Patient Turnover and Nursing Employment in Massachusetts Hospitals Before and After Health Insurance Reform: Implications for the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

Abstract

The Affordable Care Act is modeled after Massachusetts insurance reforms enacted in 2006. A linear mixed effect model examined trends in patient turnover and nurse employment in Massachusetts, New York, and California nonfederal hospitals from 2000 to 2011. The linear mixed effect analysis found that the rate of increase in hospital admissions was significantly higher in Massachusetts hospitals (p < .001) than that in California and New York (p = .007). The rate of change in registered nurses full-time equivalent hours per patient day was significantly less (p = .02) in Massachusetts than that in California and was not different from zero. The rate of change in admissions to registered nurses full-time equivalent hours per patient day was significantly greater in Massachusetts than California (p = .001) and New York (p < .01). Nurse staffing remained flat in Massachusetts, despite a significant increase in hospital admissions. The implications of the findings for nurse employment and hospital utilization following the implementation of national health insurance reform are discussed.

Keywords

nurse staffing health care workforce patient turnover Affordable Care Act hospital care acute care health reforms patient outcomes collective bargaining/labor issues

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aiken

L. H.

Sloane

D. M.

Cimiotti

J. P.

Clarke

S. P.

Flynn

Seago

J. A.

Smith

H. L.

(2010) Implications of the California nurse staffing mandate for other states. Health Services Research 45(2): 1–18.

Altman

S. H.

(2012) The lessons of Medicare’s prospective payment system show that the bundled payment program faces challenges. Health Affairs 31(9): 1923–1930.

American Hospital Association (AHA) (2000) Annual survey of hospitals, Chicago, IL: Author.

American Hospital Association (AHA) (2009) Annual survey of hospitals, Chicago, IL: Author.

American Hospital Association (AHA) (2011) Annual survey of hospitals, Chicago, IL: Author.

Auerbach

D. I.

Staiger

D. O.

Muench

Buerhaus

P. I.

(2013) The nursing workforce in an era of health care reform. New England Journal of Medicine 368(16): 1470–1472.

Ayanian

J. Z.

Van der Wees

P. J.

(2012) Tackling rising health care costs in Massachusetts. New England Journal of Medicine 367(9): 790–793.

Baumann

A. O.

Blythe

J. M.

Underwood

J. M.

(2006) Surge capacity and casualization: Human resource issues in the Post-SARS health system. Canadian Journal of Public Health 97(3): 230–232.

Buerhaus

P. I.

Auerbach

D. I.

Staiger

D. O.

Muench

(2013) Projections of the long-term growth of the registered nurse workforce: A regional analysis. Nursing Economics 31(1): 13–17.

10.

Cavouras

C. A.

(2002) Nurse staffing levels in American hospitals: A 2001 report. Journal of Emergency Nursing 28(1): 40–43.

11.

Cook

Gaynor

Stephens

Taylor

(2012) The effect of a hospital nurse staffing mandate on patient health outcomes: Evidence from California’s minimum staffing regulation. Journal of Health Economics 31(2): 340–348.

12.

Coughlin

T. A.

Long

S. K.

Sheen

Tolbert

(2012) How five leading safety-net hospitals are preparing for the challenges and opportunities of health care reform. Health Affairs 31(8): 1690–1697.

13.

Dall

T. M.

Chen

Y. J.

Seifert

R. F.

Maddox

P. J.

Hogan

P. F.

(2009) The economic value of professional nursing. Medical Care 47(1): 97–104.

14.

Division of Health Care Finance and Policy. (2010, June). Hospital inpatient and emergency department utilization trends FY 04 – FY08. Retrieved from http://www.mass.gov/eohhs/researcher/physical-health/health-care-delivery/dhcfp-publications.html#trends.

15.

Division of Health Care Finance and Policy. (2012, August). Efficiency of emergency department utilization in Massachusetts. Retrieved from http://www.mass.gov/eohhs/researcher/physical-health/health-care-delivery/health-care-cost-trends/2012-health-care-cost-trends/preliminary-reports/2012-cost-trends-ed-utilization.html.

16.

Duffield

Diers

Aisbett

Roche

(2009) Churn: Patient turnover and case mix. Nursing Economics 27(3): 185–191.

17.

Earp, B. E., Louie, D., & Blazar, P. (2013). The impact of Massachusetts healthcare reform on an orthopedic hand service. Journal of Hand Surgery, 38(11), 2212–2217. doi: 10.1016/j.jhsa.2013.04.041.

18.

Everhart

Neff

Al-Amin

Nogle

Weech-Maldonado

(2013) The effects of nurse staffing on hospital financial performance: Competitive versus less competitive markets. Health Care Management Review 38(2): 146–155.

19.

Hanchate

A. D.

Lasser

K. E.

Kapoor

Rosen

McCormick

D’Amore

M. M.

Kressin

N. R.

(2012) Massachusetts reform and disparities in inpatient care utilization. Medical Care 50(7): 569–577.

20.

Jiang, H. J., Stocks, C., & Wong, C. J. (2006). Disparities between two common data sources on hospital nurse staffing. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 38(2), 187–193.

21.

Juraschek

S. P.

Zhang

Ranganathan

V. K.

Lin

(2012) United States registered nurse workforce report card and shortage forecast. American Journal of Medical Quality 27(3): 241–249.

22.

Johnson, J. E., Smith, A. I., & Mastro, K. A. (2012). From Toyota to the bedside nurses can lead the lean way in health care reform. Nursing Administration Quarterly, 36(3), 234–242.

23.

Kane

N. M.

Singer

S. J.

Clark

J. R.

Eeckloo

Valentine

(2012) Strained local and state government finances among current realities that threaten public hospitals’ profitability. Health Affairs 31(8): 1680–1689.

24.

Kane

R. L.

Shamliyan

T. A.

Mueller

Duval

Wilt

T. J.

(2007) The association of registered nurse staffing levels and patient outcomes: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Medical Care 45(12): 1195–1205.

25.

Jones

Shin

Byrne

F. R.

Long

S. K.

(2011) Safety-net providers after health care reform: Lessons from Massachusetts. Archives of Internal Medicine 171(15): 1379–1384.

26.

Litvak

Bisognano

(2011) More patients, less payment: Increasing hospital efficiency in the aftermath of health reform. Health Affairs 30(1): 76–80.

27.

Litvak

Buerhaus

P. I.

Davidoff

Long

M. C.

McManus

M. L.

Berwick

D. M.

(2005) Managing unnecessary variability in patient demand to reduce nursing stress and improve patient safety. Joint Commission Journal on Quality Patient Safety 31(6): 330–338.

28.

Loehrer, A. P., Song, Z., Auchincloss, H. G., & Hutter, M. M. (2013). Massachusetts health care reform and reduced racial disparities in minimally invasive surgery. JAMA Surgery, 148(12), 1116–1122. doi: 10.1001/jamasurg.2013.2750.

29.

Long

S. K.

Stockley

(2011) The impacts of state health reform initiatives on adults in New York and Massachusetts. Health Services Research 46(1): 365–387.

30.

Long

S. K.

Stockley

Dahlen

(2012) Massachusetts health reforms: Uninsurance remains low, self-reported health status improves as state prepares to tackle costs. Health Affairs 31(2): 444–451.

31.

Mark, B. A., Harless, D. W., Spetz, J., Reiter, K. L., & Pink, G. H. (2013). California’s minimum nurse staffing legislation: Results from a natural experiment. Health Services Research, 48(2 Pt 1), 435–454. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2012.01465.x.

32.

McHugh

M. D.

Berez

Small

D. S.

(2013) Hospitals with higher nurse staffing had lower odds of readmissions penalties than hospitals with lower staffing. Health Affairs 32(10): 1740–1747.

33.

McHugh

M. D.

Carthon

M. B.

Sloane

D. M.

Kelly

Aiken

L. H.

(2012) Impact of nurse staffing mandates on safety-net hospitals: Lessons from California. Milbank Quarterly 90(1): 160–186.

34.

McHugh

M. D.

Kelly

L. A.

Sloane

D. M.

Aiken

L. H.

(2011) Contradicting fears, California’s nurse-to-patient mandate did not reduce the skill level of the nursing workforce in hospitals. Health Affairs 30(7): 1299–1306.

35.

McWilliams

J. M.

Landon

B. E.

Chernew

M. E.

(2013) Changes in health care spending and quality for Medicare beneficiaries associated with a commercial ACO contract. JAMA 310(8): 829–836.

36.

Mechanic

R. E.

Altman

S. H.

McDonough

J. E.

(2012) The new era of payment reform, spending targets, and cost containment in Massachusetts: Early lessons for the nation. Health Affairs 31(10): 1–9.

37.

Meyer

R. M.

Clarke

S. P.

(2011) Shifts with nurse understaffing and high patient churn linked to heightened inpatient mortality risk in a single site study. Evidence-Based Nursing 14(4): 122–123.

38.

Mohan

Grant

Batalden

McCormick

(2013) The health of safety net hospitals following Massachusetts health care reform: Changes in volume, revenue, costs, and operating margins from 2006 to 2009. International Journal of Health Services 43(2): 321–335.

39.

Myny

Van Heck

DeBacquer

Verhaeghe

Gobert

Defloor

Van Goubergen

(2012) Determining a set of measurable and relevant factors affecting nursing workload in the acute care hospital setting: A cross-sectional study. International Journal of Nursing Studies 49: 427–436.

40.

National Conference of State Legislatures. (2013). State legislation and actions opting-out or opposing certain health reforms. Retrieved from http://www.ncsl.org/documents/summit/summit2013/online-resources/State-Legislation- Opt-out.pdf.

41.

National Quality Forum (2004) National voluntary consensus standards for nursing-sensitive care: An initial performance set, Washington, DC: Author.

42.

Needleman

Buerhaus

Pankratz

V. S.

Leibson

C. L.

Stevens

S. R.

Harris

(2011) Nurse staffing and inpatient hospital mortality. New England Journal of Medicine 364: 1037–1045.

43.

Ozcan

Y. A.

Luke

R. D.

(2011) Health care delivery restructuring and productivity change: Assessing the Veterans Integrated Service Networks (VISNs) using the Malmquist approach. Medical Care Research and Review 68(Suppl. 1): 20S–35S.

44.

Park, S. H., Blegen, M. A., Spetz, J., Chapman, S. A., & De Groot, H. (2012). Patient turnover and the relationship between nurse staffing and patient outcomes. Research in Nursing & Health, 35, 277–288. doi: 10.1002/nur.21474.

45.

Patrician

P. A.

Loan

McCarthy

Fridman

Donaldson

Bingham

Brosch

L. R.

(2011) The association of shift-level nurse staffing with adverse patient events. Journal of Nursing Administration 41(2): 64–70.

46.

Shekelle

P. G.

(2013) Nurse-patient ratios as a patient safety strategy: A systematic review. Annals of Internal Medicine 158(5 Pt. 2): 404–409.

47.

Shindul-Rothschild, J. (2010, March). Health care cost trends: Cost drivers. Massachusetts Office of Health and Human Services. Boston. Retrieved from http://www.mass.gov/chia/docs/cost-trend-docs/oral-testimony/oral-testimony-shindul-rothschild.pdf.

48.

Shindul-Rothschild

(2012) Collective bargaining in nursing. In: Mason

Leavitt

Chafee

(eds) Policy and politics in nursing and health care, 6th ed. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier, pp. 455–460.

49.

Shindul-Rothschild

Berry

Long-Middleton

(1996) Where have all the nurses gone? Final results of our patient care survey. American Journal of Nursing 96(11): 25–39.

50.

Smulowitz, P. B., Lipton, R., Wharam, J. F., Adelman, L., Weiner, S. G. … Landon, B. E. (2011). Emergency department utilization after the implementation of Massachusetts health reform. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 58(3), 225–234. doi: 10.1016/j.annemergmed.2011.02.020.

51.

Sochalski

Konetzka

R. T.

Zhu

Volpp

(2008) Will mandated minimum nurse staffing ratios lead to better patient outcomes? Medical Care 46(6): 606–613.

52.

Song

Landon

B. E.

(2012) Controlling health care spending—The Massachusetts experiment. New England Journal of Medicine 366(17): 1560–1561.

53.

Sonier

Boudreaux

M. H.

Blewett

L. A.

(2013) Medicaid “welcome-mat” effect of Affordable Care Act implementation could be substantial. Health Affairs 32(7): 1319–1325.

54.

Spetz

Donaldson

Aydin

Brown

D. S.

(2008) How many nurses per patient? Measurements of nurse staffing in health services research. Health Services Research 43(5): 1674–1691.

55.

Spetz

Harless

D. W.

Herrera

C. N.

Mark

B. A.

(2013) Using minimum nurse staffing regulations to measure the relationship between nursing and hospital quality of care. Medical Care Research Review 70(4): 380–399.

56.

Staggs

V. S.

(2013) Recent trends in hospital nurse staffing in the United States. Journal of Nursing Administration 43(7–8): 388–393.

57.

Staiger

D. O.

Auerbach

D. I.

Buerhaus

P. I.

(2011) Health care reform and the health care workforce—The Massachusetts experience. New England Journal of Medicine 365: e24(1)–e24(3).

58.

Tabachnick

B. G.

Fidell

L. S.

(2012) Using multivariate statistics, 6th ed. Boston, MA: Pearson/Allyn & Bacon.

59.

Tellez

Seago

J. A.

(2013) California nurse staffing law and RN workforce changes. Nursing Economics 31(1): 18–26.

60.

The White House. (2013). Americans are enrolling through health care.gov. Retrieved from http://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2013/10/02/americans-are-enrolling-through-healthcaregov.

61.

Thompson

M. A.

Huerta

T. R.

Ford

E. W.

(2012) Mandatory insurance coverage and hospital productivity in Massachusetts: Bending the curve? Health Care Management Review 37(4): 294–300.

62.

Tierney, S. J. (2010). Nursing unit staffing: An innovative model incorporating patient acuity and patient turnover (Graduate School of Nursing Dissertations, University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, Paper 18). Retrieved from http://escholarship.umassmed.edu/gsn_diss/18.

63.

United States Census Bureau. (2012). State and county quick facts. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Commerce. Retrieved from http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/25000.html.

64.

Unruh

L. Y.

Fottler

M. D.

(2006) Patient turnover and nursing staff adequacy. Health Services Research 41(2): 599–612.

65.

Unruh

L. Y.

Zhang

N. J.

(2012) Nurse staffing and patient safety in hospitals: New variable and longitudinal approaches. Nursing Research 61(1): 3–12.

66.

Wadman

(2012) Health law worries hospitals. Nature 487: 13–14.

67.

Weissman

J. S.

Rothschild

J. M.

Bendavid

Sprivulis

Cook

E. F.

Evans

R. S.

Bates

D. W.

(2007) Hospital workload and adverse events. Medical Care 45(5): 448–455.

68.

West

Mays

Rafferty

A. M.

Rowan

Sanderson

(2009) Nursing resources and patient outcomes in intensive care: A systematic review of the literature. International Journal of Nursing Studies 46(7): 993–1011.

69.

Wong

Karaca

(2012) Did Massachusetts health care reform lower hospital inpatient cost? Value in Health 15(4): A9.