This paper presents experimentally obtained luminous flux to input power characteristics of high-pressure sodium and LED luminaires used in road lighting, confirming that when applying dimming scenarios more percentage energy savings can be achieved by an LED than by a corresponding high-pressure sodium lighting installation. However, both workshop and field experiments showed that the tested LED drivers (of either standard or improved dimming characteristics) have the disadvantage of poor power factors (down to 0.67) at low light levels achieved by dimming. In addition, an increased presence of current harmonics and high values of the current total harmonic distortion were noticed at low light levels, representing another serious disadvantage of LED technology regarding power quality. The relevant electrical characteristics of commonly used LED drivers were analysed in detail and the reasons for the poor power quality when dimming LED luminaires were recognised. A new generation of LED drivers with a considerably narrower range of input (AC) voltage will allow acceptable power factors and limited emissions of current harmonics to be achieved in practically all lighting regimes.
RadetskyLC. Specifier Reports: Streetlights for Collector Roads, Troy, NY: Lighting Research Center, 2010.
3.
BeckwithDZhangXSmalleyEChanLYandM. LED streetlight application assessment project: Pilot study in Seattle, Washington. Transportation Research Record2011; 2250: 65–75.
4.
City of Los Angeles. LED Equipment Evaluation: Pilot Project – Phase I, Los Angeles, CA: Bureau of Street Lighting, 2009.
5.
CookTShacklefordJJohnsonMPangT. LED Street Lighting, Phase III Continuation, San Francisco, CA: Pacific Gas and Electric Company, 2008.
6.
Djokic L, Cabarkapa A, Djuretic A. Drivers’ impressions under high-pressure sodium and LED street lighting. Lighting Research and Technology, First Published 20 October 2017. DOI: 1477153517727802.
VittaPDabasinskasLTuzikasAPetrulisAMeskauskasDZukauskasA. Concept of intelligent solid-state street lighting technology. Elektronika ir Elektrotechnika2012; 18: 37–40.
Keppens A, Ryckaert WR, Deconinck G, Hanselaer P. Evaluation of current and temperature effects on high power LED efficiencies: Light and Lighting Conference with Special Emphasis on LEDs and Solid State Lighting, Budapest, Hungary, 27–29 May 2009. Retrieved 13 May 2017, from https://lirias.kuleuven.be/bitstream/123456789/242284/1/CIE_2009_AK.pdf.
HuiSYRQinYX. A general photo-electro-thermal theory for light emitting diode (LED) systems. IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics2009; 24: 1967–1976.
16.
LeeCKLiSHuiSYR. A design methodology for smart LED lighting systems powered by weakly regulated renewable power grids. IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid2011; 2: 548–554.
Li F, Chen D, Song X, Chen Y. LEDs: A promising energy-saving light source for road lighting: Proceedings of the Asia-Pacific Power and Energy Engineering Conference (APPEEC), Wuhan, China, 27–31 May 2009: pp. 1–3.
20.
KosticMDjokicL. Recommendations for energy efficient and visually acceptable street lighting. Energy2009; 34: 1565–1572.
21.
AriasMVázquezASebastiánJ. An overview of the AC-DC and DC-DC converters for LED lighting applications. Automatika2012; 53: 156–172.
American National Standards Institute. American National Standard for Lighting Equipment-Harmonic Emission Limits-related Power Quality Requirements. ANSI C82.77-10-2014. Washington DC: ANSI, 2014.
25.
European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization. Voltage Characteristics of Electricity Supplied by Public Distribution Systems. EN 50160. Brussels: CENELEC, 2005.
26.
RuanXWangBYaoKWangS. Optimum injected current harmonics to minimize peak-to-average ratio of LED current for electrolytic capacitor-less AC–DC drivers. IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics2011; 26: 1820–1825.
27.
WangBRuanXYaoKXuM. A method of reducing the peak-to-average ratio of LED current for electrolytic capacitor-less AC-DC drivers. IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics2010; 25: 592–601.
28.
Rand D, Lehman B, Shteynberg A. Issues, models and solutions for triac modulated phase dimming of LED lamps: PESC 07 – IEEE 38th Annual Power Electronics Specialists Conference, Orlando, FL, Jun 17–21: 2007: 1398–1404.
29.
AriasMLamarDGLineraFFBaloccoDDialloAASebastianJ. Design of a soft-switching asymmetrical half-bridge converter as second stage of an LED driver for street lighting application. IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics2012; 27: 1608–1621.
30.
ChiuHJLoYKChenJTChengSJLinCYMouSC. A high-efficiency dimmable LED driver for low-power lighting applications. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics2010; 57: 735–743.
31.
TanSC. General n-level driving approach for improving electrical-to-optical energy-conversion efficiency of fast-response saturable lighting devices. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics2010; 57: 1342–1353.
32.
Rodrigues CRBS, Almeida PS, Soares GM, Jorge JM, Pinto DP, Braga HAC. An experimental comparison between different technologies arising for public lighting: LED luminaires replacing high pressure sodium lamps: Proceedings of the 2011 IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics, Gdansk, Poland, 27–30 June 2011: pp. 141–146.
33.
Janiga P, Gasparovsky D. Power quality in public lighting installations. In Eberhard A, editor. Power Quality. Croatia: InTech, 2011: 45–66.
34.
Nogueira FJ, Silva ES, Gomide TS, Braga MF, Braga HAC. Design of a transformerless high power factor low frequency LED driver applied to street lighting: 24th IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics, ISIE 2015, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 3–5 June 2015: pp. 1172–1177.
35.
Jettanasen C, Pothisarn C. Analytical study of harmonics issued from LED lamp driver: International MultiConference of Engineers and Computer Scientists, IMECS 2014, Hong Kong, 12–14 March 2014: pp. 683–686.
36.
Gil-De-CastroAMoreno-MunozALarssonADe La RosaJJGBollenMHJ. LED street lighting: A power quality comparison among street light technologies. Lighting Research and Technology2013; 45: 710–728.
37.
Hermoso-OrzaezMJRojas-SolaJIGago-CalderonA. Electrical consequences of large-scale replacement of metal halide by LED luminaires. Lighting Research and Technology2018; 50: 282–293.
38.
UddinSShareefHMohamedAHannanMA. Investigation of harmonic generation from dimmable LED lamps. Przeglad Elektrotechniczny2013; 89: 151–155.
