The purpose and characteristics of a teacher are interesting socio-cultural imaginaries with important implications for education. Such imaginaries influence and even dictate the purpose and imaginary of teacher education. The imaginaries are often enshrined explicitly or implicitly in teacher education policy. In this article, we deconstruct the taken-for-granted imaginary of what a teacher is in England and France and relate this ontological concern to teacher education. A comparison between England and France is of interest due to the crossing trajectories of the two countries and their contrasting histories of teacher education. Results of our analysis show that even though the teacher education systems and socio-cultural imaginaries have different origins, in today’s world, they appear to be approaching each other, whilst the concerns over what the teacher is and how they ought to be educated remain similar in the political discourse. Interestingly, where teachers are to be educated, who are to educate them, and what purpose teachers are to serve are discussed equally in both places despite their different origins and current systems of teacher education.
BallSJ (1993) What is policy? Texts, trajectories and toolboxes. Discourse Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education13(2): 10–17.
3.
BallSJ (2015) What is policy? 21 years later: Reflections on the possibilities of policy research. Discourse Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education36(3): 306–313.
4.
BoweRBallSJ (1992) Reforming Education and Changing Schools. London: Routledge.
5.
CattonarBDumayXDupriezV (2023) Old and New Segmentations: The Case of the Teaching Profession in French-Speaking Belgium. The Status of the Teaching Profession: Interactions Between Historical and New Forms of Segmentation. London: Routledge.
6.
ChildsAMenterI (2013) Teacher education in 21st century England. A case study in neoliberal public policy. Revista Española de Educación Comparada22: 93–116.
7.
ChittyC (1991) The great debate: The politics of the secondary school curriculum, 1976–88. PhD Thesis, University of London.
8.
CoppeT (2025) The expanded presence of second-career teachers: Redefining the teaching profession and career. In: DumayXPaineLSorensenT (eds) The Teaching Profession in a Globalizing World: Governance, Career, Learning. Routledge, pp. 129–142.
9.
CoppeTSarazinMMärzV, et al. (2022) (Second career) teachers’ work socialization as a networked process: New empirical and methodological insights. Teaching and Teacher Education116: 103766.
10.
DfE (1983) Teaching Quality. London: Department for Education, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
11.
DfE (1984) Circular 3/84: Initial Teacher Training Approval of Courses. London: Department for Education, House of Commons.
12.
DfE (2011) Teachers’ Standards. Guidance for School Leaders, School Staff and Governing Bodies. London: Department for Education.
13.
DumayX (ed.) (2025) The Liberalization of Teacher Employment Regimes in Europe. Online, Oxford University Press.
14.
FargesG (2017) Les Mondes enseignants. Identités et clivages. Paris: PUF.
15.
FlickU (2009) An Introduction to Qualitative Research. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
16.
FosterR (1999) School-based initial teacher training in England and France: Trainee teachers’ perspectives compared. Mentoring & Tutoring Partnership in Learning7(2): 131–143.
17.
FurlongJ (2001) Reforming teacher education, re-forming teachers: Accountability, professionalism and competence. In: PhillipsRFurlongJ (eds) Education, Reform and the State: Twenty-Five Years of Politics, Policy and Practice. London and New York: Routledge, pp.118–135.
18.
FurlongJ (2013) Education - An Anatomy of the Discipline: Rescuing the University Project?London and New York: Routledge.
19.
HelgetunJB (2021) Maintaining and changing institutionalized environments: Teacher education policymaking in England and France compared. PhD Thesis, University of Louvain.
20.
HelgetunJB (2022) The importance of context: Teacher education policy in England and France compared. In: MenterI (ed.) The Palgrave Handbook of Teacher Education Research. Online, Palgrave-Macmilan, pp. 1403–1430.
21.
HelgetunJB (2023) The global and the local: Idea flows, contexts, and the influencing of education policy in the 21st century. In: TierneyRRizviFErcikanK (eds) International Encyclopedia of Education, pp. 604–610. Online, Elsevier.
22.
HelgetunJBDecuypereM (2024) One thing can be more than one thing a comparative study of the teacher professionalization app TeacherTapp. Learning Media & Technology49(4): 563–578.
23.
HelgetunJBDumayX (2021) From scholar to craftsperson? Constructing an accountable teacher education environment in England 1976–2019. European Journal of Teacher Education44(1): 80–95.
24.
HelgetunJBPowellJJWZappM (2018) Governing educational research in Norway: Coercion, cooperation or consensus? In: ZappMMarquesMPowellJJW (eds) European Educational Research (Re)Constructed: Institutional Change in Germany, the United Kingdom, Norway, and the European Union. Oxford : Symposium Books, pp.91–111.
25.
IzadiniaM (2014) Teacher educators’ identity: A review of literature. European Journal of Teacher Education37(4): 426–441.
26.
JonesK (2016) Education in Britain: 1944 to the Present. Cambridge: Polity press.
27.
KaasilaRLutovacSUittoM (2025) Research on teacher educators’ teacher identities: Critical interpretative synthesis and future directions. European Journal of Teacher Education48(2): 403–422.
28.
LawJMolA (2001) Situating technoscience: An inquiry into spatialities. Environment and Planning D Society and Space19(5): 609–621.
29.
LawnM (2013) A systemless system: Designing the disarticulation of English state education. European Educational Research Journal12(2): 231–241.
30.
LeTendreGKHelgetunJBWooH, et al. (2026) The Teacher and the State: A Comparative Analysis of Nordic and East Asian Nations. Online, Emerald Publishing.
31.
MaclureJS (1986) Educational Documents in England and Wales: 1816 to the Present Day. London and New York: Methuen.
32.
MathouCSarazinMDumayX (2022) Whither employment protections? Deregulation and the flexibilisation of the teaching workforce in the state-funded sector. Journal of Education Policy37(2): 285–307.
33.
MenterI, et al. (2016) UK and Irish teacher education in a time of change. In: BeauchampGClarkeLHulmeM (eds) Teacher Education in Times of Change. Bristol: Policy Press, University of Bristol, pp.19–37.
34.
MenterI (2023) Teacher education research in the twenty-first century. In: MenterI (ed.) The Palgrave Handbook of Teacher Education Research. Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 19–37.
35.
OzoufJOzoufM (1992) La République des instituteurs. Paris: Seul.
36.
PhillipsR (2001) Education, the state and the politics of reform: The historical context, 1976–2001. In: PhillipsRFurlongJ (eds) Education, Reform and the State: Twenty-Five Years of Politics, Policy and Practice. London and New York: Routledge, pp. 12–29.
37.
PonsX (2014) Les inspections centrales anglaises et françaises: des trajectoires croisées ?Revue française de pédagogie (186): 23–33.
38.
ProstA Ed(2014) La formation des maîtres de 1940 a 2010. France: Presses universitaires de Rennes.
39.
SmithKFloresMA (2019) The Janus faced teacher educator. European Journal of Teacher Education42(4): 433–446.
40.
SwennenA (2024) Research on teacher education: Mirror and compass. European Journal of Teacher Education47(1): 1–4.
41.
TattoMT (2006) Education reform and the global regulation of teachers’ education, development and work: A cross-cultural analysis. International Journal of Educational Research45(4–5): 231–241.
42.
UNESCO (2024) Global report on teachers: What you need to know.
43.
VanasscheEBruneelSChristiaensL (2021) A critical examination of the conception of teacher professionalism enacted in current teacher education policy in Flanders (Belgium). In: MayerD (ed.) Teacher Education Policy and Research. Singapore: Springer, pp. 27–41.
44.
WhittyG (2014) Recent developments in teacher training and their consequences for the ‘University Project’ in education. Oxford Review of Education40(4): 466–481.
45.
WilkinsR (2023) Policy Foundations of Education. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
46.
ZappMHelgetunJBPowellJJW (2018) (Re)shaping educational research through ‘programmification’: Institutional expansion, change, and translation in Norway. European Journal of Education53(2): 202–217.
