Mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is a controversial label for forms of age-related,
intellectual difficulties unassociated with impairments in activities of daily
living. The principal issue is whether this arbitrary, heterogeneous and unreliable
term is appropriate to use clinically. Persons with the label MCI may progress to
different types of dementia, stay stable, or even improve. In this article we offer
a philosophical analysis of MCI from epistemological, ethical and semantic
perspectives. We believe that the term should currently not be used clinically.
Auchus, A.
, &
Chen, C.
(2001).
Asia regional meeting of the International Working Group for the
Harmonization of Dementia Drug Guidelines: Meeting report
. Alzheimer Disease & Associated Disorders,
15(2),
66–68
.
2.
Auchus, A.
,
Chen, C.
,
Orgogozo, J.-M.
,
Sawada, T.
,
Senanarong, V.
, &
Whitehouse, P.
(2003).
2nd Asia Pacific Regional Meeting of the International Working Group on
Harmonization of Dementia Drub Guidelines: Meetings report
. Alzheimer Disease & Associated Disorders,
17(2),
129–131
.
3.
Ballenger, J.
, &
Whitehouse, P.
(1998).
The body as cultural text. Review of Nerves and narratives: A cultural
history of hysteria in nineteenth-century British prose
. Medical Humanities Review, 12(1),
96–99
.
4.
Bamford, C.
,
Lamont, S.
,
Eccles, M.
,
Robinson, L.
,
May, C.
, &
Bond, J.
(2004).
Disclosing a diagnosis of dementia: A systematic review
. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry,
19(2),
151–169
.
5.
Bewes, T.
(2002). Reification: Or the anxiety of late capitalism.
London and New York: Verso
.
6.
Corner, L.
, &
Bond, J.
(in press).
The impact of the label of Mild Cognitive Impairment on the
individual's sense of self
. Psychiatry and Psychology Journal.
7.
Crook, T.
,
Bartus, R.
,
Ferris, S.
,
Whitehouse, P.
,
Cohen, G.
, &
Gershon, S.
(1986).
Age-associated memory impairment: Proposed diagnostic criteria and measures
of clinical change – Report of a National Institute of Mental
Health Work Group
. Developmental Neuropsychology, 2,
261–276
.
8.
Dubois, B.
(2000).
‘Prodromal Alzheimer's disease’: A more useful
concept than mild cognitive impairment?Current Opinion in Neurology, 13,
367–369
.
9.
Fahy, M.
,
Wald, C.
,
Walker, Z.
, &
Livingston, G.
(2003).
Secrets and lies: The dilemma of disclosing the diagnosis to an adult with dementia
. Age and Ageing, 32(4),
439–441
.
10.
Gauthier, S.
(2004).
Pharmacotherapy of mild cognitive impairment
. Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience,
6(4),
391–395
.
11.
Graham, J.
,
Rockwood, K.
, &
Beattie, B.
(1997).
Prevalence and severity of cognitive impairment with and without dementia
in an elderly population
. The Lancet, 349,
1793–1796
.
12.
Gubrium, J.
(2000). Narrative practice and the inner worlds of
Alzheimer disease experience. In
P. Whitehouse
,
K. Maurer
, &
J. Ballenger
(Eds.), Concepts of Alzheimer disease: Biological, clinical, and
cultural perspectives(pp. 181–203).
Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press
.
13.
Kral, V.
(1962).
Senescent forgetfulness: Benign and malignant
. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 86,
257–260
.
14.
Levy, R.
, on behalf of the Aging-Associated Cognitive Decline Working Party
(1994).
Aging-associated cognitive decline. Report of the Working Party of the
International Psychogeriatric Association
. International Psychogeriatrics, 6,
63–68
.
15.
Maslow, K.
, &
Whitehouse, P.J.
(2003).
Bridging Research and Care Symposia Panel ‘Mild cognitive
impairment: Should we be diagnosing it? What can we offer people who have it?’
Paper presented at the 11th National Alzheimer's Disease
Education Conference, 20–23 July,
Chicago, IL.
16.
Mittelman, M.
(2003).
Depression, anxiety, denial and sense of mastery in persons with mild
cognitive impairment
. The Gerontologist, 43(Special Issue I),
148–148
. (In: Program Abstracts 56th Annual Scientific Meeting: Our Future
Selves: Research, Education and Services for Early Development and Childhood in an
Aging Society.)
17.
Moody, H.
(1992). Ethics in an aging society.
Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press
.
18.
Moody, H.
(1998). The cost of autonomy, the price of
paternalism. In
R. Dobrof
,
R. Dische
, &
H.R. Moody
(Eds.), The cost of autonomy, the price of paternalism.
New York: Haworth Press
.
19.
Moody, H.
(2004). Ethical dilemmas in old age care. In
M. Johnson
(Ed.), Cambridge handbook of age and ageing.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
20.
Petersen, R.
(2003). Mild cognitive impairment: Aging to
Alzheimer's disease.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
21.
Post, S.
(2003). The concept of Alzheimer disease in a
hypercognitive society. In
P. Whitehouse
,
K. Maurer
, &
J. Ballenger
(Eds.), Concepts of Alzheimer disease: Biological, clinical, and
cultural perspectives(pp. 245–256).
Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press
.
22.
Post, S.
,
Ripich, D.
, &
Whitehouse, P.
(1994).
Discourse ethics: Research, dementia and communication
. Alzheimer Disease and Associated Disorders,
8(4),
58–65
.
23.
Powell, J.L.
, &
Moody, H.R.
(2003).
The challenge of modernity: Habermas and critical theory
. Theory and Science, 4(1) Retrieved 15
September 2005 from theoryandscience.icaap.org/volume4issue1.html.
24.
Ritchie, K.
,
Artero, S.
, &
Touchon, J.
(2001).
Classification criteria for mild cognitive impairment: A population-based
validation study
. Neurology, 56,
37–42
.
25.
Ritchie, K.
, &
Lovestone, S.
(2002).
The dementias
. Lancet, 360,
1759–1766
.
26.
Sano, M.
,
Ernesto, C.
, &
Thomas, R.
(1997).
A controlled trial of selegiline, alpha-tocopherol, or both as treatment
for Alzheimer's disease
. New England Journal of Medicine, 336,
1216–1222
.
27.
Taussig, M.
(1991). Reification and the consciousness of the patient: The
nervous system (pp. 83–109).
New York: Routledge
.
28.
Whitehouse, P.
(2002).
Review of Losing my mind: An intimate look at life with
Alzheimer'sby Thomas DeBaggio
. New England Journal of Medicine,
347(11),
861-861
.
29.
Whitehouse, P. (2003a). Letter to Lancet‘Classifications
of the dementias’, commentary on ‘The Dementias’
article by Richies and Lovestone Lancet2002,
360,1759–66. The Lancet, 361, 1227.
30.
Whitehouse, P.
(2003b).
Special article: Guidelines abstracted from the American Academy of
Neurology's Dementia Guidelines for Early Detection, Diagnosis, and
Management of Dementia
. Journal of the American Geriatric Society, 51,
869–873
.
31.
Whitehouse, P.
(2004a). Mild cognitive impairment: The beginnings of the
end of AD. Psychiatric Time: 87–88.
32.
Whitehouse, P.
(2004b).
Regulatory aspects of MCI
. Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience,
6(4),
409–414
.
33.
Whitehouse, P.
,
Maurer, K.
, &
Ballenger, J.
(2000). Concepts of Alzheimer disease: Biological, clinical,
and cultural perspectives.
Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press
.
34.
Whitehouse, P.
,
Frisoni, G.B.
, &
Post, S.
(2004).
Breaking the diagnosis of dementia
. The Lancet Neurology, 3,
124–128
.
