This paper describes an experiment to investigate the influence of luminance distribution on perceived brightness in interiors. Thirty subjects matched the brightness of mock offices using a dimmer. Two of the four mock offices used in the experiment had relatively uniform luminance distributions, created by ceiling fluorescent lighting equipped with K-12 acrylic lenses. The other two offices had a nonuniform luminance distribution created by substituting parabolic louvres for the acrylic lenses. In control comparisons subjects matched two rooms having the same luminance distribution. In experimental comparisons subjects matched two rooms having different luminance distributions. The rooms with the nonuniform luminance distribution required between five and ten percent less working plane illuminance to match the brightness of the rooms with the uniform luminance distribution. This raises the possibility of modest energy savings through lighting design.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Stevens S.S.Psychophysics: Introduction to its Perceptual , Neural, and Social Prospects (New York : Wiley ) (1976)
2.
Flynn J.E., Spencer T.J., Martyniuk O. and Hendrick C.The influence of spatial light on human judgmentProc. CIE 18th Session pp39-46 (London: CIE) (1975)
3.
Marsden A.M.Brightness: A review of current knowledgeLighting Res. Technol.1(3) 171-181 (1969)
4.
Flynn J.E., Segil A.W. and Steffy G.R.Architectural Interior Systems: Lighting, Air Conditioning, Acoustics (2nd edn) (New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold)(1988)
5.
Rea M S (ed) Lighting Handbook: Reference & Application (New York: Illuminating Engineering Society of North America) (1993 ) !
6.
Flynn J.E.A study of subjective responses to low energy and nonuniform lighting systemsLighting Design Applic.7(2) 167-179 (1977)
7.
Bodmann H.W.Quality of interior lighting based on luminanceTrans. Illum. Eng. Soc.32(1) 22-40 (1967)
8.
Bodmann H.W., Sollner G. and Voit E.Bewertung von beleuchtungsniveaus bei verschiedenen lichtarten Proc. CIE 15th Session pp502-509 (Vienna: CIE) (1963)
9.
Cuttle C. and Boyce P.R.Kruithof revisited: A study of people's responses to illuminance and color temperature of lightingLighting in Australia8(6) 17-28 (1988)
10.
Davis R.G. and Ginthner D.N.Correlated color temperature, illuminance level, and the Kruithof curveJ. Illum. Eng. Soc.19(1) 27-38 (1990)
11.
Kanaya S., Hashimoto K. and Kichize E.Subjective balance between general color rendering index, color temperature and illuminance of interior lightingProc. CIE 19th Session pp274-278 (Kyoto: CIE) (1979)
12.
Aston S.M. and Bellchambers H.E.Illumination, color rendering and visual clarityLighting Res. Technol.1(4)259-261 (1969)
13.
Bellchambers H.E. and Godby A.C.Illumination, color rendering and visual clarityLighting Res. Technol.4(2) 104-106 (1972)
14.
Boyce P.R.Investigation of the subjective balance between illuminance and lamp color propertiesLighting Res. Technol.9(1) 11-24 (1977)
15.
Rowlands E. , Loe D.L., McIntosh R.M. and Mansfield K.P.Lighting adequacy and quality in office interiors by consideration of subjective assessment and physical measurementCIE J.4(1) 23-37 (1985)
16.
Bernecker C. and Mier J.M.The effect of source luminance on the perception of environment brightnessJ. Illum. Eng. Soc.15(1) 253-271 (1985)
17.
Rothwell S.E. and Campbell F.W.The physiological basis for the sensation of gloom: Quantitative and qualitative aspectsOphthalmology and Physiological Optics7(2) 161-163 (1987)
18.
Shepherd A.J. , Julian W.G. and Purcell A.T.Gloom as a psychophysical phenomenonLighting Res. Technol.21(3) 89-97 (1989)
19.
Perry M.J., Campbell F.W. and Rothwell S.E.A physiological phenomenon and its implications for lighting designLighting Res. Technol.19(1) 1-5 (1987)
20.
Collins B.L. , Fisher W., Gillette G.L. and Marans R.W.Second-level post-occupancy evaluation analysisJ. Illum. Eng. Soc.19(2) 21-44 (1990)
21.
Cohen J.Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences (Second Edition) (Hillsdale N J: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates ) (1988)
22.
Rea M.S. and Jeffrey I.G.A new luminance and image analysis system for lighting and vision: I. Equipment and calibrationJ. Illum. Eng. Soc. NA19(1) 64-72 (1990)
23.
Kirk R.E.Experimental Design: Procedures for the Behavioral Sciences ( Belmont, California: Brooks/ Cole) (1982)
24.
Cook T.D. and Campbell D.T.Quasi-Experimentation: Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings (Boston: Houghton Mifflin) ( 1979)
25.
Slater A.I. , Perry M.J. and Carter D.J.Illuminance differences between desks: Limits of acceptabilityLighting Res. Technol.25(3) 91-103 (1993)
Berman S.M. , Jewett D.J., Fein G., Saika G. and Ashford F.Photopic luminance does not always predict perceived room brightnessLighting Res. Technol.22(1) 37-41 (1990)
28.
Berman S.M. , Jewett D.J., Bingham L.R., Nahass R.M., Perry F. and Fein G.Pupillary size differences under incandescent and high pressure sodium lampsJ Illum. Eng. Soc.16(1) 3-20 (1987)
29.
Tiller D.K. and Rea M.S.Prospects for semantic differential scaling in lighting researchLighting Res. Technol.24(1) 43-52 (1992)
