This paper surveys possible motivations for having a net wealth tax. After giving a short overview over the state of wealth taxation in OECD countries, we discuss both popular arguments for such a tax, as well as economic arguments. It is argued that classical normative principles of taxation cannot give a sound justification for a net wealth tax. The efficiency-related arguments are also discussed and shown to be theoretically ambiguous, while empirical evidence hints at a negative effect on GDP growth. Finally, it is argued that despite of widespread and persistent lobbying for a revitalization of the net wealth tax, this is unlikely to happen due to political economy constraints.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AaronH.J. and MunnellA.H. (1992) “Reassessing the Role for Wealth Transfer Taxes”, National Tax Journal, 45(2)119–143.
2.
AlbanesiS. and SleetC. (2006) “Dynamic Optimal Taxation with Private Information”, Review of Economic Studies, 73(1)1–30.
3.
AltJ.PrestonI. and SibietaL. (2010) “The Political Economy of Tax Policy”, in: J. Mirrlees et al. (eds) Dimensions of Tax Design: The Mirrlees Review, pp. 1204–1279, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
ArrowK.J. (1951) Social Choice and Individual Values, New York: Wiley.
5.
AtkinsonA.B.PikettyT. and SaezE. (2011) “Top Incomes in the Long Run of History”, Journal of Economic Literature, 49(1)3–71.
6.
BachS.BeznoskaM. and SteinerV. (2011) A Wealth Tax on the Rich to Bring Down Public Debt? Revenue and Distributional Effects of a Capital Levy, DIW Discussion Paper 1137, Berlin, DIW.
7.
BantingK.G. (1991) “The Politics of Wealth Taxes”, Canadian Public Policy/Analyse de Politiques, 17(3)351–367.
8.
BartelsL.M. (2008) Unequal Democracy. The Political Economy of the New Gilded Age, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
9.
BenhabibJ.BisinA. and ZhuS. (2011) “The Distribution of Wealth and Fiscal Policy in Economies with Finitely Lived Agents”, Econometrica, 79(1)123–257.
10.
BernheimB.D. (1987) “Does the Estate Tax Raise Revenue?”, in: SummersL.H. (ed.) Tax Policy and the Economy Vol. 1, pp. 113–138, Cambridge (MA): NBER.
11.
BinmoreK. and ShakedA. (2010) “Experimental Economics: Where Next?”, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 73(1)87–100.
12.
BoadwayR.ChamberlainE. and EmmersonC. (2010) “Taxation of Wealth and Wealth Transfers”, in: J. Mirrlees et al. (eds) Dimensions of Tax Design: The Mirrlees Review, pp. 738–814, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
13.
BrosnanS. and F. de Waal (2003) “Monkeys Reject Unequal Pay”, Nature, 425(6955)297–299.
14.
BuchananJ.M. (1975) The Limits of Liberty. Between Anarchy and Leviathan, Chicago: Chicago University Press.
15.
BurbridgeJ. (1991) “The Allocative and Efficiency Effects of Wealth Taxes”, Canadian Public Policy/Analyse de Politiques, 17(3)264–278.
16.
CagettiM. and M. De Nardi (2009) “Estate Taxation, Entrepreneurship and Wealth”, American Economic Review, 99(1)85–111.
17.
CarlssonF.DaruvalaD. and Johansson-StenmanO. (2005) “Are People Inequality-Averse, or Just Risk-Averse?”, Economica, 72(287)375–396.
18.
CarrollC.D. (2000) “Why Do the Rich Save So Much?”, in: SlemrodJ.B. (ed) Does Atlas Shrug? The Economic Consequences of Taxing the Rich, Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.
19.
CorneoG. and GrünerH.-P. (2000) “Social Limits to Redistribution”, American Economic Review, 90(5)1491–1507.
20.
CremerH. and PestieauP. (2010) Wealth and Wealth Transfer Taxation: A Survey, Andrew Young School of Policy Studies International Studies Program WP 10–17, Atlanta (GA): Georgia State University.
21.
DellF.PikettyT. and SaezE. (2005) Income and Wealth Concentration in Switzerland Over the 20th Century, CEPR Working Paper 5090, London: CEPR.
22.
DevereuxM.P. (2007) Developments in the Taxation of Corporate Profit in the OECD since 1965. Rates, Bases and Revenues, Oxford University Centre for Business Taxation Working Paper 0704, Oxford: University of Oxford.
23.
DiamondP.A. and MirrleesJ. (1971) “Optimal Taxation and Public Production I: Production Efficiency”, American Economic Review, 61(1)8–27.
24.
DixitA.K. and LondreganJ. (1996) “The Determinants of Success of Special Interests in Redistributive Politics”, Journal of Politics, 58(4)1132–1155.
25.
DuggerW.M. (1990) “The Wealth Tax: A Policy Proposal”, Journal of Economic Issues, 24(1)133–144.
26.
EdwardsJ. and KeenM. (1996) “Tax Competition and Leviathan”, European Economic Review, 40(1)113–134.
27.
EggertW. and HauflerA. (1999) “Capital Taxation and Production Efficiency in an Open Economy”, Economics Letters, 62(1)85–90.
28.
FeldL.P. and SchnellenbachJ. (2012) Formal Political Institutions and the Political Economy of Income Redistribution, mimeo., Freiburg: Walter Eucken Insitute.
29.
FiaschiD. and MarsiliM. (2012) “Distribution of Wealth and Incomplete Markets: Theory and Empirical Evidence”, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 81(1)243–267.
30.
FreyB.S. (2008) Happiness. A Revolution in Economics, Cambridge (MA): MIT Press.
31.
GiovanniniA. (1989) “National Tax Systems versus the European Capital Market”, Economic Policy, 4(9)346–386.
32.
GlennersterH. (2012) “Why Was a Wealth Tax for the UK Abandoned? Les-sons for the Policy Process and Tackling Wealth Inequality”, Journal of Social Policy, 41(2)233–249.
33.
GraetzM.J. and ShapiroI. (2005) Death by a Thousand Cuts: The Fight Over Taxing Inherited Wealth, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
34.
HallerH. (1981) Die Steuern. Grundlinien eines rationalen Systems öffentlicher Abgaben, third edition, Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.
35.
HansenN.A. and KesslerA.S. (2001) “The Political Geography of Tax H(e)avens and Tax Hells”, American Economic Review, 91(4)1103–1115.
36.
HanssonA. (2008) “The Wealth Tax and Entrepreneurial Activity”, Journal of Entrepreneurship, 17(2)139–156.
37.
HanssonA. (2010) “Is the Wealth Tax Harmful for Economic Growth?”, World Tax Journal, 2(1)19–34.
38.
HarmsP. and ZinkS. (2003) “Limits to Redistribution in a Democracy: A Survey”, European Journal of Political Economy, 19(4)651–668.
39.
HarmsP. and ZinkS. (2005) “Growing Into and Out of Social Conflict”, Economica, 72(286)267–286.
40.
HomburgS. (1999) “Competition and Co-ordination in International Capital Income Taxation”, Finanzarchiv, N.F. 56(1)1–17.
41.
IhoriT. (2001) “Wealth Taxation and Economic Growth”, Journal of Public Economics, 79(1)129–148.
42.
KeenM. and PiekkolaH. (1997) “Simple Rules for the Optimal Taxation of International Capital Income”, Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 99(3)447–461.
43.
KirchhofP. (2012) Deutschland im Schuldensog. Der Weg vom Bürgen zurück zum Bürger, München: C.H.Beck.
44.
KlevmarkenN.A. (2006) “On Household Wealth Trends in Sweden over the 1990s”, in: E.N. Wolff (ed) International Perspectives on Household Wealth, pp. 276–294, Cheltenham: Elgar.
45.
KocherlakotaN.R. (2005) “Zero Expected Wealth Taxes: A Mirrlees Approach to Dynamic Optimal Taxation”, Econometrica, 73(5)1587–1621.
46.
LayardR. (2005) Happiness: Lessons from a New Science, London: Penguin.
47.
LehnerM. et al. (2000) “The European Experience with a Wealth Tax: A Comparative Discussion”, Tax Law Review, 53(423)613–690.
48.
LindahlE.R. (1919) Die Gerechtigkeit der Besteuerung. Eine Analyse der Grenznutzenprincippen auf der Grundlage der Grenznutzentheorie, Lund: Ohlssons.
49.
MeadeJ.E. (1978) The Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation: Report of a Committee Chaired by Professor J.E. Meade for the Institute for Fiscal Studies, London: George Allen & Unwin.
50.
MillJ.S. (1863) Utilitarianism, Reprint, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998.
51.
MillJ.S. (1868) Principles of Political Economy, London: Hackett.
52.
MirrleesJ. et al. (2011) Tax by Design: The Mirrlees Review, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
OlsonM. (1965) The Logic of Collective Action. Public Goods and the Theory of Groups, Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.
55.
PerssonT. and TabelliniG. (2000) Political Economics. Explaining Economic Policy, Cambridge (MA): MIT Press.
56.
PikettyT. (2003) “Income Inequality in France, 1901–1998”, Journal of Political Economy, 111(5)1004–1042.
57.
PikettyT. and SaezE. (2003) “Income Inequality in the United States, 1913–1998”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(1)1–39.
58.
PirttiliäJ. and UusitaloR. (2010) “A ‘Leaky Bucket’ in the Real World: Estimating Inequality Aversion Using Survey Data”, Economica, 77(305)60–76.
59.
RazinA. and SadkaE. (1991) “International Tax Competiton and Gains from Tax Harmonization”, Economics Letters, 37(1)69–76.
60.
RudnickR.S. and GordonR.K. (1996) “Taxation of Wealth”, in: ThuronyiV. (ed) Tax Law Design and Drafting, Volume 1, Washington (DC): IMF. Accessed November 17, 2012. (www.imf.org/external/pubs/nft/1998/tlaw/eng/ch10. pdf)
61.
SaezE.SlemrodJ. and GiertzS.H. (2012) “The Elasticity of Taxable Income with Respect to Marginal Tax Rates: A Critical Review”, Journal of Economic Literature, 50(1)3–50.
62.
SandfordC.T. (1971) Taxing Personal Wealth, London: George Allen & Unwin.
63.
SandfordC.T.WillisJ.R.M. and IronsideD.J. (1975) An Annual Wealth Tax, London: Heinemann Educational.
64.
SchalteggerC.A.SomogyiF. and SturmJ.-E. (2011) “Tax Competition and Income Sorting: Evidence from the Zurich Metropolitan Area”, European Journal of Political Economy, 27(3)455–470.
65.
SchmidheinyK. (2006) “Income Segregation and Local Progressive Taxation: Empirical Evidence from Switzerland”, Journal of Public Economics, 90(3)429–458.
SmithA. (1784) The Wealth of Nations, London: W. Strahan.
68.
SørensenP.B. (2007) “Can Capital Income Taxes Survive? And Should They?”, CESifo Economic Studies53(2)172–228.
69.
StiglerG.J. (1970) “Director's Law of Public Income Redistribution”, Journal of Law and Economics, 13(1)1–10.
70.
StiglitzJ.E. (1969) “The Effects of Income, Wealth and Capital Gains Taxation on Risk-Taking”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 83(2)263–283.
71.
SurethC. and MaiterthR. (2005) Wealth Tax as Alternative Minimum Tax? The Impact of a Wealth Tax on Business Structure and Strategy. Arqus Quantitative Tax Research Discussion Paper 3, Paderborn: University of Paderborn.
72.
TaitA.A. (1967) The Taxation of Personal Wealth, Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
73.
VanbergV.J. (2005) “Market and State: The Perspective of Constitutional Political Economy”, Journal of Institutional Economics, 1(1)23–49.
74.
WicksellK. (1896) Finanztheoretische Untersuchungen nebst Darstellung und Kritik des Steuerwesens Schwedens, Jena: Gustav Fischer.
75.
WildasinD.E. (2000) “Factor Mobility and Fiscal Policy in the EU: Policy Issues and Analytical Approaches”, Economic Policy, 15(31)337–378.
76.
WildasinD.E. and WilsonJ.D. (2004) “Tax Competition: Bane or Boon?”, Journal of Public Economics, 88(6)1065–1091.
77.
WilsonJ.D. (2003) “The Property Tax: Competing Views and a Hybrid Theo-ry”, in: CnossenS. and H.-W. Sinn (eds) Public Finance and Public Policy in the New Century, pp. 217–236, Cambridge (MA): MIT Press.
78.
YunkerJ.A. (2010) “Capital Wealth Taxation as a Potential Remedy for Excessive Capital Wealth Inequality”, Journal of Post-Keynesian Economics, 33(1)83–104.
