Monitoring Multi-Site Damage Growth During Quasi-Static Testing of a Wind Turbine Blade using a Structural Neural System

Abstract

Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) of a wind turbine blade using a Structural Neural System (SNS) is described in this paper. Wind turbine blades are composite structures with complex geometry and sections that are built of different materials. The 3D structure, large size, anisotropic material properties, and the potential for damage to occur anywhere on the blade makes damage detection a significant challenge. A SNS based on acoustic emission (AE) monitoring (passive listening) was developed for practical low cost SHM of large composite structures such as wind turbine blades. The SNS was tested to detect damage initiation and propagation on a 9 m long wind turbine blade during a quasi-static proof test to failure at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory test facility in Golden, Colorado. Twelve piezoelectric sensors were bonded on the surface of the wind turbine blade and connected to form four continuous sensors which were used in the SNS to determine damage locations. Although 12 sensors monitored the wind turbine blade, the SNS produces only two analog output signals; one time signal to determine and locate damage, and a second time signal containing combined AE waveforms. Testing of the wind turbine blade produced some interesting results. After initial emissions due to settling of the blade diminished, damage initiated at one location on the blade. As the load was increased, damage occurred in a sequence at three other locations until there was a catastrophic buckling failure of the blade. The buckling occurred above the design load for the blade, and was due to the carbon spar cap disbonding from the fiberglass shear web under compressive bending stress. The SNS indicated the general area where the damage started and how the damage progressed, which is valuable information for verifying and improving the blade design and the manufacturing procedure. Strain gages on the blade did not provide a clear indication of damage until buckling occurred. A major outcome of this testing was to provide confidence that SHM of large composite structures that have complex geometry and multiple materials is practical using a simple, low cost SNS.

Keywords

structural neural system (SNS)continuous sensors acoustic emission (AE)wind turbine blade structural health monitoring (SHM)passive health monitoring

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Product overview of wind turbine condition monitoring by Bently Nevada Inc &lt ;http://www.proximityprobes.com/applications/wind.htm>February 2007.

Wells, R. , Hamstad, M.A. and Mukherjee, A.K. (1983). On the origin of the first peak of acoustic emission in 7075 aluminum alloy . Journal of Materials Science, 18, 1015-1020.

Sundaresan, M.J. , Schulz, M.J. and Ghoshal, A. (2002). Structural Health Monitoring static test of a wind turbine blade, Subcontractor report, March 2002, NREL/SR-500-28719.

Migliore, P. , VanDam, J. and Huskey, A. (2004). Acoustic tests of small wind turbines, AIAA-2004-1185 .

Dutton, A.G. , Blanch, M. , Vionis, P. , Kolovos, V. , Van Delft, D.R.V. , Joose, P. , Anastassopoulos, A. , Kouroussis, D. , Kossivas, T. , Ter Laak, J. , Philippidis, T.P. , Kolaxis, Y.G. , Fernando, G. , Zheng, G. , Liu, T. and Proust, A. (2000). Acoustic emission monitoring from wind turbine blades undergoing static and fatigue testing . In: Proceedings of the 15th world conference on Non-Destructive Testing, Roma, 15-21 October. <http://www.ndt.net/article/wcndt00/papers/idn553/idn553.htm>

Joose, P.A. , et al. (2002). Acoustic emission monitoring of small wind turbine blades. Journal of Solar Energy Engineering , Transactions of the ASME, 124, 446-454.

Sundaresan, M.J. , Ghoshal, A. and Schulz, M.J. (2002). Sensor array system , US patent, 6,399,939 B1, June 2002.

Kirikera, G.R. , Shinde, V. , Schulz, M.J. , Ghoshal, A. , Sundaresan, M.J. and Allemang, R.J. (2007). Damage localization in composite and metallic structures using Structural Neural System and simulated acoustic emissions . Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing , 21(1), 280-297.

Kirikera, G.R. , Lee, J.W. , Schulz, M.J. , Ghoshal, A. , Sundaresan, M.J. , Allemang, R. , Shanov, V. and Westheider, B. (2006). Initial evaluation of a Novel Active/Passive Structural Neural System for Health Monitoring of Composite Materials . Smart Materials and Structures, 15, 1275-1286.

10.

Goutham R. Kirikera , Vishal Shinde , Mark J. Schulz , Anindya Ghoshal , Mannur J. Sundaresan , Randall J. Allemang and Jong Won Lee (2008). A structural neural system for real time health monitoring of composite materials . Structural Health Monitoring, An International Journal, 7, 65-83.

11.

Mohamed, M. , van Dam, J. and Hughes, S. (2005). Blade static test plan for the 3Tex 9 meter blade , Test number: NWTC- ST-3TEX-STA-01-1205, Internal NREL report, December 2005.

12.

Martin, W.N. , Ghoshal, A. , Sundaresan, M.J. , Lebby, G.L. , Pratap, P.R. and Schulz, M.J. (2005). An artificial neural receptor system for structural health monitoring . Structural Health Monitoring, An International Journal, 4(3), 229-245.

13.

ASTM standard. Standard Practice for Characterizing Acoustic Emission Instrumentation, E750-04, pp. 371-380.

14.

Hamstad, M.A. (2000). Thirty years of advances and some remaining challenges in the application of acoustic emission to composite materials. In: Kishi, T., Ohtsu, M. and Yuyama, S. (eds), Acoustic Emission - Beyond the MILLENIUM, pp. 77-91, Elseiver .

15.

ASTM standard. Standard Practice for Acoustic Emission Monitoring of Structures During Controlled Stimulation, E569-02, vol 03.03, pp. 250-254.

16.

Prosser, W.H. (1991). The propagation characteristics of the plate modes of acoustic emission waves in thin aluminum plates and thin graphite/epoxy composite plates and tubes, PhD dissertation, John Hopkins University , NASA technical memorandum, 104187, November 1991.

17.

Fowler, T.J. (1977). Acoustic Emission Testing of Fiber Reinforced Plastics , Fall Convention, San Francisco, ASCE, October 1977, 3092 .

18.

Dunegan, H.L. (2000). An alternative to pencil lead breaks for simulation of acoustic emission signal sources, The DECI report, August 2000.

19.

Kirikera, G.R. (2006). A structural neural system for health monitoring of structures, PhD dissertation, University of Cincinnati , August 2006.

20.

van Dam, J. and Hughes, S. (2006). NWTC structural testing test report - static test of the 3-TEX 9meter blade, NWTC-ST-3TEX-STA-01-1205, Internal NREL Report , April 2006.