In this conceptual paper, I explicate the ‘punctuated epistemology’ that prevails in international marketing strategy (IMS) and I challenge the assumptions of a requisite punctuated ontology that is implied and nurtured by these epistemological commitments. I frame these assumptions under the terms ‘monochronic’ and ‘monolithic’ and articulate them through a paradigmatic case in point: the standardization versus adaptation debate. In turn, I argue that theorizing in international marketing can be enhanced through the adoption of another ontological stance. Specifically, inspired by the work of Alfred N. Whitehead, I propose an alternative commitment to a process ontology that takes account of ephemerality and mutual conditioning. By advancing the incorporation of metaphysics in international marketing research, I contribute in two broad ways: I promote a relationally embedded and time-sensitive understanding of IMS and highlight the value of philosophical considerations for theorizing purposes in our field.
AharoniY. (2013) ‘The Road to Relevance’, in DevinneyT.M.PedersenT.TihanyiL. (eds.) Advances in International Management: Volume 26 - Philosophy of Science and MetaKnowledge in International Business and Management, pp. 127–69. Bingley: Emerald.
2.
AndriopoulosC.SlaterS. (2013) ‘Exploring the Landscape of Qualitative Research in International Marketing: Two Decades of IMR’, International Marketing Review30(4): 384–412.
3.
ArcherM.S. (2003) Structure, Agency and the Internal Conversation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
4.
BahadirS.C.BharadwajS.G.SrivastavaR.K. (2015) ‘Marketing Mix and Brand Sales in Global Markets: Examining the Contingent Role of Country-Market Characteristics’, Journal of International Business Studies46(5): 596–619.
BakerR. W. (1965) ‘Marketing in Nigeria’, Journal of Marketing29(3): 40–48.
7.
BirnikA.BowmanC. (2007) ‘Marketing Mix Standardization in Multinational Corporations: A Review of the Evidence’, International Journal of Management Reviews9(4): 303–24.
8.
BjerregaardT.KlitmøllerA. (2016) ‘Conflictual Practice Sharing in the MNC: A Theory of Practice Approach’, Organization Studies37(9): 1271–95.
9.
CaylaJ.PeñalozaL. (2012) ‘Mapping the Play of Organizational Identity in Foreign Market Adaptation’, Journal of Marketing76(6): 38–54.
10.
ChungH.F.L.WangC.L.HuangP.H. (2012) ‘A Contingency Approach to International Marketing Strategy and Decision-Making Structure Among Exporting Firms’, International Marketing Review29(1): 54–87.
11.
CochoyF.GiraudeauM.McFallL. (2010) ‘Performativity, Economics and Politics: An Overview’, Journal of Cultural Economy3(2): 139–46.
12.
DalpiazE.RindovaV.RavasiD. (2016) ‘Combining Logics to Transform Organizational Agency: Blending Industry and Art at Alessi’, Administrative Science Quarterly61(3): 347–92.
13.
DavisM.S. (1971) ‘That’s Interesting! Towards a Phenomenology of Sociology and a Sociology of Phenomenology’, Philosophy of the Social Sciences1(2): 309–44.
14.
DelbridgeR.FissP.C. (2013) ‘Styles of Theorizing and the Social Organization of Knowledge’, Academy of Management Review38: 325–31.
15.
DeliosA. (2017) ‘The Death and Rebirth (?) of International Business Research’, Journal of Management Studies54(3): 391–97.
16.
DheerR.J.LenartowiczT.PetersonM.F. (2015) ‘Mapping India’s Regional Subcultures: Implications for International Management’, Journal of International Business Studies, 46(4): 443–67.
17.
DörrenbächerC.GammelgaardJ. (2016) ‘Subsidiary Initiative Taking in Multinational Corporations: The Relationship Between Power and Issue Selling’, Organization Studies37(9): 1249–70.
18.
FiratA.F. (2010) ‘Commentaries on the State of Journals in Marketing’, Marketing Theory10(4): 437–55.
19.
FiratA.F.DholakiaN. (2006) ‘Theoretical and Philosophical Implications of Postmodern Debates: Some Challenges to Modern Marketing’, Marketing Theory6(2): 123–62.
20.
GabrielssonP.GabrielssonM.SeppäläT. (2012) ‘Marketing Strategies for Foreign Expansion of Companies Originating in Small and Open Economies: The Consequences of Strategic Fit and Performance’, Journal of International Marketing20(2): 25–48.
21.
GreenwoodR.RaynardM.KodeihF., et al. (2011) ‘Institutional Complexity and Organizational Responses’, The Academy of Management Annals5(1): 317–71.
22.
HalewoodM. (2005) ‘On Whitehead and Deleuze: The Process of Materiality’, Configurations13(1): 57–76.
23.
HernesT. (2010) ‘Actor-Network Theory, Callon’s Scallops and Process-Based Organization Studies’, in TorH.MaitlisS. (eds.) Process, Sensemaking and Organizing, pp. 161–84. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
24.
HeugensP.P.LanderM.W. (2009) ‘Structure! Agency! (And Other Quarrels): A Meta-Analysis of Institutional Theories of Organization’, Academy of Management Journal52(1): 61–85.
HultmanM.RobsonM.J.KatsikeasC.S. (2009) ‘Export Product Strategy Fit and Performance: An Empirical Investigation’, Journal of International Marketing17(4): 1–23.
27.
JackG. (2008) ‘Postcolonialism and Marketing’, in TadajewskiM.DouglasB. (eds.) Critical Marketing: Issues in Contemporary Marketing, pp. 363–83. Chichester: Wiley.
28.
JarzabkowskiP. (2004) ‘Strategy as Practice: Recursiveness, Adaptation, and Practices-in-Use’, Organization Studies25(4): 529–60.
29.
JiangJ.WeiR. (2012) ‘Influences of Culture and Market Convergence on the International Advertising Strategies of Multinational Corporations in North America, Europe and Asia’, International Marketing Review29(6): 597–622.
30.
JunX.JiangM.LiS., et al. (2014) ‘Practice Standardization in Cross-Border Activities of Multinational Corporations: A Resource Dependence Perspective’, Management International Review54(5): 707–34.
31.
KarababaE. (2012) ‘Approaching Non-Western Consumer Cultures from a Historical Perspective: The Case of Early Modern Ottoman Consumer Culture’, Marketing Theory12(1): 13–25.
32.
KatsikeasC.S. (2003) ‘Advances in International Marketing Theory and Practice’, International Business Review12(2): 135–40.
33.
KatsikeasC.S.SamieeS.TheodosiouM. (2006) ‘Strategy Fit and Performance Consequences of International Marketing Standardization’, Strategic Management Journal27(9): 867–90.
34.
KennedyM.T.FissP.C. (2009) ‘Institutionalization, Framing, and Diffusion: The Logic of TQM Adoption and Implementation Decisions among U.S. Hospitals’, Academy of Management Journal52(5): 897–918.
35.
LagesL.F.JapS.D.GriffithD.A. (2008) ‘The Role of Past Performance in Export Ventures: A Short-Term Reactive Approach’, Journal of International Business Studies39(2): 304–25.
36.
LangleyA.SmallmanC.TsoukasH., et al. (2013) ‘Process Studies of Change in Organization and Management: Unveiling Temporality, Activity, and Flow’, Academy of Management Journal56(1): 1–13.
37.
LeonidouL.C.KatsikeasC.S. (2010) ‘Integrative Assessment of Exporting Research Articles in Business Journals During the Period 1960–2007’. Journal of Business Research, 63(8): 879–887.
38.
LimL.K.S.AcitoF.RusetskiA. (2006) ‘Development of Archetypes of International Marketing Strategy’, Journal of International Business Studies37(4): 499–524.
39.
MacKayR.B.ChiaR. (2013) ‘Choice, Chance, and Unintended Consequences in Strategic Change: A Process Understanding of the Rise and Fall of Northco Automotive’, Academy of Management Journal56(1): 208–30.
40.
MichaelM. (2002) ‘Comprehension, Apprehension, Prehension: Heterogeneity and the Public Understanding of Science’, Science, Technology and Human Values27(3): 357–78.
41.
MorganN.A.KalekaA.KatsikeasC.S. (2004) ‘Antecedents of Export Venture Performance: A Theoretical Model and Empirical Assessment’, Journal of Marketing68(1): 90–108.
42.
NayakA.ChiaR. (2011) ‘Thinking Becoming and Emergence: Process Philosophy and Organization Studies’, Research in the Sociology of Organizations32: 281–309.
43.
NonakaI.ToyamaR.HirataT. (2008) Managing Flow: A Process Theory of the Knowledge-Based Firm. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
44.
Paavilainen-MäntymäkiE.WelchC. (2013) ‘How to Escape an Unprocessual Legacy? A Viewpoint from International Business Research’, in HassettM.E.Paavilainen-MäntymäkiE. (eds.) Handbook of Longitudinal Research Methods in Organisation and Business Studies, pp. 229–49. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.
45.
PerkinsS.E. (2014) ‘When does Prior Experience Pay? Institutional Experience and the Multinational Corporation’, Administrative Science Quarterly59(1): 145–81.
46.
PoliR. (2015) ‘The Difference Between Dynamical Systems and Process Theories’, in PetrovV.ScarfeA.C. (eds.) Dynamic Being: Essays in Process-Relational Ontology, pp. 337–54. Newcastle upon Tyne, UK: Cambridge Scholar Publishing.
47.
PoulisK.PoulisE. (2012) ‘Polyethnic Market Orientation and Performance: A Fast-Moving Consumer Goods Perspective’, Journal of Marketing Management28(5-6): 609–28.
48.
PoulisK.PoulisE. (2013) ‘The Influence of Intra-National Cultural Heterogeneity on Product Standardization and Adaptation: A Qualitative Study’, International Marketing Review30(4): 357–83.
49.
PoulisK.PoulisE. (2016) ‘Problematizing Fit and Survival: Transforming the Law of Requisite Variety through Complexity Misalignment’, Academy of Management Review41(3): 503–27.
50.
PoulisK.PoulisE. (2018) ‘International Business as Disciplinary Tautology: An Ontological Perspective’, Academy of Management Perspectives32(4): 517–31.
51.
PoulisK.PoulisE.PlakoyiannakiE. (2013) ‘The Role of Context in Case Study Selection: an International Business Perspective’, International Business Review22(1): 304–14.
52.
RaffaelliR.GlynnM.A. (2014) ‘Turnkey or Tailored? Relational Pluralism, Institutional Complexity, and the Organizational Adoption of More or Less Customized Practices’, Academy of Management Journal57(2): 541–62.
53.
SahlinK.WedlinL. (2008) ‘Circulating Ideas: Imitation, Translation and Editing’, in GreenwoodR. (ed.) The SAGE Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism, pp. 218–42. Los Angeles: SAGE.
54.
SandbergJ.Dall’AlbaG. (2009) ‘Returning to Practice Anew: A Life-World Perspective’, Organization Studies30(12): 1349–368.
55.
SandbergJ.TsoukasH. (2011) ‘Grasping the Logic of Practice: Theorizing through Practical Rationality’, Academy of Management Review36(2): 338–60.
56.
SchilkeO.ReimannM.ThomasJ.S. (2009) ‘When does International Marketing Standardization Matter to Firm Performance?’, Journal of International Marketing17(4): 24–46.
57.
SchmidS.KotullaT. (2011) ‘50 Years of Research on International Standardization and Adaptation—From a Systematic Literature Analysis to a Theoretical Framework’, International Business Review20(5): 491–507.
58.
SchultzM.HernesT. (2013) ‘A Temporal Perspective on Organizational Identity’, Organization Science24(1): 1–21.
59.
SeibtJ. (2009) ‘Forms of Emergent Interaction in General Process Theory’, Synthese166: 479–512.
60.
ShaverJ. M. (2013) ‘Do We Really Need More Entry Mode Studies?’, Journal of International Business Studies44(1): 23–27.
61.
ShippA.J.JansenK.J. (2011) ‘Reinterpreting Time in Fit Theory: Crafting and Recrafting Narratives of Fit in Medias Res’, Academy of Management Review36(1): 76–101.
62.
StengersI. (2014) Thinking with Whitehead: A Free and Wild Creation of Concepts. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
63.
TanQ.SousaC.M.P. (2013) ‘International Marketing Standardization: A Meta-Analytic Estimation of its Antecedents and Consequences’, Management International Review53(5): 711–39.
64.
ThompsonM. (2011) ‘Ontological Shift or Ontological Drift? Reality Claims, Epistemological Frameworks, and Theory Generation in Organization Studies’, Academy of Management Review36(4): 754–73.
WelchC.Paavilainen-MäntymäkiE. (2014) ‘Putting Process (back) in: Research in the Internationalization Process of the Firm’, International Journal of Management Reviews16(1): 2–23.
67.
WhiteheadA.N. (1926) Science and the Modern World. London: Free Association Books.
68.
WhiteheadA.N. (1927) Symbolism: Its Meaning and Effect. New York: Macmillan.
69.
WhiteheadA.N. (1929) Process and Reality. Cambridge: University Press.
70.
WhiteheadA.N. (1938) Modes of Thought. New York: Macmillan.
71.
WhiteheadA.N. (1948) Adventures of Ideas. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
72.
WhiteheadA.N. (1964) Concept of Nature. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
73.
WhittleA.SpicerA. (2008) ‘Is Actor Network Theory Critique?’, Organization Studies29(4): 611–29.
74.
WoermannN. (2017) ‘Back to the Roots! Methodological Situationalism and the Postmodern Lesson for Studying Tribes, Practices, and Assemblages’, Marketing Theory17(2): 149–63.
75.
ZeritiA.RobsonM. J.SpyropoulouS., et al. (2014) ‘Sustainable Export Marketing Strategy Fit and Performance’, Journal of International Marketing22(4): 44–66.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
