Merger Myths: A Functional Analysis of Scale Economies in New South Wales Local Government

Abstract

Structural reform through municipal mergers is ubiquitous across the developed world and Australian local government is no exception. Advocates of council consolidation, including the New South Wales (NSW) Government in its current amalgamation program, frequently contend that larger local government entities will generate cost savings through scale economies, despite the fact that different municipal functions exhibit a wide range of production characteristics. in the NSW case, no empirical evidence has been presented in support of the claim that amalgamation will induce greater economies of scale. in order to examine this claim empirically, we undertook a functional municipal expenditure analysis for NSW using 2014 data. Our results cast considerable doubt on the scale economies claim made by the NSW Government.

Keywords

Amalgamation local government New South Wales scale economies

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abelson

and Joyeux

(2015) “New deveopment: Smoke and mirrors-fallacies in the New South Wales government's views on local government financial capacity”, Public Money & Management, 35(4):315–320.

Andrews

and Boyne

(2009) “Size, Structure and Administrative Overheads: An Empirical Analysis of English Local Authorities”, Urban Studies, 46(4):739–759.

Aulich

, Sansom

and McKinlay

(2014) “A Fresh Look at Municipal Consolidation in Australia”, Local Government Studies, 40(1): 1–20.

Australian Bureau of Statistics, Australian Taxation Revenue 2013–14, released 13/5/15, available at www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/5506.0.

Baird

(2015) Alan Jones Breakfast Show 2GB [Interview] (Friday 23rd October 2015).

Bel

and Warner

(2015) “Inter-Municipal Cooperation and Costs: Expectations and Evidence”, Public Administration, 93(1):52–67.

Byrnes

and Dollery

(2002) “Do Economies of Scale Exist in Australian Local Government? A Review of the Research Evidence”, Urban Policy and Research, 20(4):391–414.

Couch

, Gossett

, King

and Parris

(2004) “Economies of scale and the provision of public goods by municipalities”, Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research, 5(3):69–79.

Deloitte Access Economics (2013) Review of Local Government Rating Exemption Provisions.

10.

Dollery

, Grant

and Kortt

(2012) Councils in Cooperation: Shared Services and Australian Local Government. Sydney: The Federation Press.

11.

Dollery

, Crase

and Johnson

(2006) Australian Local Government Economics. Sydney: UNSW Press.

12.

Dollery

, Byrnes

and Allan

(2007) “Optimal Structural Reform in Australian Local Government: An Empirical Analysis of Economies of Scale by Council Function in New South Wales”, Urban Policy and Research, 25(4): 473–486.

13.

Dollery

B. E.

, Byrnes

and Crase

(2008) “Australian Local Government Amalgamation: A Conceptual Analysis of Population Size and Scale Economies in Municipal Service Provision”, Australasian Journal of Regional Studies, 14(2):167–175.

14.

Dollery

B. E.

and Fleming

(2006) “A Conceptual Note on Scale Economies, Size Economies and Scope Economies in Australian Local Government”, Urban Policy and Research, 24(2) 271–282.

15.

Dollery

B. E.

and Robotti

(eds.) (2008) The Theory and Practice of Local Government Reform, Edward Elgar: Cheltenham.

16.

Faulk

, Schaal

and Taylor

C.D.

(2013) “How Does Local Government Amalgamation Affect Spending? Evidence from Louisville, Kentucky”, Public Finanace & Management, 13(2):80–98.

17.

Faulk

and Hicks

(2011) Local Government Consolidation in the United States, Cambria Press: Amherst.

18.

Drew

, Grant

and Campbell

(2016) “Progressive and Reactionary Rhetoric in the Municipal Reform Debate in New South Wales Australia”, Australian Journal of Political Science, DOI: 10.1080/10361146.2016.1154926. (22/1/16).

19.

Drew

, Kortt

and Dollery

(2013) “A Cautionary Tale: Council Amalgamation in Tasmania and the Deloitte Access Economics Report”, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 72(1):55–65.

20.

Drew

and Dollery

(2014) “Keeping it in-house: Households versus Population as Alternative Proxies for Local Government Output”, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 73(2):235–246.

21.

Drew

and Dollery

(2014b) “Would Bigger Councils Yield Scale Economies in the Greater Perth Metropolitan Region? A Critique of the Metropolitan Local Government Review for Perth Local Government”, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 73(1):128–137.

22.

Drew

and Dollery

(2015) “Less Haste, More Speed: The Fit for the Future Reform Program in New South Wales Local Government”, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 75(1):1–11.

23.

Drew

, Kortt

and Dollery

(2014) “Economies of Scale and Local Government Expenditure: Evidence from Australia”, Administration & Society, 46(6):632–653.

24.

Drew

, Kortt

and Dollery

(2015) “No Aladdin's Cave in New South Wales? Local Government Amalgamation, Scale Economies and Data Envelopment Analysis Specification”, Administration & Society, doi: 10.1177/0095399715581045:1–21.

25.

Drew

, Kortt

and Dollery

(2015b) “What Determines Efficiency in Local Government? A DEA Analysis of NSW Local Government”, Economic Papers, 34 (4):243–256.

26.

Drew

and Dollery

(2015a) Submission to the General Purpose Standing Committee No. 6 Inquiry into Local Government in New South Wales.

27.

Ernst and Young (2015) Fit for the Future: Review of Business Case Estimates of Merger Net Benefits for Sydney Metropolitan Councils, October 2015.

28.

Faulk

and Grassmueck

(2012) “City-county Consolidation and Local Government Expenditures”, State and Local Government Review, 44(3):196–205.

29.

Ferguson

C. E.

(1969) Neoclassical Theory of Production and Distribution, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

30.

Fogarty

and Mugera

(2013) “Local Government Efficiency: Evidence from Western Australia”, Australian Economic Review, 46(3):300–311.

31.

Hirschman

(1991) The Rhetoric of Reaction: Perversity, Futility, Jeopardy. Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

32.

Holcombe

and Wiliams

(2009) “Are there Economies of Scale in Municipal Government Expenditures?”, Public Finance and Management, 9(3):416–438.

33.

Independent Local Government Review Panel (ILGRP) (2013) Revitalising Local Government: Final Report of the NSW Independent Local Government Review Panel, ILGRP.

34.

ILGRP (2013a) Future Directions of NSW Local Government – Twenty Essential Steps, Independent Local Government Review: Sydney.

35.

Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal (IPART) NSW (2015) Assessment of Council Fit for the Future Proposals Final Report, October 2015.

36.

Jeff Tate Consulting (2013) Assessing Processes and Outcomes of 2004 Local Government Boundary Changes in NSW, Jeff Tate Consulting, McLaren Vale.

37.

Jones

and Walker

(2007) “Explanators of Local Government Distress”, Abacus, 43 (3):396–418.

38.

McDavid

(2002) “The impacts of amalgamation on police services in the Halifax Regional Municipality”, Canadian Public Administration, 45(4):538–565.

39.

Moisio

and Uusitalo

(2013) “The Impact of Municipal Mergers on Local Public Expenditures in Finland”, Public Finance and Management, 13(3):148–166.

40.

NSW Legislative Council General Standing Committee No. 6. (2015) Senate Standing Committee Media Release: Committee finds local government reforms ‘unfit’, 29 October 2015.

41.

Pevcin

(2014) “Local Government Cost Function: Case Study Analysis for Slovenian Municipalities”, Zagreb International Review of Economics & Business, 17(1):79–86.

42.

Sancton

(2000) Merger mania. Quebec: McGill-Queens University Press.

43.

Soul

(2000) “Population Size and Political Performance of Local Government Jurisdictions”, Unpublished PhD thesis, Lismore: Southern Cross University.

44.

State Parliament of NSW [Hansard] (2014b) Legislative Assembly 11 September 2014 [full transcript], accessed 8 October 2015, (https://www.parliament.nsw.gov.au/prod/parlment/hanstrans.nsf/V3ByKeyLA20140911/$File/LA20140911.pdf).

45.

Webber

, Dollery

and Byrnes

(2002) “Measuring Economies of Scale in Australian Local Government: the case of domestic waste collection in NSW”, Australiasian Journal of Regional Studies, 8(2):201–218.

46.

Woodbury

and Dollery

(2004) “Efficiency Measurement in Australian Local Government: The Case of New South Wales Municipal Water Services”, Policy Research, 21 (5):615–636.