Research Notes: The Designated Hitter,Moral Hazard,and Hit Batters

Abstract

The rate of hit batters in the American League (AL) has exceeded the National League (NL) by an average rate of 15% per season since the introduction of the designated hitter (DH) to the AL. This difference may be the result of moral hazard by AL pitchers; however, past studies have been unable to differentiate between competing explanations. Using game-level statistics from the entire 31-year history of the DH, we find the DH to be positively correlated with hit batsmen while controlling for many factors. Results indicate that the difference in hit batsmen between leagues is real and that moral hazard explains about one half of the difference. Observations from interleague play further support the notion that the results are not an artifact of unidentified league-specific factors.

Keywords

moral hazard baseball hit batters

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bradbury, J. C. , & Drinen, D. J. (2004). Identifying moral hazard: A natural experiment in Major League Baseball. Unpublished manuscript, Sewanee: The University of the South, TN.

Goff, B. L. , Shughart, W. F. , & Tollison, R. D. (1997). Batter up! Moral hazard and the effects of the designated hitter rule on hit batsmen. Economic Inquiry, 35, 555-561.

Goff, B. L. , Shughart, W. F. , & Tollison, R. D. (1998). Moral hazard and the effects of the designated hitter rule revised. Economic Inquiry, 36, 688-692.

Kawaura, A. , & La Croix, S. J. (2002). Baseball in Japan and North America: Same game, same rules, same results? Unpublished manuscript, University of Hawaii-Manoa, Honolulu.

The Lahman baseball database (Version 5.1). (2004). Available at www.baseball1.com

Levitt, S. D. (1998). The hazards of moral hazard: Comment on Goff, Shughart, and Tollison. Economic Inquiry, 36, 685-687.

National Association of Professional Baseball Leagues . (1996). N.A.P.B.L. Umpire Manual. Chicago: Triumph Books.

Pappas, D. (1997, Fall). Terms of major league expansion. Outside the Lines. Available at http://roadsidephotos.com/baseball/expansion.htm

Retrosheet game logs. (1973-2003). Available at www.retrosheet.org/gamelogs/index.html

10.

Trandel, G. A. (2004). Hit by pitches: Moral hazard, cost-benefit, retaliation, or lack of evidence? Journal of Sports Economics, 5, 87-92.

11.

Trandel,G. A. , White, L. H. , & Klein, P. G. (1998). The effect of the designated hitter rule on hit batsmen: Pitcher’s moral hazard or the team’s cost-benefit calculation. Economic Inquiry, 36, 679-684.