Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This paper focuses on the use of vague discourse in planning. Early contributions identified vagueness as a ‘problem’ to be solved so as to avoid potential misunderstandings and conflicts. This paper adopts the complementary point of view whereby vagueness can also be a ‘resource’, that is, a strategy used by actors in adverse circumstances. A systematic analysis of the texts and illustrations of 36 urban transport plans shows that vagueness is an essential ingredient. It is used mainly as a way to hedge against unwanted public commitments in the context of major uncertainties and tension between actors.

Keywords

local transport planning planning discourse vague discourse textometry vagueness visual content analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aix-en-Provence (2015) Plan de déplacement urbains du Pays d’Aix 2015 > 2025. Construisons l’écomobilité en Pays d’Aix. Available at: https://www.agglo-paysdaix.fr/?eID=tx_atolfaldownload&objectId=16857 (accessed 17 December 2015).

Bayonne (2014) Révision du plan de déplacements urbains. Syndicat des Transports l’Agglomération Côte Basque-Adour. Available at: https://www.audap.org/userfiles/downloads/espace_partners/etudes2015/c/c5a_stacba_pdu_4.1_etat_des_lieux_strategie_20150710.pdf (accessed 18 June 2014).

Besançon (2015) Plan de déplacements urbains du Grand Besançon. Available at: https://www.grandbesancon.fr/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/07/01_PDU-TOME-1-Diagnostic-Projet-Version-approuv%C3%A9e.pdf (accessed 12 February 2015).

Brest (2002) Le plan de déplacements urbains de la communauté urbaine de Brest. Available at: https://docplayer.fr/8402482-Le-plan-de-deplacements-urbains-de-la-communaute-urbaine-de-brest.html (accessed 22 March 2002).

Brest (2014) PLUi Facteur 4. Pour une métropole plus durable. Available at: http://test.carto2012.pct.ademe.vtech.fr/data/files/pdf/action_158.pdf (accessed 20 January 2014).

Bugg

Gurran

(2011) Urban planning process and discourses in the refusal of Islamic schools in Sydney, Australia. Australian Planner 48(4): 281–291.

Buhler

Lethier

(2019) Analysing urban policy discourses using textometry: An application to French urban transport plans (2000–2015). Urban Studies 2020; 57(10): 2181–2197.

Caen (2001) Plan de déplacements urbains de l’agglomération caennaise. Available at: https://caen.fr/sites/default/files/2018-10/1.1diagnosticetetatinitialdelenvironnement-compressed.pdf (accessed 7 June 2001).

Caen (2013) Plan de déplacements urbains sur le territoire de Caen la mer 2013-2018. Available at: http://fleurysurorne.fr/documents/pdu/1-pdu-viacites-documentprincipal-112013-131121100558-phpapp02.pdf (accessed 19 November 2013).

10.

Collins Dictionary Online (2020) Collins dictionary online. Available at: https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english (accessed 14 September 2020).

11.

de Roo

Porter

(eds) (2007) Fuzzy Planning: The Role of Actors in a Fuzzy Governance Environment. Aldershot, UK; Burlington, VT: Ashgate.

12.

de Saussure

(2005) Cours de linguistique générale. Éd. critique, [Nachdr. der Ausg. 1916]. Grande bibliothèque Payot. Paris: Payot.

13.

Dijon (2012) 2012-2020. Plan de déplacements urbains. Available at: https://eservices.dijon.fr/Pages/Deliberations/Recherche-deliberations.aspx?data=U3RhcnRSb3c9MjAmR0VERG9jQW5uZWVPV1NEQVRFMj0ix4LHgjczNzQ3MjY5NmU2NzNiMjMzMjMwMzEzMiImb3dzdGF4SWRUaGVtYXRpcXVlUG9ydGFpbEFnZW50PSLHgseCMzUyZTIwNDRjMzg5NTA0YzQxNDM0NTRkNDU0ZTU0MmMyMDRkNGY0MjQ5NGM0OTU0YzM4OTIwNDU1NDIwNDU1MzUwNDE0MzQ1MjA1MDU1NDI0YzQ5NDMi (accessed 27 Septembre 2012).

14.

Fairclough

(2013) Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language, 2nd edn [Nachdr.]. London: Routledge.

15.

Hansson

(2020) Visual representation in urban transport planning: Where have all the cars gone? Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 133: 1–11.

16.

Hoch

(2007) Making plans: Representation and intention. Planning Theory 6(1): 16–35.

17.

Hopkins

(2001) Urban Development: The Logic of Making Plans. Washington, DC: Island Press.

18.

Hopkins

(2007) Using plans and plan making processes: Deliberation and representations of plans. In: Hopkins

Zapata

(eds) Engaging the Future: Forecasts, Scenarios, Plans, and Projects. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, pp.283–313.

19.

Hopkins

Knaap

G-J

(2018) Autonomous planning: Using plans as signals. Planning Theory 17(2): 274–295.

20.

Hopkins

Knaap

G-J

(2019) The “Illinois school” of thinking about plans. Journal of Urban Management 8(1): 5–11.

21.

Jacobs

(2006) Discourse analysis and its utility for urban policy research. Urban Policy and Research 24(1): 39–52.

22.

Jegen

Mérand

(2014) Constructive ambiguity: Comparing the EU’s energy and defence policies. West European Politics 37(1): 182–203.

23.

Kaza

(2019) Vain foresight: Against the idea of implementation in planning. Planning Theory 18(4): 410–428.

24.

Kaza

Hopkins

(2009) In what circumstances should plans be public? Journal of Planning Education and Research 28(4): 491–502.

25.

Kaza

Hopkins

(2012) Intentional actions, plans, and information systems. International Journal of Geographical Information Science 26(3): 557–576.

26.

Keefe

(2000) Theories of Vagueness. Cambridge Studies in Philosophy. Cambridge, UK; New York: Cambridge University Press.

27.

Krieg-Planque

(2012) Analyser les discours institutionels. Paris: Armand Colin.

28.

Krieg-Planque

Oger

(2010) Discours institutionnels. Perspectives pour les sciences de la communication. Mots 30(94): 91–96.

29.

Lexico Oxford Dictionary (2020) Resource. Oxford University Press. Available at: https://www.lexico.com/definition/resource (accessed 14 September 2020).

30.

Maccallum

Hopkins

(2011) The changing discourse of city plans: Rationalities of planning in Perth, 1955–2010. Planning Theory & Practice 12(4): 485–510.

31.

Marseille (2013) Plan de déplacements urbains Marseille Provence Métropole 2013-2023. Available at: https://marseillealaloupe.files.wordpress.com/2017/02/plan-de-dc3a9placements-urbains-mpm-2013-2023.pdf (accessed 28 June 2013).

32.

Matthews

Satsangi

(2007) Planners, developers and power: A critical discourse analysis of the redevelopment of Leith Docks, Scotland. Planning Practice and Research 22(4): 495–511.

33.

Montpellier (2012) Plan de déplacements urbains. Se déplacer autrement pour mieux se déplacer. (accessed 19 July 2012).

34.

Nantes (2000) Agglomération nantaise. Plan de déplacements urbains. 2000-2010. Available at: https://auran.org/sites/default/files/publications/documents/01-01-pdu.pdf (accessed 12 December 2000).

35.

Offner

J-M

(2006) Les plans de déplacements urbains. Paris: La Documentation française.

36.

Pineira-Tresmontant

(1988) Rigidités discursives et flou sémantique. Mots 17(1): 145–169.

37.

Porter

de Roo

(2007) The end has no merit. In: de Roo

Porter

(eds) Fuzzy Planning: The Role of Actors in a Fuzzy Governance Environment. Aldershot, UK; Burlington, VT: Ashgate, pp.1–18.

38.

Portugali

Alfasi

(2008) An approach to planning discourse analysis. Urban Studies 45(2): 251–272.

39.

Russell

(1923) Vagueness. Australasian Journal of Psychology and Philosophy 1(2): 84–92.

40.

Sabatier

(2010) Advocacy coalition framework (ACF). In: Boussaguet

Jacquot

Ravinet

(eds) Dictionnaire des politiques publiques. Références. Paris: Presses de Sciences Po, pp.49–57. Available at: https://www.cairn.info/dictionnaire-des-politiques-publiques–9782724611755-p-49.htm (accessed 14 September 2020).

41.

Shapiro

(2008) Vagueness in Context. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Oxford University Press.

42.

Sorensen

(2018) Vagueness. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2018 Edition). Available at: https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2018/entries/vagueness/ (accessed 14 September 2020).

43.

Strasbourg (2012) Plan de déplacements urbains (PDU) de la communauté urbaine de Strasbourg. Available at: http://perso.numericable.fr/g3/CUS_Annexe_3___Accessibilite.pdf (accessed 6 June 2012).

44.

Thom

(1987) La Langue de Bois. Commentaire Julliard. Paris: Julliard.

45.

Tours (2013) Plan de déplacements urbains de l’agglomération tourangelle 2013-2023. Construisons ensemble nos déplacements de demain. Available at: https://carticipe.files.wordpress.com/2017/07/fiche-cerema-concertation_pdu.pdf (accessed 19 December 2013).

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

When vagueness is a strategic resource for planning actors

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References

Supplementary Material