Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Research into state size and democracy has revealed that the very smallest states are more likely to be democratic than their larger counterparts. Being an island, as well as having a British colonial past, is also associated with a state’s observance of democratic measures. With these observations in mind, this article examines an unsuccessful attempt to reform the political and constitutional governance of the Channel Island of Alderney, a self-governing dependency of the British Crown. Why was political reform rejected on this island microjurisdiction? Was the post-Brexit agenda too crowded to permit reform? Did Alderney have other priorities? Might smallness itself be the explanation?

Keywords

islands microjurisdictions Alderney constitutional reform

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alderney Gambling Control Commission (AGCC) (2016) Annual Report 2015-16. St Anne: Alderney Gambling Control Commission.

Anckar

(1995) Size, insularity and democracy. Scandinavian Political Studies 18(4): 211–229.

Anckar

(2009) Size, islandness and democracy: A global comparison. International Political Science Review 29(4): 433–459.

Anckar

(2002) Why are small island states democracies? The Round Table 2002: 375–390.

Anckar

(2004) Regime choices in microstates: The cultural constraint. Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 42(2): 206–223.

Anckar

(2006) Islandness or smallness? A comparative look at political institutions in small island states. Island Studies Journal 1(1): 43–54.

Anckar

(2008) Microstate democracy revisited: Developments in time and space. The Open Political Science Journal 1: 75–83.

Anckar

(2010) Small is democratic, but who is small? Arts and Social Sciences Journal 1(1): 1–10.

Anon (2016a) Alderney’s population increases for the first time in 7 years. BBC News, London. Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-guernsey-35996827 (accessed 8 April 2016).

10.

Anon (2016b) Alderney spend £43k on report that concludes it’s too early to speculate on impact of Brexit. ITV News, London. Available at: http://www.itv.com/news/channel/2016-06-22/alderney-spend-43k-on-report-that-concludes-its-too-early-to-speculate-on-impact-of-brexit/ (accessed 22 June 2016).

11.

Anon (2016c) Brexit: Jersey has option to sever ties with the UK. Jersey Evening Post, St Helier. Available at: http://jerseyeveningpost.com/news/2016/06/28/brexit-jersey-has-option-to-sever-ties-with-the-uk/#6HlrEkAheh0RBksC.99 (accessed 28 June 2016).

12.

Anon (2016d) May confirms Crown Dependencies to be at Brexit talks. BBC News, London. Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36923600 (29 July 2016).

13.

Anon (2017) Alderney people to have their say on Fab Link cable. Guernsey Press, St Peter Port. Available at: http://guernseypress.com/news/2017/07/26/alderney-people-to-have-their-say-on-fab-link-cable/ (accessed 26 July 2017).

14.

Bailes

AJK

Thayer

Thorhallsson

(2016) Alliance theory and small state alliance ‘shelter’. Third World Thematics 1(1): 9–26.

15.

Bailhache

(2005) Introduction. In: Bailhache

(ed), A Celebration of Autonomy: 1204-2004: 800 Years of Channel Islands’ Law. St Helier, Jersey: Jersey Law Review Ltd, pp. 1–3.

16.

Bailhache

(2012) Dependency or Sovereignty? Time to take stock. St Helier, Jersey: Jersey and Guernsey Law Review Ltd.

17.

Baldacchino

(2002) Jurisdictional self-reliance for small island territories. The Round Table 91(365): 349–360.

18.

Baldacchino

(2007) Islands as novelty sites. Geographical Review 97(2): 165–174.

19.

Baldacchino

(2012) Islands and despots. Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 50(1): 103–120.

20.

Blackmore

(2003) Sense of place: Loss and the Newfoundland and Labrador spirit. In: Young

Davis

Igloliorte

(eds) Report to the Royal Commission on Renewing and Strengthening Our Place in Canada. St John, Newfoundland: Royal Commission on Renewing and Strengthening Our Place in Canada, pp. 341–382.

21.

Bray

(1991) Making Small Practical. London: Commonwealth Secretariat.

22.

Briguglio

(1995) Small island developing states and their economic vulnerabilities. World Development 23: 1615–1632.

23.

Clague

Gleason

Knack

(2001) Determinants of lasting democracy in poor countries. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 2001(573): 16–41.

24.

Committee of the Privy Council (1949) Report on the Island of Alderney. London: HMSO, p. 36, Cmnd 7805.

25.

Committee on Standards in Public Life (1995) First Report: The 7 Principles of Public Life. London: HMSO, p. 14, Cmnd 2850.

26.

Commonwealth Secretariat (2014) Commonwealth Secretariat: Champion of Small States. London: Commonwealth Secretariat.

27.

Commonwealth Secretariat and World Bank Joint Task Force on Small States (2000) Small States: Meeting Challenges in the Global Economy. London and Washington DC: Commonwealth Secretariat/World Bank.

28.

Connell

(2014) Alderney: Gambling, Bitcoin and the art of unorthodoxy. Island Studies Journal 9(1): 69–78.

29.

Constitution Unit (2016a) Alderney and Brexit. London: Constitution Unit.

30.

Constitution Unit (2016b) Political Governance: Programme Plan. London: Constitution Unit.

31.

Constitution Unit (2016c) Alderney’s Choices. London: Constitution Unit. Available at: http://www.alderney.gov.gg/article/156030/Review-of-Governance-2016 (accessed 1 February 2018).

32.

Corbett

(2013) Everybody knows everybody—practising politics in the pacific islands. Democratization 2013: 51–72.

33.

Corbett

Veenendaal

(2016) Westminster in small states: Comparing the Caribbean and Pacific experience. Contemp Pols 22(4): 432–449.

34.

Crossan

(2015) Poverty and Welfare in Guernsey, 1560-2015. Woodbridge: Boydell Press.

35.

Dahl

Tufte

(1973) Size and Democracy. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

36.

Dawes

(2015) Documents of constitutional importance for the Channel Islands: Reflections on a rencontre. Jersey and Guernsey LR 1: 6–32.

37.

Downes

(1988) On the statistical measure of smallness. Social and Economic Studies 37(3): 75–96.

38.

Dumienski

(2014) Microstates as Modern Protected States: Towards a New Definition of Micro-Statehood. University of Iceland: Centre for Small State Studies Working Paper.

39.

Erk

Veenendaal

(2014) Is small really beautiful? The microstate mistake. Journal of Democracy 25(3): 135–148.

40.

Fernandez

(2016a) Alderney’s Political Earthquake. ITV News. Available at: http://www.itv.com/news/channel/2016-11-28/john-fernandezs-blog-alderneys-political-earthquake/ (accessed 28 November 2016).

41.

Fernandez

(2016b) Three Sitting Members Ousted by Alderney in FAB link protest vote. Guernsey Press, St Peter Port. Available at: http://guernseypress.com/news/2016/11/28/three-sitting-members-ousted-by-alderney-in-fab-link-protest-vote/ (accessed 28 November 2016).

42.

Fry

(2000) Political legitimacy and the post-colonial state in the Pacific. Pacifica Review 12(3): 295–304.

43.

Gerring

Jaeger

Maguire

(2016) A General Theory of Power Concentration: Demographic Influences on Political Organization. Gothenburg: Varieties of Democracy Institute Working Paper.

44.

Griffith

Sedoc-Dahlberg

(1997) Democracy and human rights in the Caribbean. In: Griffith

Sedoc-Dahlberg

(eds) Democracy and Human Rights in the Caribbean. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp. 1–11.

45.

Grydehoj

(2017) A future of island studies. Island Studies Journal 12(1): 3–16.

46.

Hache

(1998) Towards a political approach to the Island question. In: Baldacchino

Greenwood

(eds) Competing Strategies of Socio-Economic Development for Small Islands. University of Prince Edward Island, Charlottetown: Institute of Island Studies, pp. 31–68.

47.

Hadenius

(1992) Democracy and Development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

48.

Hanson

(2010) Jurats as adjudicators in the Channel Islands and the importance of lay participation. Common Law World Review 39(3): 250–282.

49.

Harvey

(1996) Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference. New Jersey: Wiley-Blackwell.

50.

Harwood

(2000) Review of the Machinery of Government of Guernsey: The ‘Harwood Report’. St Peter Port: States of Guernsey, p. 19. Available at: https://gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=79138&p=0 (accessed 1 November 2000).

51.

Hay

(2006) A phenomenology of Islands. Island Studies 1(1): 19–42.

52.

Hey

JAK

(2003) Small States in World Politics. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.

53.

Home Office Efficiency & Consultancy Unit (1996) States of Alderney: Review of Internal Administration. London: Home Office.

54.

Hughes

Mander

(1860) The Treasury of Geography. London: Longman Green.

55.

Johnson

(2013) The genesis of Protocol 3: The Channel Islands and the EEC. Jersey and Guernsey LR 2013: 254–284.

56.

Johnson

(2016) Sark, the Supreme Court and the status of the Channel Islands: Or, Barclay bites back. Jersey and Guernsey LR 20(2): 126–140.

57.

Le Patourel

(1937) The Medieval Administration of the Channel Islands 1199–1399. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

58.

Le Patourel

(1984) The origins of the Channel Islands legal system. In: Jones

(ed), Feudal Empires: Norman and Plantagenet—John Le Patourel. London: Hambledon Press, pp. 198–201.

59.

Le Rendu

(2004) Jersey: Independent Dependency? The Survival Strategies of a Microstate. Stratford-Upon-Avon: Ex Libris Press.

60.

Lee

(2010) Separation of powers and fusion of powers: The roles of speakers, presiding officers and non-elected member of assemblies in small jurisdictions. Submission to States of Jersey Review of the Roles of the Bailiff, Attorney General and Solicitor General. St Helier: States of Jersey, p. 16. Available at: https://www.gov.je/SiteCollectionDocuments/Government%20and%20administration/R%20LeeSubmission%2020100518%20AL%20v1.pdf (accessed 5 May 2010).

61.

Masala

(2010) Alliances. In: Dunn Cavelty

Mauer

(eds) The Routledge Handbook of Security Studies. Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 382–392.

62.

Ministry of Justice (2013) Factsheet on the UK’s relationship with the Crown Dependencies. London: Ministry of Justice, Crown Dependencies Branch.

63.

Ministry of Justice (2016) Written Evidence to the Justice Committee Inquiry into the Implications of Brexit for the Crown Dependencies. London: Ministry of Justice.

64.

Morris

(2008) Modernizing government in the Channel Islands: New political executives in British Crown dependencies. Common Law World Review 37(1): 63–96.

65.

Morris

(2012) Constitutional practices and British Crown dependencies: The gap between theory and practice. Common Law World Review 2012; 41(1): 1–28.

66.

Neemia

(1992) Decolonization and democracy in the South Pacific. In: Crocombe

Fanaafi Le Tagaloa

(eds) Culture and Democracy in the South Pacific. Suva, Fiji: University of the South Pacific Press, pp. 1–8.

67.

OECD (2000) Trust in Government: Ethics Measures in OECD Countries. Paris: OECD.

68.

Ogier

(2012) The Law and Government of Guernsey, 2nd ed. St Peter Port: States of Guernsey.

69.

Ott

(2000) Small is Democratic. New York: Garland.

70.

Peters

(1992) The Democratic System in the Eastern Caribbean. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.

71.

Pullum

Titterington

(2015) From Sark to the Supreme Court. Jersey and Guernsey LR 19(1): 33–43.

72.

Royal Commission on the Constitution (1973) Report Vol 1 1969-1973, (hereafter Kilbrandon Report). London: HMSO, p. 612, Cmnd 5460.

73.

Sbrenik

(2004) Small island nations and democratic values. World Development 32(2): 329–341.

74.

Sherwill

(2006) A Fair and Honest Book. Raleigh, NC: Lulu Publishing.

75.

Smits

(2016) Do small jurisdictions have a more complex law? A numerical experiment in private and constitutional law. In: Albarian

Moreteau

(eds) Comparative Law and…. Aix-en-Provence: Aix-Marseille University Press, pp. 473–485.

76.

States of Alderney (n.d.) Summary of Financial Relationship Review Recommendations. St Anne: Alderney, p. 1.

77.

States of Alderney (2016a) Hansard Report States of Alderney in Committee Meeting, vol. 3(5). St Anne: Alderney, p. 33. Available at: http://www.alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=104356&p=0 (accessed 14 September 2016).

78.

States of Alderney (2016b) Hansard Report States of Alderney in Committee Meeting, vol. 3(6). St Anne: Alderney, p. 41. Available at: http://www.alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=104743&p=0 (accessed 19 October 2016.)

79.

States of Alderney (2016c) Minutes of the Policy and Finance Committee. St Anne: Alderney, p. 5. Available at: http://alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=102744&p=0 (accessed 24 May 2016).

80.

States of Alderney (2016d) Minutes of the Policy and Finance Committee. St Anne: Alderney, p. 7. Available at: http://alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=103885&p=0 (accessed 19 July 2016).

81.

States of Alderney (2016e) Minutes of Policy & Finance Committee. St Anne: Alderney, p. 7. Available at: http://www.alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=104762&p=0 (accessed 20 September 2016).

82.

States of Alderney (2016g) Written Evidence of the States of Alderney to the Justice Committee Inquiry into the Implications of Brexit for the Crown Dependencies. London: House of Commons Justice Committee. Available at: http://data.parliament.uk/WrittenEvidence/CommitteeEvidence.svc/EvidenceDocument/Justice/Implications%20of%20Brexit%20for%20the%20%20Crown%20Dependencies/written/43464.html (accessed 28 November 2016).

83.

States of Alderney (2017) Press Release—Meeting with Robin Walker MP, Parliamentary Under-Secretary for the Department for Exiting the EU. St Anne: Alderney, p. 1.

84.

States of Alderney Implementation Panel (1996) Review of the Internal Administration of the States of Alderney: Implementation Update. St Anne: States of Alderney.

85.

States of Alderney Implementation Panel (1997) Review of the Internal Administration of the States of Alderney: Second Report. St Anne: States of Alderney.

86.

States of Guernsey, Isle of Man Government and States of Jersey (2016) Letter to the Rt Hon David Cameron MP. Available at: https://gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=102988&p=0 (accessed 28 June 2016).

87.

States of Guernsey, States of Alderney (2015) Alderney Electronic Census Report. St Anne: States of Alderney, p. 20. Available at: http://www.alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=101811&p=0 (accessed 31 March 2015).

88.

States of Guernsey Policy and Resources Committee (2016) Managing the Implications for Guernsey Because of the UK’s Changing Relationship with the EU. St Peter Port: States of Guernsey, p. 25. Available at: https://gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=102958&p=0 (accessed 27 June 2016).

89.

States of Guernsey Policy Council, States of Alderney Policy & Finance Committee (2015) Joint Review of the Financial Relationship Between Guernsey and Alderney: Terms of Reference. St Peter Port: States of Guernsey. Available at: https://gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=95320&p=0 (accessed 3 March 2015).

90.

States of Guernsey Policy Council, Alderney Policy & Finance Committee (2016) Joint Review of the Financial Relationship Between Guernsey and Alderney Recommendations. St Peter Port: States of Guernsey, p. 3. Available at: https://www.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=100967&p=0 (accessed 16 February 2016).

91.

States of Jersey (2016) Brexit Information Report. St Helier: States of Jersey, p. 21. Available at: http://www.statesassembly.gov.je/AssemblyReports/2016/R.72-2016.pdf?_ga=1.223393307.1491880620.1473947069 (accessed 27 June 2016).

92.

States of Jersey (2000) Report of the Review Panel on the Machinery of Government in Jersey. St Helier: States of Jersey, p. 62. Available at: https://www.gov.je/SiteCollectionDocuments/Government%20and%20administration/ID%20ClothierReport%20100331%20CC.pdf (accessed 21 December 2000).

93.

Stepan

Skach

(1993) Constitutional frameworks and democratic constitutionalism. World Politics 46(1): 1–22.

94.

Taylor

(2013) Audit Report: States Works Department. St Anne: States of Alderney, p. 42 + Appendix. Available at: http://www.alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=84122&p=0.

95.

Taylor

(2014) Civil Service Restructure. St Anne: States of Alderney. Available at: http://www.alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=94408&p=0.

96.

Taylor

(2012) Report to States of Alderney: Organisational Assessment and Improvement. St Anne: States of Alderney, p. 33 + Appendices. Available at: http://www.alderney.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=109725&p=0.

97.

Thorndike

(1991) Politics and society in the South-Eastern Caribbean. In: Clarke

(ed), Society and Politics in the Caribbean. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 110–130.

98.

Troup

(1925) The Home Office. London: GP Putnam’s Sons Limited.

99.

UK Government (2014) Response to the Justice Select Committee’s Report ‘Crown Dependencies: developments since 2010’, p. 36, Cmnd 8837. London: Ministry of Justice. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/293235/government-response-justice-select-committees-report-crown-dependencies-developments-2010.pdf.

100.

van Leuven

(2004) Constitutional relationships within the Bailiwick of Guernsey–Alderney. Jersey LR 8(2): 131–150.

101.

Veenendaal

(2015a) Democracy in microstates; why smallness does not produce a democratic system. Democratization 22(1): 92–112.

102.

Veenendaal

(2015b) Politics and Democracy in Microstates. London: Routledge.

103.

Veenendaal

Corbett

(2015) Why small states offer important answers to large questions. Comp Pol St 48(4): 527–549.

104.

Weale

(1991) Islandness. Island Journal 8: 81–82.

Attempting constitutional reform on the island microjurisdiction of Alderney

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References