We explore the links between identity and strategy making by drawing upon a case
study of a collaborative strategy implemented by community organizations and
pharmaceutical companies involved in Canadian HIV/AIDS treatment. In implementing
collaborative strategy, our analysis shows that champions engage in identity work
that simultaneously involves: identification with their respective constituencies
and, specifically, with categories associated with high legitimacy;
counter-identification from their respective constituencies by constructing
themselves as different from its core members; and dis-identification away from
their constituency towards their collaborative partners. We also examine the
interactions between champions and other actors involved in the strategic change
process to show the limits and tensions involved in such identity work. We conclude
with a discussion of the implications for research and practice.
Afuah, A.
(2000)
‘How Much Do Your Co-opetitors’ Capabilities Matter in
the Face of Technological Change’
, Strategic Management Journal21(3):
397-404
.
2.
Albert, S.
and
Whetten, D.
(1985) ‘Organizational
Identity’, in
L. L. Cummings
and
B. M. Staw
(eds) Research in Organizational Behavior, Vol. 7, pp.
263-295.
Greenwich, CT: JAI
.
3.
Alvesson, M.
(2002) Understanding Organizational Culture.
London: Sage Publications
.
4.
Antaki, C.
and
Widdicombe, S.
, eds (1998) Identities in Talk.
London: Sage
.
5.
Arno, P. S.
and
Feiden, K. L.
(1992) Against the Odds: The Story of AIDS Drug Development,
Politics and Profits.
New York: Harper Collins
.
6.
Ashforth, B. E.
and
Mael, F.
(1989)
‘Social Identity Theory and the Organization’
, Academy of Management Review14(1):
20-39
.
7.
Astley, G.
(1984)
‘Toward an Appreciation of Collective Strategy’
, Academy of Management Review9(43):
526-535
.
8.
Avital, M.
(2000)
‘Dealing with Time in Social Inquiry: A Tension Between Method
and Lived Experience’
, Organization Science11:
665-673
.
9.
Bansal, P.
(2003)
‘From Issues to Actions: The Importance of Individual Concerns
and Organizational Values in Responding to Natural Environmental Issues’
, Organization Science14(5):
510-527
.
10.
Baron, D. P.
(1995)
‘Integrated Strategy: Market and Nonmarket Components’
, California Management Review37(2):
47-67
.
11.
Barringer, B. R.
and
Harrison, J. S.
(2000)
‘Walking a Tightrope: Creating Value Through Interorganizational Relationships’
, Journal of Management26(3):
367-385
.
12.
Bartel, C. A.
(2001)
‘Social Comparisons in Boundary-spanning Work: Effects of
Community Outreach on Members’ Organizational Identity and Identification’
, Administrative Science Quarterly46(3):
379-413
.
13.
Boeker, W.
(1997)
‘Strategic Change: The Influence of Managerial Characteristics
and Organizational Growth’
, Academy of Management Journal40(1):
152-171
.
14.
Bourdieu, P.
(2000) ‘The Biographical
Illusion’, in
P. du Gay
,
J. Evans
and
P. Redman
(eds) Identity: A Reader, pp. 297-310.
London: Sage
.
15.
Brodwin, D. R.
and
Bourgeois, L. J.
(1994) ‘Leadership Styles’,
in
C. Hardy
(ed.) Managing Strategic Action, pp. 52-61,
London: Sage
.
16.
Brown, A. D.
and
Starkey, K.
(2000)
‘Organizational Identity and Learning: A Psychodynamic Perspective’
, Academy of Management Review25(1):
102-120
.
17.
Brunsson, N.
and
Sahlin-Andersson, K.
(2000)
‘Constructing Organizations: The Example of Public Sector Reform’
, Organization Studies21(4):
721-746
.
18.
Burgelman, R.
(1983)
‘A Model of Interaction of Strategic Behavior, Corporate Context,
and the Concept of Strategy’
, Academy of Management Review8(1):
61-70
.
19.
Carpenter, M. A.
(2002)
‘The Implications of Strategy and Social Context for the
Relationship between Top Management Team Heterogeneity and Firm Performance’
, Strategic Management Journal23(3):
275-284
.
20.
Carpenter, M. A.
and
Fredrickson, J. W.
(2001)
‘Top Management Teams, Global Strategic Posture, and the
Moderating Role of Uncertainty’
, Academy of Management Journal44(3):
533-546
.
21.
Clegg, S. R.
and
Hardy, C.
(1996). ‘Representations’, in
S. R. Clegg
,
C. Hardy
and
W. Nord
(eds) Handbook of Organization Studies, pp.
676-708.
London: Sage
.
22.
Covaleski, M. A.
,
Dirsmith, M. W.
,
Heian, J. B.
and
Sajay, S.
(1998.
‘The Calculated and the Avowed: Techniques of Discipline and
Struggles over Identity in the Big Six Public Accounting Firms’
, Administrative Science Quarterly43:
293-327
.
23.
Creed, W. E. D.
and
Scully, M. A.
(2000)
‘Songs of Ourselves: Employees’ Deployment of Social
Identity in Workplace Encounters’
, Journal of Management Inquiry9(4):
391-413
.
24.
Creed, W. E. D.
,
Scully, M. A.
and
Austin, J. R.
(2002)
‘Clothes Make the Person? The Tailoring of Legitimating Accounts
and the Social Construction of Identity’
, Organization Science13(5):
475-496
.
25.
Crimp, D.
, ed. (1988) AIDS: Cultural Analysis, Cultural Activism.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
26.
Czarniawska-Joerges, B.
(1996) ‘Autobiographical Acts and Organizational
Identities’, in
S. Linstead
,
R. Grafton-Small
and
P. Jeffcutt
(eds) Understanding Management, pp. 157-171.
London: Sage
.
27.
Davis, B.
and
Harré, R.
(1990)
‘Positioning: The Discursive Production of Selves’
, Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour20(1):
43-65
.
28.
Denis, J. L.
,
Lamothe, L.
and
Langley, A.
(2001)
‘The Dynamics of Collective Leadership and Strategic Change in
Pluralistic Organizations’
, Academy of Management Journal44(4):
809-838
.
29.
Dutton, J. E.
and
Dukerich, J. M.
(1991)
‘Keeping an Eye on the Mirror: Image and Identity in
Organizational Adaptation’
, Academy of Management Journal34(3):
517-554
.
30.
Dutton, J. E.
,
Dukerich, J. M.
and
Harquail, C. V.
(1994)
‘Organizational Images and Member Identification’
, Administrative Science Quarterly39:
239-263
.
31.
Edgar, H.
and
Rothman D. J.
(1990)
‘New Rules for New Drugs: The Challenge of AIDS to the Regulatory Process’
, The Milbank Quarterly68 (supplement 1):
111-142
.
32.
Eisenhardt, K. M.
(1989)
‘Building Theories from Case Study Research’
, Academy of Management Review14(4):
532-550
.
33.
Eisenhardt, K. M.
and
Bourgeois, L. J.
(1988)
‘Politics of Strategic Decision Making in High-Velocity
Environments: Toward a Midrange Theory’
, Academy of Management Journal31(4):
737-770
.
34.
Epstein, S.
(1996) Impure Science: Aids, Activism, and the Politics of
Science.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
35.
Fairclough, N.
(1992) Discourse and Social Change.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
36.
Fiol, C. M.
(2001)
‘Revisiting an Identity-based View of Sustainable Competitive Advantage’
, Journal of Management27:
691-699
.
37.
Fiol, C. M.
(2002)
‘Capitalizing on Paradox: The Role of Language in Transforming
Organizational Identities’
, Organization Science13(6):
653-666
.
38.
Foreman, P.
and
Whetten, D. A.
(2002)
‘Members’ Identification with Multiple-identity Organizations’
, Organization Science13(6):
618-635
.
39.
Foucault, M.
(1982) ‘The Subject and
Power’, in H. Dreyfus and P. Rabinow, Michel Foucault:
Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics.
Brighton: Harvester Wheatsheaf
.
40.
Gatter, M.
(1995)
‘Anthropology, HIV and Contingent Identities’
, Social Science and Medicine41(11):
1523-1533
.
41.
Gergen, K.
(1991) The Saturated Self.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
42.
Gergen, K.
(1994) Realities and Relationships: Soundings in Social
Construction.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
43.
Gilmore, N.
(1991)
‘The Impact of AIDS on Drug Availability and Accessibility’
, AIDS5(supplement 2):
S253-S262
.
44.
Ginsberg, A.
and
Abrahamson, E.
(1991)
‘Champions of Change and Strategic Shifts: The Role of Internal
and External Change Advocates’
, Journal of Management Studies28(2):
173-191
.
45.
Gioia, D. A.
,
Schultz, M.
and
Corley, K. G.
(2000)
‘Organizational Identity, Image and Instability’
, Academy of Management Review25(1):
63-81
.
46.
Gioia, D. A.
and
Thomas, J. B.
(1996)
‘Identity, Image and Issue Interpretation: Sensemaking During
Strategic Change in Academia’
, Administrative Science Quarterly41(3):
370-403
.
47.
Glynn, M. A.
(2000)
‘When Cymbals Become Symbols: Conflict over Organizational
Identity within a Symphony Orchestra’
, Organization Science11(3):
285-298
.
48.
Golden-Biddle, K.
and
Rao, H.
(1997)
‘Breaches in the Boardroon: Organizational Identity and Conflicts
of Commitment in a Nonprofit Organization’
, Organization Science8(6):
593-612
.
49.
Gray, B.
(1989) Collaborating.
San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass
.
50.
Gulati, R.
(1998)
‘Alliances and Networks’
, Strategic Management Journal19(4):
293-317
.
51.
Gulati, R.
,
Nohria, N.
and
Zaheer, A.
(2000)
‘Strategic networks’
, Strategic Management Journal21(3):
203-215
.
52.
Gustafson, L. T.
and
Reger, R. K.
(1995)
‘Using Organizational Identity to Achieve Stability and Change in
High Velocity Environments’
, Academy of Management Journal39:
464-468
.
53.
Guth, W.
and
MacMillan, I.
(1986)
‘Strategy Implementation Versus Middle Management Self-interest’
, Strategic Management Journal7(4):
313-327
.
54.
Hacking, I.
(1986) ‘Making up People’, in
T. C. Heller
,
M. Sosna
and
D. E. Wellbery
(eds)
ReconstructingIndividualism: Autonomy, Individuality, and the Self in Western Thought,
pp. 222-236.
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
55.
Hall, Stuart
(1997) ‘The Work of Representation’
and ‘The Spectacle of the Other’, in
Stuart Hall
(ed.) Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying
Practices, pp. 233-279.
London: Sage in association with the Open University
.
56.
Hardy, C.
,
Lawrence, T.
and
Grant, D.
(2005)
‘Discourse and Collaboration: The Role of Conversations and
Collective Identity’
, Academy of Management Review30(1):
1-20
.
57.
Hardy, C.
and
Phillips, N.
(1998)
‘Strategies of Engagement: Lessons from the Critical Examination
of Collaboration and Conflict in an Interorganizational Domain’
, Organization Science9(2):
217-230
.
58.
Hardy, C.
,
Phillips, N.
and
Lawrence, T.
(2003)
‘Resources, Knowledge and Influence: The Organizational Effects
of Interorganizational Collaboration’
, Journal of Management Studies40(2):
289-315
.
59.
Harrington, M.
(1997) ‘Some Transitions in the History of AIDS
Treatment Activism’, in
J. Oppenheimer
and
H. Reckitt
(eds) Acting on AIDS: Sex, Drugs and Politics, pp.
273-286.
London: Serpent’s Tail
.
60.
Hatch, M. J.
and
Schultz, M.
(2002)
‘The Dynamics of Organizational Identity,’Human Relations55(8):
989-1018
.
61.
Heide, J.
(1994)
‘Interorganizational Governance in Marketing Channels’
, Journal of Marketing58(1):
71-85
.
62.
Holmer Nadesan, M.
(1996)
‘Organizational Identity and Space of Action’
, Organization Studies17(1):
49-81
.
63.
Huxham, C.
(1996) Creating Collaborative Advantage.
London: Sage
.
64.
Kale, P.
,
Singh, H.
and
Perlmutter, H.
(2000)
‘Learning and Protection of Proprietary Assets in Strategic
Alliances: Building Relational Capital’
, Strategic Management Journal21(3):
217-237
.
65.
Kärreman, D.
and
Alvesson, M.
(2001)
‘Making Newsmakers: Conversational Identity at Work’
, Organization Studies22(1):
59-89
.
66.
Kilduff, M.
,
Funk, J. L.
and
Mehra, A.
(1997)
‘Engineering Identity in a Japanese Factory’
,Organization Science8(6):
579-592
.
67.
Knight, D.
,
Pearce, C. L.
,
Smith, K. G.
and
Olian, J. D.
(1999)
‘Top Management Team Diversity, Group Process, and Strategic Consensus’
, Strategic Management Journal20(5):
445-465
.
68.
Krishnan, H. A.
,
Miller, A.
and
Judge, W. Q.
(1997)
‘Diversification and Top Management Team Complementarity: Is
Performance Improved by Merging Similar or Dissimilar Teams?’
, Strategic Management Journal18(5):
361-374
.
69.
Lawrence, T. B.
,
Hardy, C.
and
Phillips, N.
(2002)
‘Institutional Effects of Interorganizational Collaboration: The
Emergence of Proto-institutions’
, Academy of Management Journal45(1):
281-290
.
70.
Lawrence, T. B.
,
Phillips, N.
and
Hardy, C.
(1999)
‘Watching Whale-Watching: A Relational Theory of Organizational Collaboration’
, Journal of Applied Behavioral Science35(4):
479-502
.
71.
Lee, T. W.
(1999) Using Qualitative Methods in Organizational
Research.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
72.
Levy, D. L.
and
Kolk, A.
(2002)
‘Strategic Responses to global climate change: Conflicting
Pressures on Multinationals in the Oil Industry’
, Business and Politics4(3):
275-300
.
73.
Lieblich, A.
,
Tuval-Mashiach, R.
and
Zilber, T.
(1998) Narrative Research: Reading, Analysis and
Interpretation.
Thousand Oaks, CA, London and New Delhi: Sage
.
74.
Litvin, D.
(1997)
‘The Discourse of Diversity: From Biology to Management’
, Organization4(2):
187-210
.
75.
Lounsbury, M.
and
Glynn,M. A.
(2001)
‘Cultural Entrepreneurship: Stories, Legitimacy, and the
Acquisitions of Resources’
, Strategic Management Journal, 22:
545-564
.
76.
Maguire, S.
(2002)
‘Discourse and Adoption of Innovations: A Study of HIV/AIDS Treatments’
, Health Care Management Review27(3):
74-88
.
77.
Maguire, S.
,
Hardy, C.
and
Lawrence, T.
(2004)
‘Institutional Entrepreneurship in Emerging Fields: HIV/AIDS
Treatment Advocacy in Canada’
, Academy of Management Journal47(5):
657-679
.
78.
Maguire, S.
,
Phillips, N.
and
Hardy C.
(2001)
‘When “Silence = Death”, Keep Talking: Trust,
Control and the Discursive Construction of Identity in the Canadian HIV/AIDS
Treatment Domain’
, Organization Studies22(2):
287-312
.
79.
Marshall, C.
and
Rossman, G. B.
(1995) Designing Qualitative Research, 2nd edn.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
80.
Martin, J. L.
(2001) Organizational Culture: Mapping the Terrain.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
81.
Mehta, R.
,
Dubinsky, A. J.
and
Anderson, R. E.
(2003)
‘Leadership Style, Motivation and Performance in International
Marketing Channels: An Empirical Investigation of the USA, Finland and Poland’
, European Journal of Marketing37(1/2):
50-85
.
82.
Meyerson, D. E.
and
Scully, M. A.
(1995)
‘Tempered Radicalism and the Politics of Ambivalence and Change’
, Organization Science6(5):
585-600
.
83.
Mintzberg, H.
(1978)
‘Patterns in Strategy Formation’
, Management Science24(9):
934-949
.
84.
Orlikowski, W. J.
(1996)
‘Improvising Organizational Transformation Over Time: A Situated
Change Perspective’
, Information Systems Research7:
63-92
.
85.
Pettigrew, A. M.
,
Woodman, R. W.
and
Cameron, K. S.
(2001)
‘Studying Organizational Change and Development: Challenges for
Future Research’
, Academy of Management Journal44(4):
697-714
.
86.
Phillips, N.
and
Hardy, C.
(1997)
‘Managing Multiple Identities: Discourse, Legitimacy and
Resources in the UK Refugee System’
, Organization4(2):
159-185
.
87.
Phillips, N.
,
Lawrence, T. B.
and
Hardy, C.
(2000)
‘Interorganizational Collaboration and the Dynamics of
Institutional Fields’
, Journal of Management Studies37(1):
23-45
.
88.
Potter, J.
and
Wetherell, M.
(1987) Discourse and Social Psychology: Beyond Attitudes and
Behaviour.
London: Sage
.
89.
Powell, W. W.
,
Koput, K. W.
and
Smith-Doerr, L.
(1996)
‘Interorganizational Collaboration and the Locus of Innovation:
Networks of Learning in Biotechnology’
, Administrative Science Quarterly41(1):
116-146
.
90.
Pratt, M. G.
and
Foreman, P. O.
(2000)
‘Classifying Managerial Responses to Multiple Organizational Identities’
, Academy of Management Review25(1):
18-42
.
91.
Ravasi, D.
and
van Rekom, J.
(2003)
‘Key Issues in Organizational Identity and Identification Theory’
, Corporate Reputation Review6(2):
118-131
.
92.
Riggins, S. H.
(1997) ‘The Rhetoric of
Othering’, in
S. H. Riggins
(ed.) The Language and Politics of Exclusion, pp.
1-30.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
93.
Roy, C. M.
(1995) Living and Serving: Persons with HIV in the Canadian
AIDS Movement.
Ottawa: Canadian AIDS Society
.
94.
Schoenecker, T. S.
,
Daellenbach, U. S.
and
McCarthy, A. M.
(1995)
‘Factors Affecting a Firm’s Commitment to Innovation’
, Academy of Management Journal Best Papers Proceedings
(Special Issue):
52-57
.
95.
Schwalbe, M. L.
and
Mason-Shrock, D.
(1996)
‘Identity Work as Group Process’
, Advances in Group Processes13:
113-147
.
96.
Schweiger, D. M.
,
Sandberg, W. R.
and
Ragan, J. W.
(1986)
‘Group Approaches for Improving Strategic Decision Making: A
Comparative Analysis of Dialectical Inquiry, Devil’s Advocacy, and Consensus’
, Academy of Management Journal29(1):
51-72
.
97.
Scott, S. G.
and
Lane, V. R.
(2000)
‘A Stakeholder Approach to Organizational Identity’
, Academy of Management Review25(1):
43-62
.
98.
Shilts, R.
(1987) And the Band Played on: Politics, People, and the AIDS
Epidemic.
New York: St Martin’s Press
.
99.
Treichler, P.
(1999) How to Have Theory in an Epidemic: Cultural Chronicles
of AIDS.
Durham, NC: Duke University Press
.
100.
Tsoukas, H.
and
Chia, R.
(2002)
‘On Organizational Becoming: Rethinking Organizational Change’
, Organization Science13(5):
567-582
.
101.
Wachter, R. M.
(1991) The Fragile Coalition: Scientists, Activists and
AIDS.
New York: St Martin’s Press
.
102.
Wachter, R. M.
(1992)
‘AIDS, Activism, and the Politics of Health’
, New England Journal of Medicine326(2):
128-133
.
103.
Weick, K.
(1999)
‘Theory Construction as Disciplined Reflexology: Tradeoffs in the 90s’
, Academy of Management Review24(4):
797-806
.
104.
Weisenfeld, B.
,
Raghuram, S.
and
Garud, R.
(1999)
‘Communication Patterns as Determinants of Organizational
Identification in a Virtual Organization’
, Organization Science10(6):
777-790
.
105.
Wodak, R.
(1996) ‘The Genesis of Racist Discourse in
Austria since 1989’, in
C. R. Caldas-Coulthard
and
M. Coulthard
(eds) Texts and Practices: Readings in Critical Discourse
Analysis, pp. 107-128.
London: Routledge
.
106.
Yin, R. K.
(2003) Case Study Research: Design and Methods, 3rd
edn.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications
.
