Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) is frequently used to treat attention deficit hyperactivity disorders (ADHD) in children in China. However, until now there has been no strong evidence to prove that TCM has better efficacy than western medicine. In this systematic study of 34 studies published in the Chinese literature, the effectiveness of TCM in treating ADHD in children was examined and compared with methylphenidate (MPH), which is widely used to treat ADHD. It was found that TCM may have equal or better effectiveness than MPH. However, the lack of high-quality clinical trials to support this conclusion means that it is not currently possible to recommend any particular kind of TCM preparation for treating ADHD in children.
LernerMWigalT: Long-term safety of stimulant medications used to treat children with ADHD. J Psychosocial Nurs Ment Health Serv2008; 46: 38–48.
4.
WilensTEPrinceJBSpencerTJ: Stimulants and sudden death: What is a physician to do?Pediatrics2006; 118: 1215–1219.
5.
NissenSE: ADHD drugs and cardiovascular risk. N Engl J Med2006; 354: 1445–1448.
6.
HuHYuJ: Therapeutic principle of traditional Chinese medicine for childhood attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Chin J Clin Rehabil2005; 9: 163–165 [in Chinese].
7.
WanJQChenDHLinS: Discussion of the treatment of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in children. J Trad Chin Med1997; 38: 737–739 [in Chinese].
8.
YanKXLiX: Progress on traditional Chinese medicine for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in children. J N Med2007; 4: 955 [in Chinese].
9.
WangYS: A study of diagnosis and treatment of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in Chinese traditional medicine. Med Recapit2006; 12: 895–897 [in Chinese].
10.
HigginsJPTGreenS (eds): Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions, 5th edn.Hoboken: Wiley InterScience, 2008.
11.
WuTXLiuGJ: The concepts, design, practice and reports of allocation concealment and blinding. Chin J Evidence Based Med2007; 7: 222–225 [in Chinese].
12.
DingGAFuJRFengRM: Fifty cases of Yi Zhi mixture for hyperactive disorder in children. N J Trad Chin Med1999; 31: 16–18 [in Chinese].
13.
LiXRChenZJ: Clinical comparative observation of Duodongning and Ritalin in treating children with hyperkinetic syndrome. Chin J Integrated Trad Western Med1999; 19: 410–411 [in Chinese].
14.
JiangRL: Traditional Chinese medicine for hyperactive disorder in children. Chin J Information TCM1999; 6: 63 [in Chinese].
15.
LiLYLiangZZ: Zi Shen Ning Shen Fang for hyperactive disorder in children. J Pract Trad Chin Intern Med2000; 14: 46 [in Chinese].
16.
ChenYHHuangBZhaoX: Clinical and experimental study on treatment of childhood hyperkinetic syndrome with Yizhidan. Chin J Integrated Trad Western Med2001; 21: 19 [in Chinese].
17.
DingGAYuGHChenSF: Assessment on effect of treatment of childhood hyperkinetic syndrome by combined therapy of Yizhi mixture and Ritalin. Chin J Integrated Trad Western Med2002; 22: 255–257 [in Chinese].
18.
ChenJChenYYWangXM: Clinical study on the treatment of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder by Jiangqian granules. Chin J Integrated Trad Western Med2002; 22: 258–260 [in Chinese].
19.
LiXFLiuLQLuRJ: Fifty cases of Yi Zhi mixture for hyperactive disorder in children. China Pharm2003; 12: 67 [in Chinese].
20.
WangYPShiP: Jing Ling oral solution for hyperactive disorder in children. Chin Trad Herbal Drugs2003; 34: 162–163 [in Chinese].
21.
ZouWQ: 63 cases of integrated traditional and Western medicine for hyperactive disorder in children. Sichuan J Trad Chin Med2003; 21: 66–67 [in Chinese].
22.
ZhangFCBanYH: 66 cases of Ren Shen Gui Pi syrup for hyperactive disorder in children. Inform Trad Chin Med2003; 20: 46 [in Chinese].
23.
HuDP: Effect of Yi Zhi syrup on microelements in the serum of a child with restless disease. Chin J Pract Chin Mod Med2004; 17: 2171–2172 [in Chinese].
24.
LiYPMaRWeiXW: Clinical effect of Yi Zhi Ning Shen particles on kidney-yin deficiency and liver-yang hyperactivity in ADHD in children. Tianjin J Trad Chin Med2004; 21: 374–376 [in Chinese].
25.
LiuLQLiXFWenYG: Fifty cases of Ning Shen mixture for hyperactive disorder in children. Herald Med2004; 23: 306–307 [in Chinese].
26.
QuY: 80 cases of An Shen Yi Zhi pill for hyperactive disorder in children. Clin J Trad Chin Med2004; 16: 330–331 [in Chinese].
27.
YangH: 36 cases of integrated traditional and Western medicine for attention deficit disorder in children. Fujian J Trad Chin Med2005; 36: 34 [in Chinese].
28.
LvHF: 36 cases of Yi Zhi Ren Tang combined with Tian Ma Gou Teng for hyperactive disorder in children. Sichuan J Trad Chin Med2005; 23: 90 [in Chinese].
29.
ZhuRM: Zi Yin Yi Zhi Fang versus ritalin for hyperactive disorder in children. Chin J Hosp Pharm2005; 25: 550 [in Chinese].
30.
YangSH: Zi Shen Ping Gan soup for hyperactive disorder in children. J Chin Mod Pediatr2005; 2: 56–58 [in Chinese].
31.
XuJXMaSFYuGY: Jing Ning Zhi Dong granules for mixed type hyperactive disorder in children. China J Trad Chin Med Pharm2005; 20: 700 [in Chinese].
32.
YuZYWangJX: Jingning decoction for ADHD: An observation of 68 cases. J Pediatr Trad Chin Med2005; 1: 38–39 [in Chinese].
33.
ZhangJMQianJ: 58 cases of traditional Chinese medicine for hyperactive disorder in children. China J Chin Materia Medica2005; 30: 1221 [in Chinese].
34.
ZhaoHAYuanYTZhaoJ: A comparative study on methylphenidate combined with Duodongning capsule in treating attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Chin J Behav Med Sci2005; 14: 894–896 [in Chinese].
35.
ChengHWanLSZhangFR: The efficacy of Yi Zhi Yi Dong Tang for attention deficit hyperactive disorder in children. Jiangsu Pharm Clin Res2006; 14: 119–121 [in Chinese].
36.
HuYLFanRDongGP: 48 cases of Zi Shen Yang Gan Fa for hyperactive disorder in children. Proc Clin Med2006; 15: 790–791 [in Chinese].
37.
ZhangHLHuangJ: Discussion of the traditional Chinese medicine for the minimal brain dysfunction in children. J Integrated Trad Western Med1990; 10: 278–279 [in Chinese].
38.
LaiDLLiYR: 21 cases of Yi Zhi Ning for attention deficit hyperactive disorder in children. J Shandong Univ Trad Chin Med2006; 30: 361–362 [in Chinese].
39.
YueWZXuH: Jing Ling solution combined with ritalin for attention deficit hyperactive disorder in children. Hubei J Trad Chin Med2006; 28: 14–15 [in Chinese].
40.
KongDRHuoJFuHP: 60 cases of Qi Ju Di Huang pill for attention deficit hyperactive disorder. Shandong J Trad Chin Med2007; 26: 445–447 [in Chinese].
41.
LinYLWangZBLinZJ: Observation on the effect of methylphenidate combined with Chinese medicine Ningshen Koufu Ye on attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. World J Integrated Trad Western Med2007; 2: 722–725 [in Chinese].
42.
MaRLiXMWeiXW: Clinical observation of Yishentianjing method on treating fifty-five children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. J Tianjin Univ Trad Chin Med2007; 26: 122–125 [in Chinese].
43.
HuangY: Evaluation of the effect of Duodongning capsule plus Western medicine on attention deficit disorder. World J Integrated Trad Western Med2007; 2: 539–540 [in Chinese].
44.
ZhangLLuJFChenXR: Clinical observation of “Tiao Nao Ling” in treating childhood Gilles de la Tourette's syndrome. Shanghai J Trad Chin Med2007; 41: 44–45 [in Chinese].
45.
ZhangHZhouXF: 30 cases of integrated traditional and Western medicine for hyperactive disorder in children. J Pract Trad Chin Med2008; 24: 163 [in Chinese].
