35 Years of Public Capital Budgeting: A Review and Future Research Agenda

Abstract

This paper reviews a large number of works published over the past 35 years on public capital budgeting. the purpose of this paper is to provide a more comprehensive analysis of research on capital budgeting. Through this review, this study seeks to critically analyze the literature on the public capital budgeting, identify the research gaps, and set future research agenda based on those gaps. Our study presents a review of 106 academic studies on this topic. the main finding is that constructs, such as international capital budgeting, infrastructure maintenance, cross-state and cross-local municipalities’ analysis, need further attention. This study found that there is a lack of literature that examines how the federal, state, and local governments cope with challenges and pressures during economic decline. Future studies could examine the effects of economic decline during and after Covid-19 pandemic on changes in capital budgeting practices in different countries on national, regional and local levels. the paper is intended as a resource for researchers, practitioners, and policymakers, focusing on public capital budgeting issues.

Keywords

capital budgeting capital management capital infrastructure capital investments infrastructure maintenance review

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Afonso

(2014) “Local Government Capital Spending During and After Recessions: A Cause for Concern?”, International Journal of Public Administration, 37(8):494–505.

American Society of Civil Engineers (2013) Failure to Act: The Impact of Current Infrastructure Investment on America's Economic Future, assessed May 2, 2018 (https://www.asce.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Our_Initiatives/Infrastructure/Content_Pieces/failure-to-act-economic-impact-summary-report.pdf).

American Society of Civil Engineers (2017) The Infrastructure Report Card, assessed May 2, 2018 (https://www.infrastructurerportcard.org/wp-content-up-loads/2016/10/Grades-Chart.png).

Ammar

, Duncombe

and Wright

(2001) “Evaluating Capital Management: A New Approach”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 2(1):47–69.

Aronson

and Schwartz

(2004) “Capital Budgeting”, in: Aronson

and Schwartz

(eds) Management policies in Local Government, 4th ed., Washington, D.C.: ICMA, pp. 217–233.

Balsdon

, Brunner

and Rueben

(2003) “Private demands for public capital: evidence from school bond referenda”, Journal of Urban Economics, 54(3):610–638.

Beckett-Camarata

(2003) “An Examination of the Relationship between the Municipal Strategic Plan and the Capital Budget and its Effect of Financial Performance”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting, and Financial Management, 15(1):1–23.

Beckett-Camarata

(2008) “Capital Budgeting”, in: Rabin

(ed), Encyclopedia of Public Administration and Public Policy, New York, NY: Taylor & Francis, pp. 3–9.

Behn

(1985) “Cutback budgeting”, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 5(2):155–177.

10.

Bertelli

and John

(2013) “Public Policy Investment: Risk and Return in British Politics”, British Journal of Political Science, 43(1):741–773.

11.

Biemans

, Griffin

and Moenaert

(2007) “Twenty years of the journal of product innovation management: History, participants, and knowledge stocks and flows”, Journal of Product Innovation Management, 24(3):193–213.

12.

Bland

R.L.

(2007) A revenue guide for local government, Washington, DC: ICMA.

13.

Boex

J.L

, Martinez-Vazquez

and McNab

R.M.

(2000) “Multi-Year Budgeting: A Review of International Practices and Lessons for Developing and Transitional Economies”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 6(3):91–112.

14.

Bohn

and Inman

(1996) “Balanced-budget rules and public deficits: evidence from the U.S. states”, Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 45(1):13–76.

15.

Bozeman

(1984) “The Capital Budget: History and Future Directions”, Public Budgeting & Finance, 3(1):18–30.

16.

Bunch

(1996) “Current Practices and Issues in Capital Budgeting and Reporting”, Public Budgeting & Finance, 7(3):7–25.

17.

Calabretta

, Durisin

and Ogliengo

(2011) “Uncovering the Intellectual Structure of Research in Business Ethics: A Journey Through the History, the Classics, and the Pillars of Journal of Business Ethics”, Journal of Business Ethics, 104(1):499–524.

18.

Calia

(2001) “Are all public spending programs equal? Priority setting approaches for government budgeting”, Government Finance Review, 17(4):18–28.

19.

Ceka

(2019) “The Case of Public Capital Budgeting and Management Process in Moldova”, in: Srithongrung

, Ermasova

and Yusuf

(2019), Capital Management and Budgeting in the Public Sector, Hershey, Pennsylvania: IGI Global, pp. 134–156.

20.

Chan

(2004) “Use of Capital Budgeting Techniques and an Analytic Approach to Capital Investment Decisions in Canadian Municipal Governments”, Public Budgeting & Finance, 24(2):40–58.

21.

Chapman

(2008) “State and Local Fiscal Sustainability: The Challenges”, Public Administration Review, 68(1):115–131.

22.

Chen

(2014) “Measuring state highway sustainability: taking the fiscal dimension into account”, Public Works Management and Policy, 19 (3):255–276.

23.

Chen

(2016) “Effects of fiscal stress on state highway infrastructure finance: a composite index approach”, Municipal Finance Journal, 37(2): 1–28.

24.

Chen

(2017) “Does money matter for infrastructure outcomes? The effects of public infrastructure finance on state infrastructure quality”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting and Financial Management, 29(3):375–408.

25.

Chen

(2018) “Public infrastructure finance: symposium introduction”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting and Financial Management, 30(2):126–134.

26.

Chen

and Bartle

J.R.

(2017) Infrastructure finance: a guide for local government managers, ICMA and GFOA Policy White Paper, Washington, DC, accessed January 5, 2019 (https://icma.org/documents/infrastructure-financing-guide-local-government-managers).

27.

Choudhury

, Clingermayer

and Dasse

(2003) An Analysis of Institutional and Political Factors Affecting State Capital Expenditure. International Journal of Public Administration, 26(4):373–398.

28.

Culnan

M. J.

(1987) Mapping the intellectual structure of MIS, 1980–1985: A co-citation analysis, Management of Information System Quarterly, 11(3):341–353.

29.

Dabla-Norris

, Brumby

, Kyobe

, Mills

and Papageorgiou

(2012) “Investing in public investment: an index of public investment efficiency”, Journal of Economic Growth, 17(3):235–266.

30.

Dougherty

M.J.

and Klase

(2009) “Fiscal retrenchment in state budgeting: revisiting cutback management in a new era”, International Journal of Public Administration, 32(7):593–619.

31.

Dorotinsky

(2008) Capital Budgeting and Public Financial Management – Part I and II. IMF's PFM Blog, accessed January 5, 2018 (http://blog-pfm.imf.org).

32.

Doss

(1987) “The Use of Capital Budgeting Procedures in U.S. Cities”, Public Budgeting and Finance. 7(3):57–69.

33.

Dowall

(2001) “Rethinking statewide infrastructure policies: Lessons from California and beyond”, Public Works Management & Policy, 6(1):5–17.

34.

Dupont-Morales

M.A.

and Harris

(1994) “Strengthening Accountability: Incorporating Strategic Planning and Performance Measurement into Budgeting”, Public Productivity & Management Review, 17(3):231–239.

35.

Ebdon

(2004) “Capital Management Practices in U.S. Counties”, Public Works Management and Policy, 8(3):192–202.

36.

Ebdon

(2007) “Underpinning Government: Capital and Infrastructure Management in State and Local Government”, in: Ingraham

Patricia

(ed) In Pursuit of Performance: Management Systems in State and Local Government, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, pp. 57–81.

37.

Ermasova

(2012) Capital budgeting at the state level: an empirical analysis from the economic downturn through the present, PhD Dissertation, Bloomington, IN: SPEA, IU Publishing house.

38.

Ermasova

(2013) “Capital Budgeting in the States After the Great Recession”, State and Local Government Review, 45(2):119–130.

39.

Ermasova

(2019) “The Case of Public Capital Budgeting and Management Process in Germany”, in: Srithongrung

, Ermasova

and Yusuf

(2019) Capital Management and Budgeting in the Public Sector, Hershey, Pennsylvania: IGI Global, pp. 49–73.

40.

Ermasova

and Ebdon

(2019) “Public Capital Budgeting and Management Processes in the United States”, in: Srithongrung

, Ermasova

, and Yusuf

(eds) Capital Management and Budgeting in the Public Sector, Hershey, Pennsylvania: IGI Global, pp. 23–48.

41.

Ermasova

and Ermasova

(2019) “Public Capital Budgeting and Management Processes in Russia”, in: Srithongrung

, Ermasova

, and Yusuf

(eds) Capital Management and Budgeting in the Public Sector, Hershey, Pennsylvania: IGI Global, pp. 113–133.

42.

Ermasova

and Mikesell

(2019) “Public capital budgeting and management: The concept and its application in three important federations”, Public Finance and Management. 19(3):207–231.

43.

Farazmand

and Neill

J.P.

(1996) “Capital Decision-Making: Analysis and Judgement”, Public Budgeting and Financial Management, 8 (3): 428–452.

44.

Frankel

and Wachs

(2017) “More Than Money: Infrastructure and Governance”, Public Works Management and Policy, 22(1):6–11.

45.

Forrester

(1993) “Municipal Capital Budgeting: An Examination”, Public Budgeting & Finance, 7(1):85–103.

46.

Government Finance Research Center (1983) “Building Prosperity: Financing Public Infrastructure for Economic Development”, Washington, DC: Government Finance Research Center.

47.

Guzman

(2019) “The Case of Public Capital Budgeting and Management Process in Uzbekistan”, in: Srithongrung

, Ermasova

, and Yusuf

(eds) Capital Management and Budgeting in the Public Sector, Hershey, Pennsylvania: IGI Global, pp. 74–92.

48.

Halachmi

and Sekwat

(1997) “Strategic Capital Budgeting and Planning: Prospects at the County Level”, Public Budgeting and Financial Management, 1(1):578–596.

49.

Hamel

and Prahalad

(1989) “Strategic intent”, Harvard Business Review, 6(3):67–76.

50.

Hillhouse

A.M.

and Howard

(1963) State Capital Budgeting. Chicago, IL: Council of State Governments.

51.

Hina

, Matkin

and Morse

(2017) “Collaborative capital budgeting in U.S. local government”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 29(2):230–262.

52.

Hoyle

(1978) “Mandatory Auditor Rotation: The Arguments and Alternative”, Journal of Accountancy, 145(5):69–78.

53.

Hyde

(2002) Government Budgeting: Theory, process, and politics. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company.

54.

Hush

L.W.

and Peroff

(1988) “The Variety of State Capital Budgets”. Public Budgeting and Finance, 3(1):67–79.

55.

Hwan Chung

(2013) “Adoption of a separate capital budget in local governments: Empirical evidence from Georgia”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 25(4):617–643.

56.

Jacobs

D.F.

(2008) A Review of Capital Budgeting Practices. IMF Working Paper of Fiscal Affairs Department, assessed January 5, 2018 (http://blog-pfm.imf.org/pfmblog/files/a_review_of_capital_budgeting_practicesl.pdf).

57.

Jimenez

and Pagano

(2012) “What Factors Affect Management Quality? State Infrastructure Management and the Government Performance Project”, Public Works Management & Policy, 17(2):124–151.

58.

Johnson

R.W.

(1970) Capital Budgeting. Dubuque, Iowa: Kendall/Hunt Publishing.

59.

Khan

and Hildreth

(ed.) (2002) Budget Theory in the Public sector. New York, NY: Quorum Books.

60.

King

(1995) “Operating and capital budget reform in Minnesota: Managing public finances like the future matters”, Government Finance Review, 11(1):7–10.

61.

Klasse

(2018) “The relationship between fiscal stress and patterns of state budgeting strategies used in cutback management in the last two U. S. recessions”, Public Finance and Management, 18(1):39–63.

62.

Kovari

(2016) “Applying punctuated equilibrium theory to municipal and county operating and capital budgets”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 28(4):405–435.

63.

Kovner

and Lusk

(2010) “The sustainability budgeting model: multiple model flexible budgeting using sustainability as the synthesizing criterion”, Nursing Economics. 28(6):377–385.

64.

Levine , Rubin

C.H. I.

and Wolohojian

(1981) The politics of retrenchment: how local governments manage fiscal stress. Beverly Hills, Calif: Sage Publications.

65.

Lewis

B.D.

and Osterman

(2011) “Sub-national government capital spending in Indonesia: level, structure, and financing”, Public Administration and Development, 31(3):149–158.

66.

Lyden

and Lindenberg

M.M.

, (1983) Public Budgeting in Theory and Practice. New York, NY: Longman.

67.

Marlowe

(2013) “Strategy, priority-setting, and municipal capital budget reform: Three cases from the great recession”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 25(4):693–718.

68.

Marcelo

, Mandri-Perrott

, House

and Schwartz

J.J.

(2016) “An Alternative Approach to Project Selection: The Infrastructure Prioritization Framework”, World Bank Working Paper.

69.

McClain

J.M.

(1966) Capital Budgeting in Selected States. Lexington, Ky.: Bureau of Business Research, College of Commerce, University of Kentucky.

70.

Mikesell

(2007) Fiscal Administration: Analysis and Applications for the Public Sector, Eighth Edition, Belmont, CA: Thomson Wadsworth.

71.

Millar

(1988) “Selecting Capital Investment Projects for Local Governments”, Public Budgeting & Finance, 3(1):63–77.

72.

Miller

G.R.

(1983) “Taking stock of a discipline”, Journal of Communication, 33(3):31–41.

73.

Mintzberg

and Waters

(1985) “Of strategies, deliberate and emergent”, Strategic Management Journal, 6(3):253–259.

74.

Mintzberg

(1990) “The design school: reconsidering the basic premises of strategic management”, Strategic Management Journal, 11(3):171–195.

75.

Moak

and Gordon

(1965) Budgeting for Smaller Governmental Units. Chicago: Municipal Finance Officers Association.

76.

Moomaw

R.L.

, Mullen

J.K

and Williams

(2002) “Human and Knowledge Capital: A Contribution to Empirics of State Economic Growth”, American Economic Journal, 30(1):48–60.

77.

Munnell

A.H.

(1990) “How Does Public Infrastructure Affect Regional Economic Performance?” in: Munnell

A.A.

(ed) Is There a Shortfall in Public Capital Investment? Boston, MA: Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, pp. 23–34.

78.

Office of Management and Budget (2017) Circular A-11, accessed April 15, 2018 (https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/omb/assets/_all_current_year/a11l_2017.pdf).

79.

O'Toole

and Stipak

(1988) “Budgeting and Productivity Revisited: The Local Government Picture”, Public Productivity Review, 12(1):1–12.

80.

Pagano

and Perry

(2008) “Financing Infrastructure in the 21^st Century City”, Public Works Management & Policy, 13(1):22–38.

81.

Pagano

M.A.

(1984) “Notes on capital budgeting”, Public Budgeting & Finance, 4(3):31–40.

82.

Paul

, and Benito

(2018) “A Review of research on outward foreign direct investment from emerging countries, including China: what do we know, how do we know, and where should we be heading?” Asia Pacific Business Review, 24(1):90–115.

83.

Paul

, Parthasarathy

and Gupta

(2017) “Exporting Challenges of SMEs: A Review and Future Research Agenda”, Journal of World Business, 52(3):327–342.

84.

Poterba

(1994) “State Responses to Fiscal Crises: The Effects of Budgetary Institutions and Politics”, Journal of Political Economy, 102(5):799–821.

85.

Premchand

(2007) “Capital Budgets: Theory and Practice/ Budgeting and Budgetary Institution”, in: Shah

(ed) Government budgeting, Washington D.C.: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, pp. 91–113.

86.

Price

(2002) “Innovation in Public Finance: Implications for the Nations Infrastructure”, Public Works Management & Policy, 7(1):63–78.

87.

Pritchett

(2000) “The tyranny of concepts: CUDIE (cumulated, depreciated, investment effort) is not capital”, Journal of Economic Growth, 5(4):361–384.

88.

Pujol

(2008) “Ranking Journals Following a Matching Model Approach: An Application to Public Economics Journals”, Public Economic Theory. 10(1):55–76.

89.

Ramos-Rodriguez

and Ruiz-Navarro

(2004) “Changes in the intellectual structure of strategic management research: A bibliometric study of the strategic management journal, 1980–2000”, Strategic Management Journal, 25(10):981–1004.

90.

Richard

and Daniel

(2001) Managing Public Expenditure: A Reference Book for Transition Countries. Paris: OECD Publishing.

91.

Robinson

S.G.

(1993) Capital Planning and Budgeting, in: Petersen

J.E.

& Strachota

D. R.

(eds.), Local Government Finance: Concepts and Practices. Washington, DC: Government Finance Officers Association, pp. 65–84.

92.

Rosado-Serrano

and Dikova

(2018) “International Franchising: A Literature Review and Research Agenda”, Journal of Business Research. 85(1):238–257.

93.

Rowan

and Hillman

(1996) “Reengineering capital budgeting”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 8(4):360–383.

94.

Rubin

M.M.

and Willoughby

(2009) State budget balancing strategies: riding into the future on lessons learned from the past. 5th TAD Conference, Washington, DC.

95.

Scimago (2018) SCImago Journal and country rank, accessed July 11, 2018 (https://www.scimagojr.com/journalrank.php).

96.

Schick

(2008) “The road to PPB: The stages of budget reform”, in: Rubin

(ed), Public Budgeting. Policy, Process, and Politics. New York, NY: Economics and Business, pp. 27–44.

97.

Scorsone

E.A.

and Plerhoples

(2010) “Fiscal stress and cutback management amongst state and local governments: what have we learned and what remains to be learned?” State and Local Government Review, 42(1):171–179.

98.

Shybalkina

and Bifulco

(2019) “Does Participatory Budgeting Change the Share of Public Funding to Low Income Neighborhoods?” Public Budgeting and Finance, 39(1):45–66.

99.

Srithongrung

(2008) “The Impacts of State Capital Management Programs on State Economic Performance”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 28(3):83–107.

100.

Srithongrung

(2010) “State Capital Improvement Programs and Institutional Arrangements for Capital Budgeting: The Case of Illinois”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting and Financial Management, 22(3):407–430.

101.

Srithongrung

(2018) “Capital Budgeting and Management Practices: Smoothing Out Rough Spots in Government Outlays”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 38(1):47–71.

102.

Srithongrung

and Kriz

(2012) “From Public Infrastructure to National Economic Growth: Do Systematic Investment Practices Matter?” International Public Management Review, 13(2):19–50.

103.

Srithongrung

, Ermasova

and Yusuf

(2019) Capital Management and Budgeting in the Public Sector, Hershey, Pennsylvania: IGI Global.

104.

Srithongrung

, Yusuf

and Kriz

(2019) “A Systematic Public Capital Management and Budgeting Process.” in: Srithongrung

, Ermasova

, and Yusuf

(eds) Capital Management and Budgeting in the Public Sector. Hershey, Pennsylvania: IGI Global, pp. 1–22.

105.

Stanley

M.T.

and Block

(1984) “A survey of multinational capital budgeting”, The Financial Review, 19(1):36–54.

106.

Steiss

A.W.

(2005) Strategic Facilities Planning: Capital Budgeting and Debt Administration, Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.

107.

Steiss

(1975) Local Government Finance. Lexington, Mass.: Lexington Books.

108.

Thurmaier

and Gosling

(2008) Public Budgeting. Policy, Process, and Politics. New York, NY: ME Sharpe Inc.

109.

Walt

and Barenbaum

(2007) “Real options and public sector capital project decision-making”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 19(2):139–152.

110.

Werling

and Horst

(2014) “Catching Up: Greater Focus Needed to Achieve a More Competitive Infrastructure”. National Association of Manufacturers, accessed July 11, 2018 (http://www.nam.org/Issues/Infrastructure/Surface-Infra-structure/Infrastructure-Full-Report-2014.pdf).

111.

Wie

J-E.

and Srithongrung

(2017) “Capital management: advancing theory and practice”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 29(2): 182–208.

112.

van der Hoek

M.P.

(1996) “Fund accounting and capital budgeting: European experiences”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 8(1):26–46.

113.

Vogt

J.A.

(2004) Capital Budget and Finance: A Guide for Local Governments. NC: International City/County Management Association.