There is a growing interest in the impact of family-witnessed resuscitation. However, evidence about the effect of hospitalised patients witnessing other patients’ resuscitations is limited.
Aim:
The aim of this systematic review is to explore the existing evidence related to the impact on patients who witness resuscitation attempts on other patients in hospital settings.
Methods:
The databases BNI, CINAHL, EMBASE, MEDLINE and PsycINFO were searched with the terms ‘patient’, ‘inpatient’, ‘resuscitation’, ‘CPR’, ‘cardiopulmonary resuscitation’ and ‘witness’. The search strategy excluded the terms ‘out-of-hospital’, ‘family’ and ‘relative’. The inclusion criteria were: studies related to patients exposed to a resuscitation attempt performed on another patient; quantitative and qualitative design; and physiological or psychological outcome measures. No limitations of date, language or settings were applied.
Results:
Five of the 540 identified studies were included: two observational studies with control groups and three qualitative studies with interviews and focus groups. Articles were published between 1968 and 2006 and were mostly rated to have a low quality of evidence. Quantitative results of the observational studies showed an increased heart rate in the study group witnessing a resuscitation (p = 0.05), increased systolic blood pressure (p < 0.01) and increased anxiety (p < 0.01). The qualitative studies highlighted the coping strategies adopted by exposed patients in response to witnessing resuscitation, including denial and dissociation.
Conclusions:
Our findings suggest that patients may find witnessing resuscitation to be a stressful experience. However, the evidence is sparse and mainly of poor quality. Further research is needed in order to better understand the impacts of patients witnessing a resuscitation of another patient and to identify effective support systems.
NolanJPSoarJSmithGBet al. Incidence and outcome of in-hospital cardiac arrest in the United Kingdom National Cardiac Arrest Audit. Resuscitation2014; 85: 987–992.
2.
MeisterREWeberTPrincipMet al. Perception of a hectic hospital environment at admission relates to acute stress disorder symptoms in myocardial infarction patients. Gen Hosp Psychiatry2016; 39: 8–14.
Wilson-BarnettJ.In hospital: patients’ feelings and opinions. Nurs Times1978; 74(Suppl.): 29–32.
5.
AhmadiKS.The experience of being hospitalized: Stress, social support and satisfaction. Int J Nurs Stud1985; 22: 137–148.
6.
ShuldhamCMCunninghamGHiscockMet al. Assessment of anxiety in hospital patients. J Adv Nurs1995; 22: 87–93.
7.
BhandarkarPNMohdSAdinateshKVet al. Assessment of anxiety and depression among patients admitted in tertiary care hospital, Karimnagar. Int J Biol Med Res2011; 2: 1035–1037.
8.
GammonJ.Analysis of the stressful effects of hospitalisation and source isolation on coping and psychological constructs. Int J Nurs Pract1998; 4: 84–96.
9.
TeasdaleK.The nurse’s role in anxiety management. Prof Nurse1995; 10: 509–512.
10.
IsmailMS.Egyptian patients’ perception of their lived experience about stressors in critical care department: Intervention protocol. EJHM2008; 32: 455–467.
ZijlstraJABeesemsSGDe HaanRJet al. Psychological impact on dispatched local lay rescuers performing bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Resuscitation2015; 92: 115–121.
13.
KostoulakosNMBradleyDR.Overestimation of the effectiveness of cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Percept Mot Skills1997; 84: 1409–1410.
14.
RobertsDHirschmanDScheltemaK.Adult and pediatric CPR: Attitudes and expectations of health professionals and laypersons. Am J Emerg Med2000; 18: 465–468.
15.
Van den BulckJJM. The impact of television fiction on public expectations of survival following inhospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation by medical professionals. Eur J Emerg Med2002; 9: 325–329.
16.
JonesGKBrewerKLGarrisonHG.Public expectations of survival following cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Acad Emerg Med2000; 7: 48–53.
BoucherM.Family-witnessed resuscitation: Melanie Boucher discusses the views of patients, relatives and staff on whether family members should be present during attempts to resuscitate their loved ones. Emerg Nurse2010; 18: 10–14.
19.
ColbertJAAdlerJN.Clinical decisions. Family presence during cardiopulmonary resuscitation – Polling results. N Engl J Med2013; 368: e38.
20.
MeyersTAEichhornDJGuzzettaCEet al. Family presence during invasive procedures and resuscitation: The experience of family members, nurses, and physicians. Am J Nurs2000; 100: 32–43.
21.
PaplanusLMSalmondSWJadotteYTet al. A systematic review of family witnessed resuscitation and family witnessed invasive procedures in adults in hospital settings internationally – Part I: Perspectives of patients and families. JBI Libr Syst Rev2012; 10: 1883–2017.
22.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJet al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. BMJ2009; 339: b2535.
DalyJWillisKSmallRet al. A hierarchy of evidence for assessing qualitative health research. J Clin Epidemiol2007; 60: 43–49.
25.
JonesB.Inside the coronary care unit. The patient and his responses. Am J Nurs1967; 67: 2313–2320.
26.
PlayfairC.Human relationships: An exploration of loneliness and touch. Br J Nurs2010; 19: 124–126.
27.
VansonRJKatzBMKrekelerK.Stress effects on patients in critical care units from procedures performed on others. Heart Lung1980; 9: 494–497.
28.
WolfS.Central autonomic influences on cardiac rate and rhythm. Mod Concepts Cardiovasc Dis1969; 38: 29–34.
29.
EshelNMarcovitzDESternTA.Psychiatric consultations in less-than-private places: Challenges and unexpected benefits of hospital roommates. Psychosomatics2016; 57: 97–101.
30.
BadgerJM.Medical emergencies during cardiac rehabilitation: A naturalistic inquiry of the psychologic impact on peers. J Cardiovasc Nurs1994; 9: 37–53.
31.
BruhnJGThurmanAEJrChandlerBCet al. Patients’ reactions to death in a coronary care unit. J Psychosom Res1970; 14: 65–70.
32.
HackettTPCassemNHWishnieHA.The coronary-care unit. An appraisal of its psychologic hazards. N Engl J Med1968; 279: 1365–1370.
33.
SczekallaRM.Stress reactions of CCU patients to resuscitation procedures on other patients. Nurs Res1973; 22: 65–69.
34.
IsaksenASGjengedalE.Significance of fellow patients for patients with myocardial infarction. Scand J Caring Sci2006; 20: 403–411.
35.
FramptonSBGilpinLCharmelPA.Putting Patients First: Designing and Practicing Patient-centered Care. San Francisco, CA, USA: Jossey-Bass, John Wiley & Sons Inc., 2003.
36.
SloaneDCSloaneBC.Medicine Moves to the Mall. Baltimore: JHU Press, 2003.
37.
GeslerWBellMCurtisSet al. Therapy by design: Evaluating the UK hospital building program. Health Place2004; 10: 117–128.
38.
MabenJGriffithsPPenfoldCet al. One size fits all? Mixed methods evaluation of the impact of 100% single-room accommodation on staff and patient experience, safety and costs. BMJ Qual Saf2016; 25: 241–256.
39.
Van de GlindIDe RoodeSGoossensenA.Do patients in hospitals benefit from single rooms? A literature review. Health Policy2007; 84: 153–161.
40.
ReidJWilsonKAndersonKEet al. Older inpatients’ room preference: single versus shared accommodation. Age Ageing2015; 44: 331–333.
41.
LeighHHoferMACooperJet al. A psychological comparison of patients in “open” and “closed” coronary care units. J Psychosom Res1972; 16: 449–457.
42.
LarsenLSLarsenBHBirkelundR.An ambiguous relationship – A qualitative meta-synthesis of hospitalized somatic patients’ experience of interaction with fellow patients. Scand J Caring Sci2013; 27: 495–505.
43.
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Patient Experience in Adult NHS Services. Guidance and guidelines. London: NICE, 2012.
44.
Van der PloegHM.Stressful medical events: A survey of patients’ perceptions. In: Topics in Health Psychology. New York, NY, USA: John Wiley, 1988, pp. 193–203.
45.
GenestMLevineJRamsdenVet al. The impact of providing help: Emergency workers and cardiopulmonary resuscitation attempts. J Trauma Stress1990; 3: 305–313.
46.
MathiesenWTBjørsholCABrautGSet al. Reactions and coping strategies in lay rescuers who have provided CPR to out-of-hospital cardiac arrest victims: A qualitative study. BMJ Open2016; 6: e010671.
MøllerTPHansenCMFjordholtMet al. Debriefing bystanders of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest is valuable. Resuscitation2014; 85: 1504–1511.
49.
FulbrookPAlbarranJWLatourJM.A European survey of critical care nurses’ attitudes and experiences of having family members present during cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Int J Nurs Stud2005; 42: 557–568.
50.
AxelssonÅBFridlundBMoonsPet al. European cardiovascular nurses’ experiences of and attitudes towards having family members present in the resuscitation room. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2010; 9: 15–23.
51.
ChenCLTangJSLaiMKet al. Factors influencing medical staff’s intentions to implement family-witnessed cardiopulmonary resuscitation: A cross-sectional, multihospital survey. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2017; 16: 492–501.
52.
McMahon-ParkesKMoulePBengerJet al. The views and preferences of resuscitated and non-resuscitated patients towards family-witnessed resuscitation: A qualitative study. Int J Nurs Stud2009; 46: 220–229.
53.
BradleyCKeithlineMPetrocelliMet al. Perceptions of adult hospitalized patients on family presence during cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Am J Crit Care2017; 26: 103–110.
54.
AlbarranJMoulePBengerJet al. Family witnessed resuscitation: The views and preferences of recently resuscitated hospital inpatients, compared to matched controls without the experience of resuscitation survival. Resuscitation2009; 80: 1070–1073.
55.
De StefanoCNormandDJabrePet al. Family presence during resuscitation: a qualitative analysis from a national multicenter randomized clinical trial. PLoS One2016; 11: e0156100.
56.
LedermanZ.FPDR (family presence during resuscitation) as it is portrayed on prime-time media. US–China Education Review2013; 3: 253–260.
57.
OngMEHChungWLMeiJSE.Comparing attitudes of the public and medical staff towards witnessed resuscitation in an Asian population. Resuscitation2007; 73: 103–108.
58.
MazerMACoxLACaponJA.The public’s attitude and perception concerning witnessed cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Crit Care Med2006; 34: 2925–2928.
59.
FulbrookPLatourJAlbarranJet al. The presence of family members during cardiopulmonary resuscitation: European federation of Critical Care Nursing associations, European Society of Paediatric and Neonatal Intensive Care and European Society of Cardiology Council on Cardiovascular Nursing and Allied Professions Joint Position Statement. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs2007; 6: 255–258.
60.
BossaertLLPerkinsGDAskitopoulouHet al. European Resuscitation Council Guidelines for Resuscitation 2015: Section 11. The ethics of resuscitation and end-of-life decisions. Resuscitation2015; 95: 302–311.
