A Structural Analysis of Italy's Fiscal Policies after Joining the European Monetary Union: Are We Learning from Our Past?

Abstract

Italy's public finances improved dramatically in the period 1992–97, helping to secure participation in the European Monetary Union from the outset. There was considerable fiscal loosening in the years that followed, and the primary balance declined steadily from almost 7 per cent of GDP in 1997 to virtually zero in 2006. the paper examines the development of public finances from 1998 to 2006. the “structural” developments in the main budgetary components are assessed, excluding the effects of the economic cycle and of temporary measures. the analysis shows a rapid deterioration up to 2003, whose roots can be traced back to the consolidation of the early 1990s, achieved primarily by means of tax increases and cuts in capital expenditure. Since 2004 there has been a structural improvement, initially modest but substantial in 2006 Sustaining this adjustment and making further progress may again prove difficult, as the fiscal correction is similar in nature to the previous consolidation effort.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alesina

and Ardagna

(1998), “Tales of Fiscal Adjustment”, in Economic Policy, Vol. 13, No. 27, pp. 487–545.

Alesina

and Perotti

(1995), “Fiscal Expansions and Fiscal Adjustments in OECD Countries”, NBER Working Paper, No. 5214.

Alesina

and Perotti

(1996), “Fiscal Adjustment in the OECD Countries: Composition and Macroeconomic Effects”, NBER Working Paper, No. 5730.

Alm

and Beck

(1991), “Wiping the Slate Clean: Individual Response to State Tax Amnesties”, in Southern Economic Journal, pp. 1043–53.

Alm

and Beck

(1993), “Tax Amnesties and Compliance in the Long Run: A Time Series Analysis”, in National Tax Journal, Vol. 46, No. 1, March, pp. 53–60.

Andreoni

(1991), “The Desirability of a Permanent Tax Amnesty”, in Journal of Public Economics, pp. 143–59.

Balassone

and Zotteri

(2001), “Il patto di stabilita intemo due anni dopo: norme piu ‘morbide’, risultati piu deludenti”, in Economia Pubblica, No. 6.

Balassone

Franco

Momigliano

and Monacelli

(2002), “Italy: Fiscal Consolidation and Its Legacy”, in Banca d'Italia, The Impact of Fiscal Policy, papers presented at the Workshop organized by the Banca d'Italia in Perugia, 21–23 March.

Balassone

Franco

and Zotteri

(2004), “La finanza decentrata nell'ambito dell'Unione economica e monetaria: quali regole?”, in Stato e mercato, Il Mulino, January.

10.

Balassone

Franco

and Zotteri

(2007), “The Reliability of EMU Fiscal Indicators: Risks and Safeguards”, Banca d'Italia, Temi di discussione, No. 633, June.

11.

Banca d'Italia (1998a), “The Recent Reform of the Tax System”, in Economic Bulletin, No. 26, February.

12.

Banca d'Italia (1998b), “The Public Finances”, in Annual Report.

13.

Banca d'Italia (1999), Indicators of Structural Budget Balances, papers presented at the Workshop organized by the Banca d'Italia in Perugia, 26–28 November.

14.

Banca d'Italia (2001), “The Public Finances”, in Annual Report.

15.

Banca d'Italia (2005), “Recent Revisions of the General Government Accounts for 2001–03“, in Economic Bulletin, No. 40, March.

16.

Banca d'Italia (2007), “The Public Finances”, in Annual Report.

17.

Bernasconi

and Marenzi

(1998), “Il deficit pubblico al 3%. Linee interpretative del processo di risanamento”, in Bernardi

(ed.), La finanza pubblica italiana, Rapporto, Il Mulino.

18.

Bernasconi

and Lapecorella

(2006), “I condoni nel sistema tributario italiano”, in Guerra

M.C.

and Zanardi

(eds.), La finanza pubblica italiana: Rapporto 2006, Il Mulino.

19.

Bosi

Golinelli

and Stagni

(1990), “Le origini del debito pubblico e il costo della stabilizzazione”, in Bosi

Golinelli

and Stagni

(eds.), “Un modello a medio termine dell'economia italiana: Hermes-Italia”, Bologna, Il Mulino.

20.

Bouthevillain

Cour-Thimann

G. van den Dool, P.H. De Cos, Langenus

, Mohr

, S. Momigliano and M. Tujula (2001), “Cyclically-adjusted Budget Balance: An Alternative Approach”, ECB Working Paper, No. 77.

21.

Braz

C.R

. (2006), “The Calculation of Cyclically-adjusted Balances at Banco de Portugal: An Update”, in Banco de Portugal, Economic Bulletin, Vol. 12, No. 4.

22.

Brown

E.C

. (1956), “Fiscal Policy in the Thirties: A Reappraisal”, in American Economic Review, Vol. XLVI, No. 5, December.

23.

Buti

J. Noguera Martins and Turrini

(2006), “From Deficit to Debt and Back: Political Incentives Under Numerical Fiscal Rules”, in Banca d'Italia, Fiscal Indicators, papers presented at the Workshop organized by the Banca d'Italia in Perugia on 30 March-1 April.

24.

Cassone

and Marchese

(1995), “Tax Amnesties as Special Sales Offers: the Italian Experience”, in Public Finance, Vol. 50, No. 1, pp. 51–66.

25.

Chu

C.Y.C

. (1990), “Plea Bargaining with the IRS”, in Journal of Public Economics, No. 41.

26.

Corriere della sera (1998), “Italia nella moneta unica con sei impegni”, 22 March.

27.

Cotis

J.P.

Elmeskov

and Mourougane

(2003), “Estimates of Potential Output: Benefits and Pitfalls from a Policy Perspective”, OECD Economics Department, paper presented at the CEPR conference Dating the Euro Area Business Cycle, 21 January.

28.

Crane

S.E.

and Nourzad

(1992), “Analyzing Income Tax Evasion Using Amnesty Data with Self Selection Correction: the Case of the Michigan Tax Amnesty Program”, in Slemrod

(ed.), Why People Pay Taxes: Tax Compliance and Enforcement, University of Michigan Press, pp. 167–89.

29.

Crescenzi

(2007), “I Documenti di Programmazione: Una lettura della politica economica in Italia dal Piano Marshall al DPEF 2008–2011“, Luiss University Press, Roma.

30.

Das-Gupta

and Mookherjee

(1996), “Tax Amnesties as Asset Laundering Devices”, in Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, No. 12, pp. 407–09.

31.

Das-Gupta

and Mookherjee

(1998), Incentives and Institutional Reform in Tax Enforcement, Oxford University Press.

32.

Degni

Emiliani

Gastaldi

Salvemini

and Virno

(2001), “Il riequilibrio della finanza pubblica negli anni Novanta”, Studi e Note di Economia, Quaderni, No. 7.

33.

Denis

K. Mc Morrow and Roger

(2002), “Production Function Approach to Calculating Potential Growth and Output Gaps – Estimates for the EU Member States and the US”, European Commission, DG ECFIN Economic Paper, No. 176.

34.

Dubin

J.A.

Graetz

and Wilde

(1992), “State Income Tax Amnesties: Causes”, in Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 107, No. 3, pp. 1057–70, August.

35.

European Commission (2001), Public Finances in EMU.

36.

European Commission (2002), Autumn Forecasts.

37.

European Commission (2006), Autumn Forecasts.

38.

European Commission (2007a), Public finances in EMU.

39.

European Commission (2007b), Autumn forecasts.

40.

Fiorentini

and Marchese

(eds.) (1997), Il fisco indulgente: amnistie e concordati nei moderni sistemi fiscali, Torino, Giappichelli.

41.

Forni

and Momigliano

(2004), “Cyclical Sensitivity of Fiscal Policies Based on Real-time Data”, in Applied Economics Quarterly, Vol. 50, No. 3, pp. 299–326.

42.

Franco

(2002), “Italy: A Never-ending Pension Reform”, in Feldstein

and Siebert

(eds.), Coping with the Pension Crisis – Where Does Europe Stand?, Chicago, Chicago University Press.

43.

Franco

(2005), “Il consolidamento interrotto”, in La finanza pubblica italiana – Rapporto 2005, Il Mulino.

44.

Franco

and Rizza

(2008), “Ensuring a Sustainable Fiscal Consolidation”, in Italy in EMU: the Challenges of Adjustment and Growth, Palgrave, forthcoming.

45.

Franzoni

L.A

. (1994), “Costly Prosecution, Tax Evasion and Amnesties”, in Economic Notes, Vol. 23, No. 2, pp. 248–65.

46.

Franzoni

L.A

. (1996), “Punishment and Grace: on the Economics of Tax Amnesties”, in Public Finance, Vol. 51, No. 3, pp. 353–68.

47.

Giorno

Richardson

Roseveare

and P. van den Noord (1995), “Estimating Potential Output, Output Gaps and Structural Budget Balances”, OECD Economics Department Working Paper, No. 152.

48.

Girouard

and André

(2005), “Measuring Cyclically-adjusted Budget Balances for OECD Countries”, OECD Economics Department Working Paper, No. 434.

49.

Graetz

and Wilde

(1993), “The Decision by Strategic Non-filers to Participate in Income Tax Amnesties”, in International Review of Law and Economics, Vol. 13, No. 3, pp. 271–83.

50.

Hagemann

(1999), “The Structural Budget Balance: the IMF's Methodology”, in Banca d'Italia, Indicators of structural budget balances, papers presented to the Workshop organized by the Banca d'Italia in Perugia on 26–28 November 1998, Rome, pp. 53–70.

51.

Hodrick

RJ.

and Prescott

E.C.

(1997), “Postwar US Business Cycle: An Empirical Investigation”, in Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 29, No. 1, pp. 1–16.

52.

IMF (2002), World Economic Outlook.

53.

IMF (2006), World Economic Outlook.

54.

IMF (2007), World Economic Outlook.

55.

ISTAT (2006), “Conti ed aggregati economici delle Amministrazioni pubbliche – Serie SEC95 – anni 1980–2005“.

56.

Kaplow

and Shavell

(1994), “Optimal Law Enforcement with Self-Reporting of Behaviour”, in Journal of Political Economy, No. 102, pp. 583–606.

57.

Koen

and P. van den Noord (2005), “Fiscal Gimmickry in Europe: One-off Measures and Creative Accounting”, OECD Economics Department Working Paper, No. 417.

58.

Kopitz

and Symansky

(1998), “Fiscal Policy Rules”, IMF Occasional Paper, No.162.

59.

Kremer

and Wendorff

(2004), “Germany After the Qualification for EMU: A Disaggregated Approach to the Analysis of Structural Public Finance Developments”, in Vierteljahreshefte zur Wirtschaftsforschung, Vol. 73, No. 3, pp. 358–70.

60.

Kremer

Braz

C.R.

Brosens

Langenus

Momigliano

and Spolander

(2006a), “A Disaggregated Framework for the Analysis of Structural Developments in Public Finances”, ECB Working Paper, No. 579.

61.

Kremer

Braz

C.R.

Brosens

Langenus

Momigliano

and Spolander

(2006b), “A Disaggregated Framework for the Analysis of Structural Developments in Public Finances”, in Banca d'Italia (2007), Fiscal Indicators, papers presented to the Workshop organized by the Banca d'Italia in Perugia on 30 March-1 April.

62.

Le Borgne

(2006), “Economic and Political Determinants of Tax Amnesties in the U.S. States”, IMF Working Paper Series, No. 222, September.

63.

Locarno

and Staderini

(2007), “Le entrate tributarie: sviluppi recenti e dinamiche di medio periodo”, Banca d'Italia, Temi di discussione, forthcoming.

64.

Malik

A.S.

and Schwab

R.M.

(1991), “The Economics of Tax Amnesties”, in Journal of Public Economics, No. 46, pp. 29–49.

65.

Marchese

(1997), “Le conseguenze dei condoni: un'analisi empirica”, in Fiorentini

and Marchese

(eds.), “Il fisco indulgente: amnistie e concordati nei moderni sistemi fiscali”, Torino, Giappichelli.

66.

Marino

M.R.

Messina

and Staderini

(2007), “Gli effetti redistributivi della riforma dell'imposta sul reddito degli anni 2003–2005”, in Rovati

(ed.), Povertà e lavoro – Giovani generazioni a rischio, Carocci Editore, Roma.

67.

Marino

M.R.

Momigliano

and Rizza

(2008), “A Structural Analysis of Italy's Fiscal Policies after Joining the European Monetary Union”, Banca d'Italia, Occasional Paper, forthcoming.

68.

Martins

J.O.

de la Maisonneuve

and Bjørnerud

(2006), “Projections of OECD Health and Long-term Care Public Expenditures”, in Banca d'Italia, Fiscal Indicators, papers presented at the Workshop organized by the Banca d'Italia in Perugia on 30 March-1 April.

69.

Mikesell

J.L

. (1986), “Amnesties for State Tax Evaders: the Nature of and Response to Recent Programs”, in National Tax Journal, Vol. 39, No. 4, pp. 507–25, December.

70.

Ministero dell'economia e delle finanze (2007), “Libro verde sulla spesa pubblica – Spendere meglio: alcune prime indicazioni”, www.tesoro.it.

71.

Mitchell

(2005), “Should We Be Surprised by the Unreliability of Real-time Output Gap Estimates? Density Estimates for the Euro Area”, National Institute of Economic and Social Research.

72.

Mc Dermott

and Westcott

(1996), “An Empirical Analysis of Fiscal Adjustments”, IMF Staff Paper, Vol. 43, No. 4, pp. 725–53.

73.

Momigliano

and Staderini

(1999), “A New Method of Assessing the Structural Budget Balance: Results for the Years 1995–2000”, in Banca d'Italia, Indicators of Structural Budget Balances, papers presented to the Workshop organized by the Banca d'Italia in Perugia on 26–28 November 1998, Rome, pp. 119–58.

74.

Momigliano

and Rizza

(2007), “Temporary Measures in Italy: Buying or Losing Time?”, in Temporary Measures and Off-budget Activities, Magyar Nemzeti Bank.

75.

National Bank of Belgium (2006), Annual Report, Chapter 6.

76.

OECD (2002), Economic Outlook.

77.

OECD (2006), Economic Outlook.

78.

Orphanides

and S. van Norden (1999), “The Reliability of Output Gap Estimates in Real Time”, in Board of Governor of the Federal Reserve System, Finance and Economics Discussion Series, No. 38.

79.

Orphanides

and S. van Norden (2002), “The Unreliability of Output Gap Estimates in Real time”, in Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 84, pp. 569–83.

80.

Prammer

(2004), “Expansionary Fiscal Consolidations? An Appraisal of the Literature on Non-Keynesian Effects of Fiscal Policy and a Case Study for Austria”, in Monetary Policy & the Economy, No. 3, pp. 35–52.

81.

Richardson

Boone

Giorno

Meacci

Rae

and Turner

(2000), “The Concept, Policy use and Measurement of Structural Unemployment: Estimating a Time-varying NAIRU Across 21 OECD Countries”, OECD Economics Department Working Paper, No. 250.

82.

Sartor

(ed.) (1998), Il risanamento mancato. La politica di bilancio nella seconda metà degli anni Ottanta, Carocci Editore, Roma.

83.

Spaventa

and Chiorazzo

(2000), Astuzia o virtù? Come accadde che l'Italia fu ammessa all'Unione Monetaria, Donzelli Editore.

84.

Staderini

(2001), “Tax Reforms to Influence Corporate Financial Policy: the Case of the Italian Business Tax Reform of 1997–98“, Banca d'Italia, Temi di discussione, No. 423.

85.

Stella

(1989), “Do Tax Amnesties Work?”, in Finance and Development, Vol. 26, No. 4, pp. 38–40.

86.

Stella

(1991), “An Economic Analysis of Tax Amnesties”, in Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 46, pp. 383–400.

87.

Uchitelle

(1989), “The Effectiveness of Tax Amnesty Programs in Selected Countries”, in Federal Reserve Bank of New York Quarterly Review, Vol. 14, No. 3, pp. 48–53, Autumn.