This study analyses new data on the service demands of gender and age subpopulations
of occasional and frequent offenders shared by health, social care and criminal
justice agencies in the UK. Using a case-linkage methodology borrowed from health
studies, we tracked the population of offenders across multiple agencies within a
Health Authority jurisdiction in an English county over a three-year period. We show
that offenders and frequent offenders demanded services in larger proportions than
non-offenders and occasional offenders, particularly drug and alcohol services. We
find that overrepresentations of males and youngsters among offenders were more
marked among frequent offenders. Using categorical principal component analyses, we
identify three typologies of frequent offenders making heavy demands on public
services, and detect key discrepancies between their problems and levels of service
provision. Our findings indicate the need to devise inter-agency strategies for the
treatment and care of different groups of offenders, while providing useful data on
their characteristics so as to make these strategies more effective.
Agresti, A.
(1990). Categorical data analysis.
New York: John Wiley
.
2.
Arseneault, L.
,
Moffitt, T. E.
,
Caspi, A.
,
Taylor, P. J.
and
Silva, P. A.
(2000).
Mental disorders and violence in a total birth cohort: Results from the
Dunedin Study
. Archives of General Psychiatry57,
979-986
.
3.
Bhui, H. S.
(2002).
Probation in England and Wales: From rehabilitation to risk
. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry13,
231-239
.
4.
Booth, A.
(2002).
Targeting the health care needs of young offenders
. Nursing Times98,
35-36
.
5.
Brennan, P. A.
,
Mednick, S. A.
and
Hodgins, S.
(2000).
Major mental disorders and criminal violence in Danish birth cohort
. Archives of General Psychiatry57,
494-500
.
6.
Bridges, G. S.
and
Steen, S.
(1998).
Racial disparities in official assessments of juvenile offenders:
Attitudinal stereotypes as mediating mechanisms
. American Sociological Review63,
554-570
.
7.
Callaghan, J.
,
Pace, F.
,
Young, B.
and
Vostanis, P.
(2003).
Primary mental health workers within youth offending teams: A new service model
. Journal of Adolescence26,
185-199
.
8.
Cann, J.
,
Falshaw, L.
and
Friendship, C.
(2004).
Sexual offenders discharged from prison in England and Wales: A 21-year
reconviction study
. Legal and Criminological Psychology9,
1-10
.
9.
Codd, H.
and
Bramhall, G.
(2002).
Older offenders and probation: A challenge for the future
? Probation Journal49,
27-34
.
10.
Coffey, C.
,
Veit, F.
,
Wolfe, R.
,
Cini, E.
and
Patton, G. C.
(2003).
Mortality in young offenders: Retrospective cohort study
. British Medical Journal327,
1381
.
11.
Crichton, J.
(1999).
Mental disorder and crime: Coincidence, correlation and cause
. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry10,
659-678
.
12.
Department of Health
(1998). Modernising social services.
London: Stationery Office
.
13.
Department of Health
(2000). The new NHS.
London: Stationery Office
.
14.
Department of Health
(2001). Changing the outlook: A strategy for developing and
modernising mental health services in prisons.
London: Department of Health
.
15.
Department of Health
(2004). Draft mental health bill.
London: Department of Health
. Cm. 6305-1.
16.
Dolan, M.
,
Holloway, J.
,
Bailey, S.
and
Smith, C.
(1999).
Health status of juvenile offenders. A survey of young offenders appearing
before the juvenile courts
. Journal of Adolescence22,
137-144
.
17.
Ezell, M. E.
and
Cohen, L. E.
(2004). Desisting from crime: Continuity and change in
long-term crime patterns of serious chronic offenders.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
18.
Fazel, S.
and
Grann, M.
(2004).
Psychiatric morbidity among homicide offenders: A Swedish population study
. American Journal of Psychiatry161,
2129-2131
.
19.
Fiske, S. T.
and
Neuberg, S. L.
(1990). A continuum of impression formation from
category-based to individuating processes: Influences of information and
motivation on attention and interpretation. In
M. P. Zanna
(ed.) Advances in experimental social psychology, vol. 23,
1-74.
San Diego, CA: Academic Press
.
20.
Fox, A.
(2002).
Aftercare for drug-using prisoners: Lessons from an international study
. Probation Journal49,
120-129
.
21.
Friendship, C.
,
Browne, K. D.
and
Beech, A. R.
(2002).
Reconviction as an outcome measure in research. A methodological note
. British Journal of Criminology42,
442-444
.
22.
Grubin, D.
(2001).
Treatment for mentally disordered offenders. Editorial
, Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health11 (Special Book Review Supplement),
109-123
.
23.
Hagell, A.
and
Dowling, S. D.
(1999). Scoping review of literature on the health and care
of mentally disordered offenders. Centre for Reviews and Dissemination,
Report 16.
London: Policy Research Bureau
.
24.
Hamilton, D. L.
,
Sherman, S. J.
and
Ruvolo, C. M.
(1990).
Stereotype-based expectancies: Effects on information processing and social behavior
. Journal of Social Issues46,
35-60
.
25.
Heidensohn, F.
(2002). Gender and crime. In
M. Maguire
,
R. Morgan
and
R. Reiner
(eds) The Oxford handbook of criminology.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
26.
Heyman, B.
,
Griffiths, C. B.
and
Taylor, J.
(2002).
Health risk escalators and the rehabilitation of offenders with learning disabilities
. Social Science and Medicine54,
1429-1440
.
27.
Hodgins, S.
(1992).
Mental disorder, intellectual deficiency and crime: Evidence from a birth cohort
. Archives of General Psychiatry49,
476-483
.
28.
Howard, J.
,
Lennings, C. J.
and
Copeland, J.
(2003).
Suicidal behaviour in a young offender population
. Crisis24,
98-104
.
29.
Kalunta-Crumpton, A.
(1998).
The prosecution and defence of black defendants in drug trials. Evidence of claims-making
. British Journal of Criminology38,
561-591
.
Keene, J.
and
Bailey, S. E.
(2000).
Shared clients: Substance misuse agency clients in generic agencies
. Addiction Research8,
279-298
.
32.
Keene, J.
and
Rodriguez, J.
(2005).
Mentally disordered offenders: A case linkage study of criminal justice and
mental health populations in the UK
. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology16,
167-191
.
33.
Keene, J.
,
Bailey, S. E.
,
Swift, L.
and
Janacek, G.
(2000).
The tracking project: A collaborative multi-agency database to inform
inter-professional policy with shared clients/patients
. Journal of Interprofessional Care14,
325-336
.
34.
Keene, J.
,
Swift, L.
,
Bailey, S.
and
Janacek, G.
(2001).
Shared patients: Multiple social and health care contact
. Health and Social Care9,
205-214
.
35.
Lemieux, C. M.
,
Dyeson, T. B.
and
Castiglione, B.
(2002).
Revisiting the literature on prisoners who are older: Are we wiser
? Prison Journal82,
440-458
.
36.
Maguire, M.
(2002). Crime statistics: The ‘data
explosion’ and its implications. In
M. Maguire
,
R. Morgan
and
R. Reiner
(eds) The Oxford handbook of criminology.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
37.
Mair, G.
and
May, C.
(1997). Offenders on probation. Home Office Research
Studies 167.
London: Home Office
.
38.
Marquart, J. W.
,
Brewer, V. E.
,
Mullings, J. L.
and
Crouch, B. M.
(1999).
Health risk as an emerging field within the new penology
. Journal of Criminal Justice27,
143-154
.
39.
Mokros, A.
and
Alison, L. J.
(2002).
Is offender profiling possible? Testing the predicted homology of crime
scene actions and background characteristics in a sample of rapists
. Legal and Criminological Psychology7,
25-43
.
40.
Mullen, P. E.
,
Burgess, P.
,
Wallace, C.
,
Palmer, S.
and
Ruschena, D.
(2000).
Community care and criminal offending in schizophrenia
. The Lancet355,
1827-1828
.
41.
Newburn, T.
(2002). Young people, crime, and youth justice.
In
M. Maguire
,
R. Morgan
and
R. Reiner
(eds) The Oxford handbook of criminology.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
42.
Office for National Statistics
(1998). Living in Britain: Results from the 1996 general
household survey.
London: The Stationery Office
.
43.
Pearson, T.
(2003).
Community criminal justice schemes
. Prison Service Journal147,
8-10
.
44.
Phillips, M. R.
,
Wolf, A. S.
and
Coons, D. J.
(1988).
Psychiatry and the criminal justice system: Testing the myths
. American Journal of Psychiatry145,
605-610
.
45.
Pitts, S.
and
Kettle, M.
(2003).
The Resettlement Pathfinders: A joint prison/probation project
. Prison Service Journal145,
34-37
.
46.
Polcin, D. L.
and
Greenfield, T. K.
(2003).
Factors associated with probation officers’ use of criminal
justice coercion to mandate alcohol treatment
. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse29,
647-670
.
47.
Retz, W.
,
Retz-Junginger, P.
,
Hengesch, G.
,
Schneider, M.
,
Thome, J.
,
Pajonk, F. G.
,
Salahi-Disfan, A.
,
Rees, O.
,
Wender, P. H.
and
Rosler, M.
(2004).
Psychometric and psychopathological characterization of young male prison
inmates with and without attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder
. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience254,
201-208
.
48.
Rosler, M.
,
Retz, W.
,
Retz-Junginger, P.
,
Hengesch, G.
,
Schneider, M.
,
Supprian, T.
,
Schwitzgebel, P.
,
Pinhard, K.
,
Dovi-Akue, N.
,
Wender, P.
and
Thome, J.
(2004).
Prevalence of attention deficit-/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and comorbid
disorders in young male prison inmates
. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience254,
365-371
.
49.
Rumgay, J.
(2003).
Drug treatment and offender rehabilitation: Reflections on evidence,
effectiveness and exclusion
. Probation Journal50,
41-51
.
50.
Schanda, H.
,
Knecht, G.
,
Schreinzer, D.
,
Stompe, T.
,
Ortwein-Swoboda, G.
and
Waldhoer, T.
(2004).
Homicide and major mental disorders: A 25-year study
. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica110,
98-107
.
51.
Sestoft, D.
(1996).
Trends in Danish research on crime and mental health (1970-94): A review
. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry50,
161-168
.
52.
Shepherd, J. P.
(2003).
Explaining feast or famine in randomized field trials. Medical science and
criminology compared
. Evaluation Review27,
290-315
.
53.
Singleton, N.
and
Meltzer, H.
(1988).
Mental disorders in our prisons
. Social Trends Quarterly, Winter.
54.
Singleton, N.
,
Meltzer, H.
,
Gatward, R.
,
Coid, J.
and
Deasy, D.
(1988). Psychiatric morbidity among prisoners in England and
Wales.
London: The Stationery Office
.
55.
Solomon, P.
and
Draine, J.
(1999a).
Explaining lifetime criminal arrests among clients of a psychiatric
probation and parole service
. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law27,
239-251
.
56.
Solomon, P.
and
Draine, J.
(1999b).
Using clinical and criminal involvement factors to explain homelessness
among clients of a psychiatric probation and parole service
. Psychiatric Quarterly70,
75-87
.
57.
Thomson, L. D. G.
(1999).
Substance abuse and criminality
. Current Opinion in Psychiatry12,
653-657
.
58.
Tiihonen, J.
,
Isohanni, M.
,
Rasanen, P.
,
Koiranen, M.
and
Moring, J.
(1997).
Specific major mental disorders and criminality: A 26-year prospective
study of the 1966 northern Finland birth cohort
. American Journal of Psychiatry154,
840-845
.
59.
Toch, H.
and
Adams, K.
(1989). The disturbed violent offender.
New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
.
60.
Van der Heijden, P. G. M.
and
De Leeuw, J.
(1989).
Correspondence analysis, with special attention to the analysis of panel
data and event history data
. Sociological Methodology19,
43-87
.
61.
Wallace, C.
,
Mullen, P.
,
Burgess, P.
,
Palmer, S.
,
Ruschena, D.
and
Browne, C.
(1998).
Serious criminal offending and mental disorder. Case linkage study
. British Journal of Psychiatry172,
477-484
.
62.
Walton, D.
(2000).
Driving down prolific offending: Police and probation on board - a
community partnership
. Prison Service Journal131,
25-27
.
63.
Woodward, M.
,
Williams, P.
,
Nursten, J.
and
Badger, D.
(1999).
The epidemiology of mentally disordered offending. A systematic review of
studies based on the general population of criminality combined with
psychiatric illness
. Journal of Epidemiology and Biostatistics4,
101-113
.
64.
Young, A.
,
Monteiro, B.
and
Ridgeway, S.
(2000).
Deaf people with mental health needs in the criminal justice system: A
review of the UK literature
. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry11,
556-570
.
65.
Xiao, J.
,
Preston, N. J.
and
Kisely, S.
(2004).
What determines compulsory community treatment? A logistic regression
analysis using linked mental health and offender databases
. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry38,
613-618
.
