Ethnography and Experiments: Cultural Models and Expertise Effects Elicited with Experimental Research Techniques

Abstract

This article reports the results of two independent studies dealing with saliency effects within the domain of folkbiological knowledge. In study 1, the authors present data from a free-listing task that explored tree-name generation among Tzotzil Maya of Zinacantán (Chiapas). Study 2 compares Menominee Native Americans with majority culture (nonprofessional) fish experts in central Wisconsin. The studies explore patterns of informant agreement and disagreement, looking at the accessibility of certain kinds of biological knowledge, both within and across cultural groups. The authors show that differences in levels of expertise and practice, as well as habitual patterns of knowledge organization (spontaneous categorization), can lead to significant differences in the salience or accessibility of certain types of knowledge.

Keywords

culture and cognition saliency effects experimental ethnography Cultural Consensus Model

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atran, S. , D. Medin , N. Ross , E. Lynch , J. Coley , Ek’ Ucan , and V. Vapnarsky . 1999. Folkecology and commons management in the Maya lowlands. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 96:7598-7603.

Boster, J. , and J. Johnson . 1989. Form or function: A comparison of expert and novice judgment of similarities among fish. American Anthropologist 91:866-889.

Breedlove, D. , and R. Laughlin . 1993. The flowering of man; A Tzotzil botany of Zinacantán. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institute.

Cancian, F. 1965. Economics and prestige in a Maya community: The religious cargo system in Zinacantán. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Garro, L. 2000. Remembering what one knows and the construction of the past: A comparison of cultural consensus theory and cultural schema theory. Ethnos 28 (3): 275-319.

Hall, P. , and M. Pecore . 1995. Case study: Menominee tribal enterprises. Madison: Institute for Environmental Studies and the Land Tenure Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Hong, Y. , M. Morris , C. Chui , and V. Martinez . 2000. Multicultural minds: A dynamic constructivist approach to culture and cognition. American Psychologist 55:709-720.

Keil, F. C. 1995. The growth of causal understanding of natural kinds: Modes of construal and the emergence of biological thought. In Causal Cognition, edited by A. Premack and D. Sperber , 234-262. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

Keil, F. C. , D. T. Levin , B. A. Richman , and G. Gutheil . 1999. Mechanism and explanation in the development of biological thought. In Folkbiology, edited by D. L. Medin and S. Atran , 285-320. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

10.

López, A. , S. Atran , J. Coley , D. L. Medin , and E. E. Smith . 1997. The tree of life: Universal and cultural features of folkbiological taxonomies and inductions. Cognitive Psychology 32:251-295.

11.

Medin, D. L. , E. Lynch , J. D. Coley , and S. Atran . 1997. Categorization and reasoning among tree experts: Do all roads lead to Rome? Cognitive Psychology 39:49-96.

12.

Medin, D. L. , N. Ross , S. Atran , R. Burnett , and S. Blok . 2002. Categorization and reasoning in relation to culture and expertise. In Psychology of learning and motivation, edited by B. Ross , 1-41. New York: Academic.

13.

Medin, D. L. , N. Ross , S. Atran , D. Cox , J. Coley , J. B. Proffitt , and S. Blok . Forthcoming. Folkbiology of freshwater fish. Cognition.

14.

Romney, A. K. , S. Weller , and W. Batchelder . 1986. Culture as consensus: A theory of culture and informant accuracy. American Anthropologist 88:313-333.

15.

Ross, N. 1994a. Die Entwicklung der Blumenindustrie in Zinacantán. Zeitschrift ür Ethnologie 119:59-73.

16.

Ross, N. 1994b. Der traditionelle Hausbau der Tzotzil-Maya von San Andrés Larraínzar (Mexiko). Jahrbuch des Museums für Völkerkunde zu Leipzig 1:265-98.

17.

Ross, N. 1995. Lokale Reaktionen auf das Problem von Landknappheit: Die Blumenindustrie von Zinacantán, Chiapas. Kritische Ökologie 12/13 (3): 14-22.

18.

Ross, N. 2004. Culture and cognition: Implications for theory and method. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

19.

Schmidt, S. H. 1995. A survey of lakes on the Menominee Reservation, Wisconsin. Master’s thesis, University of Wisconsin, Stevens Point.

20.

Weller, S. 1987. Shared knowledge, intracultural variation, and knowledge aggregation. American Behavioral Scientist 31:178-193.

21.

Weller, S. , and A. K. Romney . 1988. Systematic data collection. London: Sage.