We use panel data regressions on US federal and state R&D funding at public universities during 1985–2012 to estimate whether federal academic R&D subsidy is a complement or substitute for state funding of academic research. the results indicate a statistically significant but modest substitution effect. We further find that there is essentially no substitution during periods of rapid growth of federal R&D spending. However, during periods of relatively slow growth in federal funding, the substitution effect is substantial—a one dollar cut below the average growth rate of federal funding leads to an increase of about 65 cents above the average growth rate of state funding.
Blume-KohoutM.E., KumarK.B., and SoodN. (2014) “University R&D funding strategies in a changing federal funding environment”, Science and Public Policy, 42(3):355–368.
2.
BozemanB., and CorleyE. (2004) “Scientists' collaboration strategies: Implications for scientific and technical human capital”, Research Policy, 33(4):599–616.
3.
BushV. (1945) Science, the endless frontier: A report to the President. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
4.
ClarkB.Y., and WhitfordA.B. (2010) “Does more federal environmental funding increase or decrease states' efforts?” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 30(1):136–152.
5.
ConnollyL.S. (1997) “Does external funding of academic research crowd out institutional support?” Journal of Public Economics, 64(3):389–406.
6.
De FigueiredoJ.M., and SilvermanB.S. (2006) “Academic earmarks and the returns to lobbying”, Journal of Law and Economics, 49(2):597–625.
FeldsteinM.S. (1978) “The effect of a differential add-on grant: Title I and local education spending”, Journal of Human Resources, 13(4):443–458.
9.
FellerI. (1997) “Federal and state government roles in science and technology”, Economic Development Quarterly, 11(4):283–295.
10.
FisherR.C. (2007) State and Local Public Finance. (3E). Mason, OH: Thompson South-Western.
11.
GamkharS. (2000) “Is the response of state and local highway spending symmetric to increases and decreases in federal highway grants?” Public Finance Review, 28(1):3–25.
12.
GamkharS. (2003) “Federal budget and trust fund institutions: Do they matter in measuring the impact of federal highway grants?” Public Budgeting and Finance, 23(1):1–21.
13.
GamkharS., and OatesW. (1996) “Asymmetries in the response to increases and decreases in intergovernmental grants: Some empirical findings”, National Tax Journal, 49(4):501–512.
14.
GamkharS., and SimS. (2001) “The impact of federal alcohol and drug abuse block grants on state and local government substance abuse program expenditures: The role of federal oversight”, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 26(6):1261–1290.
15.
GordonN. (2004) “Do federal grants boost school spending? Evidence from Title I”, Journal of Public Economics, 88(9–10):1771–1792.
16.
GramlichE.M. (1987) “Federalism and federal deficit reduction”, National Tax. Journal, 40(3):299–313.
17.
HinesJ.R., and ThalerR.H. (1995) “Anomalies: The flypaper effect”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9(4):217–226.
18.
JacobsenK., and McGuireT.G. (1996) “Federal block grants and state spending: The alcohol, drug abuse, and mental health block grant and state agency behavior”, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 21(4):751–768.
19.
KnightB. (2002) “Endogenous federal grants and crowd-out of state government spending: Theory and evidence from federal highway aid program”, American Economic Review, 92(1):71–92.
20.
McLendonM.K., HearnJ.C., and MokherC.G. (2009) “Partisans, professionals, and power: The role of political factors in state higher education funding”, The Journal of Higher Education, 80(6):686–713.
21.
National Science Foundation, Division of Science Resources Statistics (2007) Academic Research and Development Expenditures: Fiscal Year 2006, Arlington, VA: National Science Foundation.
22.
PayneA.A. (2003) “The effects of congressional appropriation committee membership on the distribution of federal research funding to universities”, Economic Inquiry, 41(2):325–345.
23.
SavageJ. D. (1999) Funding Science in America: Congress Universities, and the Politics of the Academic Pork Barrel, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
WuY. (2013) “The cross-state distribution of federal funding in the USA: The case of financing academic research and development”, Science and Public Policy, 40(3):316–326.
