In this article we provide a review of Protection Motivation Theory with a focus
on the interaction effects and combinatorial rules, in order to resolve
conflicting findings in the literature. Our review suggests that perceived cost
is the main driver of persuasion. We propose that consumers use a combination of
decision-making strategies, with an initial use of the elimination by aspects
rule followed by the weighted additive rule. In the proposed model, consumers
rank the variables and set minimum cut-offs. A weighted additive relationship
takes place only when and if the minimum cut-off levels for variables are met.
This analysis helps explain inconsistent findings from the literature and adds
insight into the decision-making process involved when consumers consider
whether or not to follow a particular recommended health behavior.
Aspinwall, L.G.
,
Kemeny, M.E.
,
Taylor, S.E.
,
Schneider, S.G.
and
Dudley, J.
(1991) `
Psychosocial Predictors of Gay Men's AIDS Risk-reduction Behavior'
, Health Psychology10(6):
432—44
.
2.
Bandura, A.
(1977) `
Self-efficacy: Toward a Unifying Theory of Behavioral Change'
, Psychological Review84(2):
191—215
.
3.
Beck, K.H.
(1984) `
The Effects of Risk Probability, Outcome Severity, Efficacy of Protection
and Access to Protection on Decision Making: A Further Test of Protection
Motivation Theory
', Social Behavior and Personality12(2):
121—5
.
4.
Bettman, R.J.
,
Luce, M.F.
and
Payne, J.W.
(1998) `
Constructive Consumer Choice Processes
', Journal of Consumer Research25(3):
187—217
.
5.
Block, L.G.
and
Keller, P.A.
(1998) `
Beyond Protection Motivation: An Integrative Theory of Health Appeals
', Journal of Applied Social Psychology28(17):
1585—609
.
6.
Boer, H.
and
Seydel, E.R.
(1996) `Protection Motivation Theory', in
M. Conner
and
P. Norman
(eds) Predicting Health Behavior: Research and Practice with Social
Cognition Models, pp. 95—120.
Buckingham: Open University Press
.
7.
Boster, F.J.
and
Mongeau, P.
(1984) `
Fear-arousing Persuasive Messages
', Communication Yearbook8:
330—75
.
8.
Courneya, K.S.
and
Hellsten, L.-A.M.
(2001) `
Cancer Prevention as a Source of Exercise Motivation: An Experimental Test
Using Protection Motivation Theory', Psychology, Health, andMedicine6(1):
59—64
.
9.
Das, E.H.H.J.
,
de Wit, J.B.F.
and
Stroebe, W.
(2003)
`Fear Appeals Motivate Acceptance of Action Recommendations: Evidence for a
Positive Bias in the Processing of Persuasive Messages
', Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin29(5):
650—64
.
10.
Eagly, A.H.
and
Chaiken, S.
(1993) `The Psychology of Attitudes'.
Orlando
, FL:
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
.
11.
Floyd, D.L.
,
Prentice-Dunn, S.
and
Rogers, R.W.
(2000)
`A Meta-analysis of Research on Protection Motivation Theory
', Journal of Applied Social Psychology30(2):
407—29
.
12.
Frileux, S.
,
Sastre, M.T.M.
,
Mullet, E.
and
Sorum, P.C.
(2004) `
The Impact of the Preventive Medical Message on Intention to Change Behavior'
, Patient Education and Counseling52(1):
79—88
.
13.
Griffeth, R.
and
Rogers, R.
(1976) `
Effects of Fear Arousing Components of Driver Education on Trainee's
Attitudes and Simulator Performance'
, Journal of Educational Psychology69(4):
501—6
.
14.
Hodgkins, S.
and
Orbell, S.
(1998) `
Can Protection Motivation Theory Predict Behavior? A Longitudinal Test
Exploring the Role of Previous Behavior
', Psychology and Health13(2):
237—51
.
15.
Hogarth, R.M.
(1987) Judgment and Choice. 2nd ed.
New York: Wiley
.
16.
Kleinot, M.C.
and
Rogers, R.
(1982) `
Identifying Effective Components of Alcohol Misuse Prevention Programs',
Journal ofStudies on Alcohol43(7):
802—11
.
17.
Krishnamurthy, P.
,
Cismaru, M.
and
Nagpal, A.
(2004) `
The Role of Cost and Efficacy in Persuasiveness of Health Recommendations
', paper presented at the Society of Consumer Psychology Summer
Conference, Honolulu, Hawaii, July.
18.
Kyes, K.B.
(1995) `
Using Fear to Encourage Safer Sex: An Application of Protection Motivation Theory
', Journal of Psychology and Human Sexuality7(3):
21—37
.
19.
Lazarus, R.S.
(1991) `
Progress on a Cognitive-Motivational-Relational Theory of Emotion
', American Psychologist46(8):
819—34
.
20.
Maddux, J.E.
and
Rogers, R.W.
(1983) `
Protection Motivation and Self-efficacy: A Revised Theory of Fear Appeals
and Attitude Change
', Journal of Experimental Social Psychology19(5):
469—79
.
21.
Maddux, J.E.
,
Sherer, M.
and
Rogers, R.W.
(1982) `
Self-efficacy Expectancy and Outcome Expectancy: Their Relationship and
Their Effects on Behavioural Intentions
', Cognitive Therapy and Research: 6(2):
207—11
.
22.
Mewborn, C.
and
Rogers, R.
(1979) `
Effects of Threatening and Reassuring Components of Fear Appeals on
Physiological and Verbal Measures of Emotion and Attitudes'
, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology15(3):
242—53
.
23.
Milne, S.
,
Sheeran, P.
and
Orbell, S.
(2000) `
Prediction and Intervention in Health-related Behavior: A Meta-analytic
Review of Protection Motivation Theory'
, Journal of Applied Social Psychology30(1):
106—43
.
24.
Neuwirth K.
,
Dunwoody, S.
and
Griffin, R.J.
(2000) `
Protection Motivation and Risk Communication'
, Risk Analysis20(5):
721—34
.
25.
Pechmann, C.
,
Zhao, G.
,
Goldberg, M.E.
and
Reibling, E.T.
(2003) `
What to Convey in Antismoking Advertisements for Adolescents: The Use of
Protection Motivation Theory to Identify Effective Message Themes
', Journal of Marketing67(2):
1—18
.
26.
Rimal, R.N.
and
Real, K.
(2003) `
Perceived Risk and Efficacy Beliefs as Motivators of Change Use of the Risk
Perception Attitude (RPA) Framework to Understand Health Behaviors
', Human Communication Research29(3):
370—99
.
27.
Rippetoe, P.
and
Rogers, R.
(1987) `
Effects of Components of Protection Motivation Theory on Adaptive and
Maladaptive Coping with a Health Threat'
, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology52(3):
596—604
.
28.
Rogers, R.W.
(1975) `
A Protection Motivation Theory of Fear Appeals and Attitude Change
', Journal of Psychology91(5):
93—114
.
29.
Rogers, R.W.
(1983) `Cognitive and Physiological Processes in Fear Appeals
and Attitude Change: A Revised Theory of Protection Motivation', in
J.T. Cacioppo
and
R.E. Petty
(eds) Social Psychophysiology, pp.
153—76.
New York: Guilford Press
.
30.
Rogers, R.W.
(1985) `
Attitude Change and Information Integration in Fear Appeals
', Psychological Reports56(1):
183—88
.
31.
Rogers, R.W.
and
Mewborn, C.R.
(1976) `
Fear Appeals and Attitude Change: Effects of a Threat's Noxiousness,
Probability of Occurrence, and the Efficacy of Coping Responses
', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology34(1):
54—61
.
32.
Rogers, R.W.
and
Prentice-Dunn, S.
(1997) `Protection Motivation Theory ', in
D. Gochman
(ed.) Handbook of Health Behavior Research: Vol. 1. Determinants of
Health Behavior: Personal and Social, pp.
113—32.
New York: Plenum Press
.
33.
Self, C.A.
and
Rogers, R.W.
(1990) `
Coping with Threats to Health: Effects of Persuasive Appeals on Depressed,
Normal, and Antisocial Personalities', Journal of BehavioralMedicine13(4):
343—57
.
34.
Sturges, J.W.
and
Rogers, R.W.
(1996) `
Preventive Health Psychology from a Development Perspective: An Extension
of Protection Motivation Theory
', Health Psychology15(3):
158—66
.
35.
Tanner, J.F.
,
Hunt, J.B.
and
Eppright, D.R.
(1991) `
The Protection Motivation Model: A Normative Model of Fear Appeals
', Journal of Marketing55(3):
36—45
.
36.
Tversky, A.
(1972) `
Elimination by Aspects: A Theory of Choice'
, Psychological Review79(4):
281—99
.
37.
United States Department of Health and Human Services — Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention, URL (consulted May, 2006): http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dnpa/obesity
38.
United States Department of Health and Human Services — Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention
, `Take a Small Step to Get Health' campaign, URL (consulted May
2006): www.smallstep.gov
39.
United States Department of Health and Human Services — Ad Council
, URL (consulted May 2006): www.adcouncil.org
40.
Weinstein, N.D.
(1993) `
Testing Four Competing Theories of Health-protective Behaviour
', Health Psychology12(4):
324—33
.
41.
Weinstein, N.D.
(2000) `
Perceived Probability, Perceived Severity, and Health-protective Behaviour
', Health Psychology19(1):
65—74
.
42.
Witte, K.
(1992a) `Preventing AIDS through Persuasive Communications: A
Framework for Constructing Effective Culturally-specific Health Messages
', in
R. Korzenny
and
S. Ting-Toomey
(eds) International and Intercultural Communication Annual 16, pp.
67—86.
Newbury Park
,
CA: Sage
.
43.
Witte, K.
(1992b) `
Putting the Fear Back into Fear Appeals: The Extended Parallel Process Model
', Communication Monographs59(4):
329—49
.
44.
Witte, K.
(1992c) `
The Role of Threat and Efficacy in AIDS Prevention
', International Quarterly of Community Health Education12(3):
225—49
.
45.
Wurtele, S.K.
(1988) `
Increasing Women's Calcium Intake: The Role of Health Beliefs, Intentions,
and Health Value
', Journal of Applied Social Psychology18(8):
627—39
.
46.
Wurtele, S.K.
and
Maddux, J.E.
(1987) `
Relative Contributions of Protection Motivation Theory Components in
Predicting Exercise Intentions and Behavior
', Health Psychology6(5):
453—66
.
47.
Yzer, M.C.
,
Fisher, J.D.
,
Misovich, S.J.
,
Bakker, A.B.
and
Siero, F.W.
(1998) `
The Effects of Information about AIDS Risk and Self-efficacy on Women's
Intentions to Engage in AIDS Preventive Behavior
', Journal of Applied Social Psychology28(20):
1837—52
.
