In the United States, 1.4 million nursing home residents have been severely impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic with at least 25,923 resident and 449 staff deaths reported from the virus by June 1, 2020. The majority of residents have chronic illnesses and conditions and are vulnerable to infections and many share rooms and have congregate meals. There was evidence of inadequate registered nurse (RN) staffing levels and infection control procedures in many nursing homes prior to the outbreak of the virus. The aim of this study was to examine the relationship of nurse staffing in California nursing homes and compare homes with and without COVID-19 residents. Study data were from both the California and Los Angeles Departments of Public Health and as well as news organizations on nursing homes reporting COVID-19 infections between March and May 4, 2020. Results indicate that nursing homes with total RN staffing levels under the recommended minimum standard (0.75 hours per resident day) had a two times greater probability of having COVID-19 resident infections. Nursing homes with lower Medicare five-star ratings on total nurse and RN staffing levels (adjusted for acuity), higher total health deficiencies, and more beds had a higher probability of having COVID-19 residents. Nursing homes with low RN and total staffing levels appear to leave residents vulnerable to COVID-19 infections. Establishing minimum staffing standards at the federal and state levels could prevent this in the future.
AbramsH. R.LoomerL.GandiA.GrabowskiD. C. (2020, June 2). Characteristics of U.S. nursing homes with COVID-19 cases. Journal of American Geriatrics Society. Brief report. June 2:10.111/jgs.16661.
2.
American Nurses’ Association. (2014). Nursing staffing requirements to meet the demands of today’s long term care consumer recommendations from the Coalition of Geriatric Nursing Organizations (CGNO). Position Statement 11/12/14. www.nursingworld.org
BostickJ. E.RantzM. J.FlesnerM. K.RiggsC. J. (2006).
Systematic review of studies of staffing and quality in nursing homes.Journal of American Medical Directors Association,
7, 366–376.
California State Auditor. (2014, October). California Department of Public Health: It has not effectively managed investigations of complaints related to long-term health care facilities (Report No. 2014-111). Sacramento, CA: California State Auditor.
7.
California State Auditor. (2018, May). Skilled nursing facilities: Absent effective state oversight, substandard quality of care has continued (Report No. 2017-109). Sacramento, CA: California State Auditor.
8.
California State Auditor. (2020, January). State high risk (Report No. 2019-601). Sacramento, CA: California State Auditor.
9.
CastleN. G. (2008).
Nursing home caregiver staffing levels and quality of care: A literature review. Journal of Applied Gerontology,
27, 375–405.
10.
CastleN. G.AndersonR. A. (2011).
Caregiver staffing in nursing homes and their influence on quality of care. Medical Care,
49(6), 545–552.
11.
CastleN. G.WagnerL. M.FergusonJ. C.HandlerS. M. (2011).
Nursing home deficiency citations for safety. Journal of Aging and Social Policy,
23(1), 34–57.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2001). Report to congress: Appropriateness of minimum nurse staffing ratios in nursing homes phase II final report. (See Kramer AM, Fish R. “The Relationship Between Nurse Staffing Levels and the Quality of Nursing Home Care.” Chapter 2. Abt Associates, Inc.)
Comondore, V. R., Devereaux, P. J., Zhou, Q., Stone, S. B., Busse, J. W., Ravindran, N. C., Burns, K. E., Haines, T., Stringer, B., Cook, D. J., Walter, S. D., Sullivan, T., Berwanger, O., Bhandari, M., Banglawala, S., Lavis, J. N., Petrisor, B., Schünemann, H., Walsh, K., . . . Guyatt, G. H. (2009).
Quality of care in for-profit and not-for-profit nursing homes: Systematic review and meta-analysis. British Medical Journal,
339, b2732.
26.
CornellP. Y.GrabowskiD. C.NortonE. C.RahmanM. (2019).
Do report cards predict future quality? The case of skilled nursing facilities.Journal of Health Economics,
66, 208–221.
27.
Dabney, B. W. & Kalisch, B. J. (2015). Nurse staffing levels and patient-reported missed nursing care. J. Nurs Care Quality, 15; 30(4): 306–312.
28.
DellefieldM. E.CastleN. G.McGiltonK. S.SpilsburyK. (2015).
The relationship between registered nurses and nursing home quality: An integrative review (2008-2014). Nursing Economics33(2), 95–108.
29.
DolanJ.MejiaB. (2020, April 14). Coronavirus is attacking nursing homes with poor infection track records in L.A. County. Los Angeles Times.
GaurS.DumyatiG.NaceD. A.JumpR. L. P. (2020).
Unprecedented solutions for extraordinary times: Helping long-term care settings deal with the COVID-19 pandemic. Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology,
30, 1–8.
GengF.StevensonD. G.GrabowskiD. C. (2019).
Daily nursing home staffing levels highly variable, often below CMS expectations.Health Affairs,
38(7) 1095–1100.
35.
GoldsteinM.Silver-GreenbergJ.GebeloftR. (2020, May 7). Push for profits left nursing homes struggling to provide care. The New York Times.
36.
GrabowskiD. C.FengZ.HirthR.RahmanM.MorV. (2013).
Effect of nursing home ownership on the quality of post-acute care: An instrumental variables approach. Journal of Health Economics,
32(1),12–21.
37.
GrabowskiD. C.StewartK. A.BroderickS. M.CootsL. A. (2008).
Predictors of nursing home hospitalization: A review of the literature.Med Care Research and Review,
65(1), 3–39
38.
GrahamC.RossLBuenoE. B.HarringtonC. (2018).
Assessing the quality of nursing homes in managed care organizations integrating LTSS for dually eligible beneficiaries. Inquiry,
55, 1–10.
39.
HarringtonC.DellefieldM.HalifaxE.FlemingM.BakerjianD. (in press).
Appropriate staffing standards for U.S. nursing homes. Health Services Insights.
40.
HarringtonC.KovnerC.Kayser-JonesJ.BergerS.MohlerM.BurkeR.Zimmerman, D. (2000).
Experts recommend minimum nurse staffing standards for nursing facilities in the United States. Gerontologist,
40(1), 1–12.
41.
HarringtonC.MollottR. J.EdelmanT. S.WellsJ.ValanejadD. (2020).
U.S. nursing home violations of international and domestic human rights standards.International Journal of Health Services,
50(1), 62–72.
42.
HarringtonC.OlneyB.CarrilloH.KangT. (2012).
Nurse staffing and deficiencies in the largest for-profit chains and chains owned by private equity companies.Health Services Research,
47(1 pt I), 106–128.
43.
HarringtonC.RossL.NewmanJ. (2017, December).
Using post acute and long term care quality report cards.The Hospitalist,
7, 1–4.
44.
HarringtonC.SchnelleJ. F.McGregorM.SimmonsS. F. (2016).
The need for minimum staffing standards in nursing homes. Health Services Insights,
9, 13–19.
45.
Hessels, A.J., Paliwal, M., Weaver, S.H., Siddiqui, D., & Wurmser, T.A. (2019). Impact of patient safety culture on missed nursing care and adverse patient events. J Nursing Care Quality, 34(4), 287–294.
46.
Institute of Medicine. (2004). Keeping patients safe: Transforming the work environment of nurses.
National Academy of Medicine.
47.
JacksonM. M.FiererJ.Barrett-ConnorE., Fraser, D., Klauber, M. R., Hatch, R., Burkhart, B., & Jones, M. (1992).
Intensive surveillance for infections in a three year study of nursing home patients.American Journal of Epidemiology,
135, 685–696.
48.
Kalisch, B.J., Tschannen, D., & Lee, K.H. (2011). Do staffing levels predict missed nursing care? Intern J. Quality Health Care, 23(3): 302–308.
49.
Kalisch, B.J., Xie, B., & Dabney, B.W. (2014). Patient-reported missed nursing care correlated with adverse events. Amer J. Med Quality, 29(5): 415–422.
50.
LeeY. L.ThruppL. D.FriisR. H., Fine, M., Maleki, P., & Cesario, T. C. (1992).
Nosocomial infection and antibiotic utilization in geriatric patients: A pilot prospective surveillance program in skilled nursing facilities.Gerontology,
38, 223–232.
51.
LevineS.BonnerA.PerryAMeladyD.UnroeK. T. (2020).
COVID-19 in older adults: Transfers between nursing homes and hospitals. Journal of Geriatric Emergency Medicine,
1(5), 1–7.
52.
LiY.HarringtonC.MukamelD. B.CenX.CaiX.Temkin-GreenerH. (2015).
Nurse staffing hours at nursing homes with high concentrations of minority residents, 2001-2011. Health Affairs,
34, 2129–2137. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2015.0422
53.
LiY.HarringtonC.Temkin-GreenerH.KaiY.CaiXCenX.MukamelD. B. (2015).
Deficiencies in care at nursing homes and in racial/ethnic disparities across homes fell, 2006–11. Health Affairs,
34(7), 1139–1146.
54.
LiY.Temkin-GreenerH.ShanG.CaiX. (in press).
COVID-19 infections and deaths among Connecticut nursing home residents: Facility correlates. Journal of American Geriatrics Society.
55.
LinH. (2014).
Revisiting the relationship between nurse staffing and quality of care in nursing homes: An instrumental variables approach.Journal of Health Economics,
37, 13–24.
MathewsA. W.FullerA.De AvilaJ. (2020, May 1). Thinly-staffed nursing homes face challenges in pandemic. Wall Street Journal.
58.
MukamelD. B.AminA.WeimerD. L.LaddH.SharitJ.SchwarzkopfR.SorkinD. H. (2016).
Personalizing nursing home compare and the discharge from hospitals to nursing homes. Health Services Research,
1(6), 2076–2094.
59.
O’NeillC.HarringtonC.KitchenerM.SalibaD. (2003).
Quality of care in nursing homes: An analysis of the relationships among profit, quality, and ownership.Medical Care,
41 (12), 1318–1330.
60.
RahmanM.GozaloP.Tyler, D., GrabowskiD. C.TrivediA.MorV. (2014).
Dual eligibility, selection of skilled nursing facility, and length of Medicare paid postacute stay. Medical Care Research and Review,
7 (4), 384–401.
61.
RauJ. (2018, July 8). ‘It’s Almost Like a Ghost Town.’ Most nursing homes overstated staffing for years. New York Times.
62.
RauJ. (2020, March 4). Coronavirus stress test: Many 5-star nursing homes have infection-control lapses. Kaiser Health News.
RichardsC. (2002).
Infections in residents of long-term care facilities: An agenda for research. Report of an expert panel.Journal of American Geriatrics Society,
50, 570–576.
65.
RossL.HarringtonC. (2017). California nursing homes: Staffing levels and quality of care.
University of California.
SchnelleJ. F.SchroyerL. D.SarafA. A.SimmonsS. F. (2016)
Determining nurse aide staffing requirements to provide care based on resident workload: A discrete event simulation model. Journal of American Medical Directors Association,
17, 970–977.
68.
SchnelleJ. F.SimmonsS. F.HarringtonC.CadoganM.GarciaE.Bates-JensenB. (2004).
Relationship of nursing home staffing to quality of care?Health Services Research,
39 (2), 225–250.
69.
SimmonsS. F.SchnelleJ. F. (2004).
Individualized feeding assistance care for nursing home residents: Staffing requirements to implement two interventions.Journal Gerontology A Biology Science Medical Science,
59(9), M966–73.
70.
SpectorW. D.LimcangcoR.WilliamsC.RhodesW.HurdD. (2013).
Potentially avoidable hospitalizations for elderly long-stay residents in nursing homes. Medical Care,
51 (8), 673–681.
71.
StevensonK. B. (1999).
Regional data set of infection rates for long-term care facilities: Description of a valuable benchmarking tool. American Journal of Infection Control,
27, 20–26.
72.
StevensonD.BramsonJ. S.GrabowskiD. C. (2013).
Nursing home ownership trends and their impacts on quality of care: A study using detailed ownership data from Texas.Journal of Aging & Social Policy,
25, 30–47.
73.
StrausbaughI. J.JosephC. L. (2000).
The burden of infections in long-term care.Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology,
21, 674–679.
74.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2016, October 4).
Medicare and Medicaid programs: Reform of requirements for long-term care facilities. Final Rule. Federal Register,81 (192), 68688–68872.
75.
U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2007). Nursing homes: Efforts to strengthen federal enforcement have not deterred some homes from repeatedly harming residents (Report No. GAO-07-241). Washington, DC: U.S. GAO.
76.
U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2009a, August). CMS’s specific focus facility methodology should better target the most poorly performing facilities which tend to be chain affiliated and for-profit (Report No. GAO-09-689). Washington, DC: U.S. GAO.
77.
U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2009b). Nursing homes: Addressing the factors underlying understatement of serious care problems requires sustained CMS and state commitment (Report No. GAO-10-70). Washington, DC: U.S. GAO.
78.
U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2020, May 20). Infection control deficiencies were widespread and persistent in nursing homes prior to COVID-19 pandemic. Washington, DC: U.S. GAO.
79.
U.S. Office of the Inspector General. (2014, February). Adverse events in skilled nursing facilities:National incidence among Medicare beneficiaries (Report No. OEI-06-11-00370). Washington, DC: U.S. OIG.
80.
U.S. Office of the Inspector General. (2019, April). Trends in deficiencies at nursing homes show that improvements are needed to ensure the health and safety of residents. HHS Data Brief. Washington, DC: U.S. OIG.
81.
WernerR. M.KnoetzkaR. T.PolskyD. (2016).
Changes in consumer demand following public reporting of summary quality ratings: An evaluation in nursing homes. Health Services Research,
51 (Suppl 2), 1291–309.
82.
White, E.M., Aiken, L.H., & McHugh, M.D. (2019). Registered nurse burnout, job satisfaction and missed care in nursing homes. J. Am Geriatrics Society, 67(10): 2065–2071.
