerCarl. 2013. “A New Measure of State Government Ideology, and Evidence that Both the New Measure and an Old Measure Are Valid.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly13 (2): 164–82.
6.
BerryWilliam D.FordingRichard C.HansonRussell L.2003. “Reassessing the ‘Race to the Bottom’ in State Welfare Policy.” Journal of Politics65 (2): 327–49.
7.
BerryWilliam D.RingquistEvan J.FordingRichard C.HansonRussell L.1998. “Measuring Citizen Ideology and Government Ideology in the American States, 1960–1993.” American Journal of Political Science42:327–48.
8.
BerryWilliam D.RingquistEvan J.FordingRichard C.HansonRussell L.2007a. “The Measurement and Stability of State Citizen Ideology.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly7 (2): 111–32.
9.
BerryWilliam D.RingquistEvan J.FordingRichard C.HansonRussell L.2007b. “A Rejoinder: The Measurement and Stability of State Citizen Ideology.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly7 (2): 160–66.
10.
BerryWilliam D.RingquistEvan J.FordingRichard C.HansonRussell L.2015. “Assessing the Validity of Enns and Koch’s Measure of State Policy Mood.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly15 (4): 425–435.
11.
BracePaulArceneauxKevinJohnsonMartinUlbigStacy G.2004. “Does State Political Ideology Change over Time?”Political Research Quarterly57 (4): 529–40.
12.
BracePaulArceneauxKevinJohnsonMartinUlbigStacy G.2006. “Rejoinder to Berry, Ringquist, Fording, and Hanson ‘Comment.’” Political Research Quarterly59 (4): 655.
13.
BracePaulArceneauxKevinJohnsonMartinUlbigStacy G.2007. “Reply to ‘The Measurement and Stability of State Citizen Ideology.’” State Politics & Policy Quarterly7 (2): 133–40.
14.
CarseyThomas M.HardenJeffrey J.2010. “New Measures of Partisanship, Ideology, and Policy Mood in the American States.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly10 (2): 136–56.
15.
CaugheyDevinWarshawChristopher. 2015. “Dynamic Estimation of Latent Opinion Using a Hierarchical Group-Level IRT Model.” Political Analysis23(2): 197-211.
16.
De BoefSuzannaKeeleLuke. 2008. “Taking Time Seriously.” American Journal of Political Science52 (1): 184–200.
EllisChristopherStimsonJames A.2012. Ideology in America. New York: Cambridge University Press.
19.
EnnsPeter K.2013. “Punitive Politics in the U.S. States.” Paper prepared for presentation at the Annual Meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago, IL.
20.
EnnsPeter K.2014. “The Public’s Increasing Punitiveness and Its Influence on Mass Incarceration in the United States.” American Journal of Political Science58 (4): 857–72.
21.
EnnsPeter K.KellstedtPaul M.2008. “Policy Mood and Political Sophistication: Why Everybody Moves Mood.” British Journal of Political Science38 (3): 433–54.
22.
EnnsPeter K.KochJulianna. 2013. “Public Opinion in the U.S. States: 1956 to 2010.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly13 (3): 349–72.
23.
EnnsPeter K.MasakiTakaakiKellyNathan. 2014. “Time Series Analysis and Spurious Regression: An Error Correction.” Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Southern Political Science Association, New Orleans, LA.
24.
EnnsPeter K.WlezienChristopher. 2011. “Group Opinion and the Study of Representation.” In Who Gets Represented? eds. EnnsPeter K.WlezienChristopher. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, pp. 1–25.
25.
EriksonRobert S.WrightGerald C.McIverJohn P.1993. Statehouse Democracy: Public Opinion and Policy in the American States. New York: Cambridge University Press.
26.
EriksonRobert S.WrightGerald C.McIverJohn P.2007. “Measuring the Public’s Ideological Preferences in the 50 States: Survey Responses versus Roll Call Data.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly7 (2): 141–51.
27.
EriksonRobert S.MacKuenMichael B.StimsonJames A.2002. The Macro Polity. New York: Cambridge University Press.
28.
FordingRicard C.BerryWilliam D.2007. “The Historical Impact of Welfare Programs on Poverty: Evidence from the American States.” Policy Studies Journal35 (1): 37–60.
29.
HardenJeffrey J.2011. “A Bootstrap Method for Conducting Statistical Inference with Clustered Data.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly11 (2): 223–46.
30.
HardenJeffrey J.2012. “Improving Statistical Inference with Clustered Data.” Statistics, Politics, and Policy3 (1:1-28).
31.
JacobyWilliam G.SchneiderSaundra K.2009. “A New Measure of Policy Spending Priorities in the American States.” Political Analysis17 (1): 1–24.
32.
KellyNathan J.EnnsPeter K.2010. “Inequality and the Dynamics of Public Opinion: The Self-reinforcing Link between Economic Inequality and Mass Preferences.” American Journal of Political Science54 (4): 855–70.
33.
LaxJeffrey R.PhillipsJustin H.2009. “How Should We Estimate Public Opinion in the States?”American Journal of Political Science53:107–21.
34.
LublinDavid. 2004. The Republican South. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
35.
MacKuenMichael B.EriksonRobert S.StimsonJames A.1989. “Macropartisanship.” American Political Science Review83:1125–42.
36.
NickellStephen. 1981. “Biases in Dynamic Models with Fixed Effects.” Econometrica49 (6): 1417–26.
37.
NorranderBarbara. 2001. “Measuring State Public Opinion with the Senate National Election Study.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly1 (1): 111–25.
38.
PachecoJulianna. 2011. “Using National Surveys to Measure Dynamic U.S. State Public Opinion: A Guideline for Scholars and an Application.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly11 (4): 415–539.
39.
PachecoJulianna. 2014. “Measuring and Evaluating Changes in State Opinion across Eight Issues.” American Politics Research42 (6): 986–1009.
40.
PageBenjamin I.ShapiroRobert Y.1992. The Rational Public: Fifty Years of Trends in Americans’ Policy Preferences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
41.
ParkDavid K.GelmanAndrewBafumiJoseph. 2004. “Bayesian Multilevel Estimation with Poststratification: State-Level Estimates from National Polls.” Political Analysis12:375–85.
42.
ShirleyKenneth E.GelmanAndrew. 2015. “Hierarchical Models for Estimating State and Demographic Trends in US Death Penalty Public Opinion.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society178 (1): 1–28.
43.
StimsonJames A.1991. Public Opinion in America: Moods, Cycles, and Swings. Boulder: Westview Press.
44.
WeberRonald E.HopkinsAnne H.MezeyMichael L.MungerFrank J.1972. “Computer Simulation of State Electorates.” Public Opinion Quarterly36:549–565.
45.
WrightGeraldEriksonRobert S.McIverJohn P.1985. “Measuring State Partisanship and Ideology Using Survey Data.” Journal of Politics47 (2): 469–89.
