An experiment was conducted to evaluate the effect of a spectral power distribution (SPD) optimized to increase spatial brightness compared to one approximating a typical blue-pump, phosphor-converted LED (YAG:Ce). Chromatically and luminance-adapted participants completed a reading task, visual search task, numerical verification task and provided ratings for brightness, vividness, warmth and preference over the course of approximately 20 min for each of four lighting conditions (two SPDs by two illuminance levels (nominally 250 lx and 500 lx)). As a final task, the participants chose the brighter SPD between the two SPDs that were alternated every 5 s. In alignment with a past experiment where participants provided ratings after viewing 60 stimuli for about 20 s to 30 s each, the brightness-optimized SPD was rated as brighter, more vibrant and more preferred than the PC-like SPD. When evaluated as a choice in a rapid sequential presentation, the brightness-optimized SPD was chosen as brighter than the PC-like SPD 28 out of 30 times. There was not a statistically significant change in spontaneous blink rate (an indicator of visual fatigue) or blink duration, nor any difference in glare, eye fatigue or eye discomfort. Results for visual performance were mixed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Commission Internationale de l’Eclairage. International Lighting Vocabulary. CIE S017/E:2020. Vienna, Austria: Commission Internationale de l’Eclairage, 2011.
2.
HuZZhangPHuangY, et al. The impact of melanopic illuminance and CCT on spatial brightness perception of illuminated interiors and energy-saving implications. Building and Environment2022; 223: 109524.
3.
ReaMSMouXBulloughJD.Scene brightness of illuminated interiors. Lighting Research and Technology2016; 48: 823–831.
4.
RoyerMAbboushiBRodriguez-Feo BermudezE.Relative contributions of sc-DER, mel-DER, color rendition, chromaticity, and illuminance to spatial brightness perception. Leukos2025; 21: 309–331.
5.
KhanhTQBodrogiPZandiB, et al. Brightness perception under photopic conditions: experiments and modeling with contributions of S-cone and ipRGC. Sci Rep2023; 13: 14542.
6.
TillerDKVeitchJA.Perceived room brightness: pilot study on the effect of luminance distribution. Lighting Research and Technology1995; 27: 93–101.
7.
DuffJKellyKCuttleC.Perceived adequacy of illumination, spatial brightness, horizontal illuminance and mean room surface exitance in a small office. Lighting Research and Technology2017; 49: 133–146.
8.
FotiosSAtliDChealC, et al. Lamp spectrum and spatial brightness at photopic levels: a basis for developing a metric. Lighting Research and Technology2015; 47: 80–102.
9.
YuHAkitaT.The effect of illuminance and correlated colour temperature on perceived comfort according to reading behaviour in a capsule hotel. Building and Environment2019; 148: 384–393.
10.
FotiosSGadoT.A comparison of visual objectives used in side-by-side matching tests. Lighting Research and Technology2005; 37: 117–130.
11.
FlynnJESpencerTJ.The effects of light source color on user impression and satisfaction. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society1977; 6: 167–179.
12.
VrabelPLBerneckerCAMistrickRG.Visual performance and visual clarity under electric light sources: Part II – Visual clarity. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society1998; 27: 29–41.
13.
BermanSMJewettDLFeinG, et al. Photopic luminance does not always predict perceived room brightness. Lighting Research and Technology1990; 22: 37–41.
14.
BermanSMLiebelB.Essay by Invitation. LD+A, 1996: 12–17.
15.
FotiosSALevermoreGJ.Chromatic effect on apparent brightness in interior spaces II: sws Lumens model. Lighting Research and Technology1998; 30: 103–106.
16.
FotiosSALevermoreGJ.Chromatic effect on apparent brightness in interior spaces I: Introduction and colour gamut models. Lighting Research and Technology1998; 30: 107–110.
17.
FotiosSALevermoreGJ.Chromatic effect on apparent brightness in interior spaces III: Chromatic brightness model. Lighting Research and Technology1998; 30: 107–110.
18.
FotiosSLevermoreGJ.Perception of electric light sources of different colour properties. Lighting Research and Technology1997; 29: 161–171.
19.
ZeleAJAdhikariPFeiglB, et al. Cone and melanopsin contributions to human brightness estimation. Journal of the Optical Society of America A2018; 35: B19.
20.
BulloughJD.Cone and melanopsin contributions to human brightness estimation: comment. Journal of the Optical Society of America A2018; 35: 1780–1782.
21.
AkashiYBoycePR.A field study of illuminance reduction. Energy and Buildings2006; 38: 588–599.
22.
BoycePRAkashiYHunterCM, et al. The impact of spectral power distribution on the performance of an achromatic visual task. Lighting Research and Technology2003; 35: 141–156.
23.
BoycePRCuttleC.Effect of correlated colour temperature on the perception of interiors and colour discrimination performance. Lighting Research and Technology1990; 22: 19–36.
24.
VienotFDurandMLMahlerE.Kruithof’s rule revisited using LED illumination. Journal of Modern Optics2009; 56: 1433–1446.
25.
Van de PerreLSmetKAGHanselaerP, et al. The effect of correlated colour temperature and wall luminance on spatial brightness and scene preference in a windowless office setup. Lighting Research and Technology2023; 56: 316–336.
26.
JinLXuePZhangL, et al. Visual and non-visual effects of integrated lighting based on spectral information. Building and Environment2023; 242: 110617.
27.
MaJHLeeJKChaSH.Effects of lighting CCT and illuminance on visual perception and task performance in immersive virtual environments. Building and Environment2022; 209. 108678.
28.
BaniyaRRTetriEHalonenL.A study of preferred illuminance and correlated colour temperature for LED office lighting. Light and Engineering2015; 23: 39.
29.
TillerDKHuXHouserKW.Tuning the fluorescent spectrum for the trichromatic visual response: a pilot study. Leukos2005; 1: 7–23.
30.
HuXHouserKWTillerDK.Higher color temperature lamps may not appear brighter. Leukos2006; 3: 69–81.
31.
RoyerMPHouserKW.Spatial brightness perception of trichromatic stimuli. Leukos2012; 9: 89–108.
32.
HouserKWFotiosSARoyerMP.A Test of the S/P ratio as a correlate for brightness perception using rapid-sequential and side-by-side experimental protocols. Leukos2009; 6: 119–137.
33.
WeiMHouserKWOrlandB, et al. Field study of office worker responses to fluorescent lighting of different CCT and lumen output. Journal of Environmental Psychology2014; 39: 62–76.
34.
KimITJangIHChoiAS, et al. Brightness perception of white LED lights with different correlated colour temperatures. Indoor and Built Environment2015; 24: 500–513.
35.
JuJChenDLinY.Effects of correlated color temperature on spatial brightness perception. Color Research and Application2012; 37: 450–454.
36.
YuHAkitaT.Effects of illuminance and color temperature of a general lighting system on psychophysiology while performing paper and computer tasks. Building and Environment2023; 228: 109796.
37.
ManavB.An experimental study on the appraisal of the visual environment at offices in relation to colour temperature and illuminance. Building and Environment2007; 42: 979–983.
38.
DeLawyerTTsujimuraSShinomoriK.Relative contributions of melanopsin to brightness discrimination when hue and luminance also vary. Journal of the Optical Society of America A2020; 37: A81.
39.
BoycePR.Investigations of the subjective balance between illuminance and lamp colour properties. Lighting Research and Technology1977; 9: 11–24.
40.
FotiosSAtliDChealC, et al. Lamp spectrum and spatial brightness at photopic levels: Investigating prediction using S/P ratio and gamut area. Lighting Research and Technology2015; 47: 595–612.
41.
YamakawaMTsujimuraS-IOkajimaK.A quantitative analysis of the contribution of melanopsin to brightness perception. Scientific Reports2019; 9: 1–8.
42.
BeseneckerUCBulloughJD.Investigating visual mechanisms underlying scene brightness. Lighting Research and Technology2017; 49: 16–32.
43.
FotiosSA.Chromatic adaptation and the relationship between lamp spectrum and brightness. Lighting Research and Technology2006; 38: 3–17.
44.
KolbHFernandezENelsonR.Webvision: The Organization of the Retina and Visual System. Salt Lake City, UT., USA: University of Utah Health Sciences Center, 1995.
45.
FairchildMDReniffL.Time course of chromatic adaptation for color-appearance judgments. Journal of the Optical Society of America A1995; 12: 824.
46.
RinnerOGegenfurtnerKR.Time course of chromatic adaptation for color appearance and discrimination. Vision Research2000; 40: 1813–1826.
47.
ZhangYValsecchiMGegenfurtnerKR, et al. The time course of chromatic adaptation in human early visual cortex revealed by SSVEPs. Journal of Vision2023; 23: 1–13.
48.
RoyerMPAbboushiBRodriguez-Feo BermudezE.Relative contributions of sc-DER, mel-DER, color rendition, chromaticity, and illuminance to spatial brightness perception. Leukos.
49.
DoMTHYauKW.Adaptation to steady light by intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America2013; 110: 7470–7475.
SextonTJBleckertATurnerMH, et al. Type I intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells of early post-natal development correspond to the M4 subtype. Neural Development2015; 10: 17.
52.
MureLS.Intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells of the human retina. Frontiers in Neurology2021; 12: 636330.
53.
WebsterMA.Visual adaptation. Annual Review of Vision Science2015; 1: 547–567.
54.
ViolaAUJamesLMSchlangenLJM, et al. Blue-enriched white light in the workplace improves self-reported alertness, performance and sleep quality. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health2008; 34: 297–306.
55.
HoffmannGGuflerVGriesmacherA, et al. Effects of variable lighting intensities and colour temperatures on sulphatoxymelatonin and subjective mood in an experimental office workplace. Applied Ergonomics2008; 39: 719–728.
56.
ChiuHPLiuCH.The effects of three blue light filter conditions for smartphones on visual fatigue and visual performance. Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing & Service Industries2020; 30: 83–90.
57.
ShiYTuYWangL, et al. Spectral influence of the normal LCD, blue-shifted LCD, and OLED smartphone displays on visual fatigue: a comparative study. Displays2021; 69: 102066.
58.
ZhangYStudent MemberSTuY, et al. Assessment of visual fatigue under LED tunable white light with different blue components. Journal of the Society for Information Display2020; 28: 24–35.
59.
MathôtSBerberyanHBüchelP, et al. Effects of pupil size as manipulated through ipRGC activation on visual processing. NeuroImage2023; 283: 120420.
60.
ChakrabortyRCollinsMJKricancicH, et al. The intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cell (ipRGC) mediated pupil response in young adult humans with refractive errors. Journal of Optometry2022; 15: 112–121.
61.
ChenSKBadeaTCHattarS.Photoentrainment and pupillary light reflex are mediated by distinct populations of ipRGCs. Nature2011; 476: 92–96.
62.
PiquadoTIsaacowitzDWingfieldA.Pupillometry as a measure of cognitive effort in younger and older adults. Psychophysiology2010; 47: 560–569.
63.
SimonsonEBrozekJ.The effect of spectral quality of light on visual performance and fatigue. Journal of the Optical Society of America1948; 38: 830–840.
64.
Illuminating Engineering Society (IES). ANSI/IES TM-24-20: Optional Method for Adjusting the Recommended Illuminance for Visually Demanding Tasks Within IES Illuminance Categories P Through Y Based on Light Source Spectrum. New York, NY. Illuminating Engineering Society.
65.
SmithSReaM.Relationships between office task performance and ratings of feelings and task evaluations under different light sources and levels. CIE Publication No. 50, 1980: 207–211.
66.
BermanSM.Energy efficiency consequences of scotopic sensitivity. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society1992; 21: 3–14.
67.
BermanSM.A new retinal photoreceptor should affect lighting practice. Lighting Research and Technology2008; 40: 373–376.
68.
CajochenCMünchMKobialkaS, et al. High sensitivity of human melatonin, alertness, thermoregulation, and heart rate to short wavelength light. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism2005; 90: 1311–1316.
69.
MillsPRTomkinsSCSchlangenLJM. The effect of high correlated colour temperature office lighting on employee wellbeing and work performance. Journal of Circadian Rhythms2007; 5: 2.
70.
CajochenC.Alerting effects of light. Sleep Medicine Reviews2007; 11: 453–464.
71.
LokRSmoldersKCHJBeersmaDGM, et al. Light, alertness, and alerting effects of white light: a literature overview. Journal of Biological rhythms2018; 33: 589–601.
72.
SahinLWoodBMPlitnickB, et al. Daytime light exposure: effects on biomarkers, measures of alertness, and performance. Behavioural Brain Research2014; 274: 176–185.
73.
BrownTMTsujimuraSIAllenAE, et al. Melanopsin-based brightness discrimination in mice and humans. Current Biology2012; 22: 1134–1141.
74.
SpitschanMBockASRyanJ, et al. The human visual cortex response to melanopsin-directed stimulation is accompanied by a distinct perceptual experience. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America2017; 114: 12291–12296.
75.
RazaAIodiceMDumortierD, et al. Contributions of melanopsin and illuminance of metameric white light on spatial brightness and pupil size. Journal of the Optical Society of America A2025; 42: B467.
76.
MaschaEJVetterTR.Significance, errors, power, and sample size: the blocking and tackling of statistics. Anesthesia & Analgesia2018; 126: 691–698.
77.
ReaMS.Visual performance with realistic methods of changing contrast. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society1981; 10: 164–177.
78.
SternJABoyerDSchroederD.Blink rate: a possible measure of fatigue. Human Factors1994; 36: 285–297.
MaffeiAAngrilliA.Spontaneous eye blink rate: an index of dopaminergic component of sustained attention and fatigue. International Journal of Psychophysiology2018; 123: 58–63.
81.
ColzatoLSVan Den WildenbergWPMVan WouweNC, et al. Dopamine and inhibitory action control: evidence from spontaneous eye blink rates. Experimental Brain Research2009; 196: 467–474.
82.
LüdeckeDBen-ShacharMPatilI, et al. Performance: an R package for assessment, comparison and testing of statistical models. Journal of Open Source Software2021; 6: 3139.
83.
HuntRW.Light and dark adaptation and the perception of color. Journal of the Optical Society of America1952; 42: 190–199.
