Some desiderata for a taxonomy of conscientious objection in health care: A reply to Gamble and Saad

Abstract

In a recent issue of this journal, Gamble and Saad offer a taxonomy of conscientious objection in health care with the aim of increasing the common ground in the debate over conscientious objection to prevent parties from talking past each other and help facilitate greater progress on this issue. Although we agree that this is an important and worthwhile project, Gamble and Saad's proposal suffers from several serious weaknesses that limit its ability to do the work set out for it. In this paper, we identify some of the major problems with this particular attempt in order to highlight some desiderata for a taxonomy of conscientious objection in health care that can serve as a guide for developing improved taxonomies of this kind in the future.

Keywords

Conscience conscientious objection bioethics and medical ethics clinical ethics codes of ethics professional ethics in medicine

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Cantor

. Conscientious objection gone awry–restoring selfless professionalism in medicine. N Engl J Med 2009; 360: 1484–1485.

Schuklenk

. Conscientious objection in medicine–private ideological convictions must not supersede public service obligations. Bioethics 2015; 29: ii–iii.

Giubilini

. Objections to conscience: an argument against conscience exemptions in healthcare. Bioethics 2017; 31: 400–408.

Stahl

Emanuel

. Physicians, not conscripts–conscientious objection in health care. N Engl J Med 2017; 376: 1380–1385.

Liao

Goligher

. Conscientious objection in health care. N Engl J Med 2017; 377: 96–98.

Gamble

Saad

. A taxonomy of conscientious objection in healthcare. Clin Ethics 2022; 17: 63–70.

Wicclair

. Conscientious Objection in Health Care: An Ethical Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011.

Neal

. Conscientious objection, ‘proper medical treatment’, and professionalism: the limits of accommodation for conscience in healthcare. In: Adenitire

(ed.) Religious Beliefs and Conscientious Exemptions in a Liberal State. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2019, pp.135–156.

Fovargue

Neal

. ‘In good conscience’: conscience-based exemptions and proper medical treatment. Med Law Rev 2015; 23: 221–241.

10.

Strickland

. Conscientious objection in medical students: a questionnaire survey. J Med Ethics 2012; 38: 22–25.