Using heterogeneous COVID-19 stadium attendance restrictions during the 2020 NFL season as an instrumental variable for stadium attendance and a novel panel data containing historical NFL game outcomes, attendance, weather, penalty assessment and visitor travel information between 2009 and 2022, I examine the effect of home stadium attendance on a variety of match outcomes, while controlling for a comprehensive set of covariates. I find that home stadium fans influence the outcomes of NFL games in favor of the home team, and that this result is insensitive to the inclusion of other factors previously suggested to explain home advantage in gridiron football. Neither the size of the home crowd nor the home crowd density has any measurable effect on referee home bias in the NFL, suggesting NFL home fans directly influence match outcomes by negatively affecting visiting team performance, possibly through a crowd noise distraction mechanism.
AlbertJ.KoningR. H. (2007). Statistical thinking in sports. CrC Press.
2.
AngristJ. D.KruegerA. B. (2001). Instrumental variables and the search for identification: From supply and demand to natural experiments. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15(4), 69–85.
3.
BenzL.BlissT.LopezM. (2024). A comprehensive survey of the home advantage in American football. Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports, 20(4), 277–291.
4.
BorghesiR. (2007). The home team weather advantage and biases in the NFL betting market. Journal of Economics and Business, 59(4), 340–354.
5.
BoudreauxC. J.SandersS. D.WaliaB. (2017). A natural experiment to determine the crowd effect upon home court advantage. Journal of Sports Economics, 18(7), 737–749.
6.
BoykoR. H.BoykoA. R.BoykoM. G. (2007). Referee bias contributes to home advantage in English Premiership football. Journal of Sports Sciences, 25(11), 1185–1194.
7.
BrymerR.RodenbergR. M.ZhengH.HolcombT. R. (2021). College football referee bias and sports betting impact. Eastern Economic Journal, 47, 91–106.
8.
BrysonA.DoltonP.ReadeJ. J.SchreyerD.SingletonC. (2021). Causal effects of an absent crowd on performances and refereeing decisions during COVID-19. Economics Letters, 198, 109664.
9.
CohenF.GonzalezF. (2024). Understanding the link between temperature and crime. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 16(2), 480–514.
10.
CrossJ.UhrigR. (2023). Do fans impact sports outcomes? A COVID-19 natural experiment. Journal of Sports Economics, 24(1), 3–27.
11.
DabadghaoS. S.VaziriB. (2022). The predictive power of popular sports ranking methods in the NFL, NBA, and NHL. Operational Research, 22(3), 2767–2783.
12.
DohmenT.SauermannJ. (2016). Referee bias. Journal of Economic Surveys, 30(4), 679–695.
13.
EhrlichJ.PotterJ. (2023). Estimating the effect of attendance on home advantage in the National Basketball Association. Applied Economics Letters, 30(11), 1471–1482.
14.
EhrlichJ.PotterJ.SandersS.PaulR. (2024). Spectators or influencers? The crowd effect upon winning in the NFL: A natural experiment. International Journal of Sport Finance, 19(1), 3–24.
15.
FarnellA. (2023). False start? An analysis of NFL penalties with and without crowds. Journal of Sports Economics, 24(6), 695–716.
16.
FischerK.HaucapJ. (2021). Does crowd support drive the home advantage in professional football? Evidence from german ghost games during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Sports Economics, 22(8), 982–1008.
17.
FullagarH. H.DelaneyJ.DuffieldR.MurrayA. (2019). Factors influencing home advantage in American collegiate football. Science and Medicine in Football, 3(2), 163–168.
18.
GanzS. C.AllsopK. (2024). A mere fan effect on home-court advantage. Journal of Sports Economics, 25(1), 30–53.
19.
GongH. (2022). The effect of the crowd on home bias: Evidence from NBA games during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Sports Economics, 23(7), 950–975.
20.
GuéretteJ.BlaisC.FisetD. (2021). The absence of fans removes the home advantage associated with penalties called by National Hockey League referees. PloS One, 16(8), e0256568.
21.
HeilmannK.KahnM. E.TangC. K. (2021). The urban crime and heat gradient in high and low poverty areas. Journal of Public Economics, 197, 104408.
22.
KleibergenF.PaapR. (2006). Generalized reduced rank tests using the singular value decomposition. Journal of Econometrics, 133(1), 97–126.
23.
KoningR. H. (2011). Home advantage in professional tennis. Journal of Sports Sciences, 29(1), 19–27.
24.
MoskowitzT.WertheimL. J. (2011). Scorecasting: The hidden influences behind how sports are played and games are won. Crown Archetype.
25.
NicholsM. W. (2014). The impact of visiting team travel on game outcome and biases in NFL betting markets. Journal of Sports Economics, 15(1), 78–96.
26.
OleaJ. L. M.PfluegerC. (2013). A robust test for weak instruments. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 31(3), 358–369.
27.
PriceM.YanJ. (2022). The effects of the NBA COVID bubble on the NBA playoffs: A case study for home-court advantage. American Journal of Undergraduate Research, 18, 3–14.
28.
ReadeJ.SchreyerD.SingletonC. (2022). Echoes: What happens when football is played behind closed doors?Economic Inquiry, 60(3), 10–1111.
29.
RickmanN.WittR. (2008). Favouritism and financial incentives: A natural experiment. Economica, 75(298), 296–309.
30.
SchwartzB.BarskyS. F. (1977). The home advantage. Social Forces, 55(3), 641–661.
31.
ScoppaV. (2021). Social pressure in the stadiums: Do agents change behavior without crowd support?Journal of Economic Psychology, 82, 102344.
32.
SmithE. E.GroetzingerJ. D. (2010). Do fans matter? The effect of attendance on the outcomes of major league baseball games. Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports, 6(1), 1–24.
33.
SnyderK.LopezM. (2015). Consistency, accuracy, and fairness: A study of discretionary penalties in the NFL. Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports, 11(4), 219–230.
StockJ. H.WrightJ. H.YogoM. (2002). A survey of weak instruments and weak identification in generalized method of moments. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 20(4), 518–529.
36.
StockJ. H.YogoM. (2002). Testing for weak instruments in linear IV regression.
37.
TamteR. R. (2018). Walter camp and the creation of American football. University of Illinois Press.
38.
ThraneC. (2024). No crowd, no roar, no home advantage: Evidence from ice hockey. European Sport Management Quarterly, 24(4), 921–933.
39.
VerginR. C.SosikJ. J. (1999). No place like home: An examination of the home field advantage in gambling strategies in NFL football. Journal of Economics and Business, 51(1), 21–31.
40.
WaldA. (1940). The fitting of straight lines if both variables are subject to error. The Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 11(3), 284–300.
41.
WolaverA. M.MageeC. (2022). Ghost games: Crowds, referee bias, and home advantage in european football leagues. Journal of Sport Behavior, 45(3), 91–107.
