The Unbearable Liveness of News Television in India

Abstract

The last two decades in India have seen an enormous growth of satellite television. News has established itself in the meanwhile not merely as a source of information but also of entertainment. Available in all regional languages through several competing channels, and presented elaborately, television news has come to establish a mode of address, which defines one’s sense of time and space, and configures one’s sense of the dramatic situated in others’ stories. This article engages with the implications of “liveness”—as material and as affect—toward convergence of news narratives. Discussing two of the most widely covered recent stories—Aarushi Talwar’s murder and Baby Falak—the article foregrounds the class antagonism and scandalous anxieties of Indian televisual publics, and argues that news television invites us to trade liveness for news. Thus, news media not only liberates itself of the rigor of news production but also entertains us by reaffirming our deepest anxieties and competing with other modes of intertextual entertainment available on rival channels.

Keywords

liveness news television Baby Falak Aarushi Talwar evidence enunciation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akoijam

Indira

. 2013. “No Focus on Development Issues.” The Hoot, October 8. http://www.thehoot.org/web/No-focus-on-development-issues/6159-1-1-9-true.html (accessed December 25, 2013).

Batabyal

Somnath

. 2011. “Editorial! Where Art Thou? News Practices in Indian Television.” In Indian Mass Media and the Politics of Change, edited by Batabyal

Somnath

Chowdhry

Angad

Gaur

Meenu

Pohjonen

Matti

, 42–67. New Delhi: Routledge.

Baudrillard

Jean

. 1984. The Evil Demon of Images. Sydney: Power Institute.

Beckett

Paul

Pokharel

Krishna

. 2012. “Falak: The Complete True Story of ‘India’s Baby.’” The Wall Street Journal, June 10.http://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/2012/06/10/falak-the-complete-true-story-of-indias-baby/ (accessed February 5, 2015).

Bhandare

Namita

. 2011. “Aarushi on Prime Time.” Hindustan Times, February 18. http://www.hindustantimes.com/columnsothers/aarushi-on-prime-time/article1-664072.aspx (accessed February 5, 2015).

Bhatia

Rahul

. 2013. “The Network Effect.” The Caravan, December 1. http://www.caravanmagazine.in/reportage/network-effect (accessed January 30, 2015).

Bhushan

Sandeep

. 2013. “Manufacturing News.” Economic & Political Weekly 48 (23): 12–5.

Bhushan

Sandeep

. 2014. “How the Television News Industry Scripted the Indian Elections.” The Caravan, May 15. http://www.caravanmagazine.in/vantage/television-scripted (accessed May 28, 2014).

Bhutia

Ugen

. 2013. “Media at Its Jingoistic Worst.” The Hoot, May 4. http://thehoot.org/web/Media-at-its-jingoistic-worst/6770-1-1-14-true.html (accessed December 25, 2013).

10.

Bolter

Jay David

Grusin

Richard

. 2000. Remediation: Understanding New Media. Cambridge: MIT Press.

11.

Bourdon

Jerome

. 2000. “Live Television Is Still Alive.” Media, Culture & Society 22 (5): 531–56.

12.

Chadha

Kalyani

. 2012. “Twitter as Media Watch-Dog? Lessons from India’s Radia Tapes Scandal.” Global Media and Communications 8 (2): 171–76.

13.

Chaudhury

Shoma

. 2010. “Media Ethics: Why We Need Both Panic and a Pinch of Salt.” Tehelka 7, no. 48 (December 4). http://archive.tehelka.com/story_main48.asp?filename=Ne041210CoverstoryIII.asp (accessed February 5, 2015).

14.

Chaudhury

Shoma

. 2012a. “Can the Media Bail Itself Out in Time?” Tehelka 9, no. 50 (December 15). http://www.tehelka.com/can-the-media-bail-itself-out-in-time/ (accessed February 5, 2015).

15.

Chaudhury

Shoma

. 2012b. “The Tail Has Begun to Wag the Dog.” Tehelka 9, no. 30 (June 28). http://www.tehelka.com/the-tail-has-begun-to-wag-the-dog/ (accessed February 5, 2015).

16.

Chaudhury

Shoma

. 2013. “Framed? The Aarushi-Hemraj Murder Case—An Investigation.” Tehelka 10, no. 26 (June 29). http://www.tehelka.com/framed-the-aarushi-hemraj-murder-case-an-investigation/ (accessed February 5, 2015).

17.

Coleridge

1993. The Paper Tigers: The Latest, Greatest Newspaper Tycoons. London: Heinemann.

18.

Couldry

Nick

. 2004. “Liveness, ‘Reality,’ and the Mediated Habitus from Television to the Mobile Phone.” The Communication Review 7 (4): 353–61.

19.

Dalal

Sucheta

. 2001. “Who Calls the Shots?” Alternate Media Times 5(18). http://magiclanternfoundation.org/issue18/ (accessed February 5, 2015).

20.

Express News Service. 2010. “Aarushi Murder Case: SC Slams ‘Sensationalist’ Media.” The Indian Express, August 9. http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/aarushi-murder-case-sc-slams-sensationalist-media/658048/ (accessed December 16, 2014).

21.

Feuer

Jane

. 1983. “The Concept of Live Television: Ontology vs. Ideology.” In Regarding Television, edited by Kaplan

E. Ann

, 12–22. Los Angeles: American Film Institute/University Publications of America.

22.

French

Patrick

. 2011. “Worse than a Daughter’s Death.” OPEN, February 5. http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/nation/worse-than-a-daughter-s-death (accessed February 5, 2015).

23.

Ghosh

Shohini

. 2008. “Here We Are Now, Entertain us.” Hindustan Times, June 3. http://www.hindustantimes.com/bigidea/here-we-are-now-entertain-us/article1-315032.aspx (accessed February 5, 2015).

24.

Ghosh

Shohini

. 2013. “The Talwars and Presumed Guilt.” The Hoot, November 26. http://www.thehoot.org/web/The-Talwars-and-presumed-guilt/7127-1-1-5-true.html (accessed June 24, 2014).

25.

Gurha

Alka

. 2013. “TV Debates Polarise Further.” The Hoot, July 18. http://thehoot.org/web/TVdebatespolarisefurther/6910-1-1-14-true.html (Accessed June 24, 2014).

26.

Jain

Gaurav

. 2011. “The House We blew down.” Tehelka 8, no. 7 (February 19). http://www.tehelka.com/the-house-we-blew-down/ (accessed February 5, 2015).

27.

Jose

Vinod K.

2011.” News without Principle.” The Caravan, January 1. http://www.caravanmagazine.in/perspectives/news-without-principle (accessed February 5, 2015).

28.

Jose

Vinod K.

2012. “On the Success of Ethics.” The Caravan, December 1. http://www.caravanmagazine.in/perspectives/success-ethics (accessed February 5, 2015).

29.

Kaul

Rhythma

. 2012. “Abandoned, 2-Yr-Old Battles for Life in ICU.” Hindustan Times, January 25. http://www.hindustantimes.com/newdelhi/abandoned-2-yr-old-battles-for-life-in-icu/article1-802284.aspx (accessed February 5, 2015).

30.

Kumar

Akshaya

. 2014. “Satyamev Jayate: Return of the Star as a Sacrificial Figure.” South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 37 (2): 239–54.

31.

Liang

Lawrence

. 2013. “Naked Truths.” The Caravan, February 1. http://www.caravanmagazine.in/periscope/naked-truths (accessed October 16, 2014).

32.

Majumdar

Ushinor

. 2013. “Aarushi-Hemraj Murder Case—Shoddy Probe, Flawed Verdict?” Tehelka 49, no. 10 (December 7). http://www.tehelka.com/shoddy-probe-flawed-verdict/ (accessed February 5, 2015).

33.

Mehta

Vinod

. 2012. “Watched on Our Watch.” Outlook, May 4.

34.

Moudgil

Manu

Alam

Monazir

. 2013a. “Jingoism on the Airwaves.” The Hoot, July 14. http://thehoot.org/web/Jingoismontheairwaves/6903-1-1-9-true.html (accessed June 24, 2014).

35.

Moudgil

Manu

Alam

Monazir

. 2013b. “Unpacking the News.” The Hoot, July 14. http://www.thehoot.org/web/Unpacking-the-news/6885-1-1-9-true.html (accessed June 24, 2014).

36.

Nanda

Vartika

. 2006. “Television Crime Reporting in India.” In Making News: Handbook of the Media in Contemporary India, edited by Sahay

Uday

, 189–200. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.

37.

Newsclick Production. 2011. “‘Indian Media—Politically Free, Prisoners of Profit’—P. Sainath.” NewsClick, June 20. http://newsclick.in/international/indian-media-politically-free-prisoners-profit-psainath (accessed June 24, 2014).

38.

Polanki

Pallavi

. 2011. “The Aftermath.” OPEN, February 4. http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/nation/the-aftermath (accessed February 5, 2015).

39.

Prasad

M. Madhava

. 2005. “The Subjects of News Television.” Journal of the Moving Image 4. www.jmionline.org/article/the_subjects_of_news_television (accessed December 16, 2014).

40.

Rajagopal

Arvind

. 2001. Politics after Television: Religious Nationalism and the Reshaping of the Indian Public. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

41.

Rajagopal

Arvind

. 2009. “Introduction.” In The Indian Public Sphere: Readings in Media History, edited by Rajagopal

Arvind

, 1–28. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.

42.

Rajagopal

Arvind

. 2012. “Wanted: A Communications Policy.” The Hindu, January 24. http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/wanted-a-communications-policy/article2826250.ece (accessed February 5, 2015).

43.

Raman

Anuradha

. 2013. “Footaging It Fleetly.” Outlook, December 23. http://www.outlookindia.com/article/Footaging-It-Fleetly/288837 (accessed October 14, 2014).

44.

Roy

Abhijit

. 2006. “Live(li)ness and Network Publics in Post-liberalization Indian Popular Films.” Journal of the Moving Image 5. www.jmionline.org/articles/2006/Live(li)ness_and_Net.pdf (accessed December 16, 2014).

45.

Sardesai

Rajdeep

. 2007. “Ghosts in the Machine.” IBNLive, January 8. http://ibnlive.in.com/blogs/rajdeepsardesai/1/1297/ghosts-in-the-machine.html (Accessed January 30, 2015).

46.

Sen

Shaunak

. 2014. “Decoding the Big Indian Sting.” Sarai. http://sarai.net/decoding-the-big-indian-sting/#06 (accessed October 16, 2014).

47.

Sonwalkar

Prasun

. 2002. “‘Murdochization’ of the Indian Press: From By-line to Bottom-Line.” Media Culture Society 24:821–34.

48.

Susan

Nisha

. 2008. “Slander and Lies.” Tehelka 5, no. 23 (June 14). http://archive.tehelka.com/story_main39.asp?filename=Ne140608slanderandlies.asp (accessed February 5, 2015).

49.

Thakurta

Paranjoy Guha

. 2013. “Curbing Media Monopolies.” Economic & Political Weekly 48 (16): 10–14.

50.

Thakurta

Paranjoy Guha

Chaturvedi

Subi

. 2012. “Corporatisation of the Media: Implications of the RIL-Network18-Eenadu Deal.” Economic & Political Weekly 47 (7): 10–3.

51.

Wal

Aradhana

. 2013. “Every Move She Makes. They’ll Be Watching Her.” Tehelka 10, no. 27 (June 7). http://www.tehelka.com/every-move-she-makes-theyll-be-watching-her/ (accessed February 5, 2015).

52.

Zettl

Herbert

. 1978. “The Rare Case of Television Aesthetics.” Journal of the University Film Association 30 (2): 3–8.