Predicting lamp spectrum effects at mesopic levels. Part 2: Preferred appearance and visual acuity

Abstract

Laboratory tests were carried out to investigate lighting for pedestrians at mesopic levels under lamps of different spectral power distribution. This paper reports an evaluation of lamp spectrum effects on visual acuity, using Landolt ring charts of high and low luminance contrast, and forced choice judgements of the preferred appearance of human hands, a colour array and an illuminated space. These were carried out alongside judgements of brightness reported in a previous paper. Five types of lamp were used, including standard high pressure sodium, two metal halide and a fluorescent lamp of broader spectral distribution and a two-colour solid state device (LED). It was found that lamp spectrum affected judgements of preferred appearance, with the high pressure sodium and LED lamps being considered poor compared with the two metal halide lamps; these results correlated better with the CIE General Colour Rendering Index than other metrics of lamp spectral characteristics. It was also found that acuity was affected by lamp spectral power distribution, with the high pressure sodium (HPS) lamp enabling more Landolt rings to be correctly read than lamps of higher S/P ratio.

References

British Standards Institution (BSI) BS EN 13201-2: 2003. Road Lighting - Part 2: Performance Requirements. London: BSI, 2003.

British Standards Institution (BSI) BS5489-1: 2003. Code of Practice for the Design of Road Lighting - Part 1: Lighting of Roads and Public Amenity Areas. London: BSI, 2003.

Loewen LJ , Steel GD , Suedfeld P. Perceived safety from crime in the urban environment. Journal of Environmental Psychology 1993; 13: 323-333.

Boyce PR , Eklund NH , Hamilton B. , Bruno LD Perceptions of safety at night in different lighting conditions. Lighting Research and Technology 2000; 32: 79-91.

Fotios S. , Cheal C. Predicting lamp spectrum effects at mesopic levels. Part 1: Brightness. Lighting Research & Technology (in press).

Rea MS , Freyssinier-Nova JP Color rendering: A tale of two metrics. Color Research and Application 2008; 33: 192-202.

Commission Internationale de L’Éclairage. Recommended System for Visual Performance Based Mesopic Photometry. CIE Publication 191. Vienna: CIE, 2010.

Fotios SA , Cheal C. , Boyce PR Light source spectrum, brightness perception and visual performance in pedestrian environments: A review. Lighting Research and Technology 2005; 37: 271-294.

Fotios SA , Cheal C. Lighting for subsidiary streets: Investigation of lamps of different SPD. Part 1 : Visual performance. Lighting Research and Technology 2007; 39: 215-232.

10.

Berman SM , Navvab M. , Martin MJ , Sheedy J. , Tithof WA Comparison of traditional and high colour temperature lighting on the near acuity of elementary school children. Lighting Research & Technology 2006; 38: 41-52.

11.

Boyce PR , Akashi Y. , Hunter CM , Bullough JD The impact of spectral power distribution on the performance of an achromatic visual task. Lighting Research and Technology 2003; 35: 141-161.

12.

Schanda J. A combined colour preference-colour rendering index. Lighting Research and Technology 1985; 17: 31-34.

13.

Kanaya S. , Hashimoto K. , Kichize E. Subjective balance between general color rendering index, color temperature, and illuminance of interior lighting: Proceedings of the CIE 19th Session (Kyoto), Vienna: CIE, 1979.

14.

Quellman EM , Boyce PR The light source color preferences of people of different skin tones. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society 2002; 31: 109-118.

15.

Boyce PR , Bruno LD An evaluation of high pressure sodium and metal halide light sources for parking lot lighting. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society , 1999; 28: 16-32.

16.

Chen L. The accuracy of color naming under different light sources at low photopic to low mesopic conditions. MS thesis. Troy, NY: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, 1998.

17.

Lambe R. Potential pitfalls when using luxmeters and implications of lighting level on the relative efficiency of light sources: Proceedings of Lightec 96, Cambridge UK, Sept 9-10: 1996.

18.

Konica Minolta . Luminance Meter LS-100 LS-110 Instruction Manual . Japan: Konica Minolta, 1987.

19.

Bailey IL , Lovie JE New design principles for visual acuity letter charts. American Journal of Optometry and Physiological Optics 1976; 53: 740-745.

20.

Vrabel PL , Bernecker CA , Mistrick RG Visual performance and visual clarity under electric light sources: Part 1. Visual performance. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society 1995; 24: 69-80.

21.

Dunn-Rankin P. , Knezek GA , Wallace S. , Zhang S. Scaling Methods. 2nd Edition, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2004.

22.

Field A. Discovering Statistics Using SPSS. London: SAGE Publications, 2005.

23.

Coolican H. Research Methods and Statistics in Psychology. 2nd Edition, London: Hodder and Stoughton , 1994.

24.

Crow EL , Davis FA , Maxfield MW Statistics Manual. New York: Dover Publications, 1960.

25.

Moore DS , McCabe GP Introduction to the Practise of Statistics, 2nd Edition, New York: WH Freeman, 1993.

26.

Navvab MA Comparison of visual performance under high and low color temperature fluorescent lamps. Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society 2001; 30: 170-175.