Helmholtz Reciprocity: its validity and application to reflectometry

Abstract

Many measurements of reflection properties of materials or components depend for their validity on the Helmholtz Reciprocity Principle. Yet this principle is widely misunderstood, and is stated in textbooks in various forms which have different meanings. This paper examines Helmholtz's own statements of his Reciprocity Principle, which restrict its applicability to corresponding states of polarization for incident and emergent fluxes. This interpretation contrasted with those of more generalised statements, which either allow any incident and emergent states of polarization or which merely require an interchange of unrestricted incident and emergent states of polarization. A comprehensive set of measurements on five matt and two glossy white standard materials has enabled luminance factors to be compared for (0°/45°) and (45°/0°) conditions as well as for the special conditions (0°/57°) and (57°/0°) involving Brewster's Angle for the glossy samples. Each of these nine comparisons has been carried out with all 15 possible combinations of s- and p-plane polarized and unpolarized light. The 135 tests of reciprocity demonstrate that significant and sometimes large discrepancies occur for non-corresponding states of incident and emergent polarizations, whereas no significant discrepancies occur for corresponding states of polarization.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Helmholtz, H. von , Handbuch der Physiologischen Optik, 168-169 (Leopold Voss, Leipzig, 1867).

Helmholtz, H. von , Handbuch der Physiologischen Optik, Second Edn. 207-208 (Leopold Voss , Hamburg and Leipzig, 1896).

Helmholtz, H. von , Handbuch der Physiologischen Optik, Third Edn., 198-199 (Leopold Voss , Hamburg and Leipzig, 1909).

Helmholtz, H. von , Vorlesungen über der Theorie der Warme, 158-161, Edited by Franz Richortz (Barth, Leipzig , 1903).

Helmholtz, H. von , Physiological Optics, Vol. 1, 230-231, Translation by J. P. C. Southall (Optical Society of America, Rochester, N.Y., 1924 ).

Hills, M.E. , Olsen, A.L. and Nichols, L.W. , Polarization in Cary 14 spectrophotometers and its effect on transmittance measurements of anisoptropic materials, Appl. Optics 7, 1437-1441 (1968).

Grum, F. and Costa, L.F. , Determination of polarization in optical instruments and its metrological implications, Appl. Optics 13, 2228-2232 (1974).

Clarke, F.J.J. , Lambert, G.E.V. and Sparrock, J.M.B. , Research on absolute reflection standards at the National Physical Laboratory, Proceedings of Symposium, Colour measurements in industry, 25-40 (The Colour Group , London, 1967).

Clarke, F.J.J. , Garforth, F.A. and Parry, D.J. , Goniophotometric and polarization properties of the common white reflection standards, NPL Report MOM 26 ( National Physical Laboratory, Teddington, 1977).

10.

Clarke, F.J.J. , Garforth, F.A. and Parry, D.J. , Goniophotometric and polarization properties of white reflection standard materials, Ltg. Res. & Technol. , 15, 133-149 (1983).

11.

Erb, W. , Zur Gültigkeit des Helmholtzen Reziprozitats-theorems bei diffuser Reflexion, Optik 48, 425-438 (1977).

12.

Carmer, D.C. and Bair, M.E. , Some polarization characteristics of magnesium oxide and other diffuse reflectors, Appl. Optics, 8, 1597-1605 (1969).

13.

Robertson, A.R. , Effect of polarization on reflectance factor measurements, Appl. Optics, 11, 1936-1941 (1972).

14.

Walsh, J.W.T. , Photometry, Second Edn., 136-138 (Constable , London, 1953).

15.

Kartachevskaya, V.E. , Korte, H. and Robertson, A.R. , International comparison of measurement of luminance factor, and reflectance of white diffusing samples, Appl. Optics, 14, 2694-2702 (1975).

16.

Erb, W. , A summary of properties and reflection values of materials which are used as reflection standards, PTB Report Opt-3 (1975).

17.

CIE (Commission Internationale de l'Eclairage) , Colorimetry, Publication No. 15, Bureau de la CIE, 52 Boulevard Malesherbes, 75008 Paris (1971).